lppkbz dks nckrk gs çèkkuea=h dk oäo;

Transcription

1 laln esa lq"kek Lojkt izdk'kdh; lppkbz dks nckrk gs çèkkuea=h dk oäo; yksdiky foèks;d dh ekax dks ysdj lkekftd dk;zdrkz Jh vuuk gtkjs ds vfuf'prdkyhu vu'ku ds eqìs ij izèkkuea=h MkW- eueksgu flag us laln esa odro; fn;ka xr 17 vxlr 2011 dks bl odro; ij ppkz ds nksjku yksdlhkk es a foi{k dh usrk Jherh lq"kek Lojkt us izèkkuea=h ds rdksza dh èkftt;ka mm+krs gq, dgk fd ge lalnh; izfø;kvksa ds lkfk gsaa lalnh; yksdra= dks detksj djus dh btktr ge fdlh dks ugha nsaxsa ysfdu ukxfjd vfèkdkj lokszifj gsaa ns'k vktkn gsa esa ukxfjdksa ds vfèkdkjksa ij jksd yxkus dh ljdkj dh uhfr dks [kkfjt djrh gwaa yksdlhkk esa ^rsyaxkuk jkt; ds xbu esa gq, foyec ls mriuu flfkfr rfkk bl lecuèk esa ljdkj }kjk mbk, x, dne* ds eqìs ij yksdlhkk esa foi{k dh usrk Jherh lq"kek Lojkt us è;kukd"kz.k izlrko izlrqr fd;ka xr 5 vxlr 2011 dks bl izlrko ij ppkz dh 'kq:vkr djrs gq, Jherh lq"kek Lojkt us dkaxzsl dh oknkf[kykqh ij tedj izgkj fd;ka Jherh Lojkt us rsyaxkuk jkt; xbu ds ckjs es a ljdkj ls foèks;d ykus dk vkxzg dj vk'oklu fn;k fd Hkktik bl foèks;d dks nks frgkbz cgqer fnykus esa iw.kz lg;ksx djsxha ge bl iqflrdk es a mijksdr nksuks a eqìs ij O;kid tutkxj.k dh n`f"v ls Jherh lq"kek Lojkt }kjk fn, x, Hkk"k.kksa dk leikfnr ikb izdkf'kr dj jgs gsaa vk'kk gs ikbd blls vo'; ykhkkfuor gksaxsa Hkkjrh; turk ikvhz vxlr 2011 izdk'kd Hkkjrh; turk ikvhz 11] v'kksd jksm] ubz fnyyh&110001

2 iz/kkuea=h ds odro; ij ppkz lppkbz dks nckrk gs çèkkuea=h dk oäo; yksdiky fo/ks;d dks ysdj Jh vuuk gtkjs ds vfuf'prdkyhu vu'ku ds eqìs ij iz/kkuea=h MkWeueksgu flag }kjk fn, x, odro; ij yksdlhkk esa foi{k dh usrk Jherh lq"kek Lojkt }kjk fn, x, Hkk"k.k dk leikfnr ikb % vè;{k egksn;k] blls igys fd es a bl oäo; ij viuh ckr çkje d:a esa vkils,d fuosnu djuk pkgrh gw aa vkius ;g ppkz çkje djus ls igys ihb ls,d fo'ks"k fvii.kh dh FkhA 'kk;n dksbz lanz vkids fnekx es a t:j jgk gksxk] tks vkius og fvii.kh dha ysfdu mldk lcls igyk myya?ku vkt lalnh; dk;z ea=h us fd;ka vkmok.kh th] bl lnu ds ofj"bre lkaln gsaa lcls T;knk vuqoh vksj vknj.kh; gsaa mugksaus [km+s gksdj cgqr f'k"vrk ds lkfk viuh,d ckr vkids lkeus j[kh] ysfdu lalnh; dk;zea=h us [km+s gksdj tks dgk vki fjdkwmz esa nsf[k,a egksn;k] esa Lo;a lalnh; dk;zea=h jgh gwa vksj lalnh; dk;zeaf=;ksa dk igyk yslu ;gh gksrk gs fd os Lo;a ugè cksyrs gs a vksj lnu dks pyus nsrs gsaa vè;{k th] çèkkuea=h th us,d yack oäo;] folr`r oäo; lnu ds lkeus j[kk gsa ysfdu esa dguk pkgwaxh ;g bruk yack&pksm+k oäo; lppkbz dks mtkxj de djrk gs vksj nckrk T;knk gsa viuh iwjh dh iwjh fteesnkjh ljdkj ds duèkks a ls mbkdj çèkkuea=h us fnyyh iqfyl ds duèks ij Mky nha vè;{k th] bl ns'k es a z"vkpkj dh eqfge cgqr rsth ls dbz fnuks a ls py jgh gsa vki Lo;a lk{kh gsaa vki Lo;a lk{kh gsa fd laln dk iwjk 'khrdkyhu l= bl z"vkpkj dh s av p< x+;k] ysfdu mlds ifj.kkelo:i lÿkk i{k ds rhu&rhu yksx vkt tsy ds hrj gsaa ;g mlh dk ifj.kke gsa vkt bl vkanksyu dk usr`ro vék gtkjs dj jgs gsaa ysfdu ljdkj dk jos;k le> ls ijs gsaa ljdkj,dne vlarqfyr O;ogkj dj jgh gs vksj ;g vlarqfyr O;ogkj ckj&ckj ns[kus esa vk jgk gsa vkt çèkkuea=h bl oäo; ds yxx pkj&ikap isjkxzk l es a ikfyz;kes avjh lqçheslh dh ckr djrs gsaa lnu dh çfø;kvksa dh ckr djrs gsaa ;g ckr lgh gs] esa h dg jgh gw a fd ;g lgh gsa ikfyz;kes avjh çkslsl dh ckr djrs gsaa lalnh; çfø;kvks a ds ekè;e ls dkuwu cukus dh ckr djrs gsaa igyk ç'u çèkku ea=h th vkils gs fd ikfyz;kesav çkslsl dks njfdukj djus dke fdlus fd;k\ lkjs ds lkjs foi{k dks njfdukj djds v..kk gtkjs dh Vhe ds lkfk ckr djus dk fu.kz; fdlus fd;k\ usrk lnu lers ikap ofj"b ea=h bl ljdkj ds v..kk gtkjs dh Vhe ds lkfk csbsa tc v..kk gtkjs gels feyus vk,] rks geus muls iwnk fd vkius foi{k ds ckdh yksxksa dks blds ckgj D;ksa j[kk] bl ij mugksaus dgk fd geus ljdkj ls dgk Fkk fd bles a ckdh foi{k ds yksx h gksus pkfg,a ysfdu ljdkj us dgk fd ge vksj vki gh Bhd gsaa esa iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd rc rks ge vksj vki gh Bhd gsa] ml le; rks vki vksj os gh Bhd rs] ysfdu tc ckr fcxm+ xbz rks ljdkj dk lqj cny x;ka ljdkj dks ikfyz;kesav çkslsl ;kn vk;ka rc ljdkj us gesa fpfî;ka fy[kè] rc ljdkj us vkwy ikvê ehçvx cqykbza lkjs usrk tks ;gka csbs gs a],d&,d usrk us mugs a ogka dgk fd ml le; vkidks gekjh ;kn D;ksa ugè vkbza vè;{k th] og dfiy flccy tks lcls T;knk csbrs Fks muds lkfk] ckn es a mugs a z"vkpkjh crkrs gsaa dkaxzsl çoäk] tks blh lnu ds lnl; gsa] og dgrs gsa fd v..kk gtkjs Åij ls uhps rd z"vkpkj es a fyir gsaa c'khj cæ lkgc dk,d 'ksj gs & nq'euh tedj djks] ij bruh xqatkb'k jgs fqj dh ge nkslr cu tk,a] rks 'kfe±nk u gksaa esme], deiuh fdlus dgk Fkk\ esaus uke ysdj dgk fd dkaxzsl ds 1 2

