Transportation Prospects for 2030 Vehicles

Transcription

1 Transportation Prospects for 2030 Vehicles Thirteenth Annual Washington Energy Policy Conference New Energy Dynamics - Recession and Beyond Washington, DC John German Senior Fellow, ICCT April 27, 2009

2 1. Technology Development 2. Fuels 3. Customers 4. Summary

3 Efficiency/CO2 Reduction Strategies Efficiency/CO2 reduction No single solution multi-pronged approach Fleet tests Research for mass production EV/FCV development for future HEV expansion Clean diesel Friction Variable reduction valves DI turbo Cylinder deactivation Transmissions Aero, tires HCCI weight High efficient gasoline engine Base engine and vehicle improvements

4 2002 NAS CAFE Report

5 Lightweight Materials! High strength steel - also improves safety! Aluminum Requires lots of electricity, price has been going up! Plastic Cheap, color goes below surface Less rigid and must paint! Carbon fiber Very strong and light Difficult to work with and expensive! Safety is extremely important! Must be able to manufacturer on assembly line! Must be able to repair and recycle or reuse

6 Next-generation Gasoline Engines Camless Valve Actuation HCCI Engine Lift sensor Upper spring Coil Armature Yoke Hydraulic tappet Lower spring Conventional EX IN Negative valve overlap EX NOL IN!"#!$%&#!'() Improvement in fuel economy: 30% Honda Prototype Engine Base ( Electro-magnetic valve ) 20 Heat release rate HCCI SI Crank angle [ATDC deg] Requires increasing the self-ignition region

7 Are We Looking the Wrong Way?! Combustion work focuses on raising output efficiency over typical driving cycles From roughly 20% to 35%! Heat losses are the 800-pound gorilla in the closet

8 i-dtec - Super Clean Diesel for US Improved Combustion New Combustion Chamber Design High Pressure Piezo Common Rail Lower Compression Ratio Combustion Pressure Sensor Closed-coupled Catalytic Converter! Diesel Particulate Filter (DPF) New Software LNC Control Combustion Control Cetane Estimation Under Floor Lean NOx CAT System Improved Lean NOx Catalyser Rich Air/Fuel Ratio Spike Control Sulfur Regeneration Emission Stabilizing System NOx O 2 HC,CO OBD-II System N 2 CO 2 + H 2 O Source: American Honda Motor Co.

9 Basic Hybrid System Designs 1) Belt-Driven Alternator/Starter 2) Integrated Motor Assist 3) Power-Split Battery Engine Battery Inverter Inverter Generator Inverter Motor Trans Engine Power Split Device Motor GM/BMW/Chrysler 2-mode is a power-split variation

10 Hybrid System Attributes Stop/ start Regen brake Alternator support Launch/P ower assist Electric drive BAS beltdriven alternator starter IMA integrated motor assist Powersplit 12v Yes Limited Limited 42v <100v >100v >100v Crank to idle Crank to idle Crank to idle Crank to idle Moderate Moderate Limited Moderate Moderate Moderate Extended Moderate Moderate Limited Extended Moderate Extended Moderate Increasing benefits and cost with each step

11 Crystal Ball is Very Cloudy! Improved gasoline engines keep raising the bar Especially a problem for diesels! Diesels: Towing, low rpm torque, highway efficiency But will public recognize improvements in noise, vibration, smell, starting, and emissions?! Hybrids: City efficiency and electrical synergies But reduces space and concerns about battery life! Market split? Diesels for larger vehicles and rural areas Hybrids for smaller vehicles and urban areas! Both must slash costs for mass market Diesels currently cheaper, but Tier 2 will add major costs Hybrid costs will likely decrease faster in the future

12 2007 MIT Study of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Plug-in Hybrids, Battery EVs, and Fuel Cell EVs.

13 2030/2035 Technology Comparison Toyota Camry with projected 2030/2035 technology Plug-in hybrid and conventional hybrid offer same GHG on U.S. average grid > 45 mpg Petroleum Consumption > 70 mpg Better GHG Source: 2007 MIT Study

14 Cost-Effectiveness Comparison All compared to 2030 NA-SI baseline Base Case: Estimated OEM battery cost from Tables 16 and 26 Units HEV PHEV-10 PHEV-30 PHEV-60 Battery Size kwh Specific Cost $/kwh $900 $420 $320 $270 Battery Cost $ $900 $1,450 $2,700 $4,500 Optimistic Case based on a $200/kWh battery Source: 2007 MIT Study

15 Future Hybrid Potential!Must compare to future gasoline engines Gasoline engines will improve dramatically!watch direction of battery development HEVs need higher power batteries Current batteries have 2 to 3 times excess energy storage, to ensure adequate power and durability PHEVs need higher energy batteries!high power Li-ion batteries currently in development will decrease HEV costs increasing PHEV cost premium

