2013 Minnesota Corn Performance Trials

Transcription

1 2013 Minnesota Corn Performance Trials Prepared by: Tom Hoverstad, Matt Bickell, Jeff Coulter, George Nelson, Steve Quiring and Mark Hanson University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station Results of the Minnesota Corn Evaluation Program are presented in this bulletin. The program was conducted by the University of Minne Agricultural Experiment Station to provide unbiased information for use by corn growers when they choose which brand of corn to buy and The program was financed in part by entry fees from private seed companies that chose to place their entries for testing. TEST LOCATIONS Test zones, locations and maturities are as follows: Southern Zone: Lamberton, Rochester and Waseca Early Maturity Trial Relative Maturity (RM) and earlier entries Late Maturity Trial RM and later entries Central Zone: Hutchinson, and Rosemount Early Maturity Trial - 96 RM and earlier entries Late Maturity Trial - 97 RM and later entries Northern Zone: Crookston, Rothsay and Staples TESTING PROCEDURE Entries: Seed corn companies choose their entries for each zone. Entries in each trial were based on the relative maturity (RM) provided by the company. The University of Minnesota Corn Testing Committee could also choose entries in each test. All locations tested three replications for each entry. PRESENTATION OF DATA Yields are given for individual locations along with yields and harvest moisture contents averaged across locations for Reported yields are adjusted to 15.5% grain moisture. Entries are ranked within a maturity group by moisture content averaged across locations for IDENTIFICATION OF TRAITS Genetic modifications of entries will be identified using generic terms to describe the trait without identifying the specific event for genetic modification. For example Bt will indentify genetic modification for corn borer resistance but will not differentiate between the Bt 11 event, the YieldGuard corn borer event or the Herculex corn borer event. Identifiers will be: Bt = Europeon corn borer resistance CRW = Corn rootworm resistance GLY = glyphosate herbicide resistance LL = Liberty herbicide resistance LEAST SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE The LSD (Least Significant Difference) figures at the bottom of the yield columns in the tables are statistical measures of variability in the trials. These values may be used to determine whether the difference between any two entries is likely to be a real difference or just natural variation. If the yield difference between two entries is equal to or greater than the LSD, then one can be confident that the two entries probably differ in yield potential. We show LSD values with a 0.2 alpha level which means that when two entries differ in yield by the LSD value or more, one can be 80% confident that the two entries differ in yield potential. The higher yielding one is the better entry from the yield standpoint. If the yield difference between two entries is less than the LSD, the two entries probably do not differ significantly in yield potential. Page 1

2 Table 2. Individual Trial Information Previous Planting Harvest Location Cooperators Crop Date Date Lamberton Steve Quiring Soybean 3-Jun 25-Oct Rochester Fritz Brietenbach Soybean 3-Jun 8-Nov Waseca Tom Hoverstad Soybean 13-May 24-Oct Hutchinson Nathan Winter Paul Wright Corn 17-May 4-Nov Morris George Nelson Soybean 15-May 23-Oct Rosemount Jerry Holz Soybean 4-Jun 11-Nov Rothsay Doug Holen Soybean 14-May 29-Oct Crookston Mark Hanson Wheat 15-May 30-Oct Staples Bob Schafer Soybean 16-May 30-Oct Page 4

3 Early Maturity entries, Southern, 2013 Source Entry Traits Maturity Lamberton Rochester Waseca Bu/Acre % Moisture 97 and earlier RM entries Anderson Seeds 689R GLY Anderson Seeds 689VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Anderson Seeds Renk RK585VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY AgriGold A6203VT3PRIB Bt,CRW,GLY DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY Renk RK568VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Renk RK557SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6202VT3PRO Bt,CRW,GLY and earlier RM Averages: to 101 RM entries Anderson Seeds 537R GLY Epley E9802SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DuPont Pioneer P9917AMX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 588VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY DuPont Pioneer P0062AMX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 615VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Mycogen Seeds 2H456 Bt,CRW,GLY Anderson Seeds Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-4343 VT3PRO Bt,CRW,GLY Viking 58-98N Renk RK598SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9501SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 615R GLY Anderson Seeds Titan Pro SCI 3M00-SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI 3M98-SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Viking D81-01RL Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Mycogen Seeds 2T498 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Viking 60-01N DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6252STXRIB Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9898RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1238GT3000 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E DuPont Pioneer P0193AM Bt,GLY,LL Croplan 4099 SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI 3M01-2P Bt,GLY,LL Viking E62-00R Bt,GLY Renk RK581SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Mycogen Seeds 2Y479 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6257STXRIB Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Mycogen Seeds 2A507 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL to 101 RM Averages: Page 5

