Challenges & Opportunities for Self-Consumption Business Models in Europe

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Challenges & Opportunities for Self-Consumption Business Models in Europe"

Nicholas Watts
5 years ago
Views:

1 Challenges & Opportunities for Self-Consumption Business Models in Europe PV Markzttan Masson, Director Ir Gaëtan Masson Director, Vice-Chairman, EU PV Technology & Innovation Platform Operating Agent, IEA-PVPS Task 1

2 BECQUEREL INSTITUTE Research orientedinstitute and consulting companyfor Solar Technologies. Global PV Market Analysis including competitiveness IndustryAnalysisincludingquality& reliability Integration into electricity systems(grids and markets) In-house experts / Global network of experts and stakeholders PV Market Alliance partner 2

3 FROM 1.1 TO 50 GW IN 11 YEARS? 51 GW 230 GW 16% IEA-PVPS

4 WHATTO EXPECT? 4

5 2 PV WORLDS Distributed PV Producers Self-consumption, energy effiency, grid parity, competition with utilities distribution business Prosumers One technology Centralized PV Grid injection, PPA, competition with utilities generation business 5

6 THE EVOLUTIONOF SEGMENTS 6

7 ROOFTOP PV DEVELOPMENT 7

8 WHATTO EXPECTIN EUROPE? 8

9 EUROPEAN FORECASTS PER SEGMENT 9

10 SHARE OF SC BUSINESS MODELS 10

11 SELF-CONSUMPTION 11

12 BUSINESS MODELS Savings on the electricity bill + Sale of excess PV electricity Net-metering Selfconsumption + market price + FiT/FiP FiT / TGC Producers Sale of electricity Prosumers Market price (+ premium? FiP) 12

13 WITHOR WITHOUTPV Building without PV Electricity bill - Electricity comes from the grid Sales of PV Electricity Electricity bill Building with PV - Part of electricity produced by PV is consumed in the building (reducing the electricity bill) - Non-consumed electricity goes to the grid and is sold - When PV is not producing, the electricity comes from the grid 13

14 COMPETITIVE PV? CAPEX of PV System + OPEX of PV System Savingson electricity bills < + Sales of excess electricity During PV systems lifetime (20-35 years) 14

15 ECONOMICSOF SELF-CONSUMPTION + self-consumption taxes + sales of PV electricity Savings& Sales 15

16 COMPONENTS OF ELECTRICITY How much can be compensated from the electricitybill? Maximum savings on electricity bills (average) Spain Germany Austria 79% 83% 85% Denmark Poland UK Portugal Switzerland Netherlands Belgium France Turkey Italy 94% 96% 97% 97% 97% 97% 97% 97% 98% 99% 16

17 SALES OF PV ELECTRICITY Access to wholesale electricity markets 1. Current Excess PV electricity gets a FiT 2. Current Excess PV electricity gets a FiP above the market price 3. Future Excess PV electricity gets the market price though an aggregator 4. Future Excess PV electrivity gets the market price directly European Legislation pushed to integrate renewable into wholesale electricity markets 17

SELF-CONSUMPTIONRATIO SC ratio = PV production locally consumed/ total PV production Hypothesis used: 50% SC - Commercial segment / 75% SC - Industrial segment - Example: commercial segment in France

18 SELF-CONSUMPTIONRATIO SC ratio = PV production locally consumed/ total PV production Hypothesis used: 50% SC - Commercial segment / 75% SC - Industrial segment - Example: commercial segment in France Retail electricity price: 0,144 EUR/kWh - Wholesale market price: 0,045 EUR/kWh - Average value of PV electricity compared to the LCOE of PV electricity(average): 0,10 EUR/kWh 25% SC 0,061 EUR/kWh 50% SC 0,083 EUR/kWh 75% SC 0,116 EUR/kWh 100% SC 0,144 EUR/kWh 18

19 THE SC RATIO CHALLENGE Self-consumption of PV installations 20 to 100% Challenge: minimizing grid injection Solutions: decrease PV system size, DSM, Storage 19

