Subject: Project No MW wind farm at Village Badabagh, District Jaisalmer, Rajasthan.

Transcription

1 To, The UNFCCC CDM Registration Team Germany November 2, 2006 Subject: Project No MW wind farm at Village Badabagh, District Jaisalmer, Rajasthan. Submissions from the Project Participant: Senergy Global Private Limited Comment 1: The PDD does not provide necessary data used to calculate OM and BM and hence the determination of baseline emission factor is not transparent Reply: The detailed calculations for establishment of baseline emission factors were provided to the DOE during validation of the subject candidate CDM project and the same was checked by the DOE. The detailed data as well as the calculations for the same is attached with the replies as Annexure 1 in the form of Microsoft Excel Sheet. The data used for calculations has been obtained from Central Electricity Authority (Govt. of India) and NRLDC (Northern Region Load Dispatch Centre the government of India entity responsible for maintaining the complete northern grid). Additionally we would like to submit that the baseline calculations have been carried out using the latest version of AMS 1D (version 9, 28 July 2006) for small scale grid connected wind energy projects. The baseline value so obtained is most conservative for the grid connected projects in northern grid of India. There are 2 projects already registered with UNFCCC at a relatively higher baseline value namely: Project Ref: 376 registered on 4th June 2006 with baseline emission factor of Project Ref: 330 registered on 21st July 2006 with baseline emission factor of With complete & exhaustive calculations using the three year average (using ACM 002 as the benchmark for AMS 1D) of all the operating facilities of northern grid, which we have used as the basis of our baseline calculations, the baseline emission factor for our project comes out to be: which is conservative in all respects. Comment 2: The project has a confusing & strange arrangement. There are 6 investors however these investors are not the project participants, but the relationship between Senergy Global & Project (wind farm) is not clear. Clarification is needed on this issue. Reply: The DNA approval in India has two components namely the DNA approval to the project and the trading conditions (the complete DNA approval letter is enclosed with the replies as Annexure 2). The Indian DNA has a adopted a standard practice to issue the DNA approval to a single entity even in the case of bundled CDM projects.

2 There are two registered projects from India with similar conditions: Project 1. Ref No. 310 registered on 29 May 2006 in which Enercon India Limited is project participant whereas the wind turbines are owned by different entities namely: - Enercon Wind Farm Jaisalmer Limited - Compucom Software Limited - Shriram Transport Company - LNJ Group - R K Marbles Group - Desai Brothers Limited - Dempo Industries Private Limited - Hindustan Platinum Private Limited - Revathi Equipment Limited - Renaissance Asset Management - Texmo Group - Venlon Polyester Film Limited - Dinesh Pouches Limited Project 2: Ref 112 registered on 19 February 2006 in which M P Glychem Industries Limited is project participant whereas the wind turbines are owned by different entities namely - M P Glychem Induatries Limited - Rajratan Global Wire Limited - General Foods Limited - Ruchi Soya Industries Limited - Itarasi Oil & Flour Limited The candidate CDM project for which the review has been requested is also a bundled CDM project with ownership of turbines with individual turbine owners. All the owners (6 in number) have decided to give this responsibility to Senergy Global Private Limited as their common representative as project participant for CDM due diligence. A letter confirming the same was issued by individual project participant in the name of Senergy Global Private Limited (the complete set of letters is enclosed as Annexure 3 to 8). These letters were submitted to both, the Indian DNA as well as to DOE for obtaining the host country approval and validation respectively. We hope our submission clarifies the concerns raised by the members of the CDM Executive Board. Thanking you Sincerely Chintan Shah Senergy Global Private Limited 9th Floor Eros Corporate Tower Nehru Place New Delhi

