Data Envelopment Analysis
|
|
- Maximilian Chambers
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo Systems Analysis Laboratory Aalto University School of Science and Technology P.O.Box 11100, Aalto FINLAND These slides build extensively on the teaching materials of Prof. Sri Talluri who gave a DEA course in Helsinki in 2007 (used with permission). 1
2 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 2
3 Which Decision Making Unit (DMU) is most productive? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 3
4 DEA (Charnes, Coopers & Rhodes 78) DMU = Decision Making Unit A method for measuring the productivity of DMUs which consume multiple input and produce multiple-outputs #cust x slope = 1.87 x x x DMU labor hrs. #cust. #cust/hr DMU s 1,3,4,5 are dominated by DMU 2. x Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo labor hrs.
5 Extending to multiple outputs.. 8 M.D.s works at a Hospital for the same 160 hrs in a month. Each performs exams and surgeries Which ones are most productive? Doctor #Exams #Surgeries Note: There is some efficient trade-off between the number of surgeries and exams that any one M.D. can do in a month, but what is it? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 5
6 Scatter plot of ouputs #6 efficient frontier Efficient M.D. s: These two M.D. s (#1 and #6) define the most efficient trade-off between the two outputs. #Surgeries # These points are dominated by #1 and # #Exams Pareto-Koopman efficiency along the efficient frontier: It is impossible to increase an output (or to decrease an input) without a compensating decrease (increase) in other outputs (inputs). Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 6
7 Performance gaps How bad are inefficient M.D.s relative to the efficient ones? Where are the gaps? How bad are the gaps? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 7
8 Reference set Nearest efficient DMUs define a reference set and linear combination of the reference set inputs and outputs of a hypothetical composite unit (HCU) Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 8
9 Summary of DEA thus far Input/output productivity is defined relative to the efficient frontier This frontier characterizes observed efficient trade-offs among inputs and outputs for a given set of DMUs Efficiency is defined as the relative distance to the frontier Nearest point on the frontier is the efficient comparison unit (hypothetical comparison unit, HCU) Differences in inputs and outputs between DMU and HCU correspond to productivity gaps (improvement potential) But how can we do this analysis systematically? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 9
10 A real example on NY Area Sporting Goods Stores Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 10
11 Productivity Conceptually, productivity (efficiency) is the ratio between outputs and inputs Productivity = Outputs Inputs Yet reality is rather more complex Inputs Outputs equipment facility space server labor mgmt. labor Technology + Decision Making #type A cust. #type B cust. quality index $ oper. profit Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 11
12 Differences among Operating Units (DMUs) Mix of customers served Availability and cost of inputs Configuration of production facilities Processes and practices used Examples Bank branches, retail stores, clinics, schools, etc Questions: How to compare the productivity of diverse operating units that serve diverse markets? What are the best practice and under-performing units? What are the trade-offs among inputs and outputs? Where are the improvement opportunities and how big are they? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 12
13 Some approaches Operating ratios Examples: Labor hours per transaction, sales per square meter Appropriate for highly standardized operations But these do not reflect the varying mix of inputs/outputs of diverse operations Financial approach: Convert everything to monetary terms Concerns Inputs in Outputs in Some inputs/outputs cannot be valued in (non-profit) Profitability is not the same as operating efficiency (e.g. variances in margins and local costs matter as well) Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 13
14 Profitability vs. efficiency Profitability is a function of three elements Input prices (costs) Output prices Technical efficiency: How much input is required to generate the output Improving operations calls for an understanding of technical efficiency, not just overall profitability. Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 14
15 Variants of DEA Models CCR Model Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes (1978) Assumes constant returns to scale in production possibilities: an increase in the amount of inputs leads to a proportional increase in outputs BCC Model Banker, Charnes and Cooper (1984) Constant returns to scale not assumed, efficiency depends on the scale of operations Super efficiency model DEA models with weight information Cross-efficiency models in DEA Ratio-based Efficiency Analysis (REA) Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 15 15
16 Notation Data K #operating units(dmus) k=1,...,k M N # inputs #outputs m=1,...,m n=1,...,n y observed level of output n fromdmu k nk x observed level of input m fromdmu k mk Model variables v u E m n k weight of input i weight on output n efficiency ofdmu k (0-100%) E = k Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo m mk 16 å å N n=1 M m=1 u y n v x nk
17 Evaluating the CCR efficiency of DMU k Choose nonnegative I/O weights to This is equivalent to max subject to å å n m å å u,v ³ 0 n uy n v x m m nl ml n m uy n v x m nk mk 1, l=1,...,k max max subject to E 1, k=1,...,k Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 17 k subject to å m å n m å mk n E k Weighted input of DMU k is normalized to one uy - v x 0, l=1,...,k u,v ³ 0 n n å nk n nl m ml m m uy v x =1
18 An example with 4 DMUs Four DMUs, one input, one output The efficiency ratio is highest for DMU A Max.efficiency = 1 Input weight twice as high as output weight Efficiencies of other DMUs E B = 6/8 = 0.75 E C = 9/12 = 0.75 E D = 10/16 = Output needed to reach efficiency = 2x4 = 8 Actual output = 6 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 18
19 Input-Oriented CCR Ratio Model How much less inputs should an inefficient DMU use in order to become efficient? min l K å i=1 K å i=1 i ³ l l q subject to x qx, m=1,...,m i mi mk y ³ y, n=1,...,n i ni nk 0, i=1,...,k Optimal θ is the same efficiency as from the primal model Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 19 19
20 Dual formulation Dual variable associated with DMU i λ >0 Þ DMUi is in the reference set of DMU k i These variables can be used to construct an efficient hypothetical composite unit (HCU) with y ˆ = K å n i ni i=1 K å x ˆ = λ x, m=1,...,m Input n of HCU m i mi i such that λ y, n=1,...,n yˆ ³ y, n=1,...,n n nk xˆ x, m=1,...,m m λ i mk Output n of HCU Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 20
21 Uses of the HCU HCU can be used to measure how much more the DMU should produce or how much less it should consume inputs in order to become efficient D Output= yˆ -y ³ 0, n=1,...,n n nk D Input =x -xˆ ³ 0, m=1,...,m mk m Cf. spreadsheet examples Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 21
22 Excessive uses of inputs by inefficient DMUs Examples B should produce its current output (6) with one unit less of inputs in order to reach the efficient frontier The gap is therefore one unit D Input =4-3=1 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 22