3 a çoäk] blh lnu ds lnl; gsa] cfyd esa rks mugsa lykg nsuk pkgrh gwa euh"k frokjh th dks] fd vkidk jktusfrd thou vh 'kq: gqvk gs] igyh ckj lkaln cudj vk, gks] FkksM+k k"kk dk la;e lh[kksa ;g 'ksj es aus vkids fy, gh i<k+ fd nq'euh tedj djks] ij bruh xqatkb'k jgs fqj dh ge nkslr cu tk,a] rks 'kfe±nk u gksaa vè;{k th] vxys fnu dkaxzsl dh ehçvx gqbz] lw=ksa ds gokys ls dgk x;k fd v..kk gtkjs ij futh geyk ugè fd;k tk,xk] O;fäxr geyk ugè fd;k tk,xka vki tkurh gsa fd deku ls fudyk rhj vksj eqag ls fudyh ckr dh okil ugè vkrha futh geyk rks gks pqdk] O;fäxr geyk rks gks pqdka mlds ckn cpk D;k Fkk] ysfdu esa vkt çèkku ea=h th ls iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd vki tks ikfyz;kesav çkslsl dh ckr dj jgs gsa] ml ikfyz;kes av çkslsl dks [kre djus dk dke vkidh gh ljdkj us fd;k gsa vksj vkt vki gekjs ls ckr dj jgs gsaa esa nwljh ckr dguk pkgrh gwaa çèkku ea=h th vkius vius oäo; ds isjkxzkq 11 esa fy[kk gs fd vki ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa ds cm+s j{kd gsaa 'Our Government acknowledges the right of citizens to hold peaceful protest'. blls T;knk vlr; ckr dksu lh gks ldrh gs\ pkj twu dh jkr dks] Lokeh jkenso ds lefkzdks a ij] lksrs gq, yksxks a ij] tu&dhrzu djrs gq, yksxksa ij tks ykfb;ka cjlkbz x;è] D;k og ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa dk j{k.k Fkk\ es a iwnuk pkgrh gw a fd vh 9 vxlr dks] vaxz stks a kjr NksM+ks ds fnu] kjrh; turk ikvê ds ;qok ekspkz ds yksxks a ij tks ykfb;ka cjlkdj],d viax dks iwjk fodykax dj fn;k x;k] D;k og ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa dk j{k.k Fkk\ esa iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd fcuk èkkjk 144 rksm+s e;wj fogkj ds jsflms al ls vék gtkjs dks fxj rkj djuk D;k ukxfjd vfèkdkjks a dk j{k.k Fkk\ os dg jgs Fks fd oäo; vpnk gs] es a dguk pkgrh gw a fd mudk oäo; vlr; dk iqçynk gsa vè;{k th] ftl rjg ls dy ns'k z"vkpkj ds f[kykq m}sfyr gqvk gs] z"vkpkj ds f[kykq tks yksx?kjks a ls ckgj fudyrs gsa ;s ljdkj mu ij vr;kpkj djrh gs] ;s ljdkj z"vkpkjh h gs vksj vr;kpkjh h gsa vh ml rjq ls dksbz dg jgk Fkk fd vkj,l,l dks yksx] vxj vkj,l,l dk lefkzu fdlh vkanksyu dks fey tk,] rks x`g ea=h dks irk ugè D;k gks tkrk gs] fqj os mÿksftr gks tkrs gsaa çèkku ea=h th] esa iwnuk pkgrh gw a fd blh fnyyh ds vanj ftykuh ds usr`ro es a vyxkooknh vkdj k"k.k nsdj pys tkrs gs a] vkidh fnyyh iqfyl pw a h ugè djrha muds ukxfjd vfèkdkjks a ds j{kd vki t:j gsa] ysfdu vxj dksbz xokos'k es lkèkq vk tk,] vxj dksbz xkaèkh Vksih yxk, xkaèkhoknh vk tk, vksj vxj dksbz vkj,l,l dk lefkzd vk tk,] rks vko ns[kk u rko] cl ykfb;ka pykvksa ;gh dke djus dh vkius ckr dh gsa os tks vkj,l,l dh ckr dj jgs gsa] esa muls iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd vkidks vkj,l,l ls fp< D+;ks a gs\ vjs] vkj,l,l rks,d ns'kä lalfkk gsa vè;{k th] bl lnu ds 116 lkaln vkj,l,l ds çfr J)k j[krs gsa] ml lnu ds 45 lkaln vkj,l,l ds çfr J)k j[krs gsa] ns'k ds 7 jkt;ksa ds eq[;ea=h vkj,l,l ds çfr J)k j[krs gsa vksj vki le>rs gsa fd vkj,l,l dks ns'k dk lefkzu ugè gs\ ysfdu,d ckj vxj fdlh vkanksyu dks vkj,l,l dk lefkzu fey tk, rks iwjh dh iwjh ljdkj mÿksftr gks tkrh gsa blfy, es a iwnuk pkgrh gw a çèkku ea=h th fd vkius ckj&ckj bl oäo; esa fnyyh iqfyl dk uke fy;ka dy bl ljdkj ds pkj&pkj ea=h psuyksa ij tkdj ljdkj dk cpko D;k dgrs gq, dj jgs Fks fd gesa D;k ekywe] iqfyl dfe'uj tkusa tc ekuuh; fpnecje th ls iwnk x;k fd vék gtkjs dgka gsa rks mugksaus dgk fd eq>s ugè irk] iqfyl dfe'uj ls iwnks\ ekuuh; ea=h th] vki lnu ls tk D;ksa jgs gsa] vkius dgk Fkk fd eq>s ugè irk] iqfyl dfe'uj ls iwnksa dy jkr dks psuy ij ukjk;.k lkeh] vfecdk lksuh ckj&ckj dg jgs Fks fd eftlvªsv ls iwnks fd D;ksa mudks can fd;k] D;ksa mudks fjgk fd;k vksj vkt ekuuh; çèkkuea=h th us ogh dh ogh ckr ;gka fy[k nha lqcg rks eftlvªsv dks ;g yx jgk Fkk D;ksafd fnyyh iqfyl us dgk fd os 'kkafr ax dj ns axs] mudk vkanksyu Çgld gks tk,xk] blfy, mugs a lkr fnu ds fy, frgkm+ st fn;ka ysfdu 'kke dks fnyyh iqfyl dks yxk fd,slk ugè gksxk D;ksafd mugksaus,d ;kfpdk Mky nh] blfy, mugsa NksM+ fn;ka vè;{k th] ;g ljdkj vfu.kz; dh flfkfr es a gs vksj ;g ljdkj vius fy, fu.kz; h vksv ugè ikrha 3 4