20 IMPACT OF SC RATIOS Ratios are smaller in the residential sector (20-30%). DSM, system size, storage can increased them. Percentage (%) 100.0% 90.0% 80.0% 70.0% 60.0% Selfconsumption / Consumption Autoconsumption / PV production Commercial and industrial applications can reach higher ratios. 50.0% 40.0% 30.0% But is local optimization of SC optimum from a system point of view? 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% PV power (kwp) 20

21 DSM & STORAGE SOLUTIONS DSM Electricity Storage Other uses(out of the load) H&C, Transport 21

22 SELF-CONSUMPTIONBUSINESSCASE - A simple (residential) business model in Belgium PV electricityproduction cost: 0,12 EUR/kWh (950 kwh/kwp+ 1,5 EUR/WP + 4%) Residential electricity prices 0,2 EUR/kWh (assuming 100% savings on electricity bill) Value of injectedelectricity= 0,04 EUR/kWh (Net-metering with grid tax: +0,13 0,12 = +0,01 EUR/kWh) With30% SC: +0,09 0,12 = -0,03 EUR/kWh With70% SC: +0,15 0,12 = +0,03 EUR/kWh Margin for investment in Smart tools, storage or H&C NPV_20years (i=2%) for a 5kWp PV system = 2400 EUR 22

23 REGULATIONS & PARAMETERS 23

A NEEDFOR REGULATIONS Onsite Self- Consumption Excess PV Electricity Right to selfconsume Revenues for selfconsumed PV electricity Charges to finance T&D costs Value of excess electricity Maximum

24 A NEEDFOR REGULATIONS Onsite Self- Consumption Excess PV Electricity Right to selfconsume Revenues for selfconsumed PV electricity Charges to finance T&D costs Value of excess electricity Maximum timeframe for compensation Self-consumption is legally permitted Savings on the variable price of electricity from the grid Additional costs associated to self-consumption such as fees or taxes may exist Net metering: energetic compensation (credit in kwh) Net billing: monetary compensation (credit in monetary unit) Self-consumption: real time (e.g 15 minutes) Net metering and net billing: time frame is typically one year although there are some exceptions (from credits that can be rolled over to the following billing cycle to quarterly compensation) Key: Same between shemes Main differences 24

25 CATEGORIESOF SELF-CONSUMPTION On-site PV selfconsumption Excess PV electricity Other characteristics of the system Right to self-consume Revenues from self-consumed PV Charges to finance T&D costs Revenues from excess electricity Maximum timeframe for credit compensation Geographical compensation Regulatory scheme duration Third-party ownership Grid codes and additional taxes/fees Other enablers of self-consumption Clarify existing and future schemes, Allow comparison from one scheme to another Consider some emerging questions such as: - Howtofinancethegrid? - How to keep government revenues stable? 11 System capacity limit - Howtosaveutilities? 12 Aggregate capacity limit 25

26 WHICHPOLICIES? Right to selfconsume Revenues from self-consumed PV Additional revenues on selfconsumed PV Charges to finance T&D cost Revenues from excess electricity Maximum timeframe for compensation Production based: classical "FiT" - style. No self-consumption Self-consumption with constrains Self-consumption + FiT Net-billing Net-metering Self-consumption + Premium Not Allowed Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A Savings on the electricity bill GC, FiP Savings on the electricity bill Netting of production revenues and consumption costs Savings on the electricity bill Savings on the electricity bill N/A No No No No Premium N/A Yes No No No No N/A Zero < retail price <= retail price = retail price > retail price N/A Real-time Real-time Long period Long period Real time 26

