SDG&E High Voltage DC WECC Path 46 Rating Increase Comprehensive Progress Report
|
|
- Cecilia Wilcox
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 SDG&E High Voltage DC WECC Path 46 Rating Increase Comprehensive Progress Report San Diego Gas & Electric, a Sempra Energy Utility SDGE HVDC Phase 1 Project No Revision 01 11/29/2018
2 SDG&E High Voltage DC WECC Path 46 Rating Increase Comprehensive Progress Report Prepared for San Diego Gas & Electric, a Sempra Energy Utility SDGE HVDC Phase 1 San Diego, CA Project No Revision 01 11/29/2018 Prepared by Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc. Kansas City, Missouri COPYRIGHT 2017 BURNS & McDONNELL ENGINEERING COMPANY, INC.
3 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INTRODUCTION Overview HVDC Project Background and Plan of Service Additional Benefits of the HVDC Project Study Objective and Scope Path 46, West of Colorado River STUDY DESCRIPTION AND METHODOLOGY Power Flow Analysis Transient Stability Analysis Post-Transient Stability Analysis SIMULTANEOUS INTERACTIONS STUDY RESULTS Non-Simultaneous Rating Power Flow Analysis Results Transient Stability Analysis Results Post-Transient Stability Analysis Results CONCLUSION APPENDIX A POWER FLOW RESULTS San Diego Gas & Electric i Burns & McDonnell
4 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Table of Contents LIST OF FIGURES Page No. Figure 2-1: SDG&E s Existing System - SWPL Figure 2-2: SDG&E s Proposed HVDC Project Figure 2-3: Path 46, West of Colorado River Figure 3-1: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Delay Recovery Figure 3-2: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Normal Recovery Figure 3-3: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Normal Recovery San Diego Gas & Electric ii Burns & McDonnell
5 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Executive Summary 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) is proposing a High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission line which will utilize the existing alternating current (AC) Southwest Powerlink (SWPL) Right of Way from North Gila to Imperial Valley to Miguel. This new HVDC line includes construction of approximately 120 miles, 425 kv, three (3) terminal, bipolar, double circuit, direct current (DC) transmission line with metallic return between the existing 500 kv bus at North Gila substation, the 500 kv bus at the Imperial Valley substation and the 230 kv bus at the Miguel substation (the HVDC Project), with a rating of 3000 MW. The HVDC line will replace the existing 500 kv alternating current (AC) line that runs from North Gila to Imperial Valley to East County (ECO) to Miguel. Part of the AC line which this HVDC Project replaces, North Gila-Imperial Valley 500 kv, is one of the transmission lines which comprise the Western Electricity Coordinating Council s (WECC) West of Colorado River Transmission Path (Path 46 or WOR). Accordingly, the HVDC will become part of the WOR Path and it is expected to provide significant increase in transmission capacity on Path 46 between Arizona and southern California. The proposed Project is expected to have a maxim transfer capability of 3,000 MW and would increase the non-simultaneous rating of Path 46 by 2,100 MW from 11,200 MW to 13,300 MW. With the North Gila-Imperial Valley #2 (NGIV#2), a project currently in Phase 2 of the WECC Path Rating Process, the non-simultaneous rating of Path 46 increases by 2,300 MW from 11,200 MW (current accepted rating) to 13,500 MW or increases by 1,050 MW over the proposed Path 46 rating of 12,450 with NGIV#2. The increase in Path 46 flow with NGIV#2 is slightly over the increase from this HVDC Project alone because both projects make improvements to the southern portion of Path 46 and thus both projects face the same limit on the southern portion of Path 46. Both Path 46 rating increases are with the existing Eldorado-Lugo series capacitors by-passed. With the proposed Southern California Edison (SCE) Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Series Capacitor Project, which appears to address limits on the northern portion of Path 46, it is anticipated that additional increases to Path 46 above and beyond those described above (13,300 MW without NGIV#2 and 13,500 with NGIV#2) will be possible. That and other issues such as simultaneous ratings will be explored in Phase 2. The proposed HVDC Project can achieve a total transfer capability matching its full rating of 3,000 MW while meeting NERC reliability standards and WECC system performance criteria. San Diego Gas & Electric 1-1 Burns & McDonnell
6 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction The study identified the Hassayampa North Gila 500 kv line or the Hoodoo Wash-North Gila 500 kv line as both the critical outage and the limiting element. These are parallel paths with the critical contingencies being the loss of one side or the other. It is expected that this CPR will form the basis for the proposed Project to enter Phase 2 of the WECC three phase rating process. Once the 60-day comment period has passed and all comments have been addressed, a WECC HVDC Project Review Group will be assembled to help address the study requirements for Phase 2 and to conduct additional analysis that may be necessary to obtain a new WECC Accepted rating of 13,300 MW for Path 46 with the HVDC Project by itself or 13,500 MW with NGIV# INTRODUCTION 2.1 Overview SDG&E asked Burns & McDonnell to help them conduct a path rating study to comply with the WECC procedure for Project rating, including a path rating study to determine the potential rating increase on the WECC Path 46 (West of River (WOR)), following the addition of the proposed HVDC Project. Burns & McDonnell completed the work necessary to prepare this WECC Comprehensive Progress Report (CPR) for increasing the rating on WECC Path HVDC Project Background and Plan of Service The planned in-service date for the HVDC Line is December The Project s plan of service includes: A new AC/DC converter station (rectifier) at the North Gila 500 kv bus with 3000 MW capacity A new AC/DC converter station (rectifier/inverter) at the Imperial Valley 500 kv bus with 3000 MW capacity A new converter station (inverter) at the Miguel 230 kv bus with 3000 MW capacity Two new 425 kv three terminal bi-pole DC lines between the existing 500 kv North Gila bus, the 500 kv Imperial Valley bus and the 230 kv Miguel bus Retirement of the existing 500 kv AC transmission line from North Gila to Imperial Valley to ECO to Miguel Reconfiguration of the existing 500 kv AC transmission line between Ocotillo and Suncrest, by adding a loop-in to the ECO substation so it becomes two 500 kv line two lines running from Ocotillo to ECO to Suncrest This Plan of Service is partially show in the Figures below. The existing system is shown in Figure1-1. San Diego Gas & Electric 2-2 Burns & McDonnell
7 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction Figure 2-1: SDG&E s Existing System - SWPL The system with the SDG&E s proposed HVDC line is shown below in Figure 1-2. Figure 2-2: SDG&E s Proposed HVDC Project 2.3 Additional Benefits of the HVDC Project The addition of the HVDC Line is also expected to provide the following additional benefits: San Diego Gas & Electric 2-3 Burns & McDonnell
8 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction Increased access to renewable generation o Specifically allows increased access to renewables in El Centro, California by helping to control flow on the interties between CAISO and IID o Provides an increase in diversity of the regional energy resource mix o Reduces Green House Gas (GHG) emissions and provides improved access to both instate and out-of-state renewables to meet 60% RPS goal (2030) and the 100% carbon free goal (2045) per SB 100 Removes the transmission bottleneck on North-Gila-Imperial Valley 500 kv, following the 2015 addition of the Hassayampa-North Gila #2 project Provides rapid and precise control over the flow of power into southern California, allowing quick incremental increases or decreases in power flow as needed during normal operations and pre- or post-contingency o This control provides significant interregional benefits by solving the loop flow issue for multiple parties (APS, SDG&E, IID, and CENACE) Reduces Greater IV/San Diego and Western LA Basin local LCR requirements by increasing the imports into the resource constrained southwest Increases San Diego import capability by mitigating worst N-1-1 contingency (Sunrise & SWPL) o Increases the import capability into the Southern California Import Transmission system Reducing available fault current in San Diego Gas & Electric s transmission system o Provides fault isolation Reduce system losses Increases reliability in the southwest Make efficient use of existing transmission corridors Increases West of River (WOR) path rating 2.4 Study Objective and Scope Burns & McDonnell conducted this Path Rating Study using a WECC approved heavy autumn power flow model that had previously used for the NGIV#2 Project s path rating study. Analysis performed as part of the study included power flow, transient stability and post-transient stability. The main objective of this study was to complete the work necessary to prepare a Comprehensive Progress Report that will enable the proposed HVDC Project and its associated WECC Path 46 rating increase to complete Phase 1 and enter Phase 2 of the WECC 3 phase rating process. This study demonstrated that the proposed Project will provide an incremental transfer capability of 2,300 MW on San Diego Gas & Electric 2-4 Burns & McDonnell
