Global Biofuel Production and Food Security: Implications for Asia Pacific William T. Coyle 11 PECC Agricultural and Food Policy Forum: Moving Beyond Market Volatility to Foster Food Security Organized by CTPECC December 1-, 11
Outlook for Biofuels Background How important are biofuels? What is the outlook for biofuels? Impacts on food prices, volatility, and the food system? What others have said Current evidence Impacts on Asia-Pacific
Background Production Concentrated in Three Markets, 1 Ethanol = 8.9 billion litres US Brazil Europe Account for 89% of global biofuel production US 54.3% Brazil 33.3% Other 6.8% Europe 5.5% Biodiesel = 19.9 billion litres Europe 47% Other 8% Brazil 1% US 15%
Background Non-US PECC Minor Player, 1 6 Billion liters 5 4 3 Ethanol Biodiesel 1 US Brazil EU Non-US PECC Source: USDA, Renewable Fuel Association, National Biodiesel Board
Background With China and Canada in the Lead, 1 3. Billion liters.5. 1.5 1..5 Ethanol Biodiesel. Source: USDA, FO Licht
How important are biofuels?
How important are biofuels? Five-fold Expansion in Production
How important are biofuels? Expanding Much More Rapidly Than Oil 6 Annual % Growth ( = 1) 4 Biofuel production, 1.8 mil barrels/day Oil production, 8.1 million barrels/day 199 1995 5 1 Sources: FO Licht, BP
How important are biofuels? Biofuels Remaining a Miniscule Share of Global Transportation Fuel, 1 * * *--Converted to fossil fuel equivalent Sources: BP, Renewable Fuels Association, National Biodiesel Board
How important are biofuels? Now a Major User of U.S. Corn 18 Million tons 16 14 1 1 8 6 Feed Ethanol Exports 4 196 1965 197 1975 198 1985 199 1995 5 1 Source: USDA
How important are biofuels? A Contributor to Spiking Grain Prices? 3 1 = 1 5 Wheat Corn 15 1 5 Rice 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 Source: World Bank
How important are biofuels? Corn and Sugar Prices Out of Step? 1 = 1 5 15 Corn 1 5 Sugar 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 Source: World Bank
How important are biofuels? Sizable Land Requirements for Leading Producers Biofuel % of arable acres in (except for Brazil, which refers only to 8) Source: FAO
How important are biofuels? But Small Relative to World Grain Area Source: John Baffes and Tassos Haniotis. Placing the 6/8 Commodity Price Boom into Perspective. World Bank. July 1.
What s the outlook for biofuels?
Positive Outlook Factor #1 A New Era of High Oil Prices 1 $ per barrel 8 6 Iranian revolution in 1979 and the Iran-Iraq war in 198 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in the summer of 199 4 Asia financial crisis, 1997-99 Global financial collapse, September 8 Yom Kippur war followed by Arab embargo, October 1973 September 11, 1 terrorist attacks and global economic slowdown 197 1971 197 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 198 1981 198 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 199 1991 199 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 Source: Federal Reserve of St. Louis; West Texas Intermediate crude deflated using Producer Price Index for all commodities
Positive Outlook Factor # Supportive Public Policy in US
Positive Outlook Factor # Supportive Public Policy in the EU EU Renewable Energy Directive (RED) The EU Council and Parliament agreed in May 9 as part of the Climate Change & Energy Package to --Cut GHG emissions by % by, --Improve energy efficiency by %, and --Achieve a % share for renewable energy in total energy consumption by. Especially relevant to biofuel use, the RED sets a mandatory goal for each nation to use at least 1% renewable energy in transportation by.
Positive Outlook Factor # Supportive Public Policy in Brazil Million barrels produced per day Ethanol share of total liquid fuel production (%).5 35 Oil production. 3 5 1.5 Ethanol s share of liquid fuel (%) 1..5. Ethanol production 1975 1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 1 3 5 7 9 11 15 1 5 Source: BP
Positive Outlook Factor #3 Biofuel Not a Radical Alternative as an Additive RISK: Oil vs. Hydrogen vs. Ethanol Oil Hydrogen Biofuels Energy Security Risk High Low Low Cost per Mile High? Low Infrastructure Cost Low Very High Low Technology Risk Very Low Very High Low Environmental Cost Very High? Low Implementation Risk Very Low Very High Low Interest Group Opposition Very High High Low Political Difficulty? High Low Time to Impact - Very high Low 1 Source: Vinod Khosla, A Near Term Energy Solution, (vk@khoslaventures.com).
Uncertainties and Challenges #1 Agricultural and Energy Prices More Correlated 3 = 1 5 15 Agricultural Commodities 1 Energy 5 1961 1963 1965 1967 1969 1971 1973 1975 1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 1 3 5 7 9 Source: World Bank
Uncertainties and Challenges #1 In the Specific Case of Ethanol and Corn 5 1 15 5 3 35 4 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 1 1 = 1 Corn Ethanol
Uncertainties and Challenges #1..Leading to Declining Profits 3 = 1 Ethanol/corn Ethanol/sugar 5 15 1 5 1 1
Uncertainties and Challenges # High Oil Prices Not Just Good for Biofuels 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 1 Cost of Production (7 $) Saudi Arabia Other Middle East First-generation ethanol Russian Federation China Libya Mexico Other South America, Europe, Eurasia, and Africa 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 UK North Sea Other North America Angola Deep Water US Gulf of Mexico Deep Water Brazil Deep Water Cumulative Oil Production (million barrels per day) Nigeria Deep Water Canada Oil Sands Other South and North America Cellulosic ethanol Source: http://www.theoildrum.com/files/murphyfig_1.png
Uncertainties and Challenges #3 The Promise of Next-Generation Biofuels Still big uncertainties but numerous companies in the game. Overpromising, under delivering??? Total global production is probably less than an average first generation biofuel plant.less than 1 million gallons Key hurdles: Reducing production and capital costs, Sustaining pre commercial financial support, Developing supply arrangements, and Overcoming technical constraints, such as the blend wall. Shift in focus among some companies to biofuels closer substitutes to fossil fuels.
