NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 1 of 22

Transcription

1 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 6-NFPA [ Section No ] UL Publications. Underwriters Laboratories Inc., 333 Pfingsten Road, Northbrook, IL ANSI/UL 10B, Standard for Fire Tests of Door Assemblies, ANSI/UL 10C, Standard for Positive Pressure Fire Tests of Door Assemblies, ANSI/UL 1784, Air Leakage Tests of Door Assemblies, This proposal updates the referenced UL Standards to the current edition. Submitter Full Name: Ronald Farr Organization: UL LLC Submittal Date: Mon Jun 27 17:01:01 EDT 2016 Resolution: CI-7-NFPA Statement: At the Second Draft meeting, the committee will review the referenced publications and update to the appropriate edition date. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 1 of 22

2 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 8-NFPA [ Section No ] The operational test shall be conducted under normal HVAC airflow conditions as well as static flow pressurized conditions. The damper shall fully close/seal under both test conditions. Static pressure is not a "flow" condition. Static pressure is simply the pressure inside a vessel, and has nothing to do with flow. Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:30:21 EDT 2016 Resolution: FR-1-NFPA Statement: Static pressure is not a "flow" condition. Static pressure is simply the pressure inside a vessel, and has nothing to do with flow. Static is not defined. The proposed text is more explanatory and provides a better description of damper operation. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 2 of 22

3 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 9-NFPA [ Section No ] All indicating devices shall be witness verified to work properly and report to the intended location interface. Consistent with field verifying the operation of dampers. Add interface reads better than location. Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:35:06 EDT 2016 Resolution: The proposed change is unclear. It is requested that the submitter further clarify the changes and the intent of the changes with additional substantiation. How can witness be better defined, what is the intent of the addition of that word. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 3 of 22

4 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 4-NFPA [ Sections 7.5.1, 7.5.2, 7.5.3, 7.5.4, ] Sections 7.5.1, 7.5.2, 7.5.3, 7.5.4, Acceptance testing of smoke dampers shall be performed by a qualified person with knowledge and understanding of the operating components of the type of assembly to be tested Before testing, a visual inspection shall be performed to identify any damaged or missing parts that could create a hazard during testing or affect operation or resetting * Acceptance testing shall include the closing of the damper by every means If the damper is equipped with a variable air volume system, acceptance 3.3 Acceptance testing shall be conducted by removing electrical power or air pressure from the actuator and ensuring that the damper closes properly Electrical power or air pressure shall then be reapplied to the damper to confirm that it returns to its full-open position Acceptance testing shall be conducted after the building mechanical ventilation system has been balanced, and in operation under maximum air flow, if equipped with a variable air volume system in accordance with A record of these inspections and testing shall be made in accordance with The phrase by all means in this section is too open-ended and is subject to interpretation. The proposed new language describes specifically how the test is to be conducted. Submitter Full Name: Vickie Lovell Organization: Intercode Incorporated Affilliation: Air Movement and Control Association International NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 4 of 22

5 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Submittal Date: Fri Jun 24 14:54:31 EDT 2016 Resolution: Statement: The phrase by all means in this section is too open-ended and is subject to interpretation. The proposed new language describes specifically how the test is to be conducted. The changes are being proposed as a committee input. The committee is seeking additional information and more time is needed to further refine the language as well as compare the damper provisions in NFPA 105 with those provisions in NFPA 80. A task group has been established that will review, in depth, the damper provisions in both NFPA 80 and NFPA 105, with a focus on the inspection, testing, and maintenance requirements. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 5 of 22

6 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 10-NFPA [ Section No ] 7.5.3* Acceptance testing shall include visual witnessing the closing of the damper by every means. Consistent with other NFPA requirments Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:42:06 EDT 2016 Resolution: The committee is requesting additional information from the submitter and clarification on the intent of the proposed change. The substantiation is not clear and does not explain the change. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 6 of 22

7 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 11-NFPA [ Section No ] If the damper is equipped with installed in a variable air volume system, acceptance testing shall be conducted after the building mechanical ventilation system has been tested, adjusted, balanced, and in operation under maximum air flow. Dampers are installed in VAV systems they are not the VAV system. Added verbiage to identify completion of the testing after construction is complete. Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:44:07 EDT 2016 Resolution: FR-3-NFPA Statement: Dampers are installed in VAV systems they are not the VAV system. Added verbiage to identify completion of the testing after construction is complete. The words 'tested and adjusted' are redundant and not required. A system that is balanced has already been tested and adjusted. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 7 of 22