4 a egksn;k] esa çèkkuea=h th ls iwnuk pkgrh gw a fd D;k dksbz vkids bl vkx;zwesav dks ck; djsxk] D;k ns'k bls Lohdkjsxk fd çèkkuea=h dks irk ugè vksj fnyyh ds iqfyl dfe'uj r; dj jgs gsa fd dgka vu'ku gksxk] fdrus fnu dk vu'ku gksxk] fdrus yksx vk,axs vksj esftlvªsv r; dj jgk gs fd os lkr fnu rd tsy es a jgs axs ;k 'kke rd tsy es a jgs axsa vkius bles dgk gs fd geus damh'kul yxkbz gsaa esa vkils iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd ;s damh'kul dksu&ls dkuwu ds rgr yxkbz gs aa vki dgrs gs a fd vki çksvslv djus ds vfèkdkj dks ekurs gsa] ysfdu og çksvslv fdruk cm+k gksxk] ;g vki r; djsaxsa vu'ku fdrus fnu dk gksxk] ;g vki r; djsaxsa ogka fdruh dkjsa vk,axh] ;g vki r; djsaxsa dksbz 3 fnu ds fy, vu'ku djs ;k 9 fnu ds fy, vu'ku djs] D;k ;g ljdkj r; djsxha geus vh ns'k dh vktknh ds 64 o"kz iwjs fd, gsaa bl ns'k us lafoèkku cuk;k vksj lafoèkku us jkbv Vw çksvslv fn;k gsa tgka rd fcy dk loky gs] ljdkjh fcy ij gekjh vkifÿk;ka gsa] ogka tu yksdiky ds reke çkoèkkuks a ls h ge lger ugè gsaa ge dg pqds gs a fd ym+kbz fcy dh ugè gs] ym+kbz tu yksdiky cuke ljdkjh yksdiky dh ugè gsa ljdkjh yksdiky fcy,d fu"çkoh foèks;d gs] ;g fcy ds bavªksmd'ku ds le; es aus dgk FkkA mls çkoh cukus ds fy, LVS açmx desvh esa ge iwjh dksf'k'k dj jgs gsa vksj iwjh dksf'k'k djsaxs] ysfdu ;g ym+kbz ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa ds guu dh gsa tc vkmok.kh th o"kz 1975 dh ckr dgrs gsa] rks mugè ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa ds guu dh ckr dgrs gsa vksj tks vyksdrkaf=d jos;k ljdkj lnu ds ckgj viukrh gs] ogh vyksdrkaf=d jos;k ljdkj lnu ds vanj viuk dj foi{k dh vkokt dks can djus dk dke djrh gsa lkjh laosèkkfud lalfkkvks a dh e;kznk dks vkius ax djus dk dke fd;k gsa lh,am,sth ij vkids yksx lnu ds ckgj gh ugè lnu ds vanj h çgkj djrs gs aa ih,lh ds vanj vkids yksx gqyym+ epkrs gs aa,d lalfkk Lihdj dh :Çyx] Lihdj dh ihb cph Fkh] dy lalnh; dk;z ea=h th Lihdj dh :Çyx dks pquksrh ns dj vkius ml lalfkk dh e;kznk dks h ugè NksM+k gsa blhfy, dy vkmok.kh th vkids ikl x, vksj gekjs ofj"b yksx vanj x, rfkk mugksaus dgk fd de ls de vkidh :Çyx dk leeku rks lalnh; dk;z ea=h dks djuk pkfg,] ysfdu og h mugks aus ugè fd;ka esa vkils dguk pkgrh gw a fd z"vkpkj,d cm+k fo"k; gs] ml ij ge yksxks a us vyx ls ppkz ekaxh gsa z"vkpkj ds fo"k; ij ge yksx 193 ds rgr ppkz djds bl ljdkj dh iwjh iksy [kksysaxs] ysfdu vkids ;gka ls ;g tks oäo; vkt vk;k gs] mlesa ftl rjg ls lppkbz dks fnik;k x;k gs] dy vék gtkjs th ds lkfk ftl rjg ls O;ogkj fd;k gs] vxj os dg jgs gs a fd es a frgkm+ tsy ls fjgk ugè gksåaxka ns'k vkidks ekq ugè djsxk vksj ns'k lm+dks a ij mrjk gqvk gsa cpps ;wfuolêvh NksM+ dj] dseil NksM+ dj ckgj vk x, gs aa odhy vnkyrs a can djds ckgj gs aa tsy ds vanj vék gtkjs th dk vu'ku py jgk gsa es a vkils dguk pkgrh gw a fd ftl ikfyz;kesavjh çkslsl dh vki ckr dj jgs gsa] ml ikfyz;kesavjh çkslsl ds lkfk ge gsaa ge lqçheslh vkq ikfyz;kesav dks fdlh rjg vamjekbu u gksus nsaxs vksj u igys gksus fn;k gsa o"kz 1975 esa blh laln dh lqçheslh dks vkius [kafmr djus dk dke fd;k FkkA ge u T;wMhf'k;jh dh lqçheslh [kafmr gksus nsaxs vksj u ikfyz;kesav dh lqçheslh [kafmr gksus nsaxs] ysfdu ukxfjd vfèkdkj lcls Åij gsaa ns'k vkt vktkn gsa vkt oru vktkn gs vksj bl vktkn oru esa ukxfjd vfèkdkjksa dk guu vxj ljdkj djsxh] rks ge mldk iqjtksj fojksèk djsaxs rfkk vkids bl oäo; dks esa fljs ls udkjrh gwaa bugè 'kcnksa ds lkfk esa viuh ckr lekir djrh gwaa 5 6

5 rsyaxkuk jkt; xbu rsyaxkuk eqís ij dkaxzsl us dh oknkf[kykqh Þrsyaxkuk jkt; ds xbu esa gq, foyac ls mriuu flfkfr rfkk bl lacaèk esa ljdkj }kjk mbk, x, dneß ij yksdlhkk esa foi{k dh usrk Jherh lq"kek Lojkt }kjk fn, x, Hkk"k.k dk leikfnr ikb % vè;{k egksn;k] vkaèkz çns'k ds rsyaxkuk {ks= ls 17,eIkht bl lnu esa thrdj vkrs gsa] ysfdu 13,eIkht us viuh ihm+k vksj vkøks'k dks vfhko;fdr nsrs gq, bl lnu dh lnl;rk ls blrhqk ns fn;ka vkaèkz çns'k dh foèkku lhkk esa 119 yksx rsyaxkuk jhtu ls thrdj vkrs gsa vksj 101 yksxksa us vkaèkz çns'k dh foèkkulhkk ls blrhqk ns fn;ka vhkh vkids lkeus,d lkfkh mèkj ls cksy jgs Fks fd rsyaxkuk ds fo"k; esa ppkz gksuh pkfg,a bugksaus ftu rhuksa ds uke fy, gsa] mu rhuksa vksj,d vu; ;kuh pkj lnl;ksa us fjtkbu ugha fd;k vksj 13 us fjtkbu fd;k gsa ftu rhuksa ds uke gsa] ;g lp gs fd bu rhuksa us fjtkbu ugha fd;ka ftu pkj yksxksa us fjtkbu ugha fd;k] bugksaus muds uke fy, gsa fd Jh t;ikky jsìh us fjtkbu ugha fd;k vksj ckdh nks us fjtkbu ugha fd;ka ysfdu vè;{k th] esa ;g ckr blfy, dg jgh Fkh fd ns'k dh yksd lhkk vksj vkaèkz çns'k dh foèkku lhkk es a èkhjs&èkhjs cstqcku gks jgs rsyaxkuk dks tqcku nsus ds fy, es aus ;g è;kukd"kz.k çlrko vkt çlrqr fd;ka vè;{k th] rsyaxkuk dk bfrgkl,d rjq la?k"kz dh xkfkkvksa ls Hkjk gqvk gs] ysfdu nwljh rjq fo'okl?kkr ds çlaxksa ls Hkh ivk im+k gsa irk ugha bl lnu es a fdrus yksxks a dks ;g ekywe gs fd Hkkjr 15 vxlr] 1947 dks vktkn gqvk] ysfdu rsyaxkuk mlds lkfk vktkn ugha gqvka rsyaxkuk 17 flrecj] 1948 dks vktkn gqvk] ;kuh Hkkjr dh vktknh ds Hkh,d o"kz ls T;knk la?k"kz djds] gtkjksa yksxksa ds cfynku ds ckn rsyaxkuk dks vktknh feyha vhkh os