Uncertainties and Challenges #3 The Promise of Next- Generation Biofuels Hydrolysis Sugars Fermentation Aqueous Phase Reforming Ethanol Biobutanol Petroleum substitutes Petroleum substitutes Fischer- Tropsch Diesel Jet Fuel Biomass Gasification Syngas Fermentation Ethanol Catalysis Ethanol Source: Virent Pyrolysis Bio-oils Refining Petroleum substitutes
Uncertainties and Challenges #3 Higher-Yielding Biomass Means Less Land Needed Gallons of biofuel per acre, 15 15 1,5 First generation Next generation 1, 5 Miscanthus Sugarcane+bagasse 95 Switchgrass 71 Sugarcane, Brazil Sugar beet, EU Ethanol feedstocks 556 43 Corn, US 18 Wheat, EU 59 Palm oil EU Rape oil 14 8 66 Sunflower oil Biodiesel feedstocks US Soy oil
Uncertainties and Challenges #4 Higher Yielding Biomass Reduces Environmental Impacts -18, US corn -35, EU sugar beets -3, EU rapeseed -47, EU wheat -7, US soybeans -9, Malaysian palm oil -91, Brazil sugarcane -88, US cellulosic -11, India jatropha Source: IMF, World Economic Outlook, Oct. 17, 7, table, "Costs and Benefits of Biofuel Prodution," p. 49; Net renewable energy creation relative to petroleum-based fuels: Defined as the new energy created relative to the energy input in the production, distribution, and retailing of biofuels. Measured relative to the new energy created in the production of the respective fossil fuel (measured in megajouls/megajouls)." Percent reduction in GHG emissions "Defined as the change in life cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions per kilometer traveled by replacing fossil fuels with biofuels in conventional vehicles. Life cycle means that the emissions are measured over the production cycle of the respective fuel."
Impacts on food prices, volatility, and the food system? The research Impacts on Asia-Pacific region Concluding points
What impacts on food prices, volatility, and the food system? The research: World Bank, Mitchell (7). The increase in internationally traded food prices from January to June 8 was caused by a confluence of factors, but the most important was the large increase in biofuels production from grains and oilseeds in the U.S. and EU..7-75 percent increase in food commodities prices was due to biofuels and the related consequences of low grain stocks, large land use shifts, speculative activity and export bans. World Bank, Baffes and Haniotis (July 1). In this paper, we examined three key factors (regarding the rise in commodity prices) whose role has been somewhat controversial: speculation, the growth of demand for food commodities by emerging economies and the role of biofuels.biofuels played some role too, but much less than initially thought. Farm Foundation (July 8). Biofuels have had a major impact on corn prices, but in recent years, most of those increases have been driven by oil. IFPRI, Headey and Fan (1)..a growing number of studies are finding that biofuels production has a large positive impact on food prices, but virtually no negative impact on energy prices. In the foreseeable future, biofuels production does not look good for global food security, unless ways can be found to minimize the diversion from food production or involve poor farmers in biofuels production.
Impacts on Asia-Pacific Since biofuel production is of fairly minor significance throughout most the Asia-Pacific region, with the exception of the United States, the effects are mostly indirect. These are the principal effects: The derived demand for converting biomass to fuel represents an added component of global demand for commodities used as biofuel feedstocks. Thus, to the extent that biofuel expansion raises prices of corn, sugar, and vegetable oils, it affects the cost structure of competing users or processors. For Asia-Pacific, the feed-livestock complex would be most affected. Asia-Pacific is a large user and net importer of feedstuffs and livestock products. Production of byproduct Distilled Food price increases have their greatest impact on the urban poor who are more dependent on a money-based economy and spend large shares of their household budget on food. Higher prices increase the returns to agriculture and other primary industries, and may help to keep more resources in the primary sector than would otherwise be the case. Investment in biofuel plants provides local employment and stimulates the surrounding economy. Construction has temporary benefits, while operation has more sustained economic impacts. These impacts in the Asia-Pacific are small because production in the region outside the United States is minimal.
Concluding Points High oil prices will sustain regional interest in alternative fuels, including biofuels Biofuels will play a modest role as part of a portfolio of solutions to high energy prices including, conservation and use of other alternative fuels Constraints to future production of biofuels: --Declining/low profitability given correlation between output and input prices; --Technical limits to using ethanol or biodiesel and high cost of adapting infrastructure; Slow advances in technology for reducing costs of producing both first-generation biofuels and commercializing the conversion of cellulosic biomass; --Ambiguity about the environmental impacts; and --Era of government deficits and reduced public support.