4 Early Maturity entries, Southern, 2013, continued Source Entry Traits Maturity Lamberton Rochester Waseca Bu/Acre % Moisture 102 to 103 RM entries Croplan 4975 VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-202 Bt,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-502 Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9303SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Mycogen Seeds 2A557 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK666SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 3D-802 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-903 Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9903RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-4513 GENSS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6319VT3PRIB Bt,CRW,GLY Titan Pro SCI 3M02-SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6267STXRIB Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL to 103 RM averages: Southern, Early Maturity Averages: LSD(0.20) Page 6

5 Late Maturity entries, Southern, 2013 Source Entry Traits Maturity Lamberton Rochester Waseca Bu/Acre % Moisture 104 RM and later entries NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-805 Bt,GLY,LL Epley E1403VT2P Bt,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-905 Bt,GLY,LL Viking D84-06RL Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds DuPont Pioneer P0636HR Bt,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL AgriGold A6358VT3PRIB Bt,CRW,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9604SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-806 Bt,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI 2M04-2P Bt,GLY,LL Epley E1438VIP Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-707 Bt,GLY,LL Renk RK752SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK699SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI TP SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1509HXTLL Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-5943 GENSS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI TP SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5F-008 Bt,GLY,LL AgriGold A6408VT3PRIB Bt,CRW,GLY DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DuPont Pioneer P1151HR Bt,GLY,LL Viking 72-04N AgriGold A6376STX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1804VT3PRO Bt,CRW,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5Z-709 Bt,GLY,LL Viking 49-09N Southern, Late Maturity Averages: LSD(0.20) Page 7

6 Early Maturity entries, Central, 2013 Source Entry Traits Maturity Hutchinson Morris Rosemount Bu/Acre % Moisture 93 and earlier RM entries Viking 70-90N Anderson Seeds 747R GLY Proseed 1191 SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY DuPont Pioneer P9305YHR Bt,GLY,LL Renk RK492SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Proseed PX93VT2PB Bt,GLY Proseed PX92VT3P Bt,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9791RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI 2M93-SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL RM and earlier averages: to 96 RM entries Titan Pro SCI 93A94 Bt,CRW,LL Anderson Seeds 689R GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5X-894 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9796 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5Z-9605 Bt,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 4398 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 689VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Viking C44-95R Bt,CRW,GLY Titan Pro SCI 1M96-3P Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK585VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY Anderson Seeds DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK522SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DuPont Pioneer P9526AMX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Peterson Farms Seed 55S96 Bt,CRW,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9694SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Viking 51-95N Viking E52-95R Bt,GLY Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-3813 GENSS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI 2M95-2P Bt,GLY,LL Renk RK568VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Renk RK557SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Proseed 1295 SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL to 96 RM averages: Central, Early Maturity Averages: LSD(0.20) Page 8