vktknh dh iwjh [kq'kh euk Hkh ugha ik jgs Fks fd muds flj ij vkaèkz çns'k ds lkfk foy; dh ryokj yvd x;ha os yksx vkaèkz çns'k ds lkfk foy; ugha pkgrs Fks] blfy, fojksèk 'kq: gqvka o"kz 1953 esa,d Qty vyh deh'ku csbka mugksaus dgk fd ;g foy; mfpr ugha gksxk vksj vxj foy; djuk gh gs] rks o"kz 1961 dk,d pquko gks tkus nksa ogka rsyaxkuk ds jhtu ls vk;s gq, vxj nks&frgkbz foèkk;d ;g dgsa fd vkaèkz çns'k esa foy; dj nks] rc djuk ojuk er djuka vè;{k egksn;k] esa mèkj csbs gq, lkffk;ksa dks ;kn fnykuk pkgrh gwa fd ns'k ds çfke çèkkuea=h] cgqr ikiqyj çèkkuea=h] iafmr tokgj yky usg: th ml le; çèkkuea=h FksA mugksaus bl foy; dks csesy crkrs gq, ;g dgk Fkk fd vkaèkz vksj rsyaxkuk dk foy; mlh rjg ls gs ftl rjg ls,d buksls av ym+dh],d Hkksyh&Hkkyh ym+dh dh 'kknh,d felphfo;l c ;],d 'kjkjrh ym+ds ls dj nh tk;sa mugks aus ;g dgk Fkk fd ;g 'kknh ugha pysxha tc ;g 'kknh u pys] rks ;g ifr&iruh dh rjg vyx&vyx gks tk;saa vè;{kk th] esa fdlh HkktikbZ usrk dks dksv ugha dj jgha ;g iafmr th dk cgqpfpzr dksv gs] tks ml le; ds v[kckjksa esa Nik FkkA esa bugsa dguk pkgrh gwa fd 6 ekpz] 1956 dk bafm;u,dlçsl fudky dj ns[k ysa] buovszm dksekt esa ;g dksv Nik gqvk gsa vè;{kk th] rsyaxkuk ds yksxksa ds fojksèk ds ckotwn ;g foy; gks x;ka vè;{kk th] rsyaxkuk ds yksxksa ds fojksèk ds ckotwn foy; gks x;ka foy; dks lqpk: :i ls pykus ds fy, cgqr ç;ru fd;s x;sa rjg&rjg ds QkewZys viuk, tsls eqydh :Yl] çsftmsaf'k;y vkmzlz] QkewZyk uecj fldl] thvks uecj 610] fxxykuh deh'ku cuka brus mik; fd, x,] ysfdu muesa ls dksbz Hkh dkjxj lkfcr ugha gqvk D;ksafd lkjs mik; dkxtks a es a jg x,] èkjrh ij ugha mrj ik,a bl lcdk urhtk ogh gqvk& etz c<+rk x;k T;ksa&T;ksa nok dha ;g iqjkuk bfrgkl blfy, crk;k D;ksafd esaus igys dgk Fkk fd rsyaxkuk ds fuekz.k esa nsjh gks jgh gs] 'kk;n 7 8

6 a x`gea=h th bjhvsv gks jgs gsa] esa mugsa crkuk pkgrh FkhA esa bl ij T;knk le; ugha ys jgh gwaa ;g bfrgkl crkuk t:jh Fkk rkfd lnu dks ;g le> esa vk tk, fd foy; dh i`"bhkwfe D;k gsa vc esa orzeku ij vk jgh gwa vksj orzeku 'kq: d:axh o"kz 2004 ls] ;wih, dh igyh ljdkj lsa o"kz 2004 esa dkaxzsl dk Vhvkj,l ds lkfk le>ksrk gqvk] bdës pquko esnku esa x,a ml le; dkaxzsl dh vè;{kk us djhe uxj dh,d lhkk es a yksxks a dks vk'oklu fn;k fd ge rsyaxkuk dk fuekz.k djsaxsa yksxksa us fo'okl fd;k vksj >ksyh Hkj&Hkjdj budks oksv fn,a mlds ckn ;s ljdkj esa vk x,] ljdkj esa Vhvkj,l budk,d ikvzuj FkkA ikvzuj cuus ds ckn bugksaus,d lh,eih cuk;ka vhkh dksbz Hkh ;gka csbs ugha gsaa,d lh,eih cuka ml lh,eih esa bugksaus rhu jkbmlz ds lkfk rsyaxkuk dh fmek.m ds ckjs esa fy[kk % "The UPA Government will consider the demand for the formation of the State at an appropriate time after due consultations and consensus." rhu jkbmlz bugks aus yxk,a ;g ebz] 2004 dk lh,eih gs tc ljdkj cuha mlds ckn twu esa igyk jk"vªifr vfhkhkk"k.k gqvka mlh lh,eih ls Hkk"kk mbkbz x;h] exj,d jkbmj gvk fn;k x;ka esa jk"vªifr vfhkhkk"k.k ls i<+ jgh gwa % "The Government will consider the demand for the formation of a State at an appropriate time and after due consultations." blesa dalsull 'kcn gv x;ka gesa yxk boksy;w'ku gqvk gs] rhu jkbmlz Fks lh,eih esa] ysfdu 'kk;n ljdkj okdbz xahkhj gs vksj os dalyvs'kul dh ckr djds :d x, D;ksafd 'kk;n dalsull gksuk lahko ugha Fkk] rks dalsull 'kcn gvk fn;k x;ka ;g jk"vªifr dk vfhkhkk"k.k gs tks ljdkj dk uhfr funs Z'kd fl)kur gksrk gs] ftldks ekuuk ljdkj dh fteesnkjh gksrh gsa bldks rks vki ekusaxs\ lh,eih ds vkèkkj ij jk"vªifr vfhkhkk"k.k gqvk vksj mugksaus,d jkbmj gvkdj nks jkbmj dj fn,a o"kz 2004 ls 2009 rd] iwjk dk;zdky fudy x;k] ysfdu og mfpr le; ugha vk;ka dalyvs'kul gqbz gks axh] cgqr jktusfrd mbkivd gqbz] Vhvkj,l ls le>ksrk VwVk] mugksaus fjtkbu fd;k] nqckjk pqudj vk,] fqj fjtkbu fd;ka ml iwjs jktuhfrd?kvukøe esa esa ugha tkuk pkgrh gw aa o"kz 2004 ds ckn o"kz 2009 dk pquko gqvk] rsyaxkuk ds yksxks a us lkspk fd 'kk;n ges Vhvkj,l dks T;knk ftrk fn;k Fkk] blfy, gedks rsyaxkuk ugha feyk] bl ckj dkaxzsl dks >ksyh Hkj&Hkj ftrkvks] rks 'kk;n gesa rsyaxkuk fey tk,a,d meehn Hkjh fuxkg ls mugksaus oksv fn;k vksj rsyaxkuk ls 17 esa ls 12,eih dkaxzsl ds thrdj vk, ftuesa ls,d lnl; vhkh ;gka csbs gsaa gka] nks csbs gsa] rhkh esaus dgk fd pkj bèkj csbs gsa] 13 blrhqk nsdj pys x,] blrhqk vkidk Hkh gs] exj vki gkml vvsam dj jgs gsaa vpnh ckr gs] vki gkml vvsam dj jgs gsa] rks esjh tcku esa tcku feykus okyk dksbz,d Loj rks gsa vè;{k th] o"kz 2009 ds pquko es a 12 lkaln ogka ls dkaxz sl ds thrdj vk,] ysfdu N% eghus rd dksbz dne vkxs ugha c<+k] rks 29 uoacj] 2009 dks Vhvkj,l ds usrk ds-,l- jko us vu'ku fd;ka ;g fo"k; 7 uoacj] 2009 dks es aus bl lnu es a mbk;k FkkA es a vkt igyh ckj