9 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction Path 46 above its current Accepted Rating of 11, 200 MW to a new Proposed Rating of 13,300 MW, while complying with North America Reliability Council s (NERC) reliability standards and WECC criteria. In conjunction with the North Gila-Imperial Valley #2 (NGIV#2), a project currently in Phase 2 of the WECC Path Rating Process, this study demonstrated that the non-simultaneous rating of Path 46 increased by 2,300 MW from the current Accepted Rating of 11,200 MW to a new Proposed Rating of 13,500 MW or increases by 1,050 MW over the NGIV#2 Proposed Rating of 12,450 MW. Recent Path 46 upgrade studies have shown that there are simultaneous relationships between Path 46 and the following WECC Paths and southwestern transmission operating parameters: Lugo-Victorville 500 kv line Path 61 Southern Nevada Transmission Interface (SNTI) Path 81 Southern California Import Transmission (SCIT) Nomogram In accordance with the WECC Project Coordination, Path Rating and Progress Report Processes manual, the simultaneous relationships between Path 46 and these other paths will be evaluated and addressed in Phase 2. Further, since the SCIT nomogram varies seasonally, the effect of the increase on the Path 46 rating on the SCIT nomogram will be evaluated during the Phase 2 of this Path Rating process. This CPR details the impact of the HVDC Project and the associated Path 46 rating increase on the WECC transmission system. 2.5 Path 46, West of Colorado River The Path 46 (WOR), is shown below in Figure 2-3, and is comprised of several of the major transmission lines in the southwestern United States, west of the Colorado River and connect southern Nevada and Arizona to southern California. San Diego Gas & Electric 2-5 Burns & McDonnell
10 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction Figure 2-3: Path 46, West of Colorado River WECC Path 46 consists of the following 14 transmission lines, which are divided into three (3) subsystems: Northern System Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv line (metered at Eldorado 500 kv) Eldorado-Cima-Pisgah No. 1 & 2, 230 kv lines (metered at Eldorado 230 kv) Mohave-Lugo 500 kv line (metered at Mohave 500 kv) Julian Hinds-Mirage 230 kv line (metered at Mirage 230 kv) Mead-Victorville 287 kv line (metered at Mead 287 kv) McCullough-Victorville Nos. 1 & 2, 500 kv lines (metered at McCullough 500 kv) Marketplace-Adelanto 500 kv line (metered at Marketplace 500 kv) San Diego Gas & Electric 2-6 Burns & McDonnell
11 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 02 Introduction Southern System North Gila-Imperial Valley 500 kv line (metered at N. Gila 500 kv) Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv line (metered at Colorado River 500 kv) Underlying System El Centro-Imperial Valley 230 kv line (metered at Imperial Valley 230 kv) Ramon-Mirage 230 kv line (metered at Mirage 230 kv) Coachella-Devers 230 kv line (metered at Devers 230 kv) The East to West non-simultaneous Accepted Rating of the Path 46 increased from 10,523 MW to 11,200 MW on July 18, The WOR non-simultaneous rating of 11, 200 MW is limited by the outage of Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv line or the Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv line and subsequent implementation of the existing Blythe RAS. With the HVDC Project, the Path 46 definition of the Southern System will be changed from: To North Gila-Imperial Valley 500 kv line (metered at N. Gila 500 kv) North Gila-Imperial Valley 425 kv DC line (metered at N. Gila 500 kv) San Diego Gas & Electric 2-7 Burns & McDonnell
12 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology 3.0 STUDY DESCRIPTION AND METHODOLOGY This analysis was conducted using the WECC approved heavy autumn power flow model previously used initially by the NGIV#2 Project s path rating study as its starting base case. The base case was had the Harry Allen Eldorado 500 kv line. A Path 46 upgrade study base case (post-hvdc base case) was developed from this starting base case by modeling the proposed HVDC project s plan of service. Power transfers were made from Arizona to southern California to increase the flow on the proposed HVDC and Path 46 till a critical facility limit is reached. Apart from the stated modeling assumptions, the transmission and load assumptions in the starting base case were not altered in developing HVDC base case. Power flow, post-transient stability and transient stability analyses were performed to ensure that the system performance criteria prescribed in the NERC reliability standards and WECC criteria were met. 3.1 Power Flow Analysis Power flow analysis was performed on the HVDC base cases. The study simulated the impact of the proposed NGIV2 project and the associated Path 46 rating increase on the existing transmission system during normal operating conditions (Category P0), single event (Category P1- P2) as well as multiple (Category P3-P7) events. The outages simulated included: Selected Category P1-P2 ( kv) transmission circuit and transformer outages within Arizona, Nevada and California transmission systems. Selected critical P3-P7 events (230 kv and above) transmission and transformer outages within Arizona, Nevada and California transmission systems. The power flow analysis contingency list can be found in Attachment A. Applicable NERC reliability standard and the WECC System Performance Criteria were used to assess the adequacy of the study results. The power flow analysis evaluation criteria that were used are summarized below: Pre-contingency bus voltage must be between 0.95 per unit and 1.05 per unit unless specific minimum and maximum operating voltage requirements exists. San Diego Gas & Electric 3-1 Burns & McDonnell
13 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology Pre-disturbance loading to remain within continuous ratings of all equipment and line conductors. Post-disturbance loading to remain within emergency ratings of all equipment and line conductors. Post-disturbance bus voltages to remain within applicable criteria: o Between 0.9 per unit and 1.10 per unit for Category P1-P7 events, unless lower standards have previously been adopted. Post-disturbance bus voltage deviation to remain within applicable criteria: o o Within 5% for Category P1-P2 events, unless lower standards have previously been adopted Within 10% for Category P3-P7 events, unless lower standards have previously been adopted. Load shedding was not allowed for Category P1-P2 events unless previously defined. 3.2 Transient Stability Analysis Transient stability studies were conducted on the HVDC study base case. Transient stability runs were simulated for 15 seconds, excluding a 1 second pre-outage run, to ensure the system is stable and positively damped. All simulated faults were three-phase with a 4-cycle breaker clearing time. System damping was assessed visually with the aid of stability plots. Selected critical disturbances were simulated. Provided below are the disturbances simulated: P1: Palo Verde- Colorado River 500 kv line (Palo Verde 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Hassayampa N. Gila 500 kv line (Hassayampa 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Hassayampa Hoodoo Wash 500 kv line (Hassayampa 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Palo Verde Westwing #1 500 kv line (Palo Verde 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Palo Verde Rudd 500 kv line (Palo Verde 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Imperial Valley Ocotillo 5000 kv line (Imperial Valley 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Ocotillo ECO 500 kv line (Ocotillo 500 kv bus faulted) San Diego Gas & Electric 3-2 Burns & McDonnell