16 Plug-In Hybrid Future Challenges Battery durability will be shorter Deep discharge cycles Higher loads at lower SOC Battery pack uses ~ 4 cu. ft. Reduced vehicle utility Battery pack adds lbs Lower FE and performance Requires safe off-board charging system operation Limits market May affect resale value Cost Larger motor and power electronics Battery Market Acceptance Niche market is coming Mass market needs: Order of magnitude reduction in battery costs; Oil shortages; or Large conventional hybrid market share

17 The Real Barrier - Leadtime! Too many technology options, each with uncertain costs and benefits! Must allow time to ensure quality and reliability Rigorous product development process Prove in production on a limited number of vehicles Spread across fleet 5-year minimum product cycles Enormous capitol costs! Longer leadtime is needed for new technologies! Costs increase dramatically if normal development cycles are not followed

18 1. Technology Development 2. Fuels Customers Summary

19 A Critical Barrier to E85 Reduced Energy Density Fuel Type Performance Specification Diesel Gasoline E10 E85 Butanol Megajoules/litre BTU/U.S. gallon 147, , ,900 84, ,800 RON MON mile range on gasoline drops to 215 miles on E85

20 Next-Generation Biofuel Pathways Multiple pathways possible from non-food biomass. Many pathways result in fuels that are fungible with today s fuels. Some examples for liquid transportation fuels are shown here. Ligno-Cellulosic Biomass Crops Residue / Waste Micro-Algae Waste Oils & Fats Sacharification Gasification Pyrolysis Hydrotreating Dehydration / Hydrogenation Fermentation Fischer- Tropsch Ethanol & Butanol Gasoline-like Fuels Diesel-like Fuels

21 1. Technology Development 2. Fuels 3. Customers 3. Summary

22 Consumers are, as a general rule, LOSS AVERSE Will decline a bet with even odds of winning $110 or losing $100 Uncertainty about future fuel savings makes paying for more technology a risky bet - What MPG will I get (your mileage may vary)? - How long will my car last? - How much driving will I do? - What will gasoline cost? - What will I give up or pay to get better MPG? Causes the market to produce less fuel economy than is economically efficient

23 New Customer Profile Early Adopter Early Majority Majority Hanger- On Innovator Increasingly risk averse

24 $3.50 $3.00 Real Gasoline Price Real Gasoline Prices (2009 $ per gallon) $3.27 $2.50 $2.00 $1.50 $1.00 $0.50 $ Motor Gasoline Retail Prices, U.S. City Average, adjusted using CPI-U

25 $3.50 Fleet Fuel Economy Real Gasoline Prices and In-Use Fleet MPG (2009 $ per gallon) 35 $ $2.50 Real Gasoline Price Car mpg 25 $2.00 $1.50 $1.00 Car + Light Truck mpg MPG $ $ In-Use MPG from Transportation Energy Data Book:

26 $0.22 Gasoline Cost per Mile Real Gasoline Cost for Cars - Cents per Mile $0.20 $0.18 $0.16 $0.14 $0.12 $0.10 $0.08 $0.06 $0.04 $0.02 $

27 10.0% 9.0% Real Fuel Cost - % of Disposable Income Real Fuel Cost of Driving a Passenger Car 10,000 Miles % of Per Capita Disposable Income % of Per Capita Disposable Income 8.0% 7.0% 6.0% 5.0% 4.0% 3.0% 2.0% 1.0% 0.0% BEA, Table 2.1, Personal Income and It's Disposition

28 1. Technology Development 2. Fuels 3. Customers 4. Summary

29 Future Directions Improved gasoline engines will raise bar for other technologies Especially a problem for diesels & PHEVs Pick a number - 35, 40, 45,?? - not a problem Too much technology is coming - which is best? No silver bullet - avoid trap of single solutions Challenges are: 1. Leadtime Japan & Europe only achieving ~ 2%/yr increases 35 by 2020 is ~ 3%/yr (NHTSA/EPA will do more) 2. Customers With cheap gasoline, customers will continue to demand performance, features, and utility, not fuel economy

30 Thank You

31 The Liquid Fuel Advantage ENERGY FUTURE: Think Efficiency American Physical Society, Sept. 2008, Chapter 2, Table 1 Energy density per volume Energy density per weight kwh/liter vs gasoline KWh/kg vs gasoline Gasoline Diesel fuel % % Ethanol % % Hydrogen at 10,000 psi % % Liquid hydrogen % % NiMH battery % % Lithium-ion battery (present time) % % Lithium-ion battery (future) 0.28? 2.1%