rsyaxkuk ij ugha cksy jgh gwaa rsyaxkuk dk fuekz.k esjk ;g ges'kk fç; fo"k; jgk gs D;ksafd gekjs ;gka ls ogka,d Hkh,eih thrk ugha gsa fiazfliy viksft'ku ikvhz ds ukrs ;g gekjk QtZ curk gsa igys usrk] çfri{k ds rksj ij vkmok.kh th ges'kk cksyrs jgs vksj esa crkmaxh fd vkmok.kh th us D;k&D;k cksyk\ vc esa usrk] çfri{k ds ukrs esa cksyrh gwa D;ksafd dksbz fiazfliy viksft'ku ikvhz brus cm+s fo"k; ls vius vkidks vyx ugha j[k ldrh gsa vè;{k th] 7 fnlecj dks esa cksyh vksj og fo"k; esaus ;gka mbk;ka,d fnu ds ckn ;kuh 9 fnlecj dks vkius ps;j ls bavjohu fd;ka dslh- jko th dh gkyr fcxm+ jgh FkhA vkius ps;j ls dgk fd iwjs dk iwjk lnu muds ckjs esa fpafrr gs] dqn gksuk pkfg,a mlds ckn lnu esa gj ikvhz ds usrk cksysa xq#nkl nklxqirk th csbs gsa] og cksys] 'kjn ;kno th cksys] eqyk;e flag th cksys] ykyw th cksys] vuar xhrsth cksys] vtukyk th cksysa dksbz,slk O;fDr ugha Fkk tks ;gka u cksyk gksa ;g 9 fnlecj dh ckr gs vksj 9 fnlecj cgqr vge~ gs rsyaxkuk ds bfrgkl dh ftanxh es a blfy, es a bldh ckr dj jgh gw aa vki 9 fnlecj dks cksyha] vkids ckn lkjs usrk cksysa fqj ljdkj gjdr esa vkbza,d la;ksx cuk] 10 fnlecj dks Jherh lksfu;k xkaèkh dk tue fnu gksrk gsa 9 fnlecj dh jkr dks] 9 10

7 a vkt ds x`g ea=h Jh fpnecje us] vèkzjkf= dks?kks"k.kk dha og?kks"k.kk esa i<+dj lqukuk pkgrh gwaa The Home Minister Shri P. Chidambaram, late in the night said: "The process of forming the State of will be initiated and appropriate Resolution will be moved in the Assembly. We are concerned about Rao's health. We request him to withdraw his fast immediately. We also appeal to all concerned specially students to withdraw their agitation and help restore normalcy." lkjs jkbmlz blesa ls gv x,a u dalysvs'kal] u dalsall],d dsvsxksfjd,';ksjs al x`gea=h th dh rjq ls vk;k vksj vèkzjkf= dks vk;ka mlh le; rsyaxkuk esa ivk[ks QwVus yxsa ogka ds yksxksa dks ;g yxk fd Jherh lksfu;k xkaèkh ds tue fnu dk rksgqk ns'k ds x`gea=h us mugs a fn;k gsa vkfr'kckth gqbz] jkr dks nhokyh gqbza igyh ckj rsyaxkuk ds yksxksa dks ;g meehn iwjh gksrh yxh] D;ksafd gkse fefulvj us ;g dgk & The process of forming the State of will be initiated and appropriate Resolution will be moved in the Assembly. bles a dgha dalysv'kal vksj dalsall dh ckr ugha FkhA mugsa yxk fd tuefnu dk rksgqk feyk gsa ;g vpnh ckr FkhA vki vpnh ckr dks cqjk D;ksa ekurs gksa esaus dgk fd bl ij [kq'k gksdj yksxksa us ivk[ks QksM+sA es aus dgk fd rsyaxkuk ds yksxks a us ivk[ks QksM+ sa mudh meehn fo'okl esa cny xbz gs] D;ksafd rkjh[k vge~ gks xbza vki vpnh ckr dks Hkh cqjk eku jgs gsaa vki eq>s FkksM+k lk cksyus dk eksdk nsa] esa FkksM+k lk bamytsal vkils pkgrh gwa] vkils fjdoslv djrh gwaa vè;{k th] 10 fnlecj dks tc lnu dh csbd 'kq: gqbz] rc usrk çfri{k vkmok.kh th [km+s gq,a vkmok.kh th us dgk fd ÞeSa cgqr vkhkkjh gw a vki eq>s volj ns jgh gsaa esa lnu dks bl ckr ds fy, cèkkbz nw a fd vkius lnu esa ftl çdkj vkaèkz çns'k dh flfkfr esa glr{ksi djds,d u;k mnkgj.k çlrqr fd;k gsa laln ds glr{ksi ds dkj.k ljdkj us,d cgqr gh egroiw.kz fu.kz; fy;k gsa blds fy, esa ljdkj dks Hkh cèkkbz vksj laln dks Hkh cèkkbz nsuk pkgrk gw a] ftu nks ckrks ds ckjs esa lnu esa dy fpark çdv dh xbz FkhA mu nksuksa ckrksa dk,d çdkj ds lekèkku gks x;ka ge pkgrs Fks fd rsyaxkuk dh turk dh bpnk ds vuqlkj rsyaxkuk çns'k cusa ge pkgrs Fks fd gekjh laln ds lkfkh tks nl fnu ls vu'ku ij Fks] ftuds LokLF; dh gkyr fparktud gks xbz Fkh] muds thou dks fdlh Hkh çdkj dh gkfu u igqaps] ;s nksuksa ckrsa gks xbza] eq>s bldh cgqr [kq'kh gs vksj blds fy, esa vkidks cèkkbz nsrk gwaaß vè;{k th] esa ;g ckr dsoy blfy, dg jgh gwa fd dsoy rsyaxkuk esa gh ugha] cfyd lnu dh Hkh meehn fo'okl esa cny xbza gesa yxk fd ljdkj us,d egroiw.kz fu.kz; fy;k gsa nl fnlecj dks ç.kc eq[kthz lkgc Hkh ;gka cksys Fks vksj cèkkbz nh lnu esa] D;ksafd gesa ;g yxk fd uks fnlecj dk og fnu ekbylvksu cusxk] ehy dk irfkj cusxk] rsyaxkuk ds fuekz.k esaa ysfdu vè;{k th] eq>s gsjkuh gs fd 9 fnlecj dks bl lnu esa ;g lc?kvrk gs] rsyaxkuk esa ivk[ks pyrs gsaa ysfdu 23 rkjh[k dks x`gea=h th cny x;s vksj 14 fnu ds vanj x`gea=h dk c;ku vk x;k] there is no consensus on creation. es a iwnuk pkgrh gw a fd tc jk"vªifr vfhkhkk"k.k esa vkius dalsall 'kcn gvk fn;k Fkk] vkius dgk Fkk dsoy okbmj dalyvs'kul] uks dalsall] vkius dksbz ckr dalsll dh ugha dh FkhA 23 fnlecj dks tcfd çkslsl buhf'k,v gks tkuk pkfg, Fkk vkius dalsall dh ckr djds okfil back to square one ykdj [km+k dj fn;ka 23 fnlecj dks ;s cny x;s vksj bl lkjs esa ls fudyk] tflvl Jhd`".kk deh'ku] ftldk ftø vhkh viuh fjiksvz es a] vhkh vius odro; es a x`gea=h th us fd;k gsa esa vkt dguk pkgrh gwa] fcuk ladksp ds dguk pkgrh gwa fd tflvl Jhd`".kk deh'ku us ftruk batflvl rsyaxkuk ds lkfk fd;k gs] mls rsyaxkuk dk bfrgkl dhkh Hkwysxk ughaa vki eq>s dsoy ikap feuv nsaa ekuuh; x`gea=h th dk iwjk odro; Jhd`".kk desvh fjiksvz ij gs vksj vkius dgk gs fd mugks aus 6 Qkew Zys vkidks fn;sa ysfdu ;g igyh ckj gqvk gs vè;{k th fd brus deh'ku vksj desfv;ka bl ns'k es a cuha] ges'kk mudh fjiksvz lkoztfud rksj ij nh tkrh gsa ysfdu igyk deh'ku gs ftlus lkoztfud fjiksvz vyx ls nh gs vksj,d xqir fjiksvz vyx nh gs],d lhøsv fjiksvz mugksaus bugsa vyx ls nh gs vksj og lhøsv fjiksvz ftldk ftø x`gea=h th us vius odro; es a ugha 11 12

