S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N BEFORE THE MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION * * * * *

Transcription

1 S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N BEFORE THE MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION * * * * * In the matter of the application of CONSUMERS ) ENERGY COMPANY for authority to increase its ) rates for the generation and distribution of ) Case No. U electricity and for other relief. ) ) E R R A T A Due to an error, the Commission s March 29, 2018 order in Case No. U included an incorrect rate design summary in Attachment A and certain incorrect tariff sheets in Attachment B. The corrected rate design summary and tariff sheets are attached hereto. MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION June 11, 2018 Lansing, Michigan Kavita Kale Its Executive Secretary

2 Schedule F-2 ATTACHMENT A Consumers Energy Company Page 1 of 3 Summary of Present and Proposed Revenues by Rate Schedule Total Revenues ( a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) ( e ) Line Present Proposed Difference No. Description Sales Revenue Revenue Revenue Percent MWh $000 $000 $000 % Bundled Service Residential Class 1 Residential Service RS 12,053,207 $ 1,885,690 $ 1,930,027 $ 44, Residential Time-of-Day RT 55,778 7,508 7, Residential Electric Vehicle REV 10,001 1,448 1, Res. Dynamic Price RSDP NA 5 Res. Dynamic Price Rebate RSDPR NA 6 Total Residential Class 12,118,986 1,894,646 1,939,279 44, Secondary Class 7 Secondary Energy-only GS 3,602, , ,333 7, Sec. Energy Dynamic Price GSDP NA 9 Secondary Demand GSD 3,551, , ,112 28, Secondary Energy-only GS TOU NA 11 Total Secondary Class 7,153,720 1,001,175 1,037,444 36, Primary Class 12 Primary Energy-only GP 1,356, , ,610 3, Primary Demand GPD 11,497, , ,065 (17,367) (1.8) Standard Service 10,376, , ,850 (13,145) (1.6) Voltage Level 1 4,255, , ,933 (8,771) (3.0) Voltage Level 2 1,692, , ,272 (9,087) (5.8) Voltage Level 3 4,428, , ,646 4, Education GEI 346,427 37,822 37,560 (262) (0.7) Interruptible GI 774,700 83,614 79,654 (3,960) (4.7) 14 Primary Energy Intensive Rate EIP 255,121 16,719 16,277 (442) (2.6) 15 Primary Time of Use Pilot GPTU 303,937 29,609 29,093 (516) (1.7) 16 Total Primary Class 13,412,943 1,171,503 1,157,044 (14,459) (1.2) Lighting & Unmetered Class 17 Metered Lighting Service GML 18,204 2,024 2, Unmetered Lighting Service GUL 123,389 29,750 31,529 1, Unmetered Exp. Lighting GU-XL ,418 1,416 NA 20 Unmetered Service GU 85,150 7,729 7, Total Lighting & Unmetered Class 226,757 39,504 43,084 3, Self-generation Class 22 Small Self-generation GSG-1 27, NA 23 Large Self-generation GSG-2 33,144 5,047 1,772 (3,275) NA 24 Total Self-Generation Class 60,624 5,047 1,772 (3,275) NA 25 Total Bundled Service 32,973,030 $ 4,111,875 $ 4,178,624 $ 66, ROA Service Residential Class 26 Residential Service RS - $ - $ - $ - NA 27 Residential Time-of-Day RT NA 28 Total Residential Class NA Secondary Class 29 Secondary Energy-only GS 23,636 1,015 1, Secondary Demand GSD 213,651 6,998 8,082 1, Standard Service 146,896 4,777 5, Education GEI 66,756 2,222 2, Total Secondary Class 237,287 8,014 9,108 1, Primary Class 32 Primary Energy-only GP 67,215 1,315 1,173 (142) (10.8) 33 Primary Demand GPD 3,855,694 24,325 21,058 (3,268) (13.4) Standard Service 3,613,285 20,980 18,176 (2,804) (13.4) Voltage Level 1 1,177,791 2,316 1,947 (369) (15.9) Voltage Level 2 1,412,217 5,771 5,149 (623) (10.8) Voltage Level 3 1,023,277 12,893 11,080 (1,813) (14.1) Education GEI 242,408 3,345 2,882 (463) (13.9) Voltage Level 1 2, (2) (14.1) Voltage Level 2 78, (51) (13.0) Voltage Level 3 160,930 2,932 2,523 (410) (14.0) 34 Total Primary Class 3,922,909 25,640 22,231 (3,410) (13.3) 35 Total ROA Service 4,160,196 $ 33,654 $ 31,339 $ (2,315) (6.9) 36 Total Bundled and ROA Service 37,133,226 $ 4,145,529 $ 4,209,962 $ 64,