3 BUILD MARGIN FOR NORTHERN REGION FOR Tariff Orders/Orders Calculated Values-B/g colour Ref: Addition in generating capacity (utilities only), CEA General Review , , , , , , , ,, 2005 Name of the Plant Year- Commissioning Agency/ Owner Fuel Type Installed Cap. (MW) Gross Gen. (MU) Operating Heat Rate NCV MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM Fuel Consumpti Fi*COEFi on (Fi) COEFi (000 tco2) (000 Tonnes) NJ HEP Unit SJVNL & HP Hydro NJ HEP Unit 5 03/09/2004 SJVNL & HP Hydro Chemara HEP II Unit HP NHPC Hydro NJ HEP Unit SJVNL & HP Hydro NJ HEP Unit SJVNL & HP Hydro Chemara HEP II Unit 2 12/05/2003 HP NHPC Hydro NJ HEP Unit SJVNL & HP Hydro Chemara HEP II Unit 1 11/04/2003 HP NHPC Hydro NJ HEP Unit SJVNL & HP Hydro KOTA TPS-IV Unit RRVUNL Coal SURATGARH-III Unit RRVUNL Coal Baspa - II Unit HP Jai Prakash Hydro Baspa - II Unit2 02/08/2003 HP Jai Prakash Hydro Pragati CCGT Unit-III PrPCL Gas Baspa - II Unit HP Jai Prakash Hydro Pragati CCGT Unit-II PrPCL Gas Ramgarh CCGT Stage-II GT RRVUNL Gas/HSD Ramgarh CCGT Stage-II GT RRVUNL Gas/HSD Malana Unit1 07/09/2001 HP Malana Powe Hydro Malana Unit2 07/05/2001 HP Malana Powe Hydro Upper Sindh II Unit J&KSEB Hydro Upper Sindh II Unit2 09/11/2001 J&KSEB Hydro Pragati CCGT (Unit-1) DVB Gas Suratgarh TPS Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh TPS (Unit-3) RRVUNL Coal Wind Power Stations 06/01/2001 RRVUNL Wind Ghanvi Unit2 12/07/2000 HPSEB Hydro Ghanvi Unit HPSEB Hydro Gumma Unit HPSEB Hydro

4 Gumma Unit HPSEB Hydro Chenani III Unit J&KSEB Hydro Chenani III Unit J&KSEB Hydro Chenani III Unit J&KSEB Hydro Ranjit Sagar Unit1 10/11/2000 PSEB Hydro Ranjit Sagar Unit PSEB Hydro Ranjit Sagar Unit PSEB Hydro Ranjit Sagar Unit4 08/12/2000 PSEB Hydro Panipat TPS St IV (Unit-6) HPGCL (Haryana) Coal Faridabad CCGT (Steam) Unit NTPC Gas/Neptha Rajasthan Atomic power plant NPC Nuclear Jaisalmer Wind 06/01/2000 RSPC Wind Upper Sind II Unit 1 01/05/2000 J&KSEB Hydro Faridabad CCGT (Unit-2) Gas Turbine Unit NTPC Gas/Neptha Faridabad CCGT (Unit-1) Gas Turbine Unit NTPC Gas/Neptha Suratgarh TPS (Unit-2) Rajasthan SEB Coal Rajasthan Atomic power plant 03/10/2000 NPC Nuclear Unchachar TPP (Unit-4) NTPC Coal GHTP Bhatinda (Unit-2) PSEB Coal Suratgarh TPS (Unit-1) Rajasthan SEB Coal Unchachar (Unit-3) NTPC Coal EF BM = Σ(Fi*COEFi) / Σ(Gross Gen.) (tco2/ MWh) Gross Gen (MUs) (Fi*COEFi) (000 tco2) Total Gen from new TPS comprising of total thermal gen of NR grid (%) EF BM tco2/mwh

5 Year Gross Gen (MUs) Fi*COEFi (000 tco2) Total Thermal Total NR Generation MUs Total NonTherm. Gen MUs % Non Thermal gen is less than 50% of total NR gen.so Simple OM Method use EF OM Simple tco2/ MWh EF OM Simple Average of Three years tco2/ MWh EF BM tco2/ MWh According to ACM 0002 for wind power projects the Combined margin is calculated as follows: Combined Margin Emission Factor EF = 75% EF OM + 25% EF BM Hence, EF

6 Imports from others Imports from WREB Imports from EREB EF (WREB), tco2/gwh fs/chapter2.pdf EF of Western Grid has been considered EF (EREB), tco2/gwh fs/chapter2.pdf EF of Eastern Grid has been considered As per ACM0002 the CO2 emission factor for the net Electricity imports from the connected Electricity system, there is an option to consider 0 t CO 2 / MWh as net electricity import. As the source of the plant importing to the grid is not known and the percentage of import is very less, this option has been used for net electricity imported.