8 fd;ka blhfy, esa iwnuk pkgrh gwa fd D;k okdbz,d lhøsv fjiksvz Jhd`".kk deh'ku us vkidks nh gs vksj vxj ;s euk djsa rks mldk tokc Hkh esa nsrh gw a ysfdu ;s euk dj ugha ldrs gsaa D;ks afd vkt ds ;qx es a dksbz pht xqir jg ugha ldrh] [kksth i=dkj lc dqn fudky ykrs gsaa vc rks fjiksvsaz igys yhd gks tkrh gsaa dkaxzsl ds gh,d iwoz lkaln Jh,eukjk;.k jsìh us,d ;kfpdk vkaèkzçns'k gkbzdksvz esa nk;j dha mugksaus ;g dgk fd gesa ;g irk pyk gs fd d`".kk deh'ku us tks fjiksvz nh gs mlesa,d lhøsv fjiksvz Hkh nh gs vksj ml lhøsv fjiksvz dks ikfcyd fd;k tk,] ;g çkfkzuk mugksaus dha ftl csap ds lkeus ;g ihfv'ku yxh] ml csap ds yksxksa us ljdkj ls dgk fd vxj,slk dksbz M D;qesaV gs rks vkidks mls gekjs ikl ykuk gksxka og fjiksvz mugks aus ogka nha vè;{k th] esa dgha vksj ls ugha] esa ml ttesav ls i<+ jgh gwaa og ttesav ifcyd Mksesu esa gsa ttesav dk v ijs'ku LVs gqvk gsa esa dsoy ;g dg jgh gwa vki ugha dg ldrs gsa fd fjiksvz ugha vkbza esa blfy, ugha csbw axh] D;ks afd blh ls iksy [kqysxh] vki esjh iwjh ckr lqfu,a egksn;k] esa viuh ckr tynh lekir d:axha tt us dgk & "The Committee travelled beyond the Terms of Reference in its endeavour to persuade the Union of India not to accede to the demand for. It is demonstrated in a three-page supplementary note appending to the note representing Chapter 8." mugks aus ekuk fd,d psivj uksv,d gsa vki gsjku gks tk,axh] og uksv gs ikfyfvdy esustes av dfj,] ehfm;k esustes av dfj,a es a lnu dks pks adkus okyh phtsa dg jgh gwaa ml uksv esa fy[kk gs & "There is a need for ensuring unity among the leaders of the Ruling Party in the State. There is also a need for providing strong and firm political leadership and placement of representatives of in key positions. This aspect was discussed with FM and HM in September Action also needs to be initiated for softening the TRS to the extent possible. " "The Congress high command must sensitize its own MPs and MLAs and educate them about the wisdom for arriving at an acceptable and workable solution. With the Ruling Party and main Opposition Party being brought on the same page, these support mechanisms have a higher probability of becoming successful. " og uksv dgrk gs fd ehfm;k esust dfj,a ehfm;k esustesav ds fy, dgk gs fd ogka brus bysdvªksfud psuyl gsa] brus fiazv ds psuyl gsaa egksn;k] tflvl jsìh dgrs gsa & "More disturbing is the suggestion given by the Committee to the Government." More disturbing is the suggestion given by the Committee to the Government and it reads: "The print media is hugely dependent on the Government for advertisement revenue and if carefully handled can be an effective tool to achieve this goal." egksn;k] ;g fjiksvz gsa ;g tflvl Jh d`".kk deh'ku dh fjiksvz ugha gs] ;g,vkbzlhlh dh fjiksvz gs vksj vkt rd,slh fjiksvz ugha vkbz gsa esa vhkh vksfksavhdsv djds j[k nsrha ;g ttesav dh dkih gsa x`gea=h th] esaus ;s ckrsa blfy, j[kha] D;ksafd ogka rjg&rjg ds èkks[ks gks jgs gsaa ;g tks ljdkj dh gjdr gs] blls grk'k gks dj yksx vkregr;k,a dj jgs gsaa finys Ms<+ o"kz esa 600 yksx ej x,a egksn;k] vki eq>s csbus ds fy, dg jgh gs a] es a tks ckr dgus tk jgh gw a] mls lqudj vkidk fny ngy tk,xka fnyyh es a,d ym+dk vk;k] ftldk uke ;knh jsìh FkkA og bruk cm+k rsyxq dk uksv vkregr;k djus ls igys fy[k dj x;ka esa dsoy pkj ykbus a vkidks i<+ dj lqukuk pkgrh gw aa ml ym+ds us fnyyh es a vkregr;k dha mlus fy[kk fd gsnjkckn Vªsu p<+us ls igys cgqr lkjs [;kyks a es a dqn lksprk gqvk ;gka vk x;ka esa pkgrk Fkk fd ek ds gkfk dk [kkuk [kkdj vksj vk'khokzn ysdj vkåa] ysfdu yxk fd dgha isj ihns u gv tk,a] blfy,,slk ugha fd;ka esa viuk bykdk NksM+ dj tk jgk gw aa esaus fdrus lius ns[ks FksA esa rsyaxkuk NksM+ dj tk jgk gwaa eu esa iwjk nq[k gsa lp cksyuk gs] eq>s ugha ekywe fd esa ;gka dsls vk x;ka ;gka vkus ds ckn eu esa,d gh bpnk gs vksj dqn ugha lksp jgk gwaa esaus tks lkspk] og d:axka rsyaxkuk gksus ds fy, esa Hkh Hkkxhnkj cuwaxka vè;{k th] eq>s yxrk Fkk fd ;g ftruk lathnk fo"k; gs] mruh lathnxh ls eq>s cksyus fn;k tk,xk ysfdu mruh lathnxh ls eq>s cksyus ugha fn;k x;k] VksdkVksdh dh xbza blfy, esa x`gea=h th] vkils T;knk 13 14