14 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology P1: Perkins Mead 500 kv line (Mead 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Mead Marketplace 500 kv line (Mead 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Harry Allen Mead 500 kv line (Harry Allen 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Navajo Crystal 500 kv line (Navajo 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Moenkopi El Dorado 500 kv line (El Dorado 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Adelanto Marketplace 500 kv line (Adelanto 500 kv bus faulted) P1: El Dorado Lugo 500 kv line (El Dorado 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Mohave Lugo 500 kv line (Lugo 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Lugo Victorville 500 kv line (Victorville 500 kv bus faulted) P1: Coachella Mirage 230 kv line (Coachella 230 kv bus faulted) P1: Ramon Mirage 500 kv line (Mirage 230 kv bus faulted) P1: Devers Mirage #1 230 kv line (Devers 230 kv bus faulted) P1: Devers - Valley #1 500 kv line (Devers 500 kv bus faulted) P6: Lugo El Dorado & Lugo Mohave 500 kv lines (Lugo 500 kv bus faulted) P6: Lugo El Dorado & El Dorado Mohave 500 kv lines (El Dorado 345 kv bus faulted) P6: Harry Allen Mead & Mead Marketplace 500 kv lines (Mead 500 kv bus faulted) P6: Coachella Mirage & Mirage Ramon 230 kv lines (Mirage 230 kv bus faulted) P7: Imperial Valley Ocotillo & Ocotillo ECO 500 lines (Ocotillo 500 kv bus faulted) P7: Palo Verde G-2 (Palo Verde 500 kv bus faulted) P7: Palo Verde Westwing #1 & kv lines (Palo Verde 500 kv bus faulted) P7: Hassayampa N. Gila & Hassayampa Hoodoo Wash 500 kv lines (Hassayampa 500 kv bus faulted) P7: PDCI line P7: SWPL HVDC line The following WECC transient voltage dip and transient frequency criteria were used to evaluate the study results. San Diego Gas & Electric 3-3 Burns & McDonnell
15 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology WECC transient voltage dip criteria: Following fault clearing, the voltage shall recover to 80% of the pre-contingency voltage within 20 seconds of the initiating event for all P1 through P7 events, for each applicable BES bus serving load. Following fault clearing and voltage recovery above 80%, voltage at each applicable BES bus serving load shall neither dip below 70% of pre-contingency voltage for more than 30 cycles nor remain below 80% of pre-contingency voltage for more than two seconds, for all P1 through P7 events. For Contingencies without a fault (P2.1 category event), voltage dips at each applicable BES bus serving load shall neither dip below 70% of pre-contingency voltage for more than 30 cycles nor remain below 80% of pre-contingency voltage for more than two seconds. WECC transient frequency criteria: WECC no longer has a transient frequency criterion. WECC transient oscillation criteria: All oscillations that do not show positive damping within 30-seconds after the start of the studied event shall be deemed unstable. A summary of the transient stability analysis evaluation criteria is provided in the figures below. San Diego Gas & Electric 3-4 Burns & McDonnell
16 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology Figure 3-1: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Delay Recovery Figure 3-2: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Normal Recovery 1 San Diego Gas & Electric 3-5 Burns & McDonnell
17 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology Figure 3-3: Transient Voltage Drip Criteria, Normal Recovery Post-Transient Stability Analysis Post-transient stability analysis was performed on the proposed Path 46 rating increase. This included modeling flow on the Path 46 with at least a 5% higher than the proposed rating of 13,300 MW (or 13,500 MW) for single outage events and 2.5% higher for multiple outage events. In this analysis, the increased flow on Path 46 was achieved by modeling additional transfers from Arizona to southern California. The outage list for the post-transient stability analysis is follows: P1: Palo Verde- Colorado River 500 kv line P1: Hassayampa N. Gila 500 kv line P1: Hassayampa Hoodoo Wash 500 kv line P1: Palo Verde Westwing #1 500 kv line P1: Palo Verde Rudd 500 kv line P1: Imperial Valley Ocotillo500 kv line San Diego Gas & Electric 3-6 Burns & McDonnell
18 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Description and methodology P1: Ocotillo ECO 500 kv line P1: Perkins Mead 500 kv line P1: Mead Marketplace 500 kv line P1: Harry Allen Mead 500 kv line P1: Navajo Crystal 500 kv line P1: Moenkopi El Dorado 500 kv line P1: Adelanto Marketplace 500 kv line P1: El Dorado Lugo 500 kv line P1: Mohave Lugo 500 kv line P1: Lugo Victorville 500 kv line P1: Coachella Mirage 230 kv line P1: Ramon Mirage 500 kv line P1: Devers Mirage #1 230 kv line P1: Devers - Valley #1 500 kv line P6: Lugo El Dorado & Lugo Mohave 500 kv lines P6: Lugo El Dorado & El Dorado Mohave 500 kv lines P6: Harry Allen Mead & Mead Marketplace 500 kv lines P6: Devers Valley #1 & kv lines P7: Imperial Valley Ocotillo & Ocotillo ECO 500 lines P7: SWPL HVDC line To meet the reliability criteria, the system must also have a positive reactive margin under the stated conditions. San Diego Gas & Electric 3-7 Burns & McDonnell
19 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Simultaneous interactions 4.0 SIMULTANEOUS INTERACTIONS Per WECC Project Coordination, Path Rating and Progress Report Processes, the CPR for the proposed Project shall include known simultaneous relationships. Recent Path 46 upgrade study showed that there are simultaneous relationships between Path 46 and each of the following known paths within the WECC transmission system: Lugo Victorville 500 kv line Path 61 Southern Nevada Transmission Interface (SNTI) Path 81 Southern California Import Transmission (SCIT) Nomogram These simultaneous relationships will be evaluated as part of the Phase 2 study of this Path rating process because of complexity of the interactions and SCE s proposed to the changes to Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave which may affect Path 61. San Diego Gas & Electric 4-1 Burns & McDonnell
20 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Results 5.0 STUDY RESULTS This section details the key study findings from the power flow, post-transient stability and transient stability analyses of the HVDC Project. NERC Reliability Standard and WECC System Performance Criteria were used to assess the adequacy of the study results. 5.1 Non-Simultaneous Rating With the HVDC Project, the non-simultaneous rating of Path 46 (WOR) increases 2,100 MW from 11,200 MW (the current Accepted Rating) to 13,300 MW (new Proposed Rating). With the addition of the NGIV#2, currently in Phase 2 of the WECC Path Rating Process, the nonsimultaneous rating of Path 46 increases by 2,300 MW from 11,200 MW (current Accepted Rating) to 13,500 MW (new Proposed Rating with HVDC and NGIV#2), which is an increase of 1,050 MW over the NGIV#2 Proposed Rating of 12,450 MW. The increase in Path 46 flow with NGIV#2 is slight over the increase from this HVDC Project alone because both projects make improvements to the southern portion of Path 46 and thus both projects face the same limit on the southern portion of Path 46. These non-simultaneous rating are achieved by allowing control features of HVDC lines, including rapid switching of the HVDC line either pre- or post-contingency. 5.2 Power Flow Analysis Results Some of the key findings from the power flow analysis include: Path 46 non-simultaneous rating can be increased from 11,200 MW (current Accepted Rating) to 13,300 MW (new Proposed Rating) with the HVDC Project (or 13,500 MW new Proposed Rating with HVDC and NGIV#2) and satisfy the NERC Reliability Standards and WECC System Performance Criteria. The Path 46 non-simultaneous rating of 13,300 MW (or 13,500 MW) is limited by contingency ratings on the following transmission lines associated with the southern portion of Path 46: o Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv line (Critical outage: Hassayampa-Hoodoo Wash 500 kv line or Hoodoo Wash-North Gila 50 kv line) o Hoodoo Wash-North Gila 500 kv line (Critical outage: Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv line) The overloads on these lines can be addressed by rapid switching on the dc converters. Both Path 46 rating increases are with the existing Eldorado-Lugo series capacitors by-passed. San Diego Gas & Electric 5-2 Burns & McDonnell