23 Output-oriented CCR model Seeks to answer how much more DMU k should produce in order to become efficient max l K å i=1 K å i=1 i ³ l l q subject to x x, m=1,...,m i mi mk y ³ qy, n=1,...,n i ni nk 0, i=1,...,k 1 Efficiency is the reciprocal of optimum θ (i.e. ) q Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 23
24 Output gaps for inefficient DMUs Examples The optimal θ for is 4/3 Thus B should produce (4/3)*6 6 = 2 units more using its current inputs to reach the efficient frontier The CCR efficiency of B is 1 over 4/3 = 0.75 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 24
25 An illustrative CCR model DMU Input 1 Input 2 Output 1 Output 2 Output max 5v +14v = u +4u +16u 5v +14v u +7u +10u 8v +15v u +9u +13u 7v +12v u,u,u,v,v ³ u +4v +16v subject to Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 25
26 Results for the illustrative example DMU 1 and DMU 3 are efficient Efficiency of 1.00 with no slacks DMU 2 is inefficient Efficiency < 1.00 DMUs 1 and 3 can be employed as benchmarks for improvement See Excel example Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 26
27 BCC Model CCR model assumes constant returns to scale (CRS) whereas the BCC model considers variable returns to scale (VRS) New constraint (convexity) min K å i=1 K å i=1 K å i=1 subject to λ x θx, m=1,...,m i mi mk λ y ³ y, n=1,...,n i ni nk λ =1, λ ³ 0 i θ i Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 27
28 Change in the set of production possibilities C is BCC efficient B is BCC inefficient A 50%-50% combination of DMUs A and C uses 6 input units and produces 6,5 output units This is more than the 6 units that BCC efficient frontier B produces The resulting BCC output efficiency becomes 1 over (6.5/6) = Similar analyses for input can be made Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 28 The resulting CCR efficient frontier
29 Super efficiency model Helps determine how much more efficient an efficient DMU is relative to other DMUs max å å m n m å mk n subject to u y v x, l=1,...,k, l ¹ k u,v ³ 0 m n å nk n nl m ml m n u y v x =1 The model does help rank inefficient DMUs DMU k under evaluation is removed from the constraint set thereby allowing its efficiency score to exceed a value of 1.00 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 29
30 Super efficiency illustrated D evaluated relative to the frontier defined by C-E-F Superefficiency defined by the distance OD/OD Similarly E evaluated in comparison with the frontier C-D-F and its superefficiency defined by the distance OE-OE By visual inspection, D is slightly more superefficient than D O 1 /I O Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 30 C A D D Efficient frontier E E F O 2 /I
31 DEA models with weight information DMUs may attain their efficiency scores for extreme weights in conventional DEA models Preference information can be captured through preference statements about the relative values of input units output units Statements impose constraints on the input/output weights The introduction of weight information often leads to lower (but never higher) efficiency scores Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 31
32 Sets of feasible weights (assurance regions) Preference statements constrain feasible weights A Dissertation is as at least as valuable as 2 Master s Theses, but not more valuable than 7 master s theses» u doctoral 2u master s, u doctoral 7u master s An article in a refereed journal is at least as valuable as a Master s Thesis» u article u master s Only relative weights matter Several elicitation methods can be employed Feasible sets defined by corresponding constraints { ( 1,..., )' 0 0, 0} { (,..., )' 0 0, 0} S = u = u u u Au u N u S = v= v v v Av v 1 M v Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 32
33 Example of a DEA model with weight restrictions max å n u y n nk subject to å m v x =1 m mk å n u y v x, l=1,...,k α v v β v, m=1,,m au u bu, n=1,,n u,v ³ 0 å n nl m ml m m m 1 m m n n 1 n n m n Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 33
34 Weight constraints illustrated (1 input, 2 outputs) Without any weight information, F is efficient Assume that the 1st output on the vertical axis is has more weight than the 2nd output on the horizontal axis Now F becomes dominated by D and E (i.e., for all weights in the revised weight set, D and E will have a higher efficiency) O 1 /I O C D A E F O 2 /I Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 34
35 Cross-efficiencies in DEA CCR efficiencies are based on the weights which are most favourable to the DMU being evaluated Yet it may be of interest to know how the DMU performs when using other weights as well. The cross efficiency score represents how the DMU performs when evaluated with the optimal weights for all DMUs A DMU with a high cross efficiency score can be considered to be a good overall performer; others are more niche DMUs Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 35
36 Cross efficiency matrix DMU N 1 Θ 11 Θ 12 Θ 13 Θ 1N 2 Θ 21 Θ 22 Θ 23 Θ 2N 3 Θ 31 Θ 32 Θ 33 Θ 3N N Θ N1 Θ N2 Θ N3 Θ NN Efficiency score of DMU 2 when evaluated with the optimal weights of DMU 1 Cross-efficiency score for DMU k computed from CR k Multiple optima are possible, selections either based on aggressive formulation or benevolent formulation. K = Θ i= 1 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 36 ik
37 Selecting inputs and outputs Examples of inputs in operations management Workers, machines, operating expenses, budget, etc. Examples of outputs Number of actual products produced Performance and activity measures such as quality levels, throughput rates, lead-times, etc. If there are M inputs and N outputs then potentially MN DMUs can be efficient To achieve discrimination the number of DMUs should be high enough Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 37
38 Designing DEA Studies Enough DMUs in relation to inputs/outputs for building an efficient frontier K>2(N +M) Ambivalence about inputs/outputs -all should matter! Approximate similarity (comparability) of DMUs Objectives Technology DEA provides relative efficiency only Choice of DMUs does matter Inclusion of global leader unit may be desirable Experiments with different I/O combinations may be necessary Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 38
39 Using the results: Efficiency Profit matrix High Profit Under-performing potential leaders Best practice comparison group Low Eff. High Eff. Under-performing possibly profitable Candidates for closure Low Profit Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 39
40 Information provided by DEA Objective measures of efficiency A reference set of comparable units Indicators of excess use of inputs Shortfalls in the production of outputs Returns to scale measure Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 40
41 DEA Summary Uses of DEA Benchmarking to identify best practice units Data mining to generate hypotheses about the drivers of efficiency Performance evaluation and measurement Caveats Essentially a black box approach - gives no information about the causes of inefficiency Strong assumptions (linearity, set of production possibilities) Should not be employed for resource allocation in any straightforward manner Results can be sensitive to selection of inputs/outputs and introduction of outlier DMUs For further Data Envelopment reading, Analysis see, e.g., W.D. Cook, L.M. Seiford Ahti Salo (2009) Data envelopment analysis 41(DEA) Thirty years on, European Journal of Operational Research 192/1, 1-17.