9 dqn u iwnrs gq,,d fuosnu djuk pkgrh gw a fd ;g dals all cgqr gks xbz] vc vkius çsl fjtksy;w'ku dh ckr dh gs ftldks phq fefulvj us dgk fd t:jr ugha gsa esjk ;g dguk gs fd eq>s dqn ugha iwnuk gsa eq>s,d fuosnu djuk gs] vki rsyaxkuk dk fcy ysdj vkb,] ;g dkalvhv~;w'kuy ves ames av fcy gs] nks&frgkbz lkaln vkidks pkfg,] ge oks lkaln tqvk,axsa ç.ko nk] vkius dy ;g vihy dh Fkh fd ge tks fcy yk jgs gsa] mu fcyksa ij foi{k vkdj lkfk nsa vkt esa vihy dj jgh gwa] vki fcy ykb,a ge lc lkfk nsaxs vksj rsyaxkuk dk fuekz.k gksuk pkfg,a ysfdu vxj esa vkils vksj ljdkj ls fcy ykus ds fy, vihy dj jgh gwa rks esa lnu ls Hkh vihy dj jgh gwa fd gesa rsyaxkuk ds fy, ejus okys yksxksa ls,d vihy djuh pkfg,a gesa dguk pkfg, fd os ejsa ugha] cfyd os rsyaxkuk curk gqvk ns[kus ds fy, ftank jgsaa mu yksxksa dk ejuk ns'k ds fgr esa ugha gksxka blfy, esa dsoy ogka ds vius cgu&hkkb;ksa ls,d vihy djuk pkgrh gwa%& "Sodhara, Sodharimanulaara, Telangana kosam balidaanam vaddhu. Telangana Choodadaaniki Brathakaali, Brathakaali" It means: "Brothers and sisters, do not sacrifice your lives for Telangana. You should live to see Telangana." Not only Lokpal or Janlokpal but citizen's rights at stake : Swaraj Calling the Congress led UPA Government not only corrupt but also repressive, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Smt. Sushma Swaraj described PM Manmohan Singh s statement on circumstances leading to Anna Hazares s arrest a bundle of lies that concealed more than it revealed. Smt. Swaraj blasted the Congress led UPA Government for trying to put the blame at Delhi Police s door for the entire arrest fiasco and hit out at Congress leaders for launching a personal attack on the social activist Shri Anna Hazare. We are publishing the synopsis of the speech made by Smt. Swaraj in Lok Sabha on August 18 for our readers. Istated in the beginning that we had sought structured discussion on the issue of corruption and we shall discuss it. But, all the leaders would like to make their comments on the statement made by Hon. Prime Minister. Before I set out to put forth my views on this statement, I would like to make one point. The Minister of Parliamentary Affairs is duty bound to ensure smooth functioning of the House. He has to ensure smooth conduct of the proceedings of the House with coordination with all the parties and groups and certainly by speaking less and maintaining his cool composure. However, the experience of the House shows that the conduct of the Minister of Parliamentary Affairs becomes more often than not the cause of disruption of the House. It happened yesterday and it has happened today also. Yesterday, he challenged the Ruling of the Chair. Today also he violated the Chair s observation immediately after the Chair had made a specific observation before the start of the discussion. Hon. Prime Minister made a long statement on the events of yesterday. Whether it is good or bad, the Chair will decide but we would say what we intend to say. The Members of the treasury benches cannot put their words in our mouth. I would like to categorically say that this statement reveals the truth less and muzzles the voice more. Hon. Prime Minister shifted the entire responsibility from the Government to the 15 16

10 shoulders of the Delhi Police. In this country, the anti-corruption campaign is going on for last so many days. As a result of which, three Members of the Ruling Party are languishing in the jail. Today this movement is being lead by Shri Anna Hazare but the attitude of the Government defies any sane thinking. The behaviour of the Government is disbalanced. This statement mentions of Parliamentary supremacy in 4-5 paragraphs. The Prime Minister's mention of Parliamentary processes and enactment of laws through the due process of Parliament. The very first question I would like to ask from the Prime Minister as to who threw to the wind the Parliamentary processes? Who decided to discuss this issue with the team Anna ignoring the entire Opposition? Five senior Minister of the Government including the Leader of the House sat with team Anna to draft the Bill. When Shri Anna visited us, we asked him as to why they kept the entire Opposition out, to which they replied that they had made this point to the Government that the members of the Opposition Parties should also be there on the Committee. But the Government replied that they themselves and the members of the team Anna are O.K. I would, therefore, like