21 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Results Although not a limiting condition, heavy loading was noted on the following transmission lines associated with the northern portion of Path 46: o o o o o Imperial Valley-El Centro 230 kv (for multiple contingencies) is a known, existing problem that is handled by various SDG&E RAS and is helped by NGIV#2 in conjunction with the HVDC Project. Lugo-Mohave 500 kv line (for the loss of McCullough-Victorville No 1 and 2) which is resolved by either the Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Series Capacitor Project or NGIV#2 in conjunction with the HVDC Project. Lugo-Victorville 500 kv line (for multiple contingencies) which is an existing problem with partially addressed by either the Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Series Capacitor Project or NGIV#2 in conjunction with the HVDC Project. Julian Hinds-Mirage 230 kv (for multiple contingencies) which is an existing problem which is resolved by the Blythe Gen RAS and is helped by either the Eldorado-Lugo- Mohave Series Capacitor Project or NGIV#2 in conjunction with the HVDC Project. Marketplace-Adelanto 500 kv (for multiple contingencies, but only in the cases with the Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Series Capacitor Project. Further study of this may be required in Phase 2. The Loss of the Bipolar HVDC line heavily loads the following elements: o o o Julian Hinds-Mirage 230 kv line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv line Lugo-Victorville 500 kv line The loss of the Bipolar HVDC may also require a gen dropping RAS (dropping as much as MW of generation). The details of this gen dropping RAS can be worked out in Phase 2. Also, these heavy loadings are improved by the either the existing Blythe RAS, existing SDG&E gen dropping RAS, the Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Series Capacitor Project or NGIV# Transient Stability Analysis Results Transient stability analysis was performed on the HVDC base case and there were no violations of WECC transient stability criteria. Specially: San Diego Gas & Electric 5-3 Burns & McDonnell
22 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Study Results All outages resulted in transient stability with positive damping. No violation of WECC transient voltage dip criteria was found. No violation of WECC transient frequency criteria was found. 5.4 Post-Transient Stability Analysis Results Post-transient stability analysis was performed on the HVDC study base case using the WECC voltage stability criteria. This analysis was done by increasing the flow on Path 46 by 5% of the proposed rating from 13,300 MW to 13,965 MW (and from 13,500 MW with NGIV#2 to 14,175 MW) for Category P1 outages and increasing the flow by 2.5% of the proposed rating from 13,300 MW to 13,633 MW (and from 13,500 MW with NGIV#2 to 13,838 MW) for Category P6 outages. Power flow solutions were achieved for all the outages simulated. Accordingly, per WECC voltage stability criteria, positive reactive margins were achieved for all outages simulated. San Diego Gas & Electric 5-4 Burns & McDonnell
23 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Conclusion 6.0 CONCLUSION As described in this CPR, this study shows that the proposed Southwest Powerlink (SWPL) High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission line can achieve a maxim transfer capability of 3,000 MW and would increase the non-simultaneous rating of WECC Path 46 (West of Colorado River (WOR)) by 2,100 MW from 11,200 MW (current Accepted Rating) to 13,300 MW (new Proposed Rating) while also satisfying NERC reliability standards and WECC system performance criteria. In conjunction with the North Gila-Imperial Valley #2 (NGIV#2) Project, which is currently in Phase 2 of the WECC Path Rating Process, this HVDC and NGIV#2 increase the non-simultaneous rating of Path 46 by 2,300 MW from 11,200 MW (current accepted rating) to 13,500 MW while also satisfying NERC reliability standards and WECC system performance criteria. This is an increase of 1,050 MW over the NGIV#2 Proposed Path 46 rating of 12,450. This study found the critical outage and limiting element to be the parallel path of Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv line and Hoodoo Wash-North Gila 500 kv line, where the loss of one over loads the other. Post contingency loading on these and other lines can be mitigated by the high-speed switching capabilities of the HVDC line. The limitations on these lines are the thermal ratings of the series capacitor on the Hoodoo Wash-North Gila 500 kv line, and the thermal rating of the series capacitor on the Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv line. Further, the study results showed that the proposed Project would not cause significant inadvertent flow on the existing WECC transmission system. Known simultaneous interactions between Path 46 and other paths such Path 61, Path 81 and the SCIT nomogram will be evaluated during Phase 2 of this WECC Path Rating Process. It is expected that this CPR will form the basis for the proposed HVDC Project to enter Phase 2 of the WECC three phase rating process. Once the 60-day comment period has passed and all comments have been addressed, a WECC HVDC Project Review Group will be assembled to help address the study requirements for Phase 2 and to conduct additional analysis that may be necessary to obtain a new WECC Accepted rating of 13,300 MW for Path 46 with the HVDC Project by itself or 13,500 MW with NGIV#2. San Diego Gas & Electric 6-1 Burns & McDonnell
24 SDG&E HVDC CPR Revision 0 Conclusion APPENDIX A POWER FLOW RESULTS San Diego Gas & Electric 6-1 Burns & McDonnell
25 SDGE High Voltage DC WECC Path 46 Rating Increase Comprehensive Progress Report Appendix A - Power Flow Results Post HVDC Pre HVDC HVDC HVDC HVDC IVNG2 IVNG2 Eld-Lugo Eld-Lugo Rating (MVA) Monitored Facility Cont Name Base Cont %Load %Load %Load %Load %Load Comments PALOVRDE COLRIVER _HVDC Bipole Outage_with Gen drop MOENKOPI ELDORDO _Line Navajo-Crystal 500 kv ckt MOENKOPI ELDORDO _Line Navajo-Crystal 500 kv ckt PALOVRDE PALOVRD _2 Gens Palo Verde double generator outage HASSYAMP HDWSH _Line Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv ckt HASSYAMP N.GILA _Line Hassayampa-HooDoo Wash 500 kv ckt resolved by dc switching HASSYAMP N.GILA _Line Hassayampa-HooDoo Wash 500 kv ckt IRONMTN IRONMTN _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt MEAD MARKETPL _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt LIBERTY PEACOCK _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt LIBTYPHS LIBERTY _Line Perkins-Mead 500 kv ckt Base Case _Line Imperial Valley-Ocotillo 500 kv ckt RUM HRA _Line Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv ckt existing problem (other 1250_2 Lines Imperial Valley-Ocotillo & Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv contingencies), resolved 1060_Line Imperial Valley-Ocotillo 500 kv ckt by phase shifter ROA RUM _Line Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv ckt _2 Lines Imperial Valley-Ocotillo & Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv HDWSH N.GILA _Line Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv ckt HDWSH N.GILA _Line Hassayampa-North Gila 500 kv ckt Base Case _Line Imperial Valley-Ocotillo 500 kv ckt IMPRLVLY ELCENTSW _Line Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv ckt _2 Lines Coachella-Mirage & Mirage-Ramon 230 kv _2 Lines Imperial Valley-Ocotillo & Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv _Line Imperial Valley-Ocotillo 500 kv ckt OTAYMESA TJI _Line Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv ckt _2 Lines Imperial Valley-Ocotillo & Ocotillo-ECO 500 kv ELDORDO LUGO _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & ELDORDO LUGO _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & ELDORDO LUGO _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & ELDORDO LUGO _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & ELDORDO LUGO _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt _Line Marketplace-Adelanto 500 kv ckt ELDORDO LUGO 500 BP _Line Lugo-Mohave 500 kv ckt _Line Lugo-Victorville 500 kv ckt _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & Base Case ELDORDO MCCULLGH _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt LUGO MOHAVE 500 BP _Line Lugo-Victorville 500 kv ckt _2 Lines McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt _Line Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv ckt _Line Lugo-Mohave 500 kv ckt LUGO VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Eldorado-Mohave 500 kv _HVDC Bipole Outage_with Gen drop _HVDC Bipole Outage Base Case PISGAH ELDORDO _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & PISGAH CIMA _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & CIMA ELDORDO _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & INYO INYO PS _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & Base Case _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt _Line Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv ckt _Line Lugo-Victorville 500 kv ckt _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv J.HINDS MIRAGE _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Eldorado-Mohave 500 kv _2 Lines Coachella-Mirage & Mirage-Ramon 230 kv _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & _HVDC Bipole Outage_with Gen drop _HVDC Bipole Outage Base Case _Line Palo Verde-Colorado River 500 kv ckt _Line Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv ckt MARKETPL ADELANTO 1200_2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Eldorado-Mohave 500 kv _2 Lines McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & MARKETPL ADELANTO 1200_2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv _2 LineS McCullough-Victorville 500 kv ckts 1 & MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv Base Case MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv Base Case MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv Base Case MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv Base Case MCCULLGH VICTORVL _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv Base Case MCCULLGH VICTORVL 500 BP _2 Lines Eldorado-Lugo 500 kv & Lugo-Mohave 500 kv resolved by dc switching existing problem (other contingencies), resolved by existing SDG&E RAS existing, address by SCE Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Project addressed by SCE Eldorado-Lugo_Mohave Project, or dc switching existing, address by SCE Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave Project existing, resolved by Blythe Gen RAS or dc switching; helped by Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave appears to be created by Eldorado-Lugo-Mohave, will need to be investigated further in Phase 2 Limiting Element Not Applicable Overload
26 Burns & McDonnell World Headquarters 9400 Ward Parkway Kansas City, MO O F
TransWest Express Project
TransWest Express Project Phase One--Feasibility Study Final Study Report November 2006 A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Executive Summary On October 21, 2005 Arizona Public Service Company
More informationTOLTEC POWER PARTNERSHIP TOLTEC POWER PROJECT INTERCONNECTION STUDY SYSTEM IMPACT STUDY
TOLTEC POWER PARTNERSHIP TOLTEC POWER PROJECT INTERCONNECTION STUDY SYSTEM IMPACT STUDY January 7, 2002 Prepared by Jorge Chacon (Consultant) Tucson Electric Power Company Ed Beck ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
More informationAPPENDIX G: Contingencies on the ISO System that may Impact Adjacent Systems
2016-2017 ISO Transmission Plan March 17, 2017 APPENDIX G: Contingencies on the ISO System that may Impact Adjacent Systems California ISO/MID G-1 2016-2017 ISO Transmission Plan March 17, 2017 Intentionally
More informationISO Transmission Plan February 2, 2015 APPENDIX H: Contingencies on the ISO System that may Impact Adjacent Systems
2014-2015 ISO Transmission Plan February 2, 2015 APPENDIX H: Contingencies on the ISO System that may Impact Adjacent Systems California ISO/MID Study Area: PG&E Bulk files: Switch_PGE_Bulk.zip 1 CptJ_Olinda_ns_slo.swt
More informationDecision on the ISO Transmission Plan
Decision on the 2013-2014 ISO Transmission Plan Neil Millar Executive Director, Infrastructure Development Board of Governors Meeting General Session March 19-20, 2014 Approving the plan means approving
More informationTransWest Express AC and DC Project Comprehensive Progress Report (CPR) 3,000 MW DC and 1,500 MW AC WECC Phase 1 Analysis
TransWest Express AC and DC Project Comprehensive Progress Report (CPR) 3,000 MW DC and 1,500 MW AC WECC Phase 1 Analysis July 25, 2018 Table of Contents 1. Introduction... 5 1.1. Project Description and
More informationAPPENDIX F: Project Need and Description
APPENDIX F: Project Need and Description California ISO/MID F-1 Intentionally left blank California ISO/MID F-2 Name Brief Description Type Lugo Victorville 500 kv Upgrade (SCE portion) The project was
More informationGateway South Transmission Project
Phase 1 Comprehensive Progress Report Volume 1 - Technical Report Report Prepared by PacifiCorp Transmission Planning Department November 21, 2008 WECC1-V4 Phase 1 Comprehensive Progress Report Executive
More information2016 SDG&E Grid Assessment Results
2016 SDG&E Grid Assessment Results CAISO Stakeholder Meeting September 22, 2016 Matthew Belden Engineer II San Diego Gas & Electric Email: MBelden@semprautilities.com 2016 Study Windows One to Five-Year
More informationTransmission Planning & Engineering P.O. Box MS 3259 Phoenix, Arizona
Transmission Planning & Engineering P.O. Box 53933 MS 3259 Phoenix, Arizona 85072-3933 March 9, 2016 Mr. Philip Augustin Chair, WECC Technical Studies Subcommittee Mr. Enoch Davies WECC Technical Staff
More informationValley - Rainbow Interconnection Project Feasibility Study Report
Attachment A Valley - Rainbow Interconnection Project Feasibility Study Report A Joint Study Effort of San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and Southern California Edison (SCE) in Cooperation with the California
More informationMarch 18, Subject: Imperial Irrigation District 2014 Annual Progress Report - Rev 1
Energy Division P.O. Box 937 333 E. Barioni Blvd. Imperial, CA 92251 www.iid.com March 18, 2014 Mr. Tracy Rolstad Chair, WECC Technical Studies Subcommittee Senior Power System Consultant Avista System
More informationMarch 7, Subject: Southern California Edison 2011 Annual Progress Report
March 7, 2011 Mr. Kyle Kohne Mr. Kent Bolton Chair, WECC Technical Studies Subcommittee WECC Technical Staff Bonneville Power Administration University of Utah Research Park P.O. Box 61409 615 Arapeen
More informationNorth Gila Generator Interconnection
A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation North Gila Generator Interconnection System Impact Study APS Contract Nos. 52107 By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning October 2, 2009
More informationTransmission Competitive Solicitation Questions Log Question / Answer Matrix Harry Allen to Eldorado 2015
No. Comment Submitted ISO Response Date Q&A Posted 1 Will the ISO consider proposals that are not within the impedance range specified? Yes. However, the benefits estimated and studies performed by the
More informationFeasibility Study. Customer Kingman Area Photovoltaic Generation Project Interconnection
Feasibility Study Customer Kingman Area Photovoltaic Generation Project Interconnection October, 2009 October 2009 i EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CONCLUSION Customer has requested network resource interconnection
More information100 MW Wind Generation Project
A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation 100 MW Wind Generation Project CUSTOMER FINAL Feasibility Study Results By Transmission Planning, APS December 21, 2007 Executive Summary This Feasibility
More informationSupplement to ISO Transmission Plan. Harry Allen-Eldorado Project Description and Functional Specifications
Supplement to 2013-2014 ISO Transmission Plan Harry Allen-Eldorado Project Description and Functional Specifications Description and Functional Specifications of Proposed Economically Driven Harry Allen
More informationSDG&E Valley-Rainbow Project
SDG&E Valley-Rainbow Project Presentation to Grid Reliability/Operations Committee Steven Mavis ISO Grid Planning Department May 24, 2000 1 Background SDG&E s 1999 Expansion Plan for 2000-2004 indicated
More informationCITY OF PASADENA APPLICATION FOR PARTICIPATING TRANSMISSION OWNER STATUS
CITY OF PASADENA APPLICATION FOR PARTICIPATING TRANSMISSION OWNER STATUS July 15, 2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page No. 1. Description of Pasadena s Transmission Lines and Facilities...1 A. Overview:... 1 B.
More informationQ217 Generator Interconnection Project
Q217 Generator Interconnection System Impact Study APS Contract No. 52588 By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning November 25, 2013 Version 2.0 Prepared by Utility System Efficiencies,
More informationUpdates and Modifications to Report
QUARTERLY COMPLIANCE REPORT (JULY 2015) OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) REGARDING STATUS OF TRANSMISSION PROJECTS AND GENERATION INTERCONNECTION PROJECTS Pursuant to Commission Decision
More informationQ95 Vicksburg 69kV. System Impact Study. APS Contract No Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning.
