SOOT SENSOR FOR EMISSION ONBOARD CONTROL SYSTEMS Victor GHEORGHIU Prof. PhD ME HAW Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, Germany Return
CONTENT Emissions Legislation Characteristic of PM-Measuring with OBD Soot Sensors Sequential Measuring with Delphi PM Sensor Continuous Measuring with SDSS Principle Behind SDSS Measurement Results for New SDSS Variants on: Blower Test Bed with Artificial Engine Soot SI MPI Engine Test Bed Conclusion and Outlook Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 2
ENGINE EMISSIONS LEGISLATION EVOLUTION Standard Measured Future standards and legislations for the soot emission (PM) and the particle counting (PC) requirements have need of new measurement technologies of soot concentration at CI and SI engines. OBD Soot Sensors For monitoring and gauging the loading degree of DPF To control the soot emissions in closed loop. CI Engines SI Engines Non-Methane Hydrocarbons Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 3
STANDARD REAL-TIME PM MEASURES LAB TEST SETUP Source: EVALUATION OF HIGH PM EMITTING LIGHT DUTY GASOLINE VEHICLES AND POTENTIAL REPAIR BENEFITS: PRELIMINARY RESULTS 19th CRC ON-ROAD VEHICLE EMISSIONS WORKSHOP, March, 2009 San Diego, California Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 4
STANDARD REAL-TIME PM MEASURES Used Instruments Tailpipe Raw Exhaust PM Instruments (TP): MPM4 (MAHA) and ETaPS Diluted Exhaust PM Instruments (CVS): EEPS and DustTrak Conclusion Each instrument measures soot concentration slightly different, i.e. they are sensitive to different soot components Even the SI (homogeneous mixture formation) and not only SIDI engines emit relative much soot Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 5
STANDARD MEASURED APROVED/PROPOSED LEGISLATION Heavy-Duty Source: Delphi Passenger Cars and Light-Duty Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 6
STANDARD MEASURED PM & PN LEGISLATIONS Heavy-Duty Source: Delphi Passenger Cars and Light-Duty Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 7
STANDARD MEASURED AND OBD LEGISLATION Heavy Duty / CI & PI EURO VI Pass Car & Light Duty / SI (DI) & CI Phase in 01 Jan 2013 Phase in 01 Sep 2014 Standard measured 10 mg/kwh Standard measured 10 mg/kwh OBD 40 mg/kwh Standard measured 4.5 mg/km Final 01 Jan 2016 Final 01 Sep 2019 OBD 25 mg/kwh OBD Soot Sensors For monitoring and gauging the loading degree of DPF Delphi Sensor for Sequential PM Measuring and for OBD of Particulate Filters To control the soot emissions in closed loop SDSS Sensor for Continuous PM Measuring, for OBD of Particulate Filters and for Closed Loop PM Control Standard measured 4.5 mg/km OBD 25 30 mg/km OBD 12 mg/km Proposed Future Extensions of Standard Drive Cycles Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 8
SEQUENTIAL MEASURING OBD SOOT SENSORS For monitoring and gauging the loading degree of DPF Delphi Sensor for Sequential PM Measuring and for OBD of Particulate Filters (Source: SAE Paper 2012-01-0372) on NEDC Emission Cycle Dead-Band Time Sensing Time Regeneration Time Sensing Time Dead-Band Time Exhaust Gas In Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 9
CONTINOUS MEASURING OBD SOOT SENSORS To control the soot emissions in closed loop Spark Discharge Soot Sensor (SDSS) for Continuous PM Measuring, OBD of Particulate Filters and Closed Loop PM Control Exhaust Gas In Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 10
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS The minimum spark discharge voltage in gases depends primarily on the electrode gap and the state of the gases, including their temperature, pressure, flow speed, moisture content and soot particle concentration. In a steady and particle-free gas environment containing a homogenous electric field between the electrodes, these dependencies are as shown in the figure. These dependencies are also known as "Paschen" curves and show the dependence of the breakdown voltage (U D ) of the product between gas pressure (p) and electrode clearance (d). Breakdown Voltage Paschen Curves Source: Wikipedia.org 1 Torr = 133.3 Pa Working Area of the SDSS Product of pressure (p) and electrode clearance (d) Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 11
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS Experiments have proven that soot (i.e. carbon) particles between and deposited on the electrodes facilitate the release of electrons by the electrical field. The required voltage for an electrical discharge falls by up to 70% as a result. It was also discovered that soot particles between and deposited on the electrodes influences the stability of the voltage at which an electrical discharge occurs. For instance, in a soot-free atmosphere (i.e. in pure air) the distribution range for the spark voltage was ±22%. In the presence of soot this range was reduced to ±4%, even in the case of very low soot concentrations. The measurement method of the SDSS is based on determining the minimum level of the electrical spark voltage in the exhaust gas at which sparks occurs between two electrodes. Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 12
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS For searching the minimum electrical spark voltage level, the sensor Electronic Control Unit (ECU) charges a spark coil with a variable level of energy by means of dwell period variation (PWM, see figure). The spark coil is then discharged across the SDSS spark gap in the exhaust gas stream. By means of an implemented spark detection facility one determines whether the energy available is sufficient to create a spark. Return Time [s] 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 13
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS The spark coil is then discharged across the SDSS spark gap in the exhaust gas stream. By means of an implemented spark detection facility one determines whether the energy available is sufficient to create a spark. If the energy was sufficient, the energy for charging the coil in the next measurement cycle can be reduced; otherwise it is increased. This process is continually repeated at frequencies of up to 200 Hz. The dwell period values (PWM) centre on the energy level (despite the static fluctuations in the sparking) which is actually required. Return Secondary Current Exhaust gas temp. = 500 C Mass flow = 124 kg/h Sparks frequency (nf) = 45 % Discharges with Sparks Time [µs] Discharges without Sparks 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 14
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS Discharges with Sparks Discharge without Spark By means of an implemented spark detection facility one determines whether the energy available is sufficient to create a spark. If the energy was sufficient, the energy for charging the coil in the next measurement cycle can be reduced; otherwise it is increased. This process is continually repeated at frequencies of up to 200 Hz. The dwell period values (PWM) centre on the energy level (despite the static fluctuations in the sparking) which is actually required. Return Legend: Secondary Current (yellow) Dwell period (PWM) (cyan) 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 15
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS The dwell period (PWM) values centre on the energy level (despite the static fluctuations in the sparking) which is actually required for nearly 50% sparks frequency Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 16
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS CROSS INFLUENCE PARAMETER In order to obtain dependence only between minimum sparking voltage (resp. PWM level) and soot concentration the influence of the other parameters, i.e. the cross influences, need to be known. Besides the minimum PWM level, all parameters which exert a significant cross influence such as temperature (s. figure), mass flow rate, airfuel ratio, voltage supply etc. need to be acquired during the measurement. PWM SDSS v.11a (unheated) SDSS v.07.2 (older version) Heating off Characteristic lines PWM, Fluid Temperature (air) for many flow rates (m L ) and two sensor variants SDSS v.11a Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 17
PRINCIPLE BEHIND SDSS CROSS INFLUENCE PARAMETER Besides the minimum PWM level, all parameters which exert a significant cross influence such as temperature (s. figure), mass flow rate, air-fuel ratio, voltage supply etc. need to be acquired during the measurement. The controlled heating of the central electrode reduce the PWM dependence from the fluid temperature remarkably. PWM SDSS v.13 Heating off SDSS v.13 Heating on SDSS v.07.5 (older version) Characteristic lines PWM, Fluid Temperature (air) for some sensor variants Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 18
BASIC DESIGN OF SDSS The sensor is basically a combination of a spark plug and a glow plug. The ceramic insulator needs to be heated in the exhaust pipe to prevent soot deposits and uncontrolled discharges between the centre electrode and the exhaust pipe (earth/ground). The demands on the ceramic of the insulators are very high, as these have to demonstrate sufficient breakdown resistance and good chemical strength at relatively high temperatures (up to 700 C) in the hot exhaust gases. Earth electrode Integrated heating element Metal casing Return Exhaust pipe Ceramic insulator Centre electrode High voltage connection 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 19
DESIGN OF OLDER SDSS VARIANTS In a previous phase, the integration of the heating element in the ceramic insulator was deemed to be too costly for the production of the sensor prototypes. For this reason a number of variants for combining the ceramic insulator and heating element (most made of platinum wire) were designed and tested. In all these cases the insulator was made from at least two bonded ceramic parts. In some sensor variants, cores of conventional spark plugs were used. Return 22 mm diameter SDSS v.07.2 (from 2006) 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 20
DESIGN OF SDSS AND MEASURING EXPERIENCES Conclusions from the analysis of the experience with SDSS v.07.2 (development stadium 2006, see FISITA F2006P241 for details): This sensor generates a reproducible signal only at temperatures of below 350 C which show a relatively good correlation to the soot concentration measurements. But if the sensor becomes sooted, it takes several minutes until the deposited soot film has burned off as a result of its relatively large dimensions. The sensor signal cannot be used during this time. Also, the sensor signal is not precise enough in the engine warm-up phase. This is probably due in part to the fact that some exhaust gas parameters for which no characteristic curves have yet been produced change rapidly at the same time. However, this dependence and therefore also its potential for use to monitor a DPF was not sufficient. Measures for the new SDSS variants: All the variant from SDSS v.13 have an integrated heating element in the ceramic insulator of the central electrode. The central electrode diameter is lower as 5 mm for reducing the needed heating power (lower as 35 W). Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 21
DESIGN OF NEW SDSS-VARIANTS Measures for the new SDSS variants: All the variant from SDSS v.13 have an integrated heating element in the ceramic insulator of the central electrode. The central electrode diameter is lower as 5 mm for reducing the needed heating power (lower as 35 W). Exhaust Gas In SDSS v.13 after measurements with high soot concentration Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 22
SDSS IN EXHAUST GAS SYSTEM Tube sections were produced to provide flexible mounting of the sensors; these sections were fitted by means of clamps at the appropriate points in the exhaust gas system. Diesel Particulate Filter (DPF) was inserted in a bypass (s. figure). The bypass vane therefore controls the amounts of the filtered and unfiltered exhaust gas mass flow, allowing the soot concentration to be varied within a certain engine operating point. DPF Vane Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 23
MEASUREMENT RESULTS FOR NEW SDSS VARIANTS ON BLOWER TEST BED AND SI MPI ENGINE TEST BED Blower with variable speed Air heater up to 600 C Acetylene burner for soot emission production Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 24
STEADY CHARACTERISTIC LINES OF NEW SDSS VARIANTS Without any Correction for other Cross Influence Parameter! SDSS v.15.x Heating on Supply 13.x V SDSS v.15.x Heating on Supply 6.x V Opacity k [1/m] Opacity k [1/m] Steady characteristic lines Opacity k, PWM for sensor variants 15.x on Blower Test Bed Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 25
MEASUREMENT ON BLOWER TEST BED Voltage Supply 13.4 V Without any Correction for other Cross Influence Parameter! Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 26
Voltage Supply 6 V Without any Correction for other Cross Influence Parameter! Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 27
FIRST MEASUREMENTS ON SI MPI ENGINE TEST BED Voltage Supply 6 V Cold Start Engine Off Repeated Start Voltage Supply 13.4 V Without any Correction for other Cross Influence Parameter! Characteristic Line k,pwm from Blower Test Bed Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 28
CONCLUSION 1. The soot sensor needs a small amount of electrical energy during the whole measurement procedure (unheated ca 30 W, heated ca 70 W). 2. The manufacturing process of the heated soot sensor should not cause significant manufacturing problems. 3. The price of a soot sensor (without sensor ECU) should be somewhere between those of the spark and glow plugs. 4. The sensor ECU is quite simple (and therefore cheap) and can: either be built as a separate unit (today's development stand), or form a unit together with the ignition coil and perhaps with the soot sensor, or still be integrated e.g. in the engine ECU. 5. The soot sensor and its ECU make up a so-called intelligent sensor, which can deliver the measured soot concentration to the engine ECU by means of a bus system (e.g. CAN). 6. The soot sensor can be used in front of and/or behind the soot filter. 7. The soot sensor is suitable to be used as a simple sensor for the detection of a certain soot concentration threshold. In this case it can be positioned e.g. behind the soot filter to determine the regeneration phase start (and eventually end) time and can also be integrated in OBD I procedure. 8. Alternatively it can be used for continuous measurements of the soot concentration. In this case the soot sensor can be integrated in the engine closed loop soot control. It also can be integrated in OBD II and OBM procedures. Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 29
OUTLOOK The cross influence parameter (e.g. sensor heating temperature, AFR, HC emission, exhaust gas temperature & mass flow rate etc) will be investigated in detail for the new SDSS variants. New SDSS prototypes will be manufactured and tested on Blower, SI MPI, SI DI and CI engines test beds. Correlation with gravimetric measurements and particle counters (PC) will be made. Industry partner for a further much more accelerated development of the SDSS will be searched. Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 30
Contact Information Victor GHEORGHIU Prof. PhD ME HAW Hamburg University of Applied Sciences Faculty TI, Engineering and Informatics Dpt. MP, Mechanical Engineering Berliner Tor 21 20099 Hamburg, Germany Tel.: + 49 40 42875-8636 Fax: + 49 40 42875-8799 grg@rzbt.haw-hamburg.de victor.gheorghiu@haw-hamburg.de www.haw-hamburg.de/pers/gheorghiu www.victor-gheorghiu.de Return 13-15 Nov. 2012 Soot Sensor for Emission Onboard Control Systems / V. GHEORGHIU 31