S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N BEFORE THE MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION * * * * *

Transcription

1 S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N BEFORE THE MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION * * * * * In the matter, on the Commission s own motion, ) to open a docket for load serving entities in ) Michigan to file their capacity demonstrations as ) Case No. U required by MCL 460.6w. ) ) At the September 15, 2017 meeting of the Michigan Public Service Commission in Lansing, Michigan. PRESENT: Hon. Sally A. Talberg, Chairman Hon. Norman J. Saari, Commissioner Hon. Rachael A. Eubanks, Commissioner ORDER OPENING DOCKET On December 21, 2016, Governor Rick Snyder signed Public Act 341 (Act 341) into law, which amended 1939 PA 3; MCL et seq. 1 Among other things, Act 341 mandates that the Commission must establish a state reliability mechanism 2 (SRM) pursuant to MCL 460.6w(8) if, by September 30, 2017, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) does not put into effect a resource adequacy tariff that includes a capacity forward auction or a prevailing state compensation mechanism. MCL 460.6w(2). Given FERC s February 2, 2017 order in Docket No. ER (February 2 order) that rejected the Competitive Retail Solution (CRS) 1 Act 341 became effective on April 20, The avowed purpose of the state reliability mechanism as stated in MCL 460.6w(12)(h) is to ensure reliability of the electric grid in this state.

2 application filed on November 1, 2016, by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc. (MISO), coupled with MISO s subsequent decision to forego a petition for rehearing of the February 2 order, it is clear that FERC will not approve a resource adequacy tariff by September 30, Under the SRM construct, the Commission has responsibility for overseeing the sufficiency of all electric providers long term arrangements for electric capacity. Accordingly, the Commission commenced SRM charge proceedings for all areas with retail choice. See, Case Nos. U-18239, U-18248, U-18253, U-18254, and U MCL 460.6w(8) requires each electric utility, alternative electric supplier (AES), cooperative electric utility, and municipally-owned electric utility (collectively, referred to as load serving entities or electric providers) to demonstrate to the Commission, in a format determined by the Commission, that each electric provider owns or has contractual rights to sufficient capacity to meet its capacity obligations as set by MISO, or the Commission, as applicable. In MCL 460.6w(8)(a) and (b), the Legislature established the dates by which all electric providers must file their capacity demonstrations with the Commission. MCL 460.6w(8)(a) requires that, by December 1 of each year, every electric utility regulated by the Commission for the purpose of selling electricity to retail customers in this state shall demonstrate that for the planning year 3 beginning four years after the beginning of the current planning year, the electric utility owns or has contractual rights to sufficient capacity to meet its capacity obligations as defined in Act 341. MCL 460.6w(8)(b) also requires that, by the seventh business day of February each year, 4 every AES, cooperative electric utility, and municipally-owned electric utility 3 The term planning year is defined in MCL 460.6w(12)(f) to mean June 1 through the following May 31 of each year. 4 The seventh business day of February 2018 is Friday, February 9, Page 2 U-18441

3 demonstrate to the Commission that, for the planning year beginning four years after the beginning of the current planning year, the AES, cooperative electric utility, or municipally-owned electric utility owns or has contractual rights to sufficient capacity to meet its capacity obligations as set by MISO, PJM Interconnection, LLC (PJM), or the Commission. However, unlike the capacity demonstrations required by the Legislature of regulated electric utilities, cooperative electric utilities, and municipally-owned electric utilities, the sixth sentence of MCL 460.6w(8)(b) requires AESs to do the following: By the seventh business day of February in 2018, an alternative electric supplier shall demonstrate to the commission, in a format determined by the commission, that for the planning year beginning June 1, 2018, and the subsequent 3 planning years, the alternative electric supplier owns or has contractual rights to sufficient capacity to meet its capacity obligations as set by the appropriate independent system operator, or commission, as applicable. In an order issued today in Case No. U-18197, the Commission addressed the format by which all electric providers shall make the capacity demonstrations required by MCL 460.6w(8). The sole purpose of Case No. U is to receive all such capacity demonstration filings required by MCL 460.6w(8). Commercially sensitive information may be filed confidentially in this docket, in accordance with the September 15, 2017 order in Case No. U While MCL 460.6w(8)(a) requires that regulated electric utilities file demonstrations for the planning year four years from the current planning year, the Commission directs those utilities to file demonstrations for the planning year beginning June 1, 2018, and the subsequent three planning years as well. The Commission finds that this data is reasonably necessary, indeed indispensable, for the proper performance of the Commission s powers and duties. MCL ; MCL ; and MCL In addition, the Commission strongly encourages the cooperative and municipallyowned electric utilities to submit capacity demonstrations for the same time period. This Page 3 U-18441

4 information would greatly assist the Commission in making the required determinations under Section 6w, and would present a cohesive outlook for electricity supply plans. 5 THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that: A. The Commission s Executive Secretary shall immediately open the docket for Case No. U B. The Commission s Executive Secretary shall serve copies of this order and today s order in Case No. U upon each electric utility, alternative electric supplier, cooperative electric utility, and municipally-owned electric utility, and on any other party to any of the following cases: Case Nos. U-18197, U-18239, U-18248, U-18253, U-18254, and U C. On or before December 1, 2017, Alpena Power Company, Consumers Energy Company, DTE Electric Company, Indiana Michigan Power Company, Northern States Power Company Wisconsin, Upper Michigan Energy Resources Corporation, Upper Peninsula Power Company, and Wisconsin Energy Power Company shall submit capacity demonstrations in this docket in accordance with the requirements established in the September 15, 2017 order in Case No. U for the planning year beginning June 1, 2018, and the subsequent three planning years, to establish that the electric utility owns or has contractual rights to capacity sufficient to meet its capacity obligations as set by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., PJM Interconnection, LLC, or the Commission, as applicable, and as required by MCL 460.6w. 5 In the September 15, 2017 order in Case No. U-18197, p. 46, the Commission finds that electric providers in the PJM footprint should file capacity demonstration plans on the same date as other providers, that is, December 1, 2017, for regulated utilities and February 9, 2018, for cooperatives and municipally-owned utilities. MCL 460.6w(11). The PJM Reliability Pricing Model Base Residual Auction (RPMBRA) is in May, and the Commission finds that providers should indicate in their demonstrations whether they intend to participate in that auction or not. If an electric provider participates in the auction, it should file an amended capacity demonstration in this docket two weeks after the close of the RPMBRA. Page 4 U-18441

5 D. On or before February 9, 2018, Alger Delta Cooperative Electric Association, Bayfield Electric Cooperative, Inc., Cherryland Electric Cooperative, Cloverland Electric Cooperative, Great Lakes Energy Cooperative, Midwest Energy Cooperative, Ontonagon County Rural Electrification Association, Presque Isle Electric & Gas Co-op, Thumb Electric Cooperative, Tri- County Electric Cooperative, Village of Baraga, City of Bay City, City of Charlevoix, Chelsea Department of Electric & Water, Village of Clinton, Coldwater Board of Public Utilities, Croswell Municipal Light & Power Department, City of Crystal Falls, Daggett Electric Department, City of Dowagiac, City of Eaton Rapids, City of Escanaba, City of Gladstone, Grand Haven Board of Light & Power, City of Harbor Springs, City of Hart Hydro, Hillsdale Board of Public Utilities, Holland Board of Public Works, Village of L Anse, Lansing Board of Water & Light, Lowell Light & Power, Marquette Board of Light & Power, Marshall Electric Department, Negaunee Department of Public Works, Newberry Water and Light Board, Niles Utilities Department, City of Norway, Village of Paw Paw, City of Petoskey, City of Portland, City of Sebewaing, City of South Haven, City of St. Louis, City of Stephenson, City of Sturgis, Traverse City Light & Power, Union City Electric Department, City of Wakefield, Wyandotte Department of Municipal Service, Zeeland Board of Public Works, AEP Energy, Inc., Calpine Energy Solutions, LLC, f/k/a Noble Americas Energy Solutions, LLC, CMS ERM Michigan LLC, Constellation Energy Services, Inc., f/k/a Integrys Energy Services Inc., Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., Dillon Power, LLC, Direct Energy Business, LLC, Direct Energy Services, LLC, EDF Energy Services, LLC, Eligo Energy MI, LLC, Energy Services Providers, Inc., d/b/a Michigan Gas & Electric, FirstEnergy Solutions, Interstate Gas Supply, Inc., d/b/a IGS Energy, Just Energy Solutions, Inc., f/k/a Commerce Energy Inc., Liberty Power Delaware, LLC, Liberty Power Holding, LLC, MidAmerican Energy Services, LLC, Nordic Energy Services, LLC, Plymouth Rock Energy, LLC, Powerone Corporation, Page 5 U-18441

6 Premier Energy Marketing LLC, Spartan Renewable Energy, Inc., Texas Retail Energy, LLC, U.P. Power Marketing, LLC, and Wolverine Power Marketing Cooperative, Inc., shall submit capacity demonstrations in this docket in accordance with the requirements established in the September 15, 2017 order in Case No. U for the planning year beginning four years after the beginning of the current planning year, i.e., June 1, 2021, to establish that the electric provider owns or has contractual rights to capacity sufficient to meet its capacity obligations for the June 1, 2021 planning year as required by MCL 460.6w. E. On or before February 9, 2018, AEP Energy, Inc., Calpine Energy Solutions, LLC, f/k/a Noble Americas Energy Solutions, LLC, CMS ERM Michigan LLC, Constellation Energy Services, Inc., f/k/a Integrys Energy Services Inc., Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., Dillon Power, LLC, Direct Energy Business, LLC, Direct Energy Services, LLC, EDF Energy Services, LLC, Eligo Energy MI, LLC, Energy Services Providers, Inc., d/b/a Michigan Gas & Electric, FirstEnergy Solutions, Interstate Gas Supply, Inc., d/b/a IGS Energy, Just Energy Solutions, Inc., f/k/a Commerce Energy Inc., Liberty Power Delaware, LLC, Liberty Power Holding, LLC, MidAmerican Energy Services, LLC, Nordic Energy Services, LLC, Plymouth Rock Energy, LLC, Powerone Corporation, Premier Energy Marketing LLC, Spartan Renewable Energy, Inc., Texas Retail Energy, LLC, U.P. Power Marketing, LLC, and Wolverine Power Marketing Cooperative, Inc., shall submit capacity demonstrations in this docket in accordance with the requirements established in the September 15, 2017 order in Case No. U for the planning year beginning June 1, 2018, and the subsequent three planning years, to establish that it owns or has contractual rights to capacity sufficient to meet its capacity obligations as set by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., or the Commission, as applicable, and as required by MCL 460.6w. Page 6 U-18441

7 The Commission reserves jurisdiction and may issue further orders as necessary. Any party desiring to appeal this order must do so by the filing of a claim of appeal in the Michigan Court of Appeals within 30 days of the issuance of this order, under MCL To comply with the Michigan Rules of Court s requirement to notify the Commission of an appeal, appellants shall send required notices to both the Commission s Executive Secretary and to the Commission s Legal Counsel. Electronic notifications should be sent to the Executive Secretary at mpscedockets@michigan.gov and to the Michigan Department of the Attorney General - Public Service Division at pungp1@michigan.gov. In lieu of electronic submissions, paper copies of such notifications may be sent to the Executive Secretary and the Attorney General - Public Service Division at 7109 W. Saginaw Hwy., Lansing, MI MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION Sally A. Talberg, Chairman Norman J. Saari, Commissioner By its action of September 15, Rachael A. Eubanks, Commissioner Kavita Kale, Executive Secretary Page 7 U-18441

8 P R O O F O F S E R V I C E STATE OF MICHIGAN ) Case No. U County of Ingham ) Angela McGuire being duly sworn, deposes and says that on September 15, 2017 A.D. she electronically notified the attached list of this Commission Order via transmission, to the persons as shown on the attached service list (Listserv Distribution List). Subscribed and sworn to before me this 15th day of September 2017 Angela McGuire Carol M. Casale Notary Public, Saginaw County, Michigan Acting in Eaton County My Commission Expires: December 13, 2020

9 Service List for U Name Meredith Beidler Lauren Donofrio Service List for U Name Richard Aaron Tracy Jane Andrews Meredith Beidler Kurt Boehm Roy Boston Christopher Bzdok Stephen Campbell John Canzano Laura Chappelle Consumers Energy Company Brian Coyer Lauren Donofrio Peter Ellsworth Mark Eyster Sean Gallagher Gary Gensch, Jr. Celeste Gill Kelly Hall Jason Hanselman Jennifer Heston Melissa Horne Don Keskey Courtney Kissel Jody Kyler Cohn Timothy Lundgren Nolan Moody Toni Newell Michael Pattwell Patrick Rorai Jim Weeks Address beidlerm@michigan.gov donofriol@michigan.gov Address raaron@dykema.com tjandrews@envlaw.com beidlerm@michigan.gov kboehm@bkllawfirm.com roy.boston@calpinesolutions.com chris@envlaw.com scampbell@clarkhill.com jcanzano@michworklaw.com lachappelle@varnumlaw.com matorrey@cmsenergy.com mpsc.filings@cmsenergy.com bwcoyer@publiclawresourcecenter.com donofriol@michigan.gov pellsworth@dickinson wright.com eysterm@michigan.gov sgallagher@clarkhill.com gary.genschjr@cmsenergy.com gillc1@michigan.gov kelly.hall@cmsenergy.com jhanselman@dykema.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mhorne@hcc law.com donkeskey@publiclawresourcecenter.com ckissel@dykema.com jkylercohn@bkllawfirm.com tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com nmoody@dickinson wright.com tlnewell@varnumlaw.com mpattwell@clarkhill.com prorai@michworkerlaw.com jweeks@mpower.org

10 Service List for U Name Richard Aaron Tracy Jane Andrews Meredith Beidler Kurt Boehm Roy Boston Christopher Bzdok Stephen Campbell John Canzano Laura Chappelle Jon Christinidis Brian Coyer Lauren Donofrio DTE Energy Company Peter Ellsworth Mark Eyster Sean Gallagher Jason Hanselman Jennifer Heston Melissa Horne Don Keskey Courtney Kissel Jody Kyler Cohn Timothy Lundgren Richard Middleton Nolan Moody Michael Moody Toni Newell Michael Pattwell Patrick Rorai Monica Stephens Jim Weeks Service List for U Name Meredith Beidler Laura Chappelle Lauren Donofrio Sharon Feldman Jason Hanselman Jennifer Heston Timothy Lundgren Toni Newell Michael Rampe Theresa Staley Monica Stephens Upper Michigan Energy Resources Corp. Address raaron@dykema.com tjandrews@envlaw.com beidlerm@michigan.gov kboehm@bkllawfirm.com roy.boston@calpinesolutions.com chris@envlaw.com scampbell@clarkhill.com jcanzano@michworklaw.com lachappelle@varnumlaw.com christinidisj@dteenergy.com bwcoyer@publiclawresourcecenter.com donofriol@michigan.gov kurmass@dteenergy.com pellsworth@dickinson wright.com eysterm@michigan.gov sgallagher@clarkhill.com jhanselman@dykema.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mhorne@hcc law.com donkeskey@publiclawresourcecenter.com ckissel@dykema.com jkylercohn@bkllawfirm.com tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com middletonr@dteenergy.com nmoody@dickinson wright.com moodym2@michigan.gov tlnewell@varnumlaw.com mpattwell@clarkhill.com prorai@michworkerlaw.com stephensm11@michigan.gov jweeks@mpower.org Address beidlerm@michigan.gov lachappelle@varnumlaw.com donofriol@michigan.gov feldmans@michigan.gov jhanselman@dykema.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com tlnewell@varnumlaw.com rampe@millercanfield.com staley@millercanfield.com stephensm11@michigan.gov christine.kane@we energies.com

11 Service List for U Name Meredith Beidler Laura Chappelle Lauren Donofrio Jason Hanselman Jennifer Heston Timothy Lundgren Toni Newell Suzanne Sonneborn Monica Stephens Upper Peninsula Power Company Sherri Wellman Service List for U Name Richard Aaron Meredith Beidler Leah Brooks Cloverland Electric Cooperative Lauren Donofrio Jason Hanselman Jennifer Heston Michael Oliva Suzanne Sonneborn Monica Stephens Address beidlerm@michigan.gov lachappelle@varnumlaw.com donofriol@michigan.gov jhanselman@dykema.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com tlnewell@varnumlaw.com sonneborns@michigan.gov stephensm11@michigan.gov ghaehnel@uppco.com wellmans@millercanfield.com Address raaron@dykema.com beidlerm@michigan.gov ljbrooks@loomislaw.com ddasho@cloverland.com donofriol@michigan.gov jhanselman@dykema.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mgoliva@loomislaw.com sonneborns@michigan.gov stephensm11@michigan.gov

12 Service List for U Name Address Richard Aaron raaron@dykema.com Tracy Jane Andrews tjandrews@envlaw.com Michael Ashton mashton@fraserlawfirm.com Robert Beach robert.beach@cmsenergy.com Meredith Beidler beidlerm@michigan.gov Kurt Boehm kboehm@bkllawfirm.com Christopher Bzdok chris@envlaw.com John Canzano jcanzano@michworklaw.com H. Chambers hrchambers@cmsenergy.com Laura Chappelle lachappelle@varnumlaw.com Consumers Energy Company matorrey@cmsenergy.com mpsc.filings@cmsenergy.com Brian Coyer bwcoyer@publiclawresourcecenter.com Sharon Feldman feldmans@michigan.gov Shannon Fisk sfisk@earthjustice.org Sean Gallagher sgallagher@clarkhill.com Gary Gensch, Jr. gary.genschjr@cmsenergy.com Kelly Hall kelly.hall@cmsenergy.com Jason Hanselman jhanselman@dykema.com Jennifer Heston jheston@fraserlawfirm.com Melissa Horne mhorne@hcc law.com John Janiszewski janiszewskij2@michigan.gov Margrethe Kearney mkearney@elpc.org Don Keskey donkeskey@publiclawresourcecenter.com Joel King kingj38@michigan.gov Jody Kyler jkylercohn@bkllawfirm.com John Liskey john@liskeypllc.com Timothy Lundgren tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com David Marvin dmarvin@fraserlawfirm.com Toni Newell tlnewell@varnumlaw.com Michael Pattwell mpattwell@clarkhill.com Patrick Rorai prorai@michworkerlaw.com Spencer Sattler sattlers@michigan.gov Patricia Sharkey psharkey@e lawcounsel.com Amit Singh singha9@michigan.gov Michael Soules msoules@earthjustice.org Theresa Staley staley@millercanfield.com Monica Stephens stephensm11@michigan.gov Bret Totoraitis bret.totoraitis@cmsenergy.com Anne Uitvlugt anne.uitvlugt@cmsenergy.com

13 Commentors in U Amy Monopoli Brett French Trevor D. Stiles Christopher Bzdok Richard Aaron Jason Hanselman Richard Middleton Thomas S. Hanrahan Jennifer Heston Michael Pattwell Lauren D. Donofrio Timothy Lundgren Kelly Hall Don Keskey James A. Ault Daniel M. Dasho Michael Moody Chris Afendoulis Rob VerHeulen Nancy Coratti Jeanne Kitchen Alan Latosz John Dulmes Joshua Lunger Melissa Seymour Gary Glenn James Bruno amonopoli@itctransco.com bfrench@atcllc.com tstiles@atcllc.com chris@envlaw.com raaron@dykema.com jhanselman@dykema.com middletonr@dteenergy.com thanrahan@wppienergy.org jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mpattwell@clarkhill.com donofriol@michigan.gov tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com kelly.hall@cmsenergy.com donkeskey@publiclawresourcecenter.com jaault@gomega.org ddasho@cloverland.com moodym2@michigan.gov ChrisAfendoulis@house.mi.gov RobVerHeulen@house.mi.gov nancy.coratti@hvs.org jeanne@totaldoor.com alatosz@algonac.k12.mi.us john@michiganchemistry.com lungerj@grandrapids.org mseymour@misoenergy.org gg@garyglenn.us BMMcShea@uss.com

14 DTE ENERGY COMPANY, ENERGY MICHIGAN, ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESSES ADVOCATING TARIFF EQUITY, RETAIL ENERGY SUPPLY ASSOCIATION, AND ALTERNATIVE ELECTRIC SUPPLIER S AES ELECTRONIC DISTRIBUTION LIST kurmass@dteenergy.com ejschneidewind@varnumlaw.com jtselecky@consultbai.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mkuchera@aepenergy.com gbass@calpinesolutions.com timothy.aufdencamp@cmsenergy.com igoodman@commerceenergy.com lael.campbell@constellation.com a.asaro@dillonpower.com Teresa.ringenbach@directenergy.com bill.hellinghausen@edfenergyservices.com regulatory@eligoenergy.com rami.fawaz@poweronecorp.com mmann@usgande.com fesmarketpolicies@fes.com lfriedeman@igsenergy.com dmartos@libertypowercorp.com jhdillavou@micamerican.com regulatory@nordicenergy-us.com spersaud@plymouthenergy.com bschlansker@premierenergyllc.com cborr@spartanrenewable.com chris.hendrix@texasretailenergy.com Zach.HALKOLA@traxys.com cborr@wpsci.com aaron.martin@cmsenergy.com Page 1 of 2

15 DTE ENERGY COMPANY, ENERGY MICHIGAN, ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESSES ADVOCATING TARIFF EQUITY, RETAIL ENERGY SUPPLY ASSOCIATION, AND ALTERNATIVE ELECTRIC SUPPLIER S AES ELECTRONIC DISTRIBUTION LIST amy.klaviter@constellation.com christina.crable@directenergy.com Bonnie.yurga@directenergy.com ryan.harwell@directenergy.com arozenblat@eligoenergy.com crericha@firstenergycorp.com cbaird-forristall@midamerican.com Page 2 of 2

16 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY, ENERGY MICHIGAN, ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESSES ADVOCATING TARIFF EQUITY, RETAIL ENERGY SUPPLY ASSOCIATION, AND ALTERNATIVE ELECTRIC SUPPLIER S ELECTRONIC DISTRIBUTION LIST michael.torrey@cmsenergy.com ejschneidewind@varnumlaw.com jtselecky@consultbai.com jheston@fraserlawfirm.com mkuchera@aepenergy.com gbass@calpinesolutions.com timothy.aufdencamp@cmsenergy.com igoodman@commerceenergy.com lael.campbell@constellation.com a.asaro@dillonpower.com Teresa.ringenbach@directenergy.com bill.hellinghausen@edfenergyservices.com regulatory@eligoenergy.com rami.fawaz@poweronecorp.com mmann@usgande.com fesmarketpolicies@fes.com lfriedeman@igsenergy.com dmartos@libertypowercorp.com jhdillavou@micamerican.com regulatory@nordicenergy-us.com spersaud@plymouthenergy.com bschlansker@premierenergyllc.com cborr@spartanrenewable.com chris.hendrix@texasretailenergy.com Zach.HALKOLA@traxys.com cborr@wpsci.com aaron.martin@cmsenergy.com Page 1 of 2

17 CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY, ENERGY MICHIGAN, ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESSES ADVOCATING TARIFF EQUITY, RETAIL ENERGY SUPPLY ASSOCIATION, AND ALTERNATIVE ELECTRIC SUPPLIER S ELECTRONIC DISTRIBUTION LIST amy.klaviter@constellation.com christina.crable@directenergy.com Bonnie.yurga@directenergy.com ryan.harwell@directenergy.com arozenblat@eligoenergy.com crericha@firstenergycorp.com cbaird-forristall@midamerican.com Page 2 of 2

18 CLOVERLAND, UMERC, & UPPCO (UP UTILITIES) SPECIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST NAME Cloverland Electric Cooperative Upper Peninsula Power Company Upper Michigan Energy Resources Corporation ADDRESS MPSC STAFF SPECIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST NAME Lauren D. Donofrio, Assistant Attorney General Meredith R. Beidler, Assistant Attorney General Bryan A. Brandenburg, Assistant Attorney General ADDRESS ABATE, CONSTELLATION NEWENERGY, SIERRA CLUB, UMERC & VERSO CORPORATION SPECIAL DISTRIBUTION COMPANY ADDRESS Association of Businesses Advocating Tariff Equity Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. Sierra Club Upper Michigan Energy Resources Corporation Verso Corporation

19 Resource Adequacy Listserv ajz research.com Updated 9/15/2017

20 Resource Adequacy Listserv electric.com Updated 9/15/2017

21 Resource Adequacy Listserv Updated 9/15/2017

22 Resource Adequacy Listserv solar.com Updated 9/15/2017

23 Resource Adequacy Listserv Updated 9/15/2017

24 AES Special Distribution Service List Company Name Address AEP Energy CMS ERM Michigan, LLC Calpine Energy Solutions, LLC Constellation Energy Services, Inc. & Constellation NewEnergy Inc. Dillon Power, LLC Direct Energy Business & Direct Energy Services EDF Energy Services, LLC Eligo Energy MI, LLC FirstEnergy Solutions Interstate Gas Supply d/b/a IGS Energy Just Energy Solutions, Inc. Liberty Power Delaware, LLC & Liberty Power Holding, LLC Michigan Gas & Electric MidAmerican Energy Services, LLC Nordic Energy Services, LLC Plymouth Rock Energy, LLC Powerone Corp Premier Energy Marketing LLC Spartan Renewable Energy Texas Retail Energy, LLC U.P. Power Marketing, LLC Wolverine Power Marketing Coop

25 U Special Distribution - Cooperatives bob.hance@teammidwest.com dbraun@techmi.coop tharrell@algerdelta.com tanderson@cherrylandelectric.coop bscott@glenergy.com debbie@ontorea.com bburns@pieg.com mkappler@homework.org sara.anderson@bayfieldelectric.com jomiller@itctransco.com

26 U Special Distribution - Municipalities pnewton@baycitymi.org chxelect@cityofcharlevoix.net jhanifan@city-chelsea.org cornishk@villageofclinton.org pbeckhusen@muni.cbpu.com jpeck@croswell-mich.com crystalfallsmgr@hotmail.com villdagg@gmail.com jbradford@dowagiac.org kreinecke@ci.eaton-rapids.mi.us mfurmanski@escanaba.org mpolega@gladstonemi.com dwalters@mpower.org trichards@cityofharborsprings.com srickard@ci.hart.mi.us mbarber@hillsdalebpu.com dkoster@hollandbpw.com manager@lansemi.org rrp@lbwl.com sdonkersloot@lowell-light.org tcarpenter@mblp.org ttarkiewicz@cityofmarshall.com vilnby@sbcglobal.net jdunlap@nilesmi.org citymanager@norwaymi.gov neilsen@pawpaw.net jdavis@ci.petoskey.mi.us mikehyland@portland-michigan.org mmccoy@sebewaing.net lhalberstadt@south-haven.com kgiles@stlouismi.com kmarklein@stephenson-mi.com jgriffith@sturgismi.gov tarends@tclp.org cmattis@visitunioncity.com cmsecretary@cityofnegaunee.com chudson@wyan.org bcook@bpw.zeeland.mi.us citymanager@cityofwakefield.org

27 GEMOTION DISTRIBUTION SERVICE LIST ITC Energy Michigan Energy Michigan Mid American Noble Americas Cloverland Cloverland Village of Baraga Linda Brauker Village of Clinton Tri-County Electric Co-Op Tri-County Electric Co-Op Tri-County Electric Co-Op Aurora Gas Company Citizens Gas Fuel Company Consumers Energy Company SEMCO Energy Gas Company Superior Energy Company Upper Peninsula Power Company WEC Energy Group Upper Peninsula Power Company Midwest Energy Coop Midwest Energy Coop Midwest Energy Coop Alger Delta Cooperative Cherryland Electric Cooperative Great Lakes Energy Cooperative Great Lakes Energy Cooperative Great Lake Energy Cooperative Liberty Power Delaware (Holdings) Stephson Utilities Department Ontonagon County Rural Elec Presque Isle Electric & Gas Cooperative, INC Thumb Electric Bishop Energy AEP Energy CMS Energy Just Energy Solutions Constellation Energy Constellation Energy Constellation New Energy DTE Energy First Energy MidAmerican Energy Updated

28 GEMOTION DISTRIBUTION SERVICE LIST My Choice Energy Calpine Energy Solutions Santana Energy Spartan Renewable Energy, Inc. (Wolverine Power Marketing Corp) Xcel Energy City of Escanaba City of Crystal Falls Lisa Felice Michigan Gas & Electric City of Gladstone Integrys Group Lisa Gustafson Tim Hoffman Interstate Gas Supply Inc Thomas Krichel Bay City Electric Light & Power Lansing Board of Water and Light Lansing Board of Water and Light Marquette Board of Light & Power Premier Energy Marketing LLC City of Marshall Doug Motley Dan Blair Marc Pauley City of Portland Alpena Power Liberty Power Wabash Valley Power Wolverine Power Lowell S. Integrys Energy Service, Inc WPSES Realgy Energy Services Volunteer Energy Services First Energy Solutions Hillsdale Board of Public Utilities Michigan Gas Utilities/Upper Penn Power/Wisconsin Michigan Gas Utilities/Qwest Zeeland Board of Public Works Direct Energy Direct Energy Direct Energy Direct Energy Realgy Corp. Jim Weeks Updated

29 GEMOTION DISTRIBUTION SERVICE LIST Indiana Michigan Power Company Santana Energy MEGA ITC Holdings Dickinson Wright Updated