A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Q95 Vicksburg 69kV System Impact Study APS Contract No. 52246 By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning December 1, 2010 Version 2.6 Final
More information2019 & 2023 Final LCR Study Results San Diego-Imperial Valley non-bulk sub-areas
2019 & 2023 Final LCR Study Results San Diego-Imperial Valley non-bulk sub-areas Luba Kravchuk Senior Regional Transmission Engineer Frank Chen - Regional Transmission Engineer Lead Stakeholder Call May
More informationUpdates and Modifications to Report
QUARTERLY COMPLIANCE REPORT (OCTOBER 2016) OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) REGARDING STATUS OF TRANSMISSION PROJECTS AND GENERATION INTERCONNECTION PROJECTS Pursuant to Commission Decision
More informationProject #148. Generation Interconnection System Impact Study Report
Project #148 Generation Interconnection System Impact Study Report June 05, 2012 Electric Transmission Planning Table of Contents Table of Contents... 2 Executive Summary... 3 Energy Resource Interconnection
More informationfor DRECP Alternatives
Transmission Technical Group Conceptual Transmission Plan for DRECP Alternatives DRECP WebEx Meeting January 9, 2013 Overview Purpose, Participants, and Timeline Generation Assumptions Transmission Assumptions
More informationGenerator Interconnection System Impact Study For
Generator Interconnection System Impact Study For Prepared for: January 15, 2015 Prepared by: SCE&G Transmission Planning Table of Contents General Discussion... Page 3 I. Generator Interconnection Specifications...
More informationMidway/Monument Area TTC Study
Midway/Monument Area TTC Study (includes the following lines: Midway Geesen 115 kv, Geesen Falcon 115 kv, Falcon Fuller 115 kv, Fuller Black Squirrel 115 kv, and Black Squirrel Monument 115 kv) Johnny
More informationFalcon-Midway 115 kv Line Uprate Project Report
Falcon-Midway 115 kv Line Uprate Project Report 12/1/2008 1 Background The function of this project is to uprate the 26.7 miles of Tri-State s 115 kv line between Midway and Falcon substations from 50
More informationReliability Must-Run Analysis th BTA Presentation. Bob Smith Manager Transmission Planning June 6, 2006
Reliability Must-Run Analysis 2006 2015 4 th BTA Presentation Bob Smith Manager Transmission Planning June 6, 2006 Outline of Presentation 2006 RMR Study Process Description of network and constraint SIL/MLSC
More informationRe: Comments on the 12/7/09 Dynamic Transfer Stakeholder Meeting
Joseph H. Rowley Vice President Project Development 101 Ash Street, HQ14A San Diego, CA 92101-3017 Tel: 619.696.4455 Fax: 619.696.2911 JRowley@SempraGeneration.com December 15, 2009 Ms. Anjali Sheffrin
More informationTRANSMISSION PLANNING CRITERIA
CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK, INC. 4 IRVING PLACE NEW YORK, NY 10003-3502 Effective Date: TRANSMISSION PLANNING CRITERIA PURPOSE This specification describes Con Edison s Criteria for assessing
More informationInterconnection System Impact Study Report Request # GI
Executive Summary Interconnection System Impact Study Report Request # GI-2008-23 34 MW Solar Generation Ranch at Hartsel, Colorado Public Service Company of Colorado Transmission Planning August 19, 2010
More informationAPS and Regional Transmission Systems Overview
APS and Regional Transmission Systems Overview Bob Smith Director Energy Delivery Asset Management and Planning Agenda About APS Regional Transmission System Overview APS Transmission System Overview Industry
More informationTHE NECESSITY OF THE 500 KV SYSTEM IN NWE S TRANSMISSION SYSTEM TO MAINTAIN RELIABLE SERVICE TO MONTANA CUSTOMERS
THE NECESSITY OF THE 500 KV SYSTEM IN NWE S TRANSMISSION SYSTEM TO MAINTAIN RELIABLE SERVICE TO MONTANA CUSTOMERS 2/27/2018 ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION PLANNING Table of Contents Table of Contents... 2 Executive
More informationUpdates and Modifications to Report
QUARTERLY COMPLIANCE REPORT (JULY 2014) OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY (U 338-E) REGARDING STATUS OF TRANSMISSION PROJECTS AND GENERATION INTERCONNECTION PROJECTS Pursuant to Commission Decision
More informationGenerator Interconnection Facilities Study For SCE&G Two Combustion Turbine Generators at Hagood
Generator Interconnection Facilities Study For SCE&G Two Combustion Turbine Generators at Hagood Prepared for: SCE&G Fossil/Hydro June 30, 2008 Prepared by: SCE&G Transmission Planning Table of Contents
More informationWestern Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region
Western Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region 2014 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report November 20, 2014 For information or questions regarding this Transmission Assessment Report,
More informationEL PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY (EPE) FACILITIES STUDY FOR PROPOSED HVDC TERMINAL INTERCONNECTION AT NEW ARTESIA 345 KV BUS
EL PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY (EPE) FACILITIES STUDY FOR PROPOSED HVDC TERMINAL INTERCONNECTION AT NEW ARTESIA 345 KV BUS El Paso Electric Company System Operations Department System Planning Section May 2004
More informationElbert County 500 MW Generation Addition Interconnection Feasibility Study Report OASIS POSTING # GI
Executive Summary Elbert County 500 MW Generation Addition Interconnection Feasibility Study Report OASIS POSTING # GI-2003-2 Xcel Energy Transmission Planning January 2004 This Interconnection Feasibility
More informationCity of Palo Alto (ID # 6416) City Council Staff Report
City of Palo Alto (ID # 6416) City Council Staff Report Report Type: Informational Report Meeting Date: 1/25/2016 Summary Title: Update on Second Transmission Line Title: Update on Progress Towards Building
More informationFour Corners 230kV Generator Interconnections Group
A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Four Corners kv Generator Interconnections Group Feasibility Study APS Contract Nos. - By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning September,
More informationConnection Engineering Study Report for AUC Application: AESO Project # 1674
APPENDIX A CONNECTION ASSESSMENT Connection Engineering Study Report for AUC Application: AESO Project # 1674 Executive Summary Project Overview FortisAlberta Inc. (FortisAlberta) submitted a System
More informationLarge Load Serving Study Report for La Plata Electric Association, Inc. Alternatives. Addendum. San Juan Major Project
Large Load Serving Study Report for La Plata Electric Association, Inc. Alternatives Addendum San Juan Major Project Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association Power System Planning December, 2008
More informationMemorandum. This memorandum requires Board action. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
California Independent System Operator Memorandum To: ISO Operations (MRTU) Committee From: Armando J. Perez, Director of Grid Planning cc: ISO Board of Governors ISO Officers Date: April 29, 2005 Re:
More informationLoad Modeling for Power System Studies
Load Modeling for Power System Studies WECC Load Modeling Task Force Dmitry Kosterev Bonneville Power Administration Transmission Planning Timescale of Interest Our primary interest is the fast dynamic
More informationAMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER 2017 FILING FERC FORM 715 ANNUAL TRANSMISSION PLANNING AND EVALUATION REPORT PART 4 TRANSMISSION PLANNING RELIABILITY CRITERIA
AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER 2017 FILING FERC FORM 715 ANNUAL TRANSMISSION PLANNING AND EVALUATION REPORT PART 4 TRANSMISSION PLANNING RELIABILITY CRITERIA AEP Texas (comprised of its Central and North Divisions
More informationTRANSMISSION CONTROL AGREEMENT APPENDIX A. Facilities and Entitlements
TRANSMISSION CONTROL AGREEMENT APPENDIX A Facilities and Entitlements (The Diagrams of Transmission Lines and Associated Facilities Placed Under the Control of the ISO were submitted by the ISO on behalf
More informationMerger of the generator interconnection processes of Valley Electric and the ISO;
California Independent System Operator Corporation Memorandum To: ISO Board of Governors From: Karen Edson Vice President, Policy & Client Services Date: August 18, 2011 Re: Decision on Valley Electric
More informationWestern Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region
Western Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region 2013 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report December 1, 2013 For information or questions regarding this Transmission Assessment Report,
More informationUpdated Transmission Expansion Plan for the Puget Sound Area to Support Winter South-to-North Transfers
Updated Transmission Expansion Plan for the Puget Sound Area to Support Winter South-to-North Transfers Puget Sound Area Study Team Bonneville Power Administration, Puget Sound Energy, Seattle City Light,
More informationBEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Exhibit No.: Commissioner: Loretta Lynch Administrative Law Judge: Meg Gottstein Witness: BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Order Instituting Investigation into ) implementation
More informationQ51 Generation Interconnection
Q51 Generation Facilities Study Results APS Contract No. 52395 By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning September 4, 2013 [Version 1.0] Q51 FACILITIES STUDY TABLE OF CONTENTS Contents 1.