8 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 1-NFPA [ Sections 7.5.4, ] Sections 7.5.4, Acceptance If the damper is equipped with a variable air volume sytem, acceptance testing shall be conducted after the building mechanical ventilation system has been balanced, and in operation under maximum air flow, if equipped with a variable air volume system in accordance with A record of these inspections and testing shall be made in accordance with Additional Proposed Changes File Name Description Approved Issued_TIA_ pdf TIA 16-1 NOTE: This public input originates from TIA issued on December 8, 2015 by the Standards Council. According to the NFPA Regs., needs to be reconsidered by the Technical Committee for the next edition of the document. Submitter Full Name: TC FDW-AAA Organization: NFPA Submittal Date: Thu Dec 31 11:35:37 EST 2015 Resolution: FR-3-NFPA Statement: Dampers are installed in VAV systems they are not the VAV system. Added verbiage to identify completion of the testing after construction is complete. The words 'tested and adjusted' are redundant and not required. A system that is balanced has already been tested and adjusted. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 8 of 22

9 Tentative Interim Amendment NFPA 105 Standard for Smoke Door Assemblies and Other Opening Protectives 2016 Edition Reference: 7.5.4, and TIA 16-1 (SC / TIA Log #1192) Pursuant to Section 5 of the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards, the National Fire Protection Association has issued the following Tentative Interim Amendment to NFPA 105, Standard for Smoke Door and Other Opening Protectives, 2016 edition. The TIA was processed by the Technical Committee on Fire Doors and Windows and was issued by the Standards Council on December 8, 2015, with an effective date of December 28, A Tentative Interim Amendment is tentative because it has not been processed through the entire standards-making procedures. It is interim because it is effective only between editions of the standard. A TIA automatically becomes a public input of the proponent for the next edition of the standard; as such, it then is subject to all of the procedures of the standards-making process. 1. Revise section and to read as follows: If the damper is equipped with a variable air volume system, acceptance testing shall be conducted after the building mechanical ventilation system has been balanced and in operation under maximum air flow A record of these inspections and testing shall be made in accordance with Revise section to read as follows: Testing of dampers with actuator shall comply with the following procedure: (1) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. (2) Verify that all obstructions, including hands, are out of the path of the damper blades and then remove electrical power or air pressure from the actuator to allow the actuator s spring return feature to close the damper. (3) Visually confirm that the damper closes completely. (4) Reapply electrical power or air pressure to reopen the damper. (5) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. Issue Date: December 8, 2015 Effective Date: December 28, 2015 (Note: For further information on NFPA Codes and Standards, please see Copyright 2015 All Rights Reserve NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 9 of 22

10 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 5-NFPA [ Section No. 7.6 ] 7.6 Periodic Inspection and Testing General Smoke dampers for dedicated and nondedicated smoke control systems shall be inspected and tested in accordance with NFPA 92, Standard for Smoke Control Sytems Combination fire/smoke dampers shall be inspected and tested in accordance with NFPA 80, Standard for Fire Doors and Other Opening Protectives * Testing Frequency Each damper shall be tested and inspected 1 year after installation * The test and inspection frequency shall then be every 4 years, except in buildings containing a hospital, where the frequency shall be every 6 years Test Method. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 10 of 22

11 0 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM General All tests shall be completed in a safe manner by personnel wearing personal protective equipment (PPE) All tests shall be completed in a safe manner by personnel wearing personal protective equipment (PPE) Fans shall not be permitted to be shut down during the test Testing of dampers shall comply with the following procedure: 2 Visual Inspection Method Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully- full open or full closed position. Verify that all obstructions, including hands, are out of the path of the damper blades and then remove electrical power or air pressure from the actuator to allow the actuator s spring return feature to close the damper. Visually confirm that the damper closes completely. Reapply electrical power or air pressure to reopen the damper. Visually as required by the system design Command and visually confirm the damper to the full closed or full open position Restore and visually confirm the damper to the original operating position as required by the system design Remote Inspection Method General Dampers inspected remotely shall be designed with the ability to indicate when the damper is fully open and fully closed Prior to using remote inspection a visual inspection of the installed damper shall be performed The visual inspection shall confirm that the position indication method accurately reflects the full open and full closed position of the damper Test Procedure Signal from the damper s position indication device to confirm that the damper is in the fully full -open or closed position as required by the system design The damper shall be Commanded and confirmed to the full closed or full open position The damper shall be confirmed to the original operating position as required by the system design Documentation All inspections and testing shall be documented indicating the location of the damper, date of inspection, name of inspector, and deficiencies discovered. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 11 of 22