to ask if that was O.K. then why the tone and tennor of the Government changed after they fell apart. Then the Government turned to the Parliamentary process, wrote letters to us and called a meeting of the Opposition Parties. One senior Minister of the Ruling Party who sat with them in all meetings, later dubbed them as corrupt. The Spokesman of the ruling Party who is an Hon. Member of this House says that Anna Hazare is neck deep in corruption. I would like to make a humble advice to him that he has just started his political career and he is elected to this august House for the very first time, therefore, he should learn modesty and mind his language. Today, I would like to say to the Prime Minister that the Government is out to undermine the Parliamentary processes of which he is making mention in his statement. The second thing he has mentioned in the 11th paragraph of his statement that the Government acknowledges the rights of the citizens. There cannot be anything untrue than this. On the night of 4th June, who lathi charged the supporters of Swami Ramdev? Was it protection of citizens rights? Recently, on August 9, the workers of the BJYM were also lathi charged on the day of Quit India Movement. Was it also an attempt to protect the rights of the citizens? Was it also protection of citizens rights to arrest Shri Anna Hazare from a residence in Mayur Vihar who did not even violate the section 144? Some Hon. Member from the Ruling Party was saying that the statement made by the Prime Minister is good but I would like to very emphatically say that this is the pack of lies. The whole country was agitated on the issue of corruption yesterday but with its actions and conduct the Government has proved not only to be corrupt but oppressor also. If the RSS lends its support to any movement in the country then our Minister of Home Affairs gets very agitated. I would like to ask the Prime Minister that the separatists under the leadership of Shri Gilani come to Delhi and make anti-india speeches in Delhi but the Delhi Police does not move at all. Therefore, this Government is the protector of the rights of such people but when a saffron clad saint or any Gandhian bearing a Gandhi cap or an RSS activist comes to Delhi then he is lathi charged. I wonder as to why the Government is irked by the RSS. In fact, the RSS is a patriotic organization. As many as 116 members of this House, 45 Members of the other House and seven Chief Minister of States have faith in RSS. Yesterday, as many as four senior Ministers of this Government while defending the Government on different Channels were responding that such questions should be put to the Commissioner of Delhi Police. It simply shows that this Government is indecisive and is not able to defend its own decisions. Will anybody buy this argument that the Prime Minister is unaware of these issues and the Commissioner of Delhi Police is deciding as to where the fast would take place, as to for how many days the fast would be allowed and as to how many people will be allowed to participate. This nation has framed the Constitution and the Constitution has given the right to protest. As far as the Bill is concerned we also have some reservations about various provisions of the Jan Lokpal but now this fight is not for Lokpal or Jan Lokpal but the greater issue is that of citizen s rights. The kind of undemocratic attitude the government adopts outside the House, the same attitude it adopts inside the House to muzzle the voice of the Opposition. This Government has brazenly attempted to undermine and malign the dignity of the Constitutional Institutions. The CAG is attacked both inside and outside this House. The Members the ruling Party create unnecessary din in the PAC. One institution of Speaker was left but yesterday the Minister of Parliamentary Affairs challenged the Ruling of the Speaker thereby undermining the dignity of the Chair. This country will never forgive for the treatment meted out to Anna Hazare. The entire nation has come on to the roads. We the Opposition have never allowed and would never allow the supremacy of Parliament to be undermined. In the year 1975 this ruling party had assaulted the supremacy of Parliament. We shall not allow the supremacy and dignity of Parliament and Judiciary to be maligned but the citizens rights are top of all. Today, country is independent. If this Government tries to violate the rights of the citizens then we shall oppose it with full strength at our command and I reject this statement in full