42 Ratio-based Efficiency Analysis (REA) 1 DEA measures efficiencies relative to the efficient frontier that is defined by production possibilties This set may not be easy to characterize Introduction of an outlier DMUs may disrupt efficiency scores DEA scores reflect DMUs performance only for weights that are most fabourable to it (cf. motivation for cross-efficiencies) REA Offers efficiency results without making assumptions about production possibilities beyond the set of DMUs that are under comparison Considers the relative efficiencies of DMUs for all feasible weights Offers several efficiency measures 1 Ahti Salo and Antti Punkka (2010). Ranking Intervals and Dominance Relations for Ratio-Based Efficiency Analysis, submitted manuscript, downloadable at Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 42
43 Efficiency measures in REA Key questions What are the best and worst rankings that a given DMU can attain in comparison with other DMUs, based on the comparison of DMUs' efficiency ratios for all feasible weights? Given a pair of DMUs, does the first DMU dominate the second one? (in the sense that the efficiency ratio of the first DMU is higher than or equal to that of the second for all feasible weights and strictly higher for some weights) How much more/less efficient can a given DMU be relative to some other DMU? Or relative to the most and least efficient DMU in some subset of DMUs? ŁRanking intervals, dominance relations, efficiency bounds Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 43
44 Efficiency ratios in CCR-DEA Efficiency score of DMU k is computed with weights u k *,v k * to maximize min l=1,...,k E k /E l Does not provide information about the efficiencies for other weights These weights depend on what DMUs are considered changing the set of DMUs can influence the order of two DMUs scores E E 3 / E * =1 E 5 E 1 / E * =1 E 3 / E * =0.98 E 1 E 2 E * DMU 1 and DMU 3 are efficient If DMU 5 is included, then DMU 2 becomes more efficient than DMU 3 in terms of its DEA score E 3 E 4 E 4 / E * =0.82 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 44 u 1
45 Efficiency dominance (1/2) DMU k dominates DMU l iff (i) its efficiency ratio is at least as high as that of DMU l for all feasible weights (ii) higher for some feasible weights E E ( uv, ) E ( uv, ) forall ( uv, ) ( S, S ) k l u v E ( uv, ) > E ( uv, ) for some ( uv, ) ( S, S ) k l u v Example, 2 outputs, 1 input Feasible weights such that 2u 1 u 2 u 1 E 1 E 2 E 3 E 4 E * DMU 3 and DMU 2 dominate DMU 4 Also the inefficient DMU 2 is nondominated u 1 =1/3 u 2 =2/3 u 1 =1/2 u 2 =1/2 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 45
46 Efficiency dominance (2/2) A graph shows dominance relations 2 among several DMU Transitive: If A dominates B, and B dominates C, then A dominates C E Asymmetric: (i) If A dom. B, then B does not dom. A and (ii) no DMU dominates itself E 1 E 2 E * Additional preference information helps establish additional relations» An exception: if A dom. B and E A = E B for some feasible weights, then it is possible that E A = E B throughout the smaller feasible region Statement 5u 1 4u 2 leads to new dominance relations u 1 =1/3 u 2 =2/3 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 46 E 3 E 4 5u 1 = 4u 2 u 1 =1/2 u 2 =1/2
47 Ranking intervals (1/2) For any feasible weights (u,v), the DMUs can be ranked based on their Efficiency Ratios The minimum ranking of DMU k, r min k, is obtained for weights such that the number of DMUs with strictly higher Efficiency Ratio is minimized The maximum ranking of DMU k, r max k, is obtained for weights such that the number of DMUs with higher or equal Efficiency Ratio is maximized E E 1 E 2 E 3 E 4 u 1 =1/3 u 2 =2/3 ranking 1 ranking 2 ranking 3 ranking 4 E * u 1 =1/2 u 2 =1/2 DMU 1 DMU 2 DMU 3 DMU 4 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 47
48 Ranking intervals (2/2) Properties Can be readily compared Provides a holistic view of efficiency ratios at a glance Show also how bad DMUs can be Are insentitive to the introduction of outlier DMUS Additional weight information can narrow (but not widen) ranking intervals CCR-DEA-efficient DMUs have the highest efficiency ratio for some weights their minimum ranking is 1 Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 48
49 Computation of dominance relations (1/2) How to determine whether DMU k dominates DMU l E ( uv, ) E ( uv, ) ( uv, ) ( S, S ) and k l u v E ( uv, ) > E ( uv, ) for some ( uv, ) ( S, S )? k l u v E ( uv, ) E ( uv, ) ( uv, ) ( S, S ) if k l u v min [ E ( uv, ) E ( uv, )] 0 ( uv, ) ( S, S ) u v Ek( uv, ) min 1... u v E ( uv, ) ( uv, ) ( S, S ) k l l (S u,s v ) is open, not bounded, and the objective function non-linear... How to solve the optimization problem? Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 49
50 Computation of dominance relations (2/2) Normalize weights so that The value of inputs of DMU k =1 The value of outputs of DMU l is equal to its value of inputs Feasible weights are now bounded, closed by linear constraints, objective function linear If the minimum is exactly 1, maximize the same objective function to see whether there N n nk n nl n= 1 n= 1 min / 1 Au u 0 M M Av v 0 vmx mk vmxml m= 1 m= 1 N min uy 1 n= 1 Au u 0 Av v 0 v x m mk v x uy n = 1 = nk u y m ml n nl N uy exists weights such that E k > E l Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 50
51 Computation of ranking intervals and efficiency bounds Minimum (best) rankings for DMU k 1. For all other DMUs, define binary variables z l so that z l = 1 if E l > E k 2. Choose a suitable normalization to come up with a MILP model 3. The minimum is 1 + the minimum of z l over (S u,s v ) Maximum rankings with a corresponding model Efficiency bounds compared to the most efficient DMU Maximum with LP similar to the computation of DEA scores Minimum 1. Minimize the linear model used for the computation of dominance relations against all DMUs in the benchmark group 2. The smallest of these is the minimum E ( uv, ) E ( uv, ) + Cz, C >> 0 l k l Comparisons to the least efficient DMU with corresponding models Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 51