12 1 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM The documentation shall have space to indicate when and how the deficiencies were corrected All documentation shall be maintained for at least three test cycles and made available for review by the AHJ. 7.6 The proposal modifies the section header to keep it consistent with the corresponding section in NFPA 80 (section 19.5) and the proposal adds the names of the referenced standards to the text The proposal adds the word General to keep this section consistent with other similar sections in the standard. The rest of the section is then renumbered accordingly The proposal attempts to accomplish two objectives by rewriting this section. First, the title of this section Dampers with Motorized Actuators is confusing as it implies that there is a periodic test method for dampers without a motorized actuator. That is not the case. UL555S requires that all smoke and combination fire smoke dampers have a factory supplied actuator. The second objective of modifying this section is to add an option to perform periodic testing on dampers remotely using position indication switches. The proposal requires that an initial visual inspection be performed prior to utilizing the remote testing option. For new construction this initial visual inspection will typically take place as part of the Acceptance Testing. Submitter Full Name: Vickie Lovell Organization: Intercode Incorporated Affilliation: Air Movement and Control Association International Submittal Date: Fri Jun 24 15:10:53 EDT 2016 Resolution: Statement: 7.6 The revision modifies the section header to keep it consistent with the corresponding section in NFPA 80 (section 19.5) and The revision adds the names of the referenced standards to the text It is often difficult to determine the date a damper was installed on large projects which require installation of numerous dampers. This poses a problem during regulatory inspections related to damper testing. The date of commissioning is documented and NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 12 of 22

13 2 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM would be easier to determine when to perform the 1 year test , change clarified when periodic inspection and test is required The revision adds the word General to keep this section consistent with other similar sections in the standard. The rest of the section is then renumbered accordingly The revision attempts to accomplish two objectives by rewriting this section. First, the title of this section Dampers with Motorized Actuators is confusing as it implies that there is a periodic test method for dampers without a motorized actuator. That is not the case. UL555S requires that all smoke and combination fire smoke dampers have a factory supplied actuator. The second objective of modifying this section is to add an option to perform periodic testing on dampers remotely using position indication switches. The proposal requires that an initial visual inspection be performed prior to utilizing the remote testing option. For new construction this initial visual inspection will typically take place as part of the Acceptance Testing. add statement from PI 3 NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 13 of 22

14 Public Input No. 12-NFPA [ Section No ] Each damper shall be tested and inspected within 1 year after of installation. Mandates the testing after job is complete and before the 1 year anniversary. Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:48:41 EDT 2016 Resolution: Statement: 7.6 The revision modifies the section header to keep it consistent with the corresponding section in NFPA 80 (section 19.5) and The revision adds the names of the referenced standards to the text It is often difficult to determine the date a damper was installed on large projects which require installation of numerous dampers. This poses a problem during regulatory inspections related to damper testing. The date of commissioning is documented and would be easier to determine when to perform the 1 year test , change clarified when periodic inspection and test is required The revision adds the word General to keep this section consistent with other similar sections in the standard. The rest of the section is then renumbered accordingly The revision attempts to accomplish two objectives by rewriting this section. First, the title of this section Dampers with Motorized Actuators is confusing as it implies that there is a periodic test method for dampers without a motorized actuator. That is not the case. UL555S requires that all smoke and combination fire smoke dampers have a factory supplied actuator. The second objective of modifying this section is to add an option to perform periodic testing on dampers remotely using position indication switches. The proposal requires NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 14 of 22 3 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM

15 4 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM that an initial visual inspection be performed prior to utilizing the remote testing option. For new construction this initial visual inspection will typically take place as part of the Acceptance Testing. add statement from PI 3 NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 15 of 22

16 Public Input No. 3-NFPA [ Section No ] Each damper shall be tested and inspected 1 year after installation acceptance testing. It is often difficult to determine the date a damper was installed on large projects which require installation of numerous dampers. This poses a problem during regulatory inspections related to damper testing. The date of commissioning is documented and would be easier to determine when to perform the 1 year test. This language is currently in the 2016 edition of NFPA 80. Submitter Full Name: Lennon Peake Organization: Koffel Associates, Inc. Submittal Date: Tue Jan 05 08:24:11 EST 2016 Resolution: Statement: 7.6 The revision modifies the section header to keep it consistent with the corresponding section in NFPA 80 (section 19.5) and The revision adds the names of the referenced standards to the text It is often difficult to determine the date a damper was installed on large projects which require installation of numerous dampers. This poses a problem during regulatory inspections related to damper testing. The date of commissioning is documented and would be easier to determine when to perform the 1 year test , change clarified when periodic inspection and test is required The revision adds the word General to keep this section consistent with other similar sections in the standard. The rest of the section is then renumbered accordingly The revision attempts to accomplish two objectives by rewriting this section. First, the title of this section Dampers with Motorized Actuators is confusing as it implies that there is a periodic test method for dampers without a motorized actuator. That is not the case. UL555S requires that all smoke and combination fire smoke dampers have a factory supplied actuator. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 16 of 22 5 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM

17 6 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM The second objective of modifying this section is to add an option to perform periodic testing on dampers remotely using position indication switches. The proposal requires that an initial visual inspection be performed prior to utilizing the remote testing option. For new construction this initial visual inspection will typically take place as part of the Acceptance Testing. add statement from PI 3 NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 17 of 22

