2017 Corn Grain Field Crop Trials Results

Transcription

1 Field Crop Trials Results Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station and the College of Food, Agricultural and Natural Resource Sciences The Minnesota Corn Evaluation Program was conducted by the University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station to provide unbiased information for use by corn growers when they choose which brand of corn to buy and grow. The program was financed in part by entry fees from private seed companies that chose to place their entries for testing. Test Test zones, locations and maturities are as follows: Southern Zone: Lamberton, Rochester and Waseca Early Maturity Trial Maturity (RM) and earlier entries. Late Maturity Trial RM and later entries. Central Zone: Hutchinson, Morris and Rosemount Early Maturity Trial - 96 RM and earlier entries. Late Maturity Trial - 97 RM and later entries. Northern Zone: Crookston, Rothsay and Staples Testing Procedure Entries: Seed corn companies choose their entries for each zone. Entries in each trial were based on the relative maturity (RM) provided by the company. The University of Minnesota Corn Testing Committee could also choose entries in each test. All locations tested three replications for each entry. Corn Grain of 2017 corn grain trials. Planting Rate and Date Bushel Weight, Pounds...56 Planting Rate, Seeds/Acre...35,000 Planting Date...May 5-29 Table 1. Companies participating in the 2017 corn grain trials. AgriGold Hybrids 5381 Akin Rd, St. Francisville, IL Albert Lea Seed House (Viking Hybrids) Box 127, 1414 W. Main St., Albert Lea, MN Anderson Seeds County Rd. 63, St. Peter, MN Blue River Hybrids th St., Ames, IA Dairyland Seed Co., Inc. Box 958, West Bend, WI Dekalb (Monsanto Co.) th Ave. SE, Kerkhoven, MN Federal Hybrids 209 3rd St. NE, West Bend, IA Legacy Seeds Inc. PO Box 68, 290 Depot Street, Scandinavia, WI Masters Choice (Sun Prairie) 305 W. Vienna St. Anna, IL seedcorn.com Munson Hybrids 1262 Knox Rd 100E, Galesburg, IL NuTech Seed 2321 North Loop Drive, Suite 230; Ames, IA Peterson Farms Seed th Ave. S.E., Harwood, ND Proseed 705 E Brewster St., Harvey, ND Thunder Seed 806 Center Ave W, Dilworth, MN Titan Pro 1301 S. 24th St., Clear Lake, IA

2 Presentation of Data Yields are given for individual locations along with yields and harvest moisture contents averaged across locations for Reported yields are adjusted to 15.5% grain moisture. Entries are ranked within a maturity group by moisture content averaged across locations for Identification of Traits Genetic modifications of entries will be identified using generic terms to describe the trait without identifying the specific event for genetic modification. For example Bt will indentify genetic modification for corn borer resistance Table 2. Individual trial information, but will not differentiate between the Bt 11 event, the YieldGuard corn borer event or the Herculex corn borer event. Identifiers will be: Bt = Europeon corn borer resistance CRW = Corn rootworm resistance GLY = Glyphosate herbicide resistance LL = Liberty herbicide resistance Least Significant Difference The LSD (Least Significant Difference) figures at the bottom of the yield columns in the tables are statistical measures of variability in the trials. These values may be used to determine whether the difference between any two entries is likely to be a real difference or just natural varia- Location Cooperators Previous Crop Planting Date Harvest Date Lamberton Steve Quiring Soybeans May 10 October 19 Rochester Fritz Brietenbach Soybeans May 8 November 6 Waseca Tom Hoverstad Soybeans May 5 October 16 Hutchinson Nathan Winter and Paul Wright Wheat May 29 November 2 Morris Curt Reese Corn May 12 November 3 Rosemount Gerry Holz Soybeans May 8 November 7 Crookston Mark Hanson Soybeans May 11 October 19 Rothsay Troy Larson Soybeans May 12 November 14 Staples Ron Nelson Soybeans May 10 November 9 tion. If the yield difference between two entries is equal to or greater than the LSD, then one can be confident that the two entries probably differ in yield potential. We show LSD values with a 0.2 alpha level, which means that when two entries differ in yield by the LSD value or more one can be 80% confident that the two entries differ in yield potential. The higher-yielding one is the better entry from the yield standpoint. If the yield difference between two entries is less than the LSD, the two entries probably do not differ significantly in yield potential. Project Leader Tom Hoverstad. Test Plot Managers Tom Hoverstad, Wade Ihlenfeld, Jeff Coulter, Curt Reese, Steve Quiring and Mark Hanson. 2