52 Example: Efficiency analysis of TKK s departments Departments consume inputs in order to produce outputs Data from TKK s reporting system 2 inputs, 44 outputs x 1 (Budget funding) y 1 (Master s Theses) x 2 (Project funding) Department y 2 (Dissertations) y 3 (Int l publications) Preferences from 7 members of the Resources Committee Ex: What is the value of a Master s thesis relative to a dissertation.? Each member responded to elicitation questions, which yielded crisp weights The feasible weights were then modeled as all possible convex combinations of these weightings Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 52
53 A B C D E F G H I J K L A B C D E F G H I J K L Efficiency bounds compared to the most efficient department A B I J G D, F, H L K C, E Dominance relations Ranking intervals Departments A, J and L are efficient But A can attain ranking 7 > 4, the worst ranking of the inefficient department K There are feasible weights so that the Efficiency Ratio of A is only 57 % of that of the most efficient department» For K, the corresponding ratio is 71% The efficiency intervals of D, F and H overlap with those of B and G Yet, for all feasible weights the Efficiency Ratios of D, F and H are smaller than those of B and G Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 53
54 Conclusion REA results use all feasible weights to evaluate DMUs Dominance relations compare DMUs pairwise Ranking intervals show which rankings can be attained by DMUs Efficiency bounds show how efficient a DMU can be compared to the DMUs in a benchmark group Computed with LP and MILP models Admits preference information Helps exclude the use of extreme weights in efficiency determination: 100 dissertations is less valuable than an article Additional preference information makes REA results more conclusive Introduction of new DMUs do not affect results for other DMUs Data Envelopment Analysis Ahti Salo 54
Benchmarking Inefficient Decision Making Units in DEA
J. Basic. Appl. Sci. Res., 2(12)12056-12065, 2012 2012, TextRoad Publication ISSN 2090-4304 Journal of Basic and Applied Scientific Research www.textroad.com Benchmarking Inefficient Decision Making Units
More informationEfficiency Measurement on Banking Sector in Bangladesh
Dhaka Univ. J. Sci. 61(1): 1-5, 2013 (January) Efficiency Measurement on Banking Sector in Bangladesh Md. Rashedul Hoque * and Md. Israt Rayhan Institute of Statistical Research and Training (ISRT), Dhaka
More informationSensitivity and stability of super-efficiency in data envelopment analysis models
Sensitivity and stability of super-efficiency in data envelopment analysis models M.Thilagam 1, V.Prakash 2 1 Assistant Professor, Department of Statistics, Presidency College, Chennai, India 2 Associate
More informationPerformance Measurement of OC Mines Using VRS Method
Performance Measurement of Using VRS Method Dr.G.Thirupati Reddy Professor, Dept of Mechanical Engineering, Sree Visvesvaraya Institute of Technology & Science, Mahabubnagar, Telengana state, INDIA Abstract
More informationCost-Efficiency by Arash Method in DEA
Applied Mathematical Sciences, Vol. 6, 2012, no. 104, 5179-5184 Cost-Efficiency by Arash Method in DEA Dariush Khezrimotlagh*, Zahra Mohsenpour and Shaharuddin Salleh Department of Mathematics, Faculty
More informationA Method for Solving Super-Efficiency Infeasibility by Adding virtual DMUs with Mean Values
` Iranian Journal of Management Studies (IJMS) http://ijms.ut.ac.ir/ Vol. Optimization 10, No. 4, Autumn of the 2017 Inflationary Inventory Control Print The ISSN: 2008-7055 pp. 905-916 Online ISSN: 2345-3745
More informationContents 1. Intro r duction 2. Research Method 3. Applications of DEA t A o Container Po rts 4. Efficiency Results 5. Conclusion
Contents 1. Introduction 2. Research Method 3. Applications of DEA to Container Ports 4. Efficiency Results 5. Conclusion - 1 - Purpose of Research As the competition among the world ports has become increasingly
More informationDATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS OF BANKING SECTOR IN BANGLADESH. Md. Rashedul Hoque, Researcher Dr. Md. Israt Rayhan, Assistant Professor
R. HOQUE, I. RAYHAN, University of Dhaka DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS OF BANKING SECTOR IN BANGLADESH Md. Rashedul Hoque, Researcher Dr. Md. Israt Rayhan, Assistant Professor Institute of Statistical Research
More informationLicensing and Warranty Agreement
Licensing and Warranty Agreement READ THIS: Do not install the software until you have read and agreed to this agreement. By opening the accompanying software, you acknowledge that you have read and accepted
More informationMAINTENANCE AND OUTAGE REPAIRING ACTIVITIES IN ELECTRICITY NETWORKS
MAINTENANCE AND OUTAGE REPAIRING ACTIVITIES IN ELECTRICITY NETWORKS Thomas Weyman-Jones Department of Economics, Loughborough University, UK Júlia Boucinha Catarina Feteira Inácio EDP Distribuição, Lisboa,
More informationData envelopment analysis with missing values: an approach using neural network
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.17 No.2, February 2017 29 Data envelopment analysis with missing values: an approach using neural network B. Dalvand, F. Hosseinzadeh
More informationThe Pennsylvania State University. The Graduate School. The Harold and Inge Marcus Department of Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering
The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School The Harold and Inge Marcus Department of Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering INTRODUCTION TO DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS AND A CASE STUDY IN HEALTH
More informationAn Approach to Discriminate Non-Homogeneous DMUs
An Approach to Discriminate Non-Homogeneous DMUs Zhongsheng HUA * Ping HE School of Management University of Science & Technology of China Hefei, Anhui 3006 People s Republic of China [005-046] Submitted
More informationLower Bound Restrictions on Intensities in Data Envelopment Analysis
C Journal of Productivity Analysis, 16, 241 261, 2001. 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Manufactured in The Netherlands. Lower Bound Restrictions on Intensities in Data Envelopment Analysis SYLVAIN BOUHNIK,
More informationA Method to Recognize Congestion in FDH Production Possibility Set