18 7 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 2-NFPA [ Section No ] Dampers with Motorized Actuators. Testing of dampers with actuators shall comply with the following procedure: (1) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. (2) Verify that all obstructions, including hands, are out of the path of the damper blades and then remove electrical power or air pressure from the actuator to allow the actuator s spring return feature to close the damper. (3) Visually confirm that the damper closes completely. (4) Reapply electrical power or air pressure to reopen the damper. (5) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. Additional Proposed Changes File Name Description Approved Issued_TIA_ pdf TIA NOTE: This public input originates from TIA was issued on December 8, 2015 by the Standards Council o. According to the NFPA Regs., this TIA must to be reconsidered by the Technical Committee for the next edition of the document. Submitter Full Name: TC FDW-AAA Organization: NFPA Submittal Date: Thu Dec 31 11:42:23 EST 2015 Resolution: Statement: 7.6 The revision modifies the section header to keep it consistent with the corresponding section in NFPA 80 (section 19.5) and The revision adds the names of the referenced standards to the text It is often difficult to determine the date a damper was installed on large projects NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 18 of 22

19 Tentative Interim Amendment NFPA 105 Standard for Smoke Door Assemblies and Other Opening Protectives 2016 Edition Reference: 7.5.4, and TIA 16-1 (SC / TIA Log #1192) Pursuant to Section 5 of the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards, the National Fire Protection Association has issued the following Tentative Interim Amendment to NFPA 105, Standard for Smoke Door and Other Opening Protectives, 2016 edition. The TIA was processed by the Technical Committee on Fire Doors and Windows and was issued by the Standards Council on December 8, 2015, with an effective date of December 28, A Tentative Interim Amendment is tentative because it has not been processed through the entire standards-making procedures. It is interim because it is effective only between editions of the standard. A TIA automatically becomes a public input of the proponent for the next edition of the standard; as such, it then is subject to all of the procedures of the standards-making process. 1. Revise section and to read as follows: If the damper is equipped with a variable air volume system, acceptance testing shall be conducted after the building mechanical ventilation system has been balanced and in operation under maximum air flow A record of these inspections and testing shall be made in accordance with Revise section to read as follows: Testing of dampers with actuator shall comply with the following procedure: (1) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. (2) Verify that all obstructions, including hands, are out of the path of the damper blades and then remove electrical power or air pressure from the actuator to allow the actuator s spring return feature to close the damper. (3) Visually confirm that the damper closes completely. (4) Reapply electrical power or air pressure to reopen the damper. (5) Visually confirm that the damper is in the fully-open position. Issue Date: December 8, 2015 Effective Date: December 28, 2015 (Note: For further information on NFPA Codes and Standards, please see Copyright 2015 All Rights Reserve NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 19 of 22

20 8 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM which require installation of numerous dampers. This poses a problem during regulatory inspections related to damper testing. The date of commissioning is documented and would be easier to determine when to perform the 1 year test , change clarified when periodic inspection and test is required The revision adds the word General to keep this section consistent with other similar sections in the standard. The rest of the section is then renumbered accordingly The revision attempts to accomplish two objectives by rewriting this section. First, the title of this section Dampers with Motorized Actuators is confusing as it implies that there is a periodic test method for dampers without a motorized actuator. That is not the case. UL555S requires that all smoke and combination fire smoke dampers have a factory supplied actuator. The second objective of modifying this section is to add an option to perform periodic testing on dampers remotely using position indication switches. The proposal requires that an initial visual inspection be performed prior to utilizing the remote testing option. For new construction this initial visual inspection will typically take place as part of the Acceptance Testing. add statement from PI 3 NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 20 of 22

21 9 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 13-NFPA [ Section No ] 7.7.2* All exposed moving parts of the damper shall be lubricated ( dry lubricated ) as required by the manufacturer. What if the manufacture has a way to lubricate that is not dry? Should not be prescriptive follow the manufactures requirments. Submitter Full Name: John Hamilton Organization: National Energy Management Ins Submittal Date: Tue Jun 28 17:58:30 EDT 2016 Resolution: FR-5-NFPA Statement: The manufacturer provides specifications for lubrication. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 21 of 22

22 0 of 20 11/4/2016 5:57 PM Public Input No. 7-NFPA [ Section No. C ] C UL Publications. Underwriters Laboratories Inc., 333 Pfingsten Road, Northbrook, IL ANSI/UL 1784, Air Leakage Tests of Door Assemblies, This proposal updates the referenced UL Standards to the current edition. Submitter Full Name: Ronald Farr Organization: UL LLC Submittal Date: Mon Jun 27 17:02:57 EDT 2016 Resolution: CI-8-NFPA Statement: At the Second Draft meeting, the committee will review the referenced publications and update to the appropriate edition date. NFPA 105 Public Input Report Page 22 of 22