RISD WHITE ROCK TRAIL PROPOSED ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AUGUST 01. 2016
DESIGN SCHEME COMPARISONS SCHEME A: 2-Story building and parking garage, no code variance required. SCHEME B: 5-Story building(3 school levels built over 2 parking level, planned development(pd) code variance required. COMPARATIVE SUMMARY POINTS* POSITIVE NEGATIVE REMARKS GREEN SPACE/PLAY AREA SCHEME A 85,000 SF / 1.95 ACRES ± 10% SCHEME B 93,000 SF / 2.13 ACRES ± 10% + STUDENT CAPACITY SCHEME A 725 TO 750 STUDENTS SCHEME B 725 TO 750 STUDENTS ON-SITE PARKING SCHEME A 240 TO 260 CARS SCHEME B 240 TO 260 CARS QUEUE CAPACITY SCHEME A 230 TO 250 CARS SCHEME B 230 TO 250 CARS COST EFFICIENCY SCHEME A $30.8M SCHEME B $29.9M AUG 2018 OPENING ASSURANCE SCHEME A NO CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED, CITY STAFF REVIEW SCHEME B VARIANCE WITH DALLAS PZ COMMISSION VARIANCE WITH CITY COUNCIL ACTION + + + + + + + + - - - Net green space potentially become equivalent given the variance range that will be resolved in the final design. Either scheme will provide requested enrollment capacity. Both schemes will provide greatly expanded parking capacity to that found at a typical RISD elementary campus Both schemes maximize queuing capacity. Stacking 5 structural levels (Scheme B) gains some economies in foundation costs. Shortest timeline to building permit. Extend process required for issuance of building permit. * Diagrams in this presentation are conceptual in nature and not representative of final plans and dimensions. Illustrations are provided as representations of building elements and potential arrangements that can be incorporated into either final design scheme.
SCHEME A - CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED 3 LANES GREEN SPACE TOTAL PLAY AREA = Approx. 85,000 SF Approx. 1.95 ACRE PARKING # LANE QUE STACK SPACE # = = 240 ~ 260 230 ~ 250 PLAY- GROUND PLAY- GROUND PLAY- GROUND BUS DROP OFF MAIN LOBBY OPEN PLAYFIELD BUS DROP OFF TURF ROOF SERVICE 3 LANES 0 50 100
SCHEME A - PARKING LV.1 FLOOR PLAN NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED 536 ft 500 ft DROP OFF AREA ADMIN. DROP OFF AREA 500 ft 3 LANES 500 ft 0 50 100
SCHEME A - PARKING LV.2 FLOOR PLAN NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED 512 ft DROP OFF AREA 512 ft DROP OFF AREA 3 LANES 0 50 100 512 ft
SCHEME A - SCHOOL LV.1 FLOOR PLAN NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED COLLABO- RATION 2ND GR. UP KG PLAYGROUND PLAYGROUND PLAYGROUND CIRC. FROM PARKING GARAGE CANOPY ABOVE COLLABO- RATION MAIN ENTRANCE ADMIN. 526 ft PARKING GARAGE BELOW / OPEN PLAYFIELD CAFETERIA KITCHEN CLINIC SUPPORT KG / 1ST GR. 2ND GR. AND UP COLLABORATION GYMNASIUM SUPPORT/STORAGE LIBRARY FOOD SERVICE ADMINISTRATION CLINIC RESTROOM GYMNASIUM FIELD/PLAY AREA CIRC. 0 30 60
SCHEME A - SCHOOL LV.2 FLOOR PLAN NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED COLLABO- RATION 2ND GR. UP LIBRARY KG ROOF ENTRANCE CANOPY LIBRARY OFFICE OPEN TO BELOW 540 ft OPEN TO BELOW ADMIN. ROOF KG / 1ST GR. LIBRARY RESTROOM OPEN TO BELOW 2ND GR. AND UP FOOD SERVICE CIRC. COLLABORATION ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT/STORAGE GYMNASIUM CLINIC FIELD/PLAY AREA 0 30 60
SCHEME A CONCEPT RENDERING NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED
SCHEME A CONCEPT RENDERING NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED
SCHEME A CONCEPT RENDERING NO CODE CHANGE REQUIRED
SCHEME B - CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED GREEN SPACE TOTAL PLAY AREA = Approx. 93,000 SF Approx. 2.13 ACRE PLAY- GROUND OPEN PLAYFIELD PARKING # LANE QUE STACK SPACE # = = 240~ 260 230 ~ 250 MAIN LOBBY BUS DROP OFF PARKING LV.1 EXIT OPEN PLAYFIELD VISITOR PARKING PARKING LV.1 ENTERANCE SERVICE PLAY- GROUND PLAY- GROUND 0 50 100
SCHEME B - PARKING LV.1 FLOOR PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED 500 ft DROP OFF AREA 500 ft 3 LANES 500 ft 0 50 100
SCHEME B - PARKING LV.2 FLOOR PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED 510 ft DROP OFF AREA 510 ft 3 LANES 510 ft 0 50 100
SCHEME B - SCHOOL LV.1 FLOOR PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED CIRC. OPEN PLAYFIELD PLAYGROUND KG GYMNASIUM 520 ft WALKWAY REST RM ADMIN TEACHER WORK RM OPEN PLAYFIELD 1ST GR STAGE CAFE KITCHEN KG / 1ST GR. LIBRARY RESTROOM CIRC. PLAYGROUND PLAYGROUND 2ND GR. AND UP FOOD SERVICE CIRC. COLLABORATION ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT/STORAGE GYMNASIUM CLINIC FIELD/PLAY AREA 0 30 60
SCHEME B - SCHOOL LV.2 FLOOR PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED CIRC. 2ND GR OPEN TO BELOW (GYM) CIRC. REST RM LIBRARY OFFICE TEACHER WORK RM 3RD GR LIBRARY 536 ft ALTERNATIVE LAYOUT TRADITIONAL LAYOUT OPEN TO BELOW (CAFE) KITCHEN ROOF CIRC. KG / 1ST GR. LIBRARY RESTROOM 2ND GR. AND UP FOOD SERVICE CIRC. COLLABORATION ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT/STORAGE GYMNASIUM CLINIC FIELD/PLAY AREA 0 30 60
SCHEME B - SCHOOL LV.3 FLOOR PLAN CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED CIRC. 4TH GR GYM ROOF CIRC. ADMIN REST RM TEACHER WORK RM 5TH GR COLLABO- RATION 6TH GR 550 ft TRADITIONAL LAYOUT ALTERNATIVE LAYOUT CAFE ROOF KITCHEN ROOF CIRC. KG / 1ST GR. LIBRARY RESTROOM 2ND GR. AND UP FOOD SERVICE CIRC. COLLABORATION ADMINISTRATION SUPPORT/STORAGE GYMNASIUM CLINIC FIELD/PLAY AREA 0 30 60
SCHEME A B ALTERNATIVE CLASSROOM LAYOUT FLOOR PLAN LAB CLASSROOM COLLABORATION CENTER PRESENTATION STAGE TECH CLASSROOM CLASSROOM
SCHEME A B ALTERNATIVE CLASSROOM LAYOUT AXONOMETRIC VIEW
SCHEME A B ALTERNATIVE CLASSROOM LAYOUT PERSPECTIVE VIEW
SCHEME B CONCEPT RENDERING CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED
SCHEME B CONCEPT RENDERING CODE VARIANCE REQUIRED