J. Basic. Appl. Sci. Res., 3(4)704-709, 2013 2013, TextRoad Publication ISSN 2090-4304 Journal of Basic and Applied Scientific Research www.textroad.com A Method to Recognize Congestion in FDH Production
More informationAn Approach to Judge Homogeneity of Decision Making Units
An Approach to Judge Homogeneity of Decision Making Units Zhongsheng HUA * Ping HE School of Management University of Science & Technology of China Hefei, Anhui 230026 People s Republic of China [005-0145]
More informationElectricity Generation Efficiency Measures: Fixed Proportion Technology Indicators
Electricity Generation Efficiency Measures: Fixed Proportion Technology Indicators Darold T Barnum (corresponding author) Department of Managerial Studies Department of Information & Decision Sciences
More informationExpert Systems with Applications
Expert Systems with Applications 38 (2011) 2172 2176 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Expert Systems with Applications journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/eswa Using the DEA-R model in the
More informationEEEE 524/624: Fall 2017 Advances in Power Systems
EEEE 524/624: Fall 2017 Advances in Power Systems Lecture 6: Economic Dispatch with Network Constraints Prof. Luis Herrera Electrical and Microelectronic Engineering Rochester Institute of Technology Topics
More informationRanking Two-Stage Production Units in Data Envelopment Analysis
Asia-Pacific Journal of Operational Research Vol. 33, No. 1 (2016) 1650002 (19 pages) c World Scientific Publishing Co. & Operational Research Society of Singapore DOI: 10.1142/S0217595916500020 Raning
More informationInternational Journal for Management Science And Technology (IJMST)
ISSN: 2320-8848 (Online) ISSN: 2321-0362 (Print) International Journal for Management Science And Technology (IJMST) Volume 1; Issue 3 Paper- 2 A Case Study on Optimal Supplier Problem Using Data Envelopment
More informationCharacterization of DEA ranking models
Retrospective Theses and Dissertations Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Dissertations 2002 Characterization of DEA ranking models Sung-Kyun Choi Iowa State University Follow this and additional
More informationEVALUATING PORT EFFICIENCY IN ASIA PACIFIC REGION WITH RECURSIVE DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS
EVALUATING PORT EFFICIENCY IN ASIA PACIFIC REGION WITH RECURSIVE DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS Hsuan-Shih Lee Professor Department of Shipping and Transportation Management National Taiwan Ocean University
More informationTopic 5 Lecture 3 Estimating Policy Effects via the Simple Linear. Regression Model (SLRM) and the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) Method
Econometrics for Health Policy, Health Economics, and Outcomes Research Topic 5 Lecture 3 Estimating Policy Effects via the Simple Linear Regression Model (SLRM) and the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) Method
More informationSample Reports. Overview. Appendix C
Sample Reports Appendix C Overview Appendix C contains examples of ParTEST reports. The information in the reports is provided for illustration purposes only. The following reports are examples only: Test
More informationContext-Dependent Data Envelopment Analysis and an Application
Context-Dependent Data Envelopment Analysis and an Application Mervenur Pala 1, Talat Şenel 2 Ondokuz Mayıs University, Department of Statistics, Samsun Turkey Abstract: Data envelopment analysis (DEA)
More informationBENCHMARK SURVEY 2013
AUSTRALIAN CAR WASH INDUSTRY BENCHMARK SURVEY 2013 This survey was undertaken in response to many requests for information about the car wash industry in Australia both the current position and the trends
More informationEVALUATION OF TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY OF STATE TRANSPORT CORPORATIONS IN TAMILNADU DEA APPROACH
International Journal of Research in Social Sciences Vol. 8 Issue 7, July 2018, ISSN: 2249-2496 Impact Factor: 7.081 Journal Homepage: Double-Blind Peer Reviewed Refereed Open Access International Journal
More informationDecision Models: Lecture 5 2. Integer Programming. Decision Models. Lecture 5. What use? Selected Applications
Decision Models: Lecture 5 2 Decision Models Lecture 5 Integer Programming! Plant location example Lakefield Corporation s Oil Trading Desk! Background Information! Blending Linear Program Summary and
More informationLocomotive Allocation for Toll NZ
Locomotive Allocation for Toll NZ Sanjay Patel Department of Engineering Science University of Auckland, New Zealand spat075@ec.auckland.ac.nz Abstract A Locomotive is defined as a self-propelled vehicle
More informationVehicle Replacement Policy - Toronto Police Service
STAFF REPORT June 21, 2000 To: From: Subject: Policy and Finance Committee Chairman, Toronto Police Services Board and City Auditor Vehicle Replacement Policy - Toronto Police Service Purpose: The purpose
More informationPERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION SECTOR OF SRI LANKA BASED ON DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF POWER DISTRIBUTION SECTOR OF SRI LANKA BASED ON DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS K.V.R.Perera 109241R Degree of Master of Science Department of Electrical Engineering University of Moratuwa
More informationResponsive Bus Bridging Service Planning Under Urban Rail Transit Line Emergency
2016 3 rd International Conference on Vehicle, Mechanical and Electrical Engineering (ICVMEE 2016) ISBN: 978-1-60595-370-0 Responsive Bus Bridging Service Planning Under Urban Rail Transit Line Emergency
More informationFebuary 2003 BANDINI GIRO LTD Profitability, Performance & Problems http://www.andidas.com/ http://www.andidas.com/ Executive Summary As the Finance Director of Bandini Grio LTD, I have been asked to prepare
More informationOptimal Power Flow Formulation in Market of Retail Wheeling
Optimal Power Flow Formulation in Market of Retail Wheeling Taiyou Yong, Student Member, IEEE Robert Lasseter, Fellow, IEEE Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Wisconsin at
More informationCars and vans CO2 regulations: even ambitious EU standards deliver less than half transport emission reductions needed to meet 2030 climate targets
Cars and vans CO2 regulations: even ambitious EU standards deliver less than half transport emission reductions needed to meet 2030 climate targets October 2017 Summary Road transport is one of the few
More informationSuburban bus route design
University of Wollongong Research Online Faculty of Engineering and Information Sciences - Papers: Part A Faculty of Engineering and Information Sciences 2013 Suburban bus route design Shuaian Wang University
More informationHybrid cluster analyzing and data envelopment analysis with interval data
Hybrid cluster analyzing and data envelopment analysis with interval data Kianoosh Kianfar 1, Mahnaz Ahadzadeh Namin 2*, Akbar Alam Tabriz 3, Esmaeil Najafi 4, Farhad Hosseinzadeh Lotfi 5 1 Department
More informationTarget Setting for Inefficient DMUs for an Acceptable Level of Efficient Performance
Global Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematic. ISSN 0973-1768 Volume 13, Number 6 (2017), pp. 1893-1902 Reearch India Publication http://www.ripublication.com Target Setting for Inefficient DMU for an
More information400/230 Volt 60Hz UPS Power
olt 60Hz Power Using ual Voltage standby generation and in one Nothing protects quite like Piller www.piller.com Contents 1 Abstract...3 2 Introduction...4 3 Alternative Power istribution...6 4 Integrating
More informationPREPARATION, TESTING AND COMPARISON OF FRICTION COMPOSITES. Nanotechnology Centre, VŠB-Technical University of Ostrava, Czech Republic
PREPARATION, TESTING AND COMPARISON OF FRICTION COMPOSITES Marek Krygel 1, Miroslav Vaculik 1,2, Jana Kukutschova 1,2, Peter Filip 1 1 Nanotechnology Centre, VŠB-Technical University of Ostrava, Czech
More informationInternational Aluminium Institute
THE INTERNATIONAL ALUMINIUM INSTITUTE S REPORT ON THE ALUMINIUM INDUSTRY S GLOBAL PERFLUOROCARBON GAS EMISSIONS REDUCTION PROGRAMME RESULTS OF THE 2003 ANODE EFFECT SURVEY 28 January 2005 Published by:
More informationTRINITY COLLEGE DUBLIN THE UNIVERSITY OF DUBLIN. Faculty of Engineering, Mathematics and Science. School of Computer Science and Statistics
ST7003-1 TRINITY COLLEGE DUBLIN THE UNIVERSITY OF DUBLIN Faculty of Engineering, Mathematics and Science School of Computer Science and Statistics Postgraduate Certificate in Statistics Hilary Term 2015
More information2010 Journal of Industrial Ecology
21 Journal of Industrial Ecology www.wiley.com/go/jie Subramanian, R., B. Talbot, and S. Gupta. 21. An approach to integrating environmental considerations within managerial decisionmaking. Journal of
More informationCourse. GNEG 1103 Introduction to Engineering. Assignment. Team Design Project. Project Selected. Solar Powered Stereo Cooler. Project Presentation
Course GNEG 1103 Introduction to Engineering Assignment Team Design Project Project Selected Solar Powered Stereo Cooler Project Presentation April 23, 2014 Team Members Kenny Callis Ronny Akhaphong Alfredo
More informationImprovement of Vehicle Dynamics by Right-and-Left Torque Vectoring System in Various Drivetrains x
Improvement of Vehicle Dynamics by Right-and-Left Torque Vectoring System in Various Drivetrains x Kaoru SAWASE* Yuichi USHIRODA* Abstract This paper describes the verification by calculation of vehicle
More informationInvestigation of Relationship between Fuel Economy and Owner Satisfaction
Investigation of Relationship between Fuel Economy and Owner Satisfaction June 2016 Malcolm Hazel, Consultant Michael S. Saccucci, Keith Newsom-Stewart, Martin Romm, Consumer Reports Introduction This
More informationChiang Kao. Network Data Envelopment. Analysis. Foundations and Extensions. ^ Springer
Chiang Kao Network Data Envelopment Analysis Foundations and Extensions ^ Springer Contents 1 Introduction 1 1.1 History of Network DEA 2 1.2 Basic Ideas of Efficiency Measurement 3 1.3 Multi-input Case
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION ENTERPRISE AND INDUSTRY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
EUROPEAN COMMISSION ENTERPRISE AND INDUSTRY DIRECTORATE-GENERAL Consumer Goods and EU Satellite navigation programmes Automotive industry Brussels, 08 April 2010 ENTR.F1/KS D(2010) European feed back to
More informationChapter 2 & 3: Interdependence and the Gains from Trade
Econ 123 Principles of Economics: Micro Chapter 2 & 3: Interdependence and the Gains from rade Instructor: Hiroki Watanabe Fall 212 Watanabe Econ 123 2 & 3: Gains from rade 1 / 119 1 Introduction 2 Productivity
More informationResidential Lighting: Shedding Light on the Remaining Savings Potential in California
Residential Lighting: Shedding Light on the Remaining Savings Potential in California Kathleen Gaffney, KEMA Inc., Oakland, CA Tyler Mahone, KEMA, Inc., Oakland, CA Alissa Johnson, KEMA, Inc., Oakland,
More information2003 fourth quarter and full-year results
Dinesh Paliwal Member of Group Executive Committee, Head of Automation Technologies Division 2003 fourth quarter and full-year results Automation Technologies Copyright 2003 ABB. All rights reserved. -
More informationTABLE OF CONTENTS. Table of contents. Page ABSTRACT ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TABLE OF TABLES TABLE OF FIGURES
Table of contents TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF TABLES TABLE OF FIGURES INTRODUCTION I.1. Motivations I.2. Objectives I.3. Contents and structure I.4. Contributions
More informationEXAMPLES OF PRODUCT ENGINEERING WITH OPTISLANG AT DIESEL SYSTEMS
WEIMARER OPTIMIERUNGS- UND STOCHASTIKTAGE 2016 EXAMPLES OF PRODUCT ENGINEERING WITH OPTISLANG AT DIESEL SYSTEMS DR. RAINER KECK ROBERT BOSCH GMBH, DIESEL SYSTEMS Agenda Diesel by Bosch Motivation/ Product
More informationANNA UNIVERSITY - M.C.A IV SEMESTER Problem Set MC1752/MC9242/ Resource Management Techniques
Sou rce S r i V e n k a t e s w a r a C o l l e g e o f E n g i n e e r i n g, S r i p e r u m b u d u r D e p a r t m e n t o f C o m p u t e r A p p l i c a t i o n s ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
More informationAnalysis of American University s Latest Made in America Index
Analysis of American University s Latest Made in America Index American Automotive Policy Council June 2016 Topline NEW RANKINGS. American University s Kogod School of Business recently released a comprehensive
More informationChapter 6 Efficiency Ranking Method using SFA and SDEA: Analysis and Discussion
Chapter 6 Efficiency Ranking Method using SFA and SDEA: Analysis and Discussion 206 The proposed approach, in this chapter is based on the theme of integration of SFA and Super efficiency model of DEA
More informationChapter 20: Cost Minimization Problem
Econ 323 Microeconomic Analysis Chapter : Cost Minimization Problem Instructor: Hiroki Watanabe Spring 13 Watanabe Econ 323 CMP 1 / 91 1 Introduction Overview Cost Minimization Problem (CMP) 2 Cost Minimization
More informationSpecial Research Study:
Special Research Study: Comparison of Water Main Pipe Installation Lengths and Costs in North and South Carolina: Raleigh, Charlotte, and Spartanburg/Greenville Client: American Chemistry Council BCC Research
More informationHIGH VOLTAGE vs. LOW VOLTAGE: POTENTIAL IN MILITARY SYSTEMS
2013 NDIA GROUND VEHICLE SYSTEMS ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY SYMPOSIUM POWER AND MOBILITY (P&M) MINI-SYMPOSIUM AUGUST 21-22, 2013 TROY, MICHIGAN HIGH VOLTAGE vs. LOW VOLTAGE: POTENTIAL IN MILITARY SYSTEMS
More informationPredicting Tractor Fuel Consumption
University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Biological Systems Engineering: Papers and Publications Biological Systems Engineering 24 Predicting Tractor Fuel Consumption
More informationJones and Mueller Matrices for Linear Retarders. Zero and Multiple Order Linear Retarders. Angle-Dependence of Linear Retarders
Lecture 8: Fixed Retarders Outline 1 Jones and Mueller Matrices for Linear Retarders 2 Zero and Multiple Order Linear Retarders 3 Crystal Retarders 4 Polymer Retarders 5 Achromatic Retarders 6 Angle-Dependence
More informationToner Cartridge Evaluation Report # Cartridge Type: EY3-OCC5745
Toner Cartridge Evaluation Report # 03-236 Cartridge Type: EY3-OCC5745 July 31, 2003 Cartridges submitted for evaluation by ELT 708 W.Kenosha Broken Arrow, OK Evaluation and Report By: National Center
More informationHigh-Speed High-Performance Model Predictive Control of Power Electronics Systems
High-Speed High-Performance Model Predictive Control of Power Electronics Systems S. MARIÉTHOZ, S. ALMÉR, A. DOMAHIDI, C. FISCHER, M. HERCEG, S. RICHTER, O. SCHULTES, M. MORARI Automatic Control Laboratory,
More informationAuc2Charge: An Online Auction Framework for Electric Vehicle Park-and-Charge
Auc2Charge: An Online Auction Framework for Electric Vehicle Park-and-Charge Qiao Xiang 1, Fanxin Kong 1, Xue Liu 1, Xi Chen 1, Linghe Kong 1 and Lei Rao 2 1 School of Computer Science, McGill University
More informationOnline Learning and Optimization for Smart Power Grid
1 2016 IEEE PES General Meeting Panel on Domain-Specific Big Data Analytics Tools in Power Systems Online Learning and Optimization for Smart Power Grid Seung-Jun Kim Department of Computer Sci. and Electrical
More informationAGRIBUSINESS (AGB) AGB Courses. Agribusiness (AGB) 1
Agribusiness (AGB) 1 AGRIBUSINESS (AGB) AGB Courses AGB 101. Introduction to Agribusiness. 4 units Prerequisite: AGB major and freshman standing. Orientation to the agribusiness sector of agriculture.
More informationEmbedded Torque Estimator for Diesel Engine Control Application
2004-xx-xxxx Embedded Torque Estimator for Diesel Engine Control Application Peter J. Maloney The MathWorks, Inc. Copyright 2004 SAE International ABSTRACT To improve vehicle driveability in diesel powertrain
More information4 COSTS AND OPERATIONS
4 COSTS AND OPERATIONS 4.1 INTRODUCTION This chapter summarizes the estimated capital and operations and maintenance (O&M) costs for the Modal and High-Speed Train (HST) Alternatives evaluated in this
More informationOPTIMIZATION STUDIES OF ENGINE FRICTION EUROPEAN GT CONFERENCE FRANKFURT/MAIN, OCTOBER 8TH, 2018
OPTIMIZATION STUDIES OF ENGINE FRICTION EUROPEAN GT CONFERENCE FRANKFURT/MAIN, OCTOBER 8TH, 2018 M.Sc. Oleg Krecker, PhD candidate, BMW B.Eng. Christoph Hiltner, Master s student, Affiliation BMW AGENDA
More informationLecture 2. Review of Linear Regression I Statistics Statistical Methods II. Presented January 9, 2018
Review of Linear Regression I Statistics 211 - Statistical Methods II Presented January 9, 2018 Estimation of The OLS under normality the OLS Dan Gillen Department of Statistics University of California,
More informationWhy Japan remains skeptical of restructuring Study of Electricity Market Bidding Characteristics for Modeling Generation Capacity Growth
Why Japan remains skeptical of restructuring Study of Electricity Market Bidding Characteristics for Modeling Generation Capacity Growth Satoru Ihara Retired (urotas@ieee.org) Tetsuo Sasaki, Toshihisa
More informationEconomics - Primary Track (
Economics 1 Economics Majors from the Department of Economics pursue careers in business, banking and finance, government, and consulting. They are also prepared to enter graduate or professional programs
More informationElectric Power Research Institute, USA 2 ABB, USA
21, rue d Artois, F-75008 PARIS CIGRE US National Committee http : //www.cigre.org 2016 Grid of the Future Symposium Congestion Reduction Benefits of New Power Flow Control Technologies used for Electricity
More informationDunlap Community Unit School District #323 Balanced Scorecard. Updated 12/13/16
Dunlap Community Unit School District #323 Balanced Scorecard d 12/13/16 Goal # 1: Promote Growth and Achievement in the Dunlap School Community # 1.A Nov Measure Increase student growth and achievement
More informationReal-time Bus Tracking using CrowdSourcing
Real-time Bus Tracking using CrowdSourcing R & D Project Report Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Technology by Deepali Mittal 153050016 under the guidance
More informationNEW HAVEN HARTFORD SPRINGFIELD RAIL PROGRAM
NEW HAVEN HARTFORD SPRINGFIELD RAIL PROGRAM Hartford Rail Alternatives Analysis www.nhhsrail.com What Is This Study About? The Connecticut Department of Transportation (CTDOT) conducted an Alternatives
More informationModels for performance benchmarking: measuring the eect of e-business activities on banking performance
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com Omega 32 (24) 313 322 www.elsevier.com/locate/dsw Models for performance benchmarking: measuring the eect of e-business activities on banking performance Wade
More informationEnvironmental Envelope Control
Environmental Envelope Control May 26 th, 2014 Stanford University Mechanical Engineering Dept. Dynamic Design Lab Stephen Erlien Avinash Balachandran J. Christian Gerdes Motivation New technologies are
More informationNETSSWorks Software: An Extended AC Optimal Power Flow (AC XOPF) For Managing Available System Resources
NETSSWorks Software: An Extended AC Optimal Power Flow (AC XOPF) For Managing Available System Resources Marija Ilic milic@netssinc.com and Jeffrey Lang jeffrey.lang@netssinc.com Principal NETSS Consultants
More informationDevelopment of a High Efficiency Induction Motor and the Estimation of Energy Conservation Effect
PAPER Development of a High Efficiency Induction Motor and the Estimation of Energy Conservation Effect Minoru KONDO Drive Systems Laboratory, Minoru MIYABE Formerly Drive Systems Laboratory, Vehicle Control
More informationWritten Exam Public Transport + Answers
Faculty of Engineering Technology Written Exam Public Transport + Written Exam Public Transport (195421200-1A) Teacher van Zuilekom Course code 195421200 Date and time 7-11-2011, 8:45-12:15 Location OH116
More informationElectricity Technology in a Carbon-Constrained Future
Electricity Technology in a Carbon-Constrained Future March 15, 2007 PacifiCorp Climate Working Group Bryan Hannegan Vice President - Environment EPRI Role Basic Research and Development Collaborative
More informationGraphically Characterizing the Equilibrium of the Neoclassical Model
Graphically Characterizing the Equilibrium of the Neoclassical Model ECON 30020: Intermediate Macroeconomics Prof. Eric Sims University of Notre Dame Spring 2018 1 / 28 Readings GLS Ch. 15 GLS Ch. 16 For
More informationEuropean Tyre and Rim Technical Organisation RETREADED TYRES IMPACT OF CASING AND RETREADING PROCESS ON RETREADED TYRES LABELLED PERFORMANCES
European Tyre and Rim Technical Organisation RETREADED TYRES IMPACT OF CASING AND RETREADING PROCESS ON RETREADED TYRES LABELLED PERFORMANCES Content 1. Executive summary... 4 2. Retreaded tyres: reminder
More informationTransmission Error in Screw Compressor Rotors
Purdue University Purdue e-pubs International Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 2008 Transmission Error in Screw Compressor Rotors Jack Sauls Trane Follow this and additional
More informationDIgSILENT Pacific PowerFactory Technical Seminar
DIgSILENT Pacific PowerFactory Technical Seminar Topic: The Wonders of Optimal Power Flow Presenter: Wayne Ong Venue: Sydney Novotel Central / Brisbane Marriott Hotel Date: 16 th and 30 th November 2017
More informationEconomics Major: Business Economics (Last Revised 03/2019)
Economics Major: Business Economics (Last Revised 03/2019) Required Business Core (39 hours) ECON 1041 Principles of Macroeconomics 3 hrs. ECON 1051 Principles of Microeconomics (ECON 1041) 3 hrs. ECON
More informationSmart Grid 2.0: Moving Beyond Smart Meters
Smart Grid 2.0: Moving Beyond Smart Meters Clean Energy Speaker Series State of the Smart Grid February 23, 2011 Prof. Deepak Divan Associate Director, Strategic Energy Institute Director, Intelligent
More informationConsumer Choice Modeling
Consumer Choice Modeling David S. Bunch Graduate School of Management, UC Davis with Sonia Yeh, Chris Yang, Kalai Ramea (ITS Davis) 1 Motivation for Focusing on Consumer Choice Modeling Ongoing general
More informationA Framework for Quantitative Analysis of Government Policy Influence on Electric Vehicle Market
Manuscript for 2015 International Conference on Engineering Design A Framework for Quantitative Analysis of Government Policy Influence on Electric Vehicle Market Namwoo Kang Manos Emmanoulopoulos Yi Ren
More informationAddressing the API Licensing Fear Factor
Addressing the API Licensing Fear Factor Overview There are motor oil consumers who have a fear of using non-api certified motor oils, i.e. motor oils that do not have the API donut certification. The
More informationTechnical Papers supporting SAP 2009
Technical Papers supporting SAP 29 A meta-analysis of boiler test efficiencies to compare independent and manufacturers results Reference no. STP9/B5 Date last amended 25 March 29 Date originated 6 October
More informationResults Report Shopping Center Energy Intensity Benchmarking Study
Results Report Shopping Center Energy Intensity Benchmarking Study Prepared for: The International Council of Shopping Centers 12221 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10020 Summer 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS
More informationThe Renewable Energy Market Investment Opportunities In Lithium. Prepared by: MAC Energy Research
The Renewable Energy Market Investment Opportunities In Lithium Prepared by: MAC Energy Research 2016 Table of Contents: Introduction. Page 2 What is Lithium?... Page 2 Global Lithium Demand Page 3 Energy
More informationQ Analyst Teleconference. 9 August 2018
9 August 218 Disclaimer This presentation contains forward-looking statements that reflect the Company management s current views with respect to certain future events. Although it is believed that the
More informationA REPORT ON THE STATISTICAL CHARACTERISTICS of the Highlands Ability Battery CD
A REPORT ON THE STATISTICAL CHARACTERISTICS of the Highlands Ability Battery CD Prepared by F. Jay Breyer Jonathan Katz Michael Duran November 21, 2002 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction... 1 Data Determination
More informationUPDATE OF THE SURVEY OF SULFUR LEVELS IN COMMERCIAL JET FUEL. Final Report. November 2012
CRC Project AV-1-10 UPDATE OF THE SURVEY OF SULFUR LEVELS IN COMMERCIAL JET FUEL Final Report November 2012 COORDINATING RESEARCH COUNCIL, INC. 3650 MANSELL ROAD SUITE 140 ALPHARETTA, GA 30022 The Coordinating
More informationScheduling. Purpose of scheduling. Scheduling. Scheduling. Concurrent & Distributed Systems Purpose of scheduling.
427 Concurrent & Distributed Systems 2017 6 Uwe R. Zimmer - The Australian National University 429 Motivation and definition of terms Purpose of scheduling 2017 Uwe R. Zimmer, The Australian National University
More informationEFFECT OF TRUCK PAYLOAD WEIGHT ON PRODUCTION
EFFECT OF TRUCK PAYLOAD WEIGHT ON PRODUCTION BY : Cliff Schexnayder Sandra L. Weber Brentwood T. Brook Source : Journal of Construction Engineering & Management / January/February 1999 Introduction : IDEAS
More information