More informationService Requested 150 MW, Firm. Table ES.1: Summary Details for TSR #
Executive Summary Firm point to point transmission service has been requested by Transmission Service Request (TSR) #75669514, under the SaskPower Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT). The TSR consists
More informationPID 274 Feasibility Study Report 13.7 MW Distribution Inter-Connection Buras Substation
PID 274 Feasibility Study Report 13.7 MW Distribution Inter-Connection Buras Substation Prepared by: Entergy Services, Inc. T & D Planning L-ENT-17A 639 Loyola Avenue New Orleans, LA 70113 Rev Issue Date
More informationProject #94. Generation Interconnection System Impact Study Report Revision
Project #94 Generation Interconnection System Impact Study Report Revision October 2, 2009 Electric Transmission Planning Table of Contents Table of Contents...2 Executive Summary...3 Energy Resource Interconnection
More informationEL PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY (EPE) GENERATOR INTERCONNECTION SYSTEM IMPACT STUDY FOR PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX GENERATION ON THE AMRAD-ARTESIA 345 KV
EL PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY (EPE) GENERATOR INTERCONNECTION SYSTEM IMPACT STUDY FOR PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX GENERATION ON THE AMRAD-ARTESIA 345 KV LINE El Paso Electric Company System Planning Department
More informationArizona Transmission Challenges
Power Task Force Agenda Number 2. Arizona Transmission Challenges Central Arizona Water Conservation District Power Committee Presentation May 18, 2017 Transmission Planning Efforts NATIONAL Section 368
More informationSupplemental Report on the NCTPC Collaborative Transmission Plan
Supplemental Report on the NCTPC 2007-2017 Collaborative Transmission Plan May 16, 2008 1 Table of Contents I. Executive Summary...1 II. Richmond-Fort Bragg Woodruff Street 230 kv Line...2 II.A. Need for
More information2020 & 2024 Draft LCR Study Results SDG&E Non-Bulk System. Frank Chen - Regional Transmission Engineer Lead Stakeholder Meeting March 14, 2019
2020 & 2024 Draft LCR Study Results SDG&E Non-Bulk System Frank Chen - Regional Transmission Engineer Lead Stakeholder Meeting March 14, 2019 ARIZONA San Diego Non-Bulk LCR Area CHINO [SCE] SERRANO [SCE]
More informationAppendix D Black Hills Project Summary
Page 1 of 28 Appendix D Black Hills Project Summary Table of Contents Black Hills Project Summary... D-1 Boone-Nyberg 115 kv Project... D-3 Rattlesnake Butte 115 kv Substation Terminal... D-6 Fountain
More informationEPRI HVDC Research. Gary Sibilant, EPRI. August 30, 2011
EPRI HVDC Research John Chan, Ram Adapa, Bernie Clairmont & Gary Sibilant, EPRI EPRI HVDC & FACTS Conference August 30, 2011 Presentation Contents 1. Team Members 2. Research Program Objective & Scope
More informationEvaluation of the Performance of Back-to-Back HVDC Converter and Variable Frequency Transformer for Power Flow Control in a Weak Interconnection
Evaluation of the Performance of Back-to-Back HVDC Converter and Variable Frequency Transformer for Power Flow Control in a Weak Interconnection B. Bagen, D. Jacobson, G. Lane and H. M. Turanli Manitoba
More informationManaging California s Electrical Supply System after the shut down of San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station
Managing California s Electrical Supply System after the shut down of San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station East Asian Alternative Energy Futures Workshop By the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center
More informationConsulting Agreement Study. Completed for Transmission Customer
Completed for Transmission Customer Proposed Resource & Transmission Carbon County, MT & 230 kv Transmission in North Wyoming August 2016 Table of Contents 1.0 Description... 1 2.0 Overall Assumptions...
More informationMILLIGAN SOLAR PROJECT
February 16, 2009 Page 1 of 18 A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation MILLIGAN SOLAR PROJECT FINAL Feasibility Study Report APS Contract 52115 Prepared by: Arizona Public Service Company Transmission
More informationOperating Procedure. EIR (webregistry) (POR/POD dropdown) AZPS NGILAN_5_N034 North Gila 500 NRTHGILA500 NRTHGILA500 NORTHGILA500_ITC
1. Procedure Detail 1.1. Purpose The California ISO market Scheduling paths are associated with the market Scheduling and tie points. In most cases, the name registered in the NAESB Electric Industry Registry
More informationTransWest Express Transmission AC and DC Project Interregional Transmission Project Submittal
TransWest Express Transmission AC and DC Project 2018 2019 Interregional Transmission Project Submittal Submittals to California Independent System Operator, WestConnect and Northern Tier Transmission
More informationOverview of APS U.S.-JORDAN ELECTRIC POWER TRANSMISSION PARTNERSHIP EXECUTIVE EXCHANGE VISIT. Bob Smith
Overview of APS U.S.-JORDAN ELECTRIC POWER TRANSMISSION PARTNERSHIP EXECUTIVE EXCHANGE VISIT Bob Smith Director Energy Delivery Asset Management and Planning Agenda About APS Regional Transmission System
More informationVerde Transmission, LLC. Verde Project. System Impact Study Report
Verde Transmission, LLC Verde Project System Impact Study Report March 2017 Prepared by: Public Service Company of New Mexico Foreword This report was prepared for Verde Transmission, LLC by the PNM Transmission/
More informationArizona Energy Consortium Conference
SunZia Southwest Transmission Project SunZia and Potential Impacts of Regionalization Arizona Energy Consortium Conference SUNZIA SOUTHWEST TRANSMISSION PROJECT SEPTEMBER 2018 0 SunZia: 500kV Project delivering
More informationATTACHMENT Y STUDY REPORT
Attachment Y Study Edwards Unit 1: 90 MW Coal Retirement December 31, 2012 ATTACHMENT Y STUDY REPORT 7/5/2013 PUBLIC / EXECUTIVE SUMMARY MISO received an Attachment Y Notification of Potential Generation
More informationCUSTOMER/ TWIN ARROWS PROJECT
A subsidiary of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation CUSTOMER/ TWIN ARROWS PROJECT V1 Facility Study Report APS Contract 52149 Prepared by: Arizona Public Service Company Transmission & Distribution Asset
More informationWashington, DC Area Low Voltage Disturbance
Washington, DC Area Low Voltage Disturbance April 7, 2015 Robert W. Cummings Sr. Director of Engineering and Reliability Initiatives NASPI Working Group Meeting October 15, 2015 Overview April 7, 2015-12:39
More informationSPS Planning Criteria and Study Methodology
SPS Planning Criteria and Study Methodology SPS subscribes to the Southwest Power Pool ("SPP") Reliability Criteria, which incorporates compliance with the appropriate North American Electric Reliability
More informationTransient Stability Analysis Tool (TSAT) Update April 11, Hongming Zhang EMS Network Applications Manager