3 ATTACHMENT A Consumers Energy Company Page 3 of 3 Summary of Present and Proposed Revenues by Rate Schedule Delivery Revenues ( a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) ( e ) Line Present Proposed Difference No. Description Sales Revenue Revenue Revenue Percent MWh $000 $000 $000 % Bundled Service Residential Class 1 Residential Service RS 12,053,207 $ 682,210 $ 719,047 $ 36, Residential Time-of-Day RT 55,778 2,777 2, Residential Electric Vehicle REV 10, Res. Dynamic Price RSDP NA 5 Res. Dynamic Price Rebate RSDPR NA 6 Total Residential Class 12,118,986 $ 685, ,565 37, Secondary Class 7 Secondary Energy-only GS 3,602, , ,580 1, Sec. Energy Dynamic Price GSDP NA 9 Secondary Demand GSD 3,551, , ,172 18, Sec. Demand Dynamic Price GSDDP NA 11 Total Secondary Class 7,153, , ,752 19, Primary Class 12 Primary Energy-only GP 1,356,398 27,615 24,764 (2,852) (10.3) 13 Primary Demand GPD 11,497,488 83,963 72,474 (11,488) (13.7) Standard Service 10,376,360 68,304 58,943 (9,361) (13.7) Voltage Level 1 4,255,429 7,108 5,960 (1,148) (16.1) Voltage Level 2 1,692,063 9,054 8,055 (999) (11.0) Voltage Level 3 4,428,869 52,142 44,927 (7,215) (13.8) Education GEI 346,427 5,241 4,532 (709) (13.5) Interruptible GI 774,700 10,418 9,000 (1,418) (13.6) 14 Primary Energy Intensive Rate EIP 255,121 2,066 1,765 (301) (14.6) 15 Primary Time of Use Pilot GPTU 303,937 4,131 3,551 (580) (14.0) 16 Total Primary Class 13,412, , ,554 (15,221) (12.9) Lighting & Unmetered Class 17 Metered Lighting Service GML 18,204 1,042 1, Unmetered Lighting Service GUL 123,389 23,264 25,910 2, Unmetered Exp. Lighting GU-XL ,145 1,144 85, Unmetered Service GU 85,150 1,286 1, Total Lighting & Unmetered Class 226,757 25,593 29,720 4, Self-generation Class 22 Small Self-generation GSG NA 23 Large Self-generation GSG-2 33,144 2,065 1,772 (293) (14.2) 24 Total Self-Generation Class 33,144 2,065 1,772 (293) (14.2) 25 Total Bundled Service 32,945,549 $ 1,155,099 $ 1,200,363 $ 45, ROA Service Residential Class 26 Residential Service RS - $ - $ - $ - NA 27 Residential Time-of-Day RT NA 28 Total Residential Class NA Secondary Class 29 Secondary Energy-only GS 23,636 1,015 1, Secondary Demand GSD 213,651 6,998 8,082 1, Standard Service 146,896 4,777 5, Education GEI 66,756 2,222 2, Total Secondary Class 237,287 8,014 9,108 1, Primary Class 32 Primary Energy-only GP 67,215 1,315 1,173 (142) (10.8) 33 Primary Demand GPD 3,855,694 24,325 21,058 (3,268) (13.4) Standard Service 3,613,285 20,980 18,176 (2,804) (13.4) Voltage Level 1 1,177,791 2,316 1,947 (369) (15.9) Voltage Level 2 1,412,217 5,771 5,149 (623) (10.8) Voltage Level 3 1,023,277 12,893 11,080 (1,813) (14.1) Education GEI 242,408 3,345 2,882 (463) (13.9) Voltage Level 1 2, (2) (14.1) Voltage Level 2 78, (51) (13.0) Voltage Level 3 160,930 2,932 2,523 (410) (14.0) 34 Total Primary Class 3,922,909 25,640 22,231 (3,410) (13.3) 35 Total ROA Service 4,160,196 $ 33,654 $ 31,339 $ (2,315) (6.9) 36 Total Bundled and ROA Service 37,105,745 $ 1,188,753 $ 1,231,702 $ 42,

4 Page 40 of 64 ATTACHMENT B M.P.S.C. No Electric Consumers Energy Company Sheet No. D LARGE GENERAL SERVICE PRIMARY DEMAND RATE GPD (Continued From Sheet No. D-31.00) Monthly Rate: (Contd) Power Supply Charges: These charges are applicable to Full Service customers. (Contd) Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL1) Demand Charges: Capacity Non-Capacity Transmission Total per kw of On-Peak Billing Demand during the billing $10.52 $7.86 $1.86 $20.24 months of June-September Capacity Non-Capacity Transmission Total per kw of On-Peak Billing Demand during the billing $9.52 $7.86 $1.86 $19.24 months of October-May Energy Charges: Non-Capacity $ per kwh for all On-Peak kwh during the billing months of June-September $ per kwh for all Off-Peak kwh during the billing months of June-September $ per kwh for all On-Peak kwh during the billing months of October-May $ per kwh for all Off-Peak kwh during the billing months of October-May This rate is subject to the Power Supply Cost Recovery (PSCR) Factor shown on Sheet No. D Delivery Charges: These charges are applicable to Full Service and Retail Open Access (ROA) customers. System Access Charge: $ per customer per month Charges for Customer Voltage Level 3 (CVL3) Capacity Charge: $ 4.19 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL2) Capacity Charge: $ 1.85 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL1) Capacity Charge: $ 0.96 per kw of Maximum Demand This rate is subject to the Surcharges shown on Sheet Nos. D-2.00 through D-3.10 and the Securitization Charges shown on Sheet Nos. D-5.00 and D-5.10 Adjustment for Power Factor: This rate requires a determination of the average Power Factor maintained by the customer during the billing period. Such average Power Factor shall be determined through metering of lagging Kilovar-hours and Kilowatt-hours during the billing period. The calculated ratio of lagging Kilovar-hours to Kilowatt-hours shall then be converted to the average Power Factor for the billing period by using the appropriate conversion factor. Whenever the average Power Factor during the billing period is above.899 or below.850, the customer bill shall be adjusted as follows: (a) (b) If the average Power Factor during the billing period is.900 or higher, a 0.50% credit will be applied to all metered-based charges, excluding surcharges. This credit shall not in any case be used to reduce the prescribed Minimum Charge. If the average Power Factor during the billing period is less than.850, a penalty will be applied to all metered-based charges, excluding surcharges, in accordance with the following table: Power Factor Penalty to % to % to % Below % first 2 months Adjustment for Power Factor shall not be applied when the On-Peak Billing Demand is based on 60% of the highest On-Peak Billing Demand created during the preceding bill months of June through September or on a Minimum On-Peak Billing Demand. (c) A Power Factor less than is not permitted and necessary corrective equipment must be installed by the customer. A 15% penalty will be applied to any metered-based charges, excluding surcharges, after two consecutive months below Power Factor and will continue as long as the Power Factor remains below Once the customer's Power Factor exceeds 0.700, it is necessary to complete two consecutive months below before the 15% penalty applies again. (Continued on Sheet No. D-32.00)

5 Page 47 of 64 ATTACHMENT B M.P.S.C. No Electric Consumers Energy Company Sheet No. D Monthly Rate: GENERAL SERVICE PRIMARY TIME-OF-USE RATE GPTU (Continued from Sheet No. D-36.10) Power Supply Charges: Charges for Customer Voltage Level 3 (CVL3) Energy Charge: Non-Capacity Capacity Total Off-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Low-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Mid-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September High-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Off-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Mid-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May High-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL2) Energy Charge: Non-Capacity Capacity Total Off-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Low-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Mid-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September High-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Off-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Mid-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May High-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL1) Energy Charge: Non-Capacity Capacity Total Off-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Low-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Mid-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September High-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Off-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Mid-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May High-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October-May Delivery Charges: System Access Charge: $ per customer per month Charges for Customer Voltage Level 3 (CVL3) Capacity Charge: $4.19 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL2) Capacity Charge: $1.85 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL1) Capacity Charge: $0.96 per kw of Maximum Demand Adjustment for Power Factor This rate requires a determination of the average Power Factor maintained by the customer during the billing period. Such average Power Factor shall be determined through metering of lagging Kilovar-hours and Kilowatt-hours during the billing period. The calculated ratio of lagging Kilovar-hours to Kilowatt-hours shall then be converted to the average Power Factor for the billing period by using the appropriate conversion factor. Whenever the average Power Factor during the billing period is above.899 or below.850, the customer bill shall be adjusted as follows: (Continued on Sheet No. D-36.30)

6 Page 51 of 64 ATTACHMENT B M.P.S.C. No Electric Consumers Energy Company Sheet No. D Monthly Rate (Contd): Power Supply Charges: (Contd) Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL2) Energy Charge: ENERGY INTENSIVE PRIMARY RATE EIP (Continued from Sheet No. D-37.10) Non-Capacity Capacity Total Off-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Low-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Mid-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September High-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Critical Peak-Summer the greater of either 150% of the High-Peak-Summer Energy Charge or the average Market price per kwh for a Critical Peak Event during the calendar months of June-September Off-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May Mid-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May High-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May Critical Peak-Winter the greater of either 150% of the High-Peak Winter Energy Charge or the average Market price per kwh for a Critical Peak Event during the calendar months of October - May Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1(CVL1) Energy Charge: Non-Capacity Capacity Total Off-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Low-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Mid-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September High-Peak-Summer $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of June-September Critical Peak-Summer Critical Peak-Summer Off-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May Mid-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May High-Peak - Winter $ $ $ per kwh during the calendar months of October - May Critical Peak-Winter the greater of either 150% of the High-Peak Winter Energy Charge or the average Market price per kwh for a Critical Peak Event during the calendar months of October - May Delivery Charges: System Access Charge: $ per customer per month Charges for Customer Voltage Level 3 (CVL3) Capacity Charge: $4.19 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL2) Capacity Charge: $1.85 per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL1) Capacity Charge: $0.96 per kw of Maximum Demand This rate is subject to the Surcharges shown on Sheet Nos. D-2.00 through D-3.10 and the Securitization Charges shown on Sheet Nos. D-5.00 and D-5.10 (Continued on Sheet No. D-37.30)

7 Page 53 of 64 ATTACHMENT B M.P.S.C. No Electric Consumers Energy Company Sheet No. D GENERAL SERVICE SELF GENERATION RATE GSG-2 (Continued From Sheet No. D-42.00) Nature of Service (Contd) Where service is supplied at a nominal voltage equal to or greater than 2,400 volts and the Company elects to measure the service at a nominal voltage above 25,000 volts, 1% shall be deducted for billing purposes, from the demand and energy measurements thus made. Where service is supplied at a nominal voltage equal to or greater than 2,400 volts and the Company elects to measure the service at a nominal voltage of less than 2,400 volts, 3% shall be added for billing purposes, to the demand and energy measurements thus made. Where service is supplied at a nominal voltage less than 2,400 volts and the Company elects to measure the service at a nominal voltage equal to or greater than 2,400 volts, 3% shall be deducted for billing purposes from the energy measurements thus made. There shall be no double billing of demand under the base rate and Rate GSG-2. Monthly Rate Standby Charges Power Supply Standby Charges For all standby energy supplied by the Company, the customer shall be responsible for the MISO Real-Time Locational Market Price (LMP) for the Company's load node (designated as "CONS.CETR" as of the date of this Rate Schedule), multiplied by the customer s consumption (kwh), plus the Market Settlement Fee of $0.002/kWh. In addition capacity charges will be assessed monthly, calculated using the highest 15 minute kw demand associated with Standby Service occurring during the Company's On-Peak billing hours will be multiplied by the highest contracted capacity purchased by the Company in that month, plus allocated transmission and ancillaries. The capacity charges will be prorated based on the number of On-Peak days that Standby Service was used during the billing month. A customer with a generator(s) nameplate rating more than 550 kw must provide written notice to the Company by December 1 if they desire standby service in the succeeding calendar months of June through September. Written notice shall be submitted on Company Form 500. If the customer fails to meet this written notice requirement, the LMP shall be increased by applying a 10% adder. Delivery Standby Charges System Access Charge: Generator that does not meet or exceed load: $ per generator installation per month Generator that meets or exceeds load: $ per generator installation per month Charges for Customer Voltage Level 3 (CVL 3) Capacity Charge: $4.19 per kw of Standby Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL 2) Capacity Charge: $1.85 per kw of Standby Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL 1) Capacity Charge: $0.96 per kw of Standby Demand This rate is subject to the Surcharges shown on Sheet Nos. D-2.00 through D-3.10 and the Securitization Charges shown on Sheet Nos. D-5.00 and D (Continued on Sheet No. D-44.00)

8 Page 54 of 64 ATTACHMENT B M.P.S.C. No Electric Consumers Energy Company Sheet No. D GENERAL SERVICE SELF GENERATION RATE GSG-2 (Continued From Sheet No. D-43.00) Monthly Rate (Contd) Standby Charges (Contd) Adjustment for Power Factor This rate requires a determination of the average Power Factor maintained by the customer during the billing period. Such average Power Factor shall be determined through metering of lagging Kilovar -hours and Kilowatt-hours during the billing period. The calculated ratio of lagging Kilovar-hours to Kilowatt-hours shall then be converted to the average Power Factor for the billing period by using the appropriate conversion factor. Whenever the average Power Factor during the billing period is above.899 or below.850, the customer bill shall be adjusted as follows: (a) If the average Power Factor during the billing period is.900 or higher, a 0.50% credit will be applied to all meteredbased charges, excluding surcharges. This credit shall not in any case be used to reduce the prescribed Minimum Charge. (b) If the average Power Factor during the billing period is less than.850, a penalty will be applied to all metered-based charges, excluding surcharges, in accordance with the following table: Power Factor Penalty to % to % to % Below % first 2 months (c) A Power Factor less than is not permitted and necessary corrective equipment must be installed by the customer. A 15% penalty will be applied to any metered-based charges, excluding surcharges, after two consecutive months below Power Factor and will continue as long as the Power Factor remains below Once the customer's Power Factor exceeds 0.700, it is necessary to complete two consecutive months below before the 15%penalty applies again. Substation Ownership Credit Where service is supplied at a nominal voltage of more than 25,000 volts, energy is measured through an Interval Data Meter, and the customer provides all of the necessary transforming, controlling and protective equipment for all of the service there shall be deducted from the bill a monthly credit. For those customers, part of whose load is served through customer-owned equipment, the credit shall be based on the billed Standby Demand. The monthly credit for the substation ownership shall be applied as follows: Delivery Charges Charges for Customer Voltage Level 2 (CVL 2) Substation Ownership Credit: $(0.65) per kw of Maximum Demand Charges for Customer Voltage Level 1 (CVL 1) Substation Ownership Credit: $(0.38) per kw of Maximum Demand For those customers served by more than one substation where one or more of the substations is owned by the customer, the credit will be applied to the customer's coincident Maximum Demand for those substations owned by the customer. This credit shall not operate to reduce the customer s billing below the prescribed minimum charges included in the rate. The credit shall be based on the kw after the 1% deduction or 3% addition has been applied to the metered kw. Transmission Interconnect Credit Where standby service is provided to a non-utility electric generator located within the Company's service territory and taking power through its transmission interconnect, where the Company has no owned infrastructure other than metering, including billing grade current transformers and potential transformers, telemetry facilities and associated wiring, the following monthly credit shall be applied to the bill: Delivery Charges Transmission Interconnect Credit: $(0.96) per kw of Standby Demand This credit shall be based on the kw after the 1% deduction has been applied to the metered kw. The credit supersedes any applicable substation ownership credit. (Continued on Sheet No. D-45.00)

9 P R O O F O F S E R V I C E STATE OF MICHIGAN ) Case No. U County of Ingham ) Lisa Felice being duly sworn, deposes and says that on June 11, 2018 A.D. she electronically notified the attached list of this Errata via transmission, to the persons as shown on the attached service list (Listserv Distribution List). Subscribed and sworn to before me this 11th day of June 2018 Lisa Felice Angela P. Sanderson Notary Public, Shiawassee County, Michigan As acting in Eaton County My Commission Expires: May 21, 2024

10 Service List for Case: U Name Address Amit T. Singh Anne Uitvlugt Bret A. Totoraitis Brian W. Coyer Bryan A. Brandenburg Celeste R. Gill Christopher M. Bzdok Consumers Energy Company 1 of 2 mpsc.filings@cmsenergy.com Consumers Energy Company 2 of 2 matorrey@cmsenergy.com Don L. Keskey donkeskey@publiclawresourcecenter.com Gary A. Gensch Jr. gary.genschjr@cmsenergy.com H. Richard Chambers hrchambers@cmsenergy.com Jason T. Hanselman jhanselman@dykema.com Jennifer U. Heston jheston@fraserlawfirm.com Jody Kyler Cohn jkylercohn@bkllawfirm.com Joel King kingj38@michigan.gov John R. Canzano jcanzano@michworkerlaw.com John R. Liskey john@liskeypllc.com Kelly M. Hall kelly.hall@cmsenergy.com Kurt J. Boehm kboehm@bkllawfirm.com Laura A. Chappelle lachappelle@varnumlaw.com Lauren D. Donofrio donofriol@michigan.gov Margrethe Kearney mkearney@elpc.org Melissa M. Horne mhorne@hcc-law.com Michael C. Soules msoules@earthjustice.org Michael J. Pattwell mpattwell@clarkhill.com Michael S. Ashton mashton@fraserlawfirm.com Michael Torrey matorrey@cmsenergy.com Monica M. Stephens stephensm11@michigan.gov Patricia F. Sharkey psharkey@e-lawcounsel.com Patrick J. Rorai prorai@michworkerlaw.com Richard J. Aaron raaron@dykema.com Robert W. Beach robert.beach@cmsenergy.com Sean P. Gallagher sgallagher@clarkhill.com Shannon Fisk sfisk@earthjustice.org Sharon Feldman feldmans@michigan.gov Spencer A. Sattler sattlers@michigan.gov Theresa A.G. Staley theresa.staley@cmsenergy.com Tim Lundgren tjlundgren@varnumlaw.com Toni L. Newell tlnewell@varnumlaw.com Tracy Jane Andrews tjandrews@envlaw.com

11