3 Table 3. Early maturity entries, southern locations, 2017 Source Entry Traits Maturity Lamberton Rochester Waseca Bu/Acre % Moisture 97 and earlier RM entries Federal Hybrids 4760 VT2 Pro GLY,Bt AgriGold A6199STXRIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds 669SRC GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds Proseed GX695 GLY,Bt,LL Anderson Seeds 795R GLY Proseed 1395 GLY,Bt Federal Hybrids 4580 VT2 Pro GLY,Bt and earlier RM averages: to 101 RM entries Anderson Seeds 675VT2P GLY,Bt Proseed 1598 GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-9599 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Viking AgriGold A628-20VT2PRO GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds 611VT2P GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt Viking Art Anderson Seeds 684R GLY Dekalb DKC49-72RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds AgriGold A629-22STX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Legacy Seeds L-4317 GENSS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Viking Viking O NuTech 5N-800 GLY,Bt,LL Viking O Anderson Seeds 611SRC GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5FN-7099 GLY,Bt,LL Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Proseed GLY,Bt Dekalb DKC51-38RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC50-08RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW AgriGold A630-31VT2RIBD1 GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-601 GLY,Bt,LL to 101 RM Averages: to 103 RM entries Viking Anderson Seeds Dekalb DKC52-84RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-702 GLY,Bt,LL Viking O.86-03UP Federal Hybrids 5370 SSTAX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics X5LN-0308 GLY,Bt,LL NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-503 GLY,Bt,LL Federal Hybrids 5280 VT2 Pro GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-9802RA GLY,Bt,LL,CRW AgriGold A6267STXRIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt Dekalb DKC53-56RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Blue River 48G to 103 RM averages: Southern locations, early maturity averages: LSD (0.20)

4 Table 4. Late maturity entries, southern locations, Source Entry Traits Maturity Lamberton Rochester Waseca Bu/Acre % Moisture 104 RM and later entries Dairyland Seed DS-6106 GLY AgriGold A636-55VT2PRO GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-9804SSX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC54-38RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-504 GLY,Bt,LL Viking Viking O.51-04GS AgriGold A6413STXRIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW AgriGold A6346VT2RIB GLY,Bt Federal Hybrids 5885 VT2 Pro GLY,Bt Legacy Seeds L-5516 GENSS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW AgriGold A636-56STX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Federal Hybrids 5550 Conv Legacy Seeds L-6047 GENSS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Viking AgriGold A635-54VT2PRO GLY,Bt Dekalb DKC56-45RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5D-906 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC58-06RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5H-806 GLY,Bt,LL Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Viking NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-308 GLY,Bt,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9508RA GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Southern locations, late maturity averages: LSD (0.20)

5 Table 5. Early maturity entries, central locations, Source Entry Traits Maturity Hutchinson Morris Rosemount Bu/Acre % Moisture 93 and earlier RM entries Dairyland Seed EXP GLY,Bt,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9090SSX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds Anderson Seeds 742R GLY Viking Art Proseed 1591 GLY,Bt Munson Hybrids A GLY,Bt,LL Munson Hybrids GLY,Bt,LL Thunder Seed 7993 VT2P GLY,Bt Thunder Seed 6791 RR GLY AgriGold A6179STXRIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dairyland Seed DS-6091 GLY RM and earlier averages: to 96 RM entries AgriGold A6199STXRIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Peterson Farms Seed 81W95 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Thunder Seed 6794 VT2P GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds 795R GLY Proseed PX694 GLY,Bt Munson Hybrids 5581VT3P GLY,Bt,CRW Thunder Seed 7396 VT2P GLY,Bt Proseed GX695 GLY,Bt,LL Anderson Seeds Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC45-65RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW AgriGold A GLY,Bt Viking O.84-95UP Viking Peterson Farms Seed 77P94 GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed EXP GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dairyland Seed DS-7294 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Titan Pro TP GLY,Bt,LL Blue River 38G NuTech\G2 Genetics X5FN-9502 GLY,Bt,LL Munson Hybrids 5695VT2P GLY,Bt Proseed 1395 GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-196 GLY,Bt,LL NuTech\G2 Genetics 5FN-5096 GLY,Bt,LL Dekalb DKC46-36RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW to 96 RM averages: Central locations, early maturity averages: LSD (0.20)