7 Late Maturity entries, Central, 2013 Source Entry Traits Maturity Hutchinson Morris Rosemount Bu/Acre % Moisture 97 to 99 RM entries NuTech/G2 Genetics 3F-198 Bt,GLY,LL Epley E9802SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-399 Bt,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 615R GLY DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5X-698 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 615VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY DuPont Pioneer P9917AMX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI TP SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Peterson Farms Seed 88A97 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 8450RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9898RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech 5N-9802 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL RM and earlier averages: Later than 99 RM entries Anderson Seeds 537R GLY DuPont Pioneer P0062AMX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5Z-200 Bt,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds Epley E1403VT2P Bt,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5Z-0105 Bt,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-202 Bt,GLY,LL Renk RK598SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds 588VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9303SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DuPont Pioneer P0193AM Bt,GLY,LL Anderson Seeds NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-502 Bt,GLY,LL AgriGold A6257STXRIB Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-4113 GENSS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-903 Bt,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 3D-802 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Peterson Farms Seed 84Y01 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9501SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK581SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI TP 39-00SS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Titan Pro SCI TP P Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9604SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK666SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1238GT3000 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9903RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5H-805 Bt,GLY,LL AgriGold A6267STX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech 5N-803 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1509HXTLL Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Epley E1438VIP Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Later than 99 RM averages: Central, Late Maturity Averages: LSD(0.20) Page 9

8 Northern, 2013 Source Entry Traits Maturity Crookston Rothsay Staples Bu/Acre % Moisture 82 and earlier RM entries Gold Country Seed VT2P Bt,GLY Hyland Seeds 3093 GLY DeKalb DKC Bt,GLY DuPont Pioneer P8210HR Bt,GLY,LL Proseed PX82M GT CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9780Q Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 8105 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK212GT GLY Blue River Hybrids 07M and earlier RM entry averages: to 87 RM entries Peterson Farms Seed 92G84 Bt,GLY,LL Gold Country Seed VT2P Bt,GLY Proseed GT Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Proseed 1283 VT2P Bt,GLY Nuseed 2852 GTCBLL Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-7085 Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-7985 Bt,GLY,LL Gold Country Seed VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9383SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 8180RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Proseed PX85VT2B Bt,GLY Dyna-Gro D24VC44RIB Bt,GLY Peterson Farms Seed 75K85 Bt,GLY Proseed 1287 GTCBLL CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,GLY Hyland Seeds 8166RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-2643 VT2PRO Bt,GLY Blue River Hybrids 23A Renk RK266VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Proseed PX85RVT2P Bt,GLY Proseed 1286 VT3P Bt,CRW,GLY Nuseed 8701 VT2P Bt,GLY Hyland Seeds 8201RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 8202RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9487RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Blue River Hybrids 21B Blue River Hybrids 25M to 87 RM entry averages: Page 10

9 Northern, 2013, continued Source Entry Traits Maturity Crookston Rothsay Staples Bu/Acre % Moisture 88 to 92 RM entries DuPont Pioneer P8906HR Bt,GLY,LL Nuseed 9202 VT2P Bt,GLY NuTech 5B-888 Bt,GLY,LL Proseed 1288 VIP3111 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL NuTech/G2 Genetics 5Z-091 Bt,GLY,LL NuTech 5B-290 Bt,GLY,LL Nuseed 9001 VP3220 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,GLY Viking VS Bt,GLY Legacy Seeds, Inc. L-3213 VT2PRO Bt,GLY Hyland Seeds 8300RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Viking VS Bt,GLY Hyland Seeds 8295RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK492SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Peterson Farms Seed 74K89 Bt,GLY Dairyland Seed DS-9791RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Hyland Seeds 8315RA Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dyna-Gro CX29SS30 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Viking VS Bt,GLY Dyna-Gro D32VC56RIB Bt,GLY to 92 RM entry averages: and later RM entries NuTech/G2 Genetics 5X-894 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Nuseed 9503 VT2P Bt,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5X-193 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Nuseed 9504 VT2P Bt,GLY NuTech/G2 Genetics 5X-795 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DeKalb DKC Bt,GLY NuTech 5N-9404 Bt,CRW,GLY,LL DuPont Pioneer P9305YHR Bt,GLY,LL Dairyland Seed DS-9694SSX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Renk RK522SSTX Bt,CRW,GLY,LL Dyna-Gro D34VP52 Bt,CRW,GLY Viking VS Bt,CRW,GLY,LL and Later RM entry averages: Northern locations averages: LSD(0.20) Page 11