Transient Stability Analysis Tool (TSAT) Update April 11, 2016 Hongming Zhang EMS Network Applications Manager Agenda Peak Online TSAT Introduction: Where we are on Wide-wide System Model (WSM) -TSAT online
More informationEl PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY 2014 BULK ELECTRIC SYSTEM TRANSMISSION ASSESSMENT FOR YEARS
El Paso Electric Company El PASO ELECTRIC COMPANY 2014 BULK ELECTRIC SYSTEM TRANSMISSION ASSESSMENT FOR YEARS 2015 2024 A Review on System Performance Following Extreme Bulk Electric System Events of the
More informationTable of Contents. Purpose. Eldorado Intertie and System (Eldorado- Moenkopi) Scheduling at Willow Beach. Operating Procedure
No. 6930 Table of Contents Purpose... 1 1. Limits, Ratings, & Effectiveness Factors... 2 2. Contingency Operations... 2 2.1 Transmission Lines Outages... 2 2.2 APS Terminal Equipment Outages... 2 2.3 SCE
More informationGENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED
DATE: June 28, 2011 STAFF: Brian Janonis Brian Moeck, PRPA Pre-taped staff presentation: none WORK SESSION ITEM FORT COLLINS CITY COUNCIL SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION Electric Transmission Update. EXECUTIVE
More information15 Nelson-Marlborough Regional Plan
15 Nelson-Marlborough Regional Plan 15.1 Regional overview 15.2 Nelson-Marlborough transmission system 15.3 Nelson-Marlborough demand 15.4 Nelson-Marlborough generation 15.5 Nelson-Marlborough significant
More informationIntroduction and Overview
Introduction and Overview Neil Millar Generation Deliverability Assessment Methodology Proposal Call December 18, 2018 Generation Deliverability Methodology Revision Process November 16, 2018: CAISO presented
More informationFour Corners Queue Transmission Interconnection Study
Four Corners Queue Transmission Interconnection Study Facility Study Results By Arizona Public Service Company Transmission Planning & Interconnection Development March 22, 2016 Version 1 FACILITIES STUDY
More informationThe Long-Range Transmission Plan
The Long-Range Transmission Plan 2015 2025 Matt Koenig Presentation to ESPWG / TPAS October 29 th, 2015 Long-Range Transmission Plan Driver of the Plan is to maintain local reliability 10-year planning
More informationAgenda Less than $50 Million Projects and Preliminary Economic Assessment Results
Agenda Less than $50 Million Projects and Preliminary Economic Assessment Results Kim Perez Stakeholder Engagement and Policy Specialist 2017-2018 Transmission Planning Process Stakeholder Meeting November
More informationEssential Reliability Services From PV Plants
Essential Reliability Services From PV Plants Mahesh Morjaria, Ph. D. VP, PV Systems Enabling a world powered by reliable, affordable solar electricity. Utility-Scale PV Plants Support Grid Stability &
More informationMerchant Transmission Interconnection PJM Impact Study Report. PJM Merchant Transmission Request Queue Position X3-028.
Merchant Transmission Interconnection PJM Impact Study Report For PJM Merchant Transmission Request Queue Position X3-028 Breed 345 kv October/2014 System Impact Study Breed 345 kv Merchant Transmission
More informationDistributed Energy Resources
Distributed Energy Resources WECC Data Subcommittee Rich Hydzik, Avista (ERSWG/DER Subgroup Lead) June 29, 2018 Why Are We Concerned About DER? Concern about changing generation fleet Large coal fired
More informationInterconnection Feasibility Study Report GIP-226-FEAS-R3
Interconnection Feasibility Study Report GIP-226-FEAS-R3 System Interconnection Request #226 70 MW Wind Generating Facility Kings County (L-6013) 2010 07 21 Control Centre Operations Nova Scotia Power
More informationDecision on Merced Irrigation District Transition Agreement
California Independent System Operator Corporation Memorandum To: ISO Board of Governors From: Karen Edson, Vice President Policy & Client Services Date: March 13, 2013 Re: Decision on Merced Irrigation
More informationAQUILA NETWORKS WESTPLAINS ENERGY COLORADO CATEGORY C CONTINGENCY STUDIES
AQUILA NETWORKS WESTPLAINS ENERGY COLORADO CATEGORY C CONTINGENCY STUDIES 2008-2012 April 2008 Table of Contents 1.0 INTRODUCTION... 2 2.0 RESULTS... 2 2.1 CATEGORY C NO SOLVE CASES... 2 2.2 CATEGORY C
More information2012 LOCAL TRANSMISSION PLAN:
Colorado PUC E-Filings System 2012 LOCAL TRANSMISSION PLAN: TRANSMISSION COORDINATION AND PLANNING COMMITTEE ANNUAL TRANSMISSION ASSESSMENT FOR BLACK HILLS/COLORADO ELECTRIC UTILITY COMPANY, L.P., D/B/A
More informationNorthernLights HVDC Project
WECC COMPREHENSIVE PROGRESS REPORT December 4, 2008 Prepared for TransCanada by Ben Williams TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY... III 1.0 BACKGROUND & INTRODUCTION... 1 1.1 BACKGROUND... 1 1.2 INTRODUCTION...
More informationA Case Study on Aggregate Load Modeling in Transient Stability Studies
A Case Study on Aggregate Load Modeling in Transient Stability Studies Presented by: Daniel Feltes Siemens PTI Coauthors: Carlos Grande-Moran, Bernardo Fernandes, James Feltes, Ming Wu and Robert Wells
More informationCalifornia Independent. System Operator. Market Overview and Design Construct
California Independent Market Overview and Design Construct Kyle Hoffman 916-608-1127 khoffman@caiso.com The ISO Vision Preferred Provider of Superior Electric Transmission Services Ensure reliable transmission
More informationStability Study for the Mt. Olive Hartburg 500 kv Line
Stability Study for the Mt. Olive Hartburg 500 kv Line Peng Yu Sharma Kolluri Transmission & Distribution Planning Group Energy Delivery Organization Entergy Sevices Inc April, 2011 New Orleans, LA 1.
More informationOpening Transmission Planning Process Stakeholder Meeting Tom Cuccia Lead Stakeholder Engagement and Policy Specialist November 19-20, 2014
Opening 2014-2015 Transmission Planning Process Stakeholder Meeting Tom Cuccia Lead Stakeholder Engagement and Policy Specialist November 19-20, 2014 Yesterday s Agenda November 19 th Topic Opening Introduction
More informationaps January 29, 2016 Docket Control Arizona Corporation Commission 1200 West Washington Street Phoenix, Arizona 85007
aps Kerri A. Carnes Manager State Regulation and Compliance Mail Station 9712 PO Box 53999 Phoenix, Arizona 85072-3999 Tel 602-250-3341 Kerri.Carnes@aps.com January 29, 2016 Docket Control Arizona Corporation
More informationTransmission Coordination and Planning Committee 2014 Q4 Stakeholder Meeting. December 18, 2014
Transmission Coordination and Planning Committee 2014 Q4 Stakeholder Meeting December 18, 2014 Agenda 1. Introductions 2. TCPC Policies 3. BHCE Planning Department Update 4. 2014 LTP Study Results 5. Stakeholder
More informationJoint Con Edison LIPA Offshore Wind Power Integration Project Feasibility Assessment
Joint Con Edison LIPA Offshore Wind Power Integration Project Feasibility Assessment For NPCC Governmental / Regulatory Affairs Advisory Group May 21 st, 2009 ON IT Executive Summary Engineers from Con
More information