27 THE DEBATEON SELF-CONSUMPTION Self-consumption will be constrained due to limited savings on the electricity bill 27

28 BUSINESS MODELS 28

29 SELF-CO BUSINESS MODELS CASE 1: Self-consumption and no compensation CASE 2: Self-consumption + FiT CASE 3: Net-billing kwh Lost PV electricity Electricity consumed from the grid kwh Excess PV electricity FiT Electricity consumed from the grid kwh Excess PV electricity Electricity consumed from the grid Monetary billing arrangement On-site PV selfconsumption Fee Avoided grid consumption On-site PV selfconsumption Avoided grid consumption On-site PV selfconsumption Avoided grid consumption PV generation Total electricity consumption PV generation Total electricity consumption PV generation Total electricity consumption CASE 4: Net-metering CASE 5: Self-consumption + additional compensation kwh Excess PV electricity Electricity consumed from the grid Energetic compensation kwh Excess PV electricity G on + export Electricity consumed from the grid Key: Lost PV electricity PV electricity self-consumed later on PV electricity receiving payment On-site PV self-consumption Electricity consumed from the grid On-site PV selfconsumption Avoided grid consumption On-site PV selfconsumption G on tariff Avoided grid consumption Cost for the prosumer Revenue for the prosumer PV generation Total electricity consumption PV generation Total electricity consumption Source: ECLAREON Analysis 29

30 SCHEMECOMPARISON Source: IEA-PVPS - Roma, Italy 30

31 COMPETITIVENESSASSESSMENT Industrial segment 1 EUR/Wp 6% WACC (real) 75% SC electrictysold at wholesalemarketprices. Austria Uncompetitive before 2019 France Competitive in the South / North in 2018 Germany Competitive Italy Competitive Spain Competitive in the South / North in 2018 Turkey Uncompetitive before 2019 in the South UK Competitive 31

32 SELF-CONSUMPTIONIMPACTS 100% 80% Taxes (19%) Description VAT Other eventual taxes on electricity Impact of PV selfconsumption Prosumer Tax Collector 60% Green taxes (23%) Subsidies and incentives for RES Prosumer Electricity Market 40% Grid charges (22%) Network costs allocated to the per kwh term 20% Energy cost (36%) Non-regulated costs: Wholesale energy price Supply costs Prosumer 0% Source: ECLAREON Analysis Key: Revenues/savings Costs/decreased revenues 32

33 INNOVATIVE BUSINESS MODELS Samebuilding, one customer One counter. Owner invests to saveon hisbill. Usual Self- Consumption ownership Same owner location Samebuilding, multiple customers Different buildings, same connection Differentplaces (virtual metering) Same place Several counters. Who invests? SEU. Severalcounters, one gridconnection. Distant consumptionand production places. SolarCitycase. OtherOwner: TPO Differentplaces (virtual metering) Investment in anotherpv system againstfree electricity 33

OPTIONS FOR DISTRIBUTED PV Different options for a new rooftop PV system BUY Equity(savings) -Lowcostof capital (real WACC close to 0% or evennegative) Ownership LOAN Medium cost of capital (real

34 OPTIONS FOR DISTRIBUTED PV Different options for a new rooftop PV system BUY Equity(savings) -Lowcostof capital (real WACC close to 0% or evennegative) Ownership LOAN Medium cost of capital (real WACC around 2-5%) Ownership LEASE Fixed length- O&M included Ownership to be debated Third-party investment Feepaidto the third-party, underthe retailelectricityprice(couldbean utility) O&M Included No ownership Possible contracts with utilities sold against guaranteed cheaper electricity prices 34

35 5 PROPOSALS FOR SC REGULATIONS 1. Guarantee the right to self-consume without additional taxes. 2. Compensation withoutlimitsof taxes and leviesfor prosumers. 3. Variable grid costs shouldn t be paid until PV reaches a criticalpenetration. Mutualizationisaccessible and fair. 4. Grandfathering clause for existing systems 5. Electricitymarketsare unstable, favoura stable value for solar electricity injected 35

36 NEXTSTEPIN EVOLUTION 36

37 Thanks for your attention Becquerelinstitute.org

A METHODOLOGY FOR THE ANALYSIS OF PV SELF-CONSUMPTION POLICIES

A METHODOLOGY FOR THE ANALYSIS OF PV SELF-CONSUMPTION POLICIES Gaëtan Masson IEA PVPS Jose Ignacio Briano & Maria Jesus Baez - CREARA Report IEA-PVPS T1-28:2016 COVER IMAGE The Red Oak Park a neighborhood