6 Table 6. Late maturity entries, central locations, Source Entry Traits Maturity Hutchinson Morris Rosemount Bu/Acre % Moisture 97 to 99 RM entries Anderson Seeds 669SRC GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics 5FN-6097 GLY,Bt,LL Thunder Seed 6798 VT2P GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed EXP GLY,Bt,LL Proseed 1598 GLY,Bt Viking Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Munson Hybrids 5710VT2P GLY,Bt Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt Sun Prairie SP2038 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC49-72RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds 675VT2P GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds 684R GLY AgriGold A628-20VT2PRO GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds Legacy Seeds L-3626 VT2P GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-9599 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Legacy Seeds L-3816 VT2PDG GLY,Bt Peterson Farms Seed 78B98 GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5FN-7099 GLY,Bt,LL RM and earlier averages: Later than 99 RM entries Munson Hybrids 6029VT2P GLY,Bt Anderson Seeds 611VT2P GLY,Bt Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt Dekalb DKC52-84RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Legacy Seeds L-4317 GENSS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds Munson Hybrids 6434SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dairyland Seed DS-9802RA GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Anderson Seeds Viking O Thunder Seed 6803 VT2P GLY,Bt Titan Pro TP P GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-702 GLY,Bt,LL Anderson Seeds 611SRC GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics X5LN-0308 GLY,Bt,LL Viking O NuTech 5N-800 GLY,Bt,LL Titan Pro TP SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC50-08RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Proseed GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-601 GLY,Bt,LL Dekalb DKC51-38RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dairyland Seed DS-9804SSX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Sun Prairie SP2272 GLY,CB,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC53-56RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Munson Hybrids 6275SS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Legacy Seeds L-5516 GENSS GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC54-38RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Later than 99 RM averages: Central locations, late maturity averages: LSD (0.20)

7 Table 7. Northern locations, Source Entry Traits Maturity Crookston Rothsay Staples Bu/Acre % Moisture 83 and earlier RM entries Thunder Seed 6880 VT2P GLY,Bt Thunder Seed 7578 VT2P GLY,Bt NuTech 5N183 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Peterson Farms Seed 79M83 GLY,Bt Thunder Seed 6882 VT2P GLY,Bt and earlier RM entry averages: to 87 RM entries Proseed 1385 GLY,Bt Peterson Farms Seed 75K85 GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-7185 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Thunder Seed 6785 VT2P GLY,Bt Sun Prairie SP1809 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Thunder Seed 4585 RR GLY Legacy Seeds L-2817 VT2P GLY,Bt Legacy Seeds L-2847 VT2P GLY,Bt Blue River 18N Dairyland Seed DS-9686 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech 5N886 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW to 87 RM entry averages: to 92 RM entries Dekalb DKC40-77RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dairyland Seed DS-9090SSX GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Viking O.88-91UP Thunder Seed 6888 VT2P GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-6091 GLY Legacy Seeds L-3017 VT2P GLY,Bt NuTech\G2 Genetics 5F-091 GLY,Bt,LL Viking 71-90UP Proseed 1591 GLY,Bt Thunder Seed 6791 RR GLY Blue River 27B Dairyland Seed EXP GLY,Bt,LL Legacy Seeds L-3115 VT2PRO RIB GLY,Bt Peterson Farms Seed 76S92 GLY,Bt to 92 RM entry averages: and later RM entries Viking Art Thunder Seed 6794 VT2P GLY, Bt Sun Prairie SP1970 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Thunder Seed 7993 VT2P GLY,Bt NuTech 5G-293 GLY,Bt,LL Proseed PX694 GLY,Bt Dairyland Seed DS-7294 GLY,Bt,LL,CRW Dekalb DKC45-65RIB GLY,Bt,LL,CRW NuTech\G2 Genetics X5FN-9502 GLY,Bt,LL NuTech\G2 Genetics 5FN-5096 GLY,Bt,LL Dairyland Seed EXP GLY,Bt,LL and Later RM entry averages: Northern locations averages: LSD (0.20)