ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: To: Copy to: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 P-members O-members L-members ISO/CS ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398 2008-05-28 Results of 2007 systematic review of ISO/TC 67/SC 4 standards Please find attached the results of the 2007 systematic review of ISO/TC 67SC 4 standards. In light of these results, the following International Standards are proposed for: CONFIRMATION ISO 10417:2004 Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Subsurface safety valve systems -- Design, installation, operation and redress ISO 10424-1:2004 Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Rotary drilling equipment -- Part 1: Rotary drill stem elements (Will be listed as a PWI until 5 P-member nominated experts can be identified) ISO 10432:2004 Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Downhole equipment -- Subsurface safety valve equipment ISO 13625:2002 Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Drilling and production equipment -- Marine drilling riser couplings ISO 17078-1:2004 Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Drilling and production equipment -- Part 1: Side-pocket mandrels Unless I hear to the contrary by: 2008-06-30, I shall assume you are in agreement with these proposals. Yours sincerely Ed Baniak Ed Baniak Secretary to ISO/TC 67/SC 4
ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398A Systematic Review voting result Reference ISO 10417:2004 Committee ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Edition number 2 Vienna agreement ISO lead 2008-05-15 English title Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Subsurface safety valve systems -- Design, installation, operation and redress French title Industries du pétrole et du gaz naturel -- Systèmes de vannes de sécurité de fond de puits -- Conception, installation, fonctionnement et réparation Start date 2007-04-15 End date 2007-09-17 Opened by ISO/CS on Status 2007-04-15 01:29:38 Closed by ISO/CS on 2007-09-19 01:14:31 Closed Voting stage Systematic review Version number 1 Vote in parallel with Note Q.1 "Recommended action" Questions Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"
Votes by members Country Member Status Confirm Confirm & Correct Revise / Amend Withdraw Abstain Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5 Argentina IRAM P-Member X No Yes No Australia SA X Austria ON X Brazil ABNT P-Member X Yes Modified Yes Yes Canada SCC P-Member X China SAC P-Member France AFNOR P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Germany DIN P-Member X Yes Identical No No Indonesia BSN P-Member X Italy UNI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Korea, Republic of KATS P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Netherlands NEN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Norway SN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Poland PKN P-Member United Kingdom BSI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No USA ANSI Secretariat X Yes Identical Yes Yes P-Member TOTALS Total of P-Members voting: 10 Confirm with or without correct: 8 Revise/Amend: 2 Withdraw: 0 8 0 2 0 2 9 Yes, 1 No TOTALS 8 0 2 0 4 9 Yes, 1 No P-Members having abstained are not counted in this vote 8 Identical, 1 Modified 8 Identical, 1 Modified 9 Yes, 1 No 9 Yes, 1 No 2 Yes, 8 No 2 Yes, 8 No
Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" 8 x Confirm Argentina (IRAM) Germany (DIN) 4 x Abstain Australia (SA) Austria (ON) Canada (SCC) Indonesia (BSN) 2 x Revise/Amend Brazil (ABNT) 0 x Abstain with survey replies 0 x Confirm, with correction of errors 0 x Withdraw Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" 9 x Yes Brazil (ABNT) Germany (DIN) 1 x No Argentina (IRAM) Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" 8 x Identical Germany (DIN) 1 x Modified Brazil (ABNT)
Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" 9 x Yes Argentina (IRAM) Brazil (ABNT) 1 x No Germany (DIN) Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" 8 x No Argentina (IRAM) Germany (DIN) 2 x Yes Brazil (ABNT) Comments from Voters Member: Comment: Date: Brazil (ABNT) Comment 2007-09-14 21:18:24 There are several Petrobras standards partially using this standard ----- It is used the SCSSV leaking criteria (400 cc/min for oil and 15 scf/min for gas) Canada (SCC) Comment 2007-08-23 17:56:29 No expertise available at this time for review of this document. Comment 2007-09-10 14:01:12 NF EN ISO 10417:2004
Germany (DIN) Comment 2007-07-25 09:23:59 DIN EN ISO 10417 See 2.1 Comment 2007-08-27 15:15:58 This IS has been adopted as national standard with reference UNI EN ISO 10417. Korea, Republic of (KATS) Comment 2007-09-17 10:22:51 To be published in the future Comment 2007-09-17 10:34:47 NEN-EN-ISO 10417:2004 Comment 2007-09-13 14:28:39 NS-EN ISO 10417 Comment 2007-08-28 10:43:23 BS EN ISO 10417:2004 Comment 2007-09-14 19:39:58 Recommended action Adopted as API RP 14B, Design, Installation, Repair and Operation of Subsurface Safety Valve Systems, 5th ed. CFR 250.801 and MMS final ruling on same section of CFR dated 4/16/2007 adopting current version of document.
ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398B Systematic Review voting result Reference ISO 10424-1:2004 Committee ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Edition number 1 Vienna agreement ISO lead 2008-05-15 English title French title Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Rotary drilling equipment -- Part 1: Rotary drill stem elements Industries du pétrole et du gaz naturel -- Équipements de forage rotary -- Partie 1: Éléments de forage rotary Start date 2007-07-15 End date 2007-12-17 Opened by ISO/CS on Status 2007-07-18 15:30:08 Closed by ISO/CS on 2007-12-18 00:54:30 Closed Voting stage Systematic review Version number 1 Vote in parallel with Note Q.1 "Recommended action" Questions Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"
Votes by members Country Member Status Confirm Confirm & Correct Revise / Amend Withdraw Abstain Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5 Argentina IRAM P-Member X No Yes No Australia SA X Austria ON X Yes Identical Yes No Brazil ABNT P-Member X No Yes No Canada SCC P-Member X China SAC P-Member France AFNOR P-Member X Yes Identical No No Germany DIN P-Member X Indonesia BSN P-Member X Italy UNI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Korea, Republic of KATS P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Netherlands NEN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Norway SN P-Member X No Yes No Poland PKN P-Member Spain AENOR O-Member X Yes Identical Yes No United Kingdom BSI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No USA ANSI Secretariat X Yes Identical Yes Yes P-Member TOTALS Total of P-Members voting: 8 Confirm with or without correct: 7 Revise/Amend: 1 Withdraw: 0 6 1 1 0 4 6 Yes, 3 No TOTALS 6 1 2 0 6 8 Yes, 3 No P-Members having abstained are not counted in this vote 6 Identical, 0 Modified 8 Identical, 0 Modified 8 Yes, 1 No 10 Yes, 1 No 1 Yes, 8 No 1 Yes, 10 No
Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" 6 x Confirm Argentina (IRAM) 4 x Abstain Australia (SA) Canada (SCC) Germany (DIN) Indonesia (BSN) 2 x Abstain with survey replies Austria (ON) 2 x Revise/Amend 1 x Confirm, with correction of errors Brazil (ABNT) 0 x Withdraw Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" 8 x Yes Austria (ON) 3 x No Argentina (IRAM) Brazil (ABNT) Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" 8 x Identical Austria (ON) 0 x Modified
Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" 10 x Yes Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) Brazil (ABNT) 1 x No Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" 10 x No Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) Brazil (ABNT) 1 x Yes Comments from Voters Member: Comment: Date: Austria (ON) Comment 2007-11-08 14:37:32 OENORM EN ISO 10424-1 Brazil (ABNT) Comment 2007-12-17 19:41:19 ------------- Brazil (ABNT) Comment File 2007-12-17 19:41:19 CommentFiles/Brazil(ABNT).doc Comment 2007-12-11 10:34:44 NF EN ISO 10424-1 Use of NF EN ISO 10424-1
Comment 2007-12-04 17:31:23 UNI EN ISO 10424-1:2005 Korea, Republic of (KATS) Comment 2007-12-17 08:47:41 KSBISO10424-1 Comment 2007-12-17 11:31:00 NEN-EN-ISO 10424-1:2004 Comment 2007-12-17 10:57:41 EN ISO 10424-1:2004 Comment 2007-11-13 11:42:48 BS EN ISO 10424-1:2004 Comment 2007-12-17 16:50:51 API Addenda need to be added. Nationally adopted after publication in 2004, but two Addenda have been added since, and the ISO document needs to be updated. Unsure
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date: Document: ISO/ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 MB 1 Clause/ Subclause/ Annex/Figure/Table (e.g. 3.1, Table 2) Paragraph/ List item/ Note/ (e.g. Note 2) Type of comment 2 BR 4.1.43 test pressure pressure above working pressure used to demonstrate structural integrity of a pressure vessel BR 6.5.3.4 Acceptance criteria The average of the three specimens shall be 54 J (40 ftlbs) or greater, with no single value less than 47 J (35 ftlbs). BR 7.5.3.4 Acceptance criteria The average impact strength of the three specimens shall be 54 J (40 ft-lbs) or greater, with no single value less than 47 J (35 ft-lbs). Comment (justification for change) Proposed change Secretariat observations on each comment submitted Change vessel x stem element. Change 40 ft-lbs X 40 ft.lb, dimensions are not used in plural, just in singular. Change 35 ft-lbs X 35 ft.lb, dimensions are not used in plural, just in singular. BR 8.2.1.3.4 Acceptance criteria The average impact strength of the three specimens shall be 54 J (40 ft-lbs) or greater, with no single value less than 47 J (35 ft-lbs). Change 35 ft-lbs X 35 ft.lb, dimensions are not used in plural, just in singular. BR Table 13 5 1/2 Reg is like NC50. There is not interchangeability with then. NC50 is with V-0,038 radius, and 51/2 Reg is with V-0,050 radius. To clarify. 1 MB = Member body (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China) ** = ISO/CS editing unit 2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial NB Columns 1, 2, 4, 5 are compulsory. FORM 13B (ISO) version 2001-09 page 6 of 6
ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398C Systematic Review voting result Reference ISO 10432:2004 Committee ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Edition number 3 Vienna agreement ISO lead 2008-05-15 English title French title Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Downhole equipment -- Subsurface safety valve equipment Industries du pétrole et du gaz naturel -- Équipement de forage vertical -- Vannes de protection de fond de puits Start date 2007-10-15 End date 2008-03-17 Opened by ISO/CS on Status 2007-10-15 00:27:45 Closed by ISO/CS on 2008-03-18 00:05:25 Closed Voting stage Systematic review Version number 1 Vote in parallel with Note Q.1 "Recommended action" Questions Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"
Votes by members Country Member Status Confirm Confirm & Correct Revise / Amend Withdraw Abstain Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5 Argentina IRAM P-Member X No Yes No Austria ON X Yes Identical Yes No Brazil ABNT P-Member X No Yes No Canada SCC P-Member X China SAC P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No France AFNOR P-Member X Yes Identical No No Germany DIN P-Member X Indonesia BSN P-Member X Italy UNI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Korea, Republic of KATS P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Netherlands NEN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Norway SN P-Member X No Yes No Poland PKN P-Member Spain AENOR O-Member X Yes Identical Yes No United Kingdom BSI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No USA ANSI Secretariat X Yes Identical No Yes P-Member TOTALS Total of P-Members voting: 9 Confirm with or without correct: 7 Revise/Amend: 2 Withdraw: 0 7 0 2 0 4 7 Yes, 3 No TOTALS 7 0 3 0 5 9 Yes, 3 No P-Members having abstained are not counted in this vote 7 Identical, 0 Modified 9 Identical, 0 Modified 8 Yes, 2 No 10 Yes, 2 No 1 Yes, 9 No 1 Yes, 11 No
Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" 7 x Confirm Argentina (IRAM) China (SAC) 3 x Abstain Canada (SCC) Germany (DIN) Indonesia (BSN) 3 x Revise/Amend Brazil (ABNT) 2 x Abstain with survey replies 0 x Confirm, with correction of errors 0 x Withdraw Austria (ON) Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" 9 x Yes Austria (ON) China (SAC) 3 x No Argentina (IRAM) Brazil (ABNT) Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" 9 x Identical Austria (ON) China (SAC) 0 x Modified
Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" 10 x Yes Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) Brazil (ABNT) China (SAC) 2 x No Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" 11 x No Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) Brazil (ABNT) China (SAC) 1 x Yes
Comments from Voters Member: Comment: Date: Austria (ON) Comment 2008-02-07 08:17:05 OENORM EN ISO 10432 Brazil (ABNT) Comment 2008-03-17 15:48:58 As this document may cover changes related to API-14A, adopted by the referred letter ballot, as well as editorial changes from supplement, and as the hydraulic control circuits for SCSSV have many standard work pressures from 34.5 to 103.5 MPa (from 5,000 to 15,000 psi) involving several manufacturer written calibration specifications, which are specific to the well parameters, we suggest the supplier/manufacturer providing the SCSSV calculation routine to calibrate all part number and serial number SCSSVs with nitrogen chamber. This could be done adding a supplement in the section 7.9, ISO 10432, third edition 2004-12-15. Due to the production demand, the necessary time to calibrate nitrogen chamber SCSSVs could be abbreviated if the calculation routine could be performed by the operator technical staff, instead waiting data from the supplier/manufacturer. