European Conference on Nanoelectronics and Embedded Systems for Electric Mobility emobility emotion 25-26 th September 2013, Toulouse, France 6-phase Fault-Tolerant Permanent Magnet Traction Drive for Electric Vehicles Chris Gould, University of Sheffield Vipulkumar Patel Jiabin Wang Dian Nugraha Radovan Vuletic Jonas Tousen Jan Klenner
High Power Motor Role of partners in supply chain IGBT 650V 22 kw 22 kw 320 V 320 V 41 kw 320 V IFAG USFD VW 6~ Gear ratio (8-10) 41 kw Multi-phase inverter with independent control Fault tolerant multiphase motor having wide speed range with high efficiency Specifications and Workbench tests
Key challenges for EV traction A B D A. Starting torque at low speed B. Acceleration C. Efficiency D. Speed range E. Power density F. Torque ripple G. Reliability & fault tolerance H. Flexibility of control
Drive train & design specifications Motor 41 kw Inverter 1 Inverter 2 32 kw Battery 2800 11000 Power train drive for segment A vehicle Nominal DC link voltage Maximum line-line voltage Cooling medium 320 V 650 V Water
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase electric motor Novel 6-phase, 18-slot, 8-pole winding configuration Improvement of safety and availability by designing the machine topology as two independent balanced 3-phase systems in single stator Fault tolerant as vehicle will continue to run with 50% power/torque output even with loss of one 3-phase system Lower torque ripple & cogging torque Lower eddy current losses in rotor PMs Lower copper losses due to shorter end-windings
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Development of winding configuration B- B- B+ B+ 6 B+ C- 5 B 7 B- A+ 4 8 C C+ C+ 3 9 A- A A- 2 1 C- C- A+ A+ A- C+ 3-phase, 9-slot, 8-/10-pole winding B+ A- B+ A- 8 7 F- 6 D+ 9 F 5 F+ E- 10 B 4 B- B- 11 1 A 3 A+ A+ 1 D- D- D- 12 D 2 E+ E+ B+ 13 E 1 C- A- 14 C 18 C+ C 15 16 17 D+ E- + D+ F+ F+ C+ C + C+ C + A+ B- E+ D- F- F- C- C- E- 6-phase, 18-slot, 8-/10-pole winding
MMF (pu) Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Normalized MMF space harmonics distribution 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 9-slot, 8-pole 18-slot, 8-pole 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 Order of harmonic The novel winding configuration eliminates many harmonics, which leads to lower eddy current loss in PM and lower torque ripple in a machine.
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Design Constraints for EV traction motor with PMs Type of constraints Volumetric Electromagnetic Thermal Design parameter Constraints Stator outer radius mm 75.00 Stack length of the motor mm 150.00 Mass of PM material kg 1.2 Maximum flux linkage (derived from maximum line-to-line voltage) mwb 74.7 Inductance (to achieve peak torque) mh > 0.256 Inductance (to achieve high efficiency in field weakening region) mh 0.721 Copper winding temperature C 180 Steel lamination temperature C 225 PM temperature C 150
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Design optimized against specifications, mechanical and thermal constraints for maximum efficiency over NEDC Cross-section of optimized design MAGWID/2 LM IPMHQ Conceptual design 1.1 kg PM material 94.4% energy efficiency over NEDC Optimized design 0.9 kg PM material 94.9% energy efficiency over NEDC
Torque, Nm Torque (Nm) Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Performance of the optimized design at rated & peak torque Rated Torque Peak Torque Torque Nm 75 140 Torque ripple % 2.5 4.2 Speed rpm 2800 2800 Peak current A 74.0 172.5 Current density A/mm 2 9.7 22.7 Copper loss W 809 4394 Iron loss W 181 273 PM eddy current loss W 8 56 Efficiency % 95.7 89.7 NEDC energy efficiency % 94.9 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 150 140 130 120 110 100 90 80 70 60 Rated torque Peak torque 50 0 60 120 180 240 300 360 Rotor angle (elect. deg) 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 Speed, rpm 0.96 0.94 0.92 0.9 0.88 0.86 0.84 0.82 0.8
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Prototype motor & inverter Rotor assembly Laminations Stator frame Stator assembly Motor assembly Inverter with instrumentation
Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Test bench for direct measurement of efficiency at USFD
Back EMF (V) Efficiency (%) Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Comparison of prediction and test results at USFD 100 98 80 60 40 20 0-20 -40 FEA Ph A FEA Ph B FEA Ph C Test Ph A Test Ph B Test Ph C 97 96 95 94 93 92 Measured Predicted -60 91-80 90-100 0 60 120 180 240 300 360 Rotor Angle (deg, electrical) Back EMF at 2800 rpm 89 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Torque (Nm) Efficiency at 2800 rpm The measured back EMF matches very well with the finite element analysis predictions with a difference being just 2.7%. The efficiency at the base speed of 2800 rpm matches closely with the prediction.
Torque (Nm) Torque (Nm) Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Measured efficiency map of inverter & motor with 320V at VW Speed (rpm) Efficiency map of 6-phase inverter Speed (rpm) Efficiency map of 6-phase motor Both the inverter and the motor exhibits high efficiency over the wide speed range.
Torque (Nm) Novel fault-tolerant 6-phase motor Measured efficiency map of power drive train at VW Speed (rpm) The novel fault-tolerant motor-inverter drive system has a high efficiency over wide speed range.
Conclusions Novel 6-phase motor is designed and developed to enhance safety and availability of power train drive. The motor is inherently fault tolerant. Loss of one 3-phase system does not result into complete loss of traction power. The new motor configuration exhibits high efficiency over a wide speed range, which is one of the key requirement for EV traction. Series of experimental measurements on a prototype motor and inverter have validated the novel fault-tolerant motor.