7 NORTHERN GRID Calculated Values-B/g colour Data Collection from Different Sources-marked with different colours Formulae: NCV * EFCO2[Ref:MNES Report] Baseline for FY, , IPP NRLDC Annual Report, , Tariff Orders/Orders 1 GWh=1 MU Fuel Cons (Fi) '000 tons = (Gross Gen MU * OHR kcal/kwh)/(ncv kcal/kg) Coal (Default)=1.58 (Ref: (1) Electricity Data, , CEA, General Review 2005, CEA General Review 2005 NTPC Presentation 1 MWh= 1000 kwh COEFi (tco2/kg of fuel) = (NCV* EFCO2)*OXID Lignite=1.19 (2) NRLDC Annual Report, , CEA Performance Review of Thermal Power Station , , STEAM = COAL OXID = 0.98 (Coal), 0.99 (Oil), (Gas)- Ref: Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines Gas/NG/LNG=2.93 (3) Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations, , ; CEA MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM CERC Website Gas=NG NCV (kcal/kg) [Ref: Baseline for RE projects under CDM, MNES report] Diesel=3.2 OXID values (Ref:Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines) Must Run and Low Cost Plants shall be eliminated from Baseline Calculations Coal (default)=4021,lignite=2800, Gas/NG/LNG= , Diesel=10316, Naptha=10750 Naptha=3.3 Fuel NCV x Gross Gross Gross Fuel Cons. Fuel Cons. Oper. HR Oper. HR COEFi Fi*COE Fi*COEFi Fi*COE Year- Cons. (Fi) Oper. HR EFCO2 Name of the Agency/ Fuel Inst.Cap. Gen. Gen. Gen. (Fi) (000 (Fi) (000 (kcal/ (kcal/ NCV (kg of Fi (000 (000 Fi (000 Commiss (000 (kcal/ kwh) Kg of OXID Plant Owner Type (MW) (MU) (MU) (MU) Tonnes) Tonnes) kwh) kwh) Kcal/Kg CO2 /kg tco2) tco2) tco2) ion Tonnes) CO2/ Kg of fuel) of fuel CHANDIGARH THERMAL Diesel Gen Set Govt Chandigarh Diesel TOTAL THERMAL (Chandigarh) DELHI THERMAL Indraprastha IPGCL Coal (IP) TPS Unit- Indraprastha IPGCL Coal (IP) TPS Unit- Indraprastha IPGCL Coal (IP) TPS Unit- Indraprastha IPGCL Coal (IP) TPS Unit- Rajghat Unit-1 IPGCL Coal Rajghat Unit-2 IPGCL Coal Pragati Gas Turbines Pr PCL Gas (CCGT) I.P.Gas Turbines Pr PCL Gas/HSD (CCGT) TOTAL THERMAL (DELHI) HARYANA THERMAL Faridabad extn HGPCor Coal Unit-1 Faridabad extn HGPCor Coal Unit-2 Faridabad extn HGPCor Coal Unit-3 Faridabad HGPCor Diesel Diesel Panipat Unit-1 HGPCor Coal Panipat Unit-2 HGPCor Coal Panipat Unit-3 HGPCor Coal Panipat Unit-4 HGPCor Coal Panipat Unit-5 HGPCor Coal Panipat Unit-6 HGPCor Coal Magnum Diesel Magnum Power Diesel (IPP) Generation Ltd Ambala (D.C) HGPCor Diesel HYDRO Western Yamuna Canal HGPCor Hydro (WYC) TOTAL THERMAL (Haryana) TOTAL HYDRO (Haryana) HIMACHAL PRADESH THERMAL Keylong HPSEB Diesel HYDRO Giri bata HPSEB Hydro Bassi HPSEB Hydro Binwa HPSEB Hydro Rongtong +Nogli+ Micro HPSEB Hydro Hydel+Thirot Andhra HPSEB Hydro Bhabha HPSEB Hydro (Sanjay) Baner HPSEB Hydro Gaj HPSEB Hydro Gumma HPSEB Hydro Ghanvi HPSEB Hydro Malana (IPP) Malana HE Hydro Project Baspa (IPP) JaiPrakash Hydro HP Ltd Sal - II HEP HPSEB Hydro 2 Station Rukti HPSEB Hydro 1.5 Gharola HPSEB Hydro 0.05 TOTAL THERMAL (HP) TOTAL HYDRO (HP) THERMAL JAMMU & KASHMIR

8 NORTHERN GRID Calculated Values-B/g colour Data Collection from Different Sources-marked with different colours Formulae: NCV * EFCO2[Ref:MNES Report] Baseline for FY, , IPP NRLDC Annual Report, , Tariff Orders/Orders 1 GWh=1 MU Fuel Cons (Fi) '000 tons = (Gross Gen MU * OHR kcal/kwh)/(ncv kcal/kg) Coal (Default)=1.58 (Ref: (1) Electricity Data, , CEA, General Review 2005, CEA General Review 2005 NTPC Presentation 1 MWh= 1000 kwh COEFi (tco2/kg of fuel) = (NCV* EFCO2)*OXID Lignite=1.19 (2) NRLDC Annual Report, , CEA Performance Review of Thermal Power Station , , STEAM = COAL OXID = 0.98 (Coal), 0.99 (Oil), (Gas)- Ref: Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines Gas/NG/LNG=2.93 (3) Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations, , ; CEA MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM CERC Website Gas=NG NCV (kcal/kg) [Ref: Baseline for RE projects under CDM, MNES report] Diesel=3.2 OXID values (Ref:Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines) Must Run and Low Cost Plants shall be eliminated from Baseline Calculations Coal (default)=4021,lignite=2800, Gas/NG/LNG= , Diesel=10316, Naptha=10750 Naptha=3.3 Fuel NCV x Gross Gross Gross Fuel Cons. Fuel Cons. Oper. HR Oper. HR COEFi Fi*COE Fi*COEFi Fi*COE Year- Cons. (Fi) Oper. HR EFCO2 Name of the Agency/ Fuel Inst.Cap. Gen. Gen. Gen. (Fi) (000 (Fi) (000 (kcal/ (kcal/ NCV (kg of Fi (000 (000 Fi (000 Commiss (000 (kcal/ kwh) Kg of OXID Plant Owner Type (MW) (MU) (MU) (MU) Tonnes) Tonnes) kwh) kwh) Kcal/Kg CO2 /kg tco2) tco2) tco2) ion Tonnes) CO2/ Kg of fuel) of fuel Gas/ (Oil Pampore J&K PDC based (OCGT) HSD) Diesel Gen Set (Bemina-5 J&K PDC Diesel MW+ Leh-2.18 MW) Karnah J&K PDC Diesel Upper Sindh J&K PDC Diesel HYDRO Lower Jhelum J&K PDC Hydro Upper Sindh J&K PDC Hydro Ganderbal J&K PDC Hydro Mohra J&K PDC Hydro Chenani J&K PDC Hydro Stakna J&K PDC Hydro Small Hyde Hydro Sewa-III J&K PDC Hydro 9 Jammu Canal J&K PDC Hydro 1 TOTAL THERMAL (J&K) TOTAL HYDRO (J&K) PUNJAB THERMAL Guru Nanak Dev TPS, PSEB Coal (Bhatinda) Unit-1 Guru Nanak Dev TPS, PSEB Coal (Bhatinda) Unit-2 Guru Nanak Dev TPS, PSEB Coal (Bhatinda) Unit-3 Guru Nanak Dev TPS, PSEB Coal (Bhatinda) Unit-4 GHTP (Lehra Mohabbat) Unit PSEB Coal GHTP (Lehra Mohabbat) Unit PSEB Coal Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-1 Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-2 Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-3 Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-4 Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-5 Guru Gobind Singh TPS PSEB Coal (Ropar) Unit-6 Jhalkeri Rice Rice PSEB Straw Fired Straw HYDRO Jogindernagar/ PSEB Hydro Shanan Upper Behari Doab Canal PSEB Hydro (UBDC) Ranjit Sagar PSEB Hydro Mukerian PSEB Hydro Anandpur Sahib PSEB Hydro Punjab Small Hydel Hydro P Hydro Ltd Dandhar PSEB Hydro 1.5 Rohil PSEB Hydro 0.8 Thuhi PSEB Hydro 0.8 TOTAL THERMAL (Punjab) TOTAL HYDRO (Punjab) THERMAL Kota TPS Unit 1 Kota TPS Unit 2 RAJASTHAN RRVUNL Coal RRVUNL Coal

9 NORTHERN GRID Calculated Values-B/g colour Data Collection from Different Sources-marked with different colours Formulae: NCV * EFCO2[Ref:MNES Report] Baseline for FY, , IPP NRLDC Annual Report, , Tariff Orders/Orders 1 GWh=1 MU Fuel Cons (Fi) '000 tons = (Gross Gen MU * OHR kcal/kwh)/(ncv kcal/kg) Coal (Default)=1.58 (Ref: (1) Electricity Data, , CEA, General Review 2005, CEA General Review 2005 NTPC Presentation 1 MWh= 1000 kwh COEFi (tco2/kg of fuel) = (NCV* EFCO2)*OXID Lignite=1.19 (2) NRLDC Annual Report, , CEA Performance Review of Thermal Power Station , , STEAM = COAL OXID = 0.98 (Coal), 0.99 (Oil), (Gas)- Ref: Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines Gas/NG/LNG=2.93 (3) Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations, , ; CEA MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM CERC Website Gas=NG NCV (kcal/kg) [Ref: Baseline for RE projects under CDM, MNES report] Diesel=3.2 OXID values (Ref:Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines) Must Run and Low Cost Plants shall be eliminated from Baseline Calculations Coal (default)=4021,lignite=2800, Gas/NG/LNG= , Diesel=10316, Naptha=10750 Naptha=3.3 Fuel NCV x Gross Gross Gross Fuel Cons. Fuel Cons. Oper. HR Oper. HR COEFi Fi*COE Fi*COEFi Fi*COE Year- Cons. (Fi) Oper. HR EFCO2 Name of the Agency/ Fuel Inst.Cap. Gen. Gen. Gen. (Fi) (000 (Fi) (000 (kcal/ (kcal/ NCV (kg of Fi (000 (000 Fi (000 Commiss (000 (kcal/ kwh) Kg of OXID Plant Owner Type (MW) (MU) (MU) (MU) Tonnes) Tonnes) kwh) kwh) Kcal/Kg CO2 /kg tco2) tco2) tco2) ion Tonnes) CO2/ Kg of fuel) of fuel Kota TPS Unit RRVUNL Coal Kota TPS Unit RRVUNL Coal Kota TPS Unit RRVUNL Coal Kota TPS Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh Unit RRVUNL Coal Suratgarh Unit RRVUNL Coal Ramgarh Gas RRVUNL Gas/HSD TPS (CCGT) Pragati CCGT RRVUNL Gas Stage-II GT-2 HYDRO Mahi Bajaj RRVUNL Hydro Sagar Rana Pratap Chambal Hydro Sagar (RPS) Jawahar Sagar Chambal Hydro (JS) Anoopgarh RRVUNL Hydro Small Hydro RRVUNL Hydro TOTAL THERMAL (Rajasthan) TOTAL HYDRO (Rajasthan) UTTAR PRADESH THERMAL Obra Unit 2 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 3 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 4 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 5 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 6 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 7 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 8 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 9 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 10 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 11 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 12 UPRVUN Coal Obra Unit 13 UPRVUN Coal Panki Unit 2 UPRVUN Coal Panki Unit 3 UPRVUN Coal Panki Unit 4 UPRVUN Coal Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-1 L Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-3 L Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-4 L Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-5 L Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-6 L Harduaganj B UPRVUN Coal Unit-7 L Paricha Unit-1 UPRVUN Coal Paricha Unit-2 UPRVUN Coal Anpara Unit 1 UPRVUN Coal Anpara Unit 2 UPRVUN Coal Anpara Unit 3 UPRVUN Coal Anpara Unit 4 UPRVUN Coal Anpara Unit 5 UPRVUN Coal HYDRO Rihand UPJVNL Hydro Obra Hydro UPJVNL Hydro Matatila UPJVNL Hydro Khara UPJVNL Hydro Chamoli UPJVNL Hydro 0.8 Suringad UPJVNL Hydro 0.8 Nirgajni UPJVNL Hydro 5 Nanital UPJVNL Hydro 0.7 Bhola UPJVNL Hydro 2.7 Tapovan UPJVNL Hydro 0.8 Chitanra UPJVNL Hydro 3 Salva UPJVNL Hydro 3 Gangori UPJVNL Hydro 0.8 TOTAL THERMAL (UP) TOTAL HYDRO (UP) UTTARANCHAL HYDRO Khatima UHPC Hydro Ramganga UHPC Hydro Ganga Canal UHPC Hydro

10 NORTHERN GRID Calculated Values-B/g colour Data Collection from Different Sources-marked with different colours Formulae: NCV * EFCO2[Ref:MNES Report] Baseline for FY, , IPP NRLDC Annual Report, , Tariff Orders/Orders 1 GWh=1 MU Fuel Cons (Fi) '000 tons = (Gross Gen MU * OHR kcal/kwh)/(ncv kcal/kg) Coal (Default)=1.58 (Ref: (1) Electricity Data, , CEA, General Review 2005, CEA General Review 2005 NTPC Presentation 1 MWh= 1000 kwh COEFi (tco2/kg of fuel) = (NCV* EFCO2)*OXID Lignite=1.19 (2) NRLDC Annual Report, , CEA Performance Review of Thermal Power Station , , STEAM = COAL OXID = 0.98 (Coal), 0.99 (Oil), (Gas)- Ref: Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines Gas/NG/LNG=2.93 (3) Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations, , ; CEA MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM CERC Website Gas=NG NCV (kcal/kg) [Ref: Baseline for RE projects under CDM, MNES report] Diesel=3.2 OXID values (Ref:Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines) Must Run and Low Cost Plants shall be eliminated from Baseline Calculations Coal (default)=4021,lignite=2800, Gas/NG/LNG= , Diesel=10316, Naptha=10750 Naptha=3.3 Fuel NCV x Gross Gross Gross Fuel Cons. Fuel Cons. Oper. HR Oper. HR COEFi Fi*COE Fi*COEFi Fi*COE Year- Cons. (Fi) Oper. HR EFCO2 Name of the Agency/ Fuel Inst.Cap. Gen. Gen. Gen. (Fi) (000 (Fi) (000 (kcal/ (kcal/ NCV (kg of Fi (000 (000 Fi (000 Commiss (000 (kcal/ kwh) Kg of OXID Plant Owner Type (MW) (MU) (MU) (MU) Tonnes) Tonnes) kwh) kwh) Kcal/Kg CO2 /kg tco2) tco2) tco2) ion Tonnes) CO2/ Kg of fuel) of fuel Yamuna (I & UHPC Hydro IV) Chibro UHPC Hydro Khodri UHPC Hydro Chilla UHPC Hydro (Rishikesh) Maneri Bhali UHPC Hydro Sobla (Sibla UHPC Hydro 6 Small Hyde Hydro 12.2 Galog UHPC Hydro 3 TOTAL HYDRO (Uttaranchal) CENTRAL GENERATING STATION THERMAL Badarpur Unit NTPC Coal Badarpur Unit NTPC Coal Badarpur Unit NTPC Coal Badarpur Unit NTPC Coal Badarpur Unit NTPC Coal Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -1 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -2 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -3 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -4 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -5 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -6 Singrauli STPS NTPC Coal Unit -7 Rihand Unit NTPC Coal Rihand Unit NTPC Coal Unchahar NTPC Coal Unit-1 Unchahar NTPC Coal Unit-2 Unchahar Jan-99 NTPC Coal Unit-3 Unchahar Oct-99 NTPC Coal Unit-4 Dadri National Capital TPP NTPC Coal (NCTPP) Unit-1 Dadri National Capital TPP NTPC Coal (NCTPP) Unit-2 Dadri National Capital TPP NTPC Coal (NCTPP) Unit-3 Dadri National Capital TPP NTPC Coal (NCTPP) Unit-4 Tanda Unit-1 NTPC Coal Tanda Unit-2 NTPC Coal Tanda Unit-3 NTPC Coal Tanda Unit-4 NTPC Coal Anta GTPS Gas/Nept NTPC (CCGT) ha Faridabad Gas/Nept NTPC GTPS (CCGT) ha Auraiya GTPS Gas/Nept NTPC (CCGT) ha Dadri GTPS NTPC Gas/HSD (CCGT) HYDRO Bairasiul NHPC Hydro Salal NHPC Hydro Tanakpur HPS NHPC Hydro Chamera HPS- NHPC Hydro Chamera HPS- NHPC Hydro Uri HPS NHPC Hydro Naptha Jhakri SJVNL Hydro Units-1,2,3,4,5,6 NUCLEAR Rajasthan Atomic Power Station (RAPS) - A NPC Nuclear

11 NORTHERN GRID Calculated Values-B/g colour Data Collection from Different Sources-marked with different colours Formulae: NCV * EFCO2[Ref:MNES Report] Baseline for FY, , IPP NRLDC Annual Report, , Tariff Orders/Orders 1 GWh=1 MU Fuel Cons (Fi) '000 tons = (Gross Gen MU * OHR kcal/kwh)/(ncv kcal/kg) Coal (Default)=1.58 (Ref: (1) Electricity Data, , CEA, General Review 2005, CEA General Review 2005 NTPC Presentation 1 MWh= 1000 kwh COEFi (tco2/kg of fuel) = (NCV* EFCO2)*OXID Lignite=1.19 (2) NRLDC Annual Report, , CEA Performance Review of Thermal Power Station , , STEAM = COAL OXID = 0.98 (Coal), 0.99 (Oil), (Gas)- Ref: Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines Gas/NG/LNG=2.93 (3) Performance Review of Thermal Power Stations, , ; CEA MNES Rept -Baseline for RE proj under CDM CERC Website Gas=NG NCV (kcal/kg) [Ref: Baseline for RE projects under CDM, MNES report] Diesel=3.2 OXID values (Ref:Revised 1996 IPCC Guidelines) Must Run and Low Cost Plants shall be eliminated from Baseline Calculations Coal (default)=4021,lignite=2800, Gas/NG/LNG= , Diesel=10316, Naptha=10750 Naptha=3.3 Fuel NCV x Gross Gross Gross Fuel Cons. Fuel Cons. Oper. HR Oper. HR COEFi Fi*COE Fi*COEFi Fi*COE Year- Cons. (Fi) Oper. HR EFCO2 Name of the Agency/ Fuel Inst.Cap. Gen. Gen. Gen. (Fi) (000 (Fi) (000 (kcal/ (kcal/ NCV (kg of Fi (000 (000 Fi (000 Commiss (000 (kcal/ kwh) Kg of OXID Plant Owner Type (MW) (MU) (MU) (MU) Tonnes) Tonnes) kwh) kwh) Kcal/Kg CO2 /kg tco2) tco2) tco2) ion Tonnes) CO2/ Kg of fuel) of fuel Rajasthan Atomic Power NPC Nuclear Station (RAPS) - B Narora Atomic Power Station, NPC Nuclear UP, (NAPS) BBMB (HYDRO) Bhakra BBMB Hydro Complex Dehar BBMB Hydro Pong BBMB Hydro TOTAL THERMAL (CGS) TOTAL HYDRO (CGS) TOTAL NUCLEAR (CGS) TOTAL BBMB HYDRO (CGS) Operating Margin Emission Factor (EF OM) Year Gross Gen (MUs) Fi*COEFi (000 tco2) Simple OM Method: Total Thermal EF OM simple = Σ(Fi*COEFi) / Σ(Gross Gen.) (tco2/ MWh) Total NR Generation MUs Build Margin Emission Factor (EF BM) Total NonTherm. Gen MUs % EF BM = Σ(Fi*COEFi) / Σ(Gross Gen.) (tco2/ MWh) Non Thermal gen is less than 50% of total NR gen.so Simple OM Method use Calculation of Build Margin shall includes either of (a) the 5 power plants that have been built most recently, or EF OM Simple tco2/ MWh (b) the power plants capacity additions in the electricity system EF OM Simple tco2/ MWh that Average of Three years comprise 20% of the system generation (in MWh) and that have been built most recently. The large value of (a) or (b) should be used for calculating EF BM Baseline Emission Factor (EF) EF= WOM * EF OM + WBM * WF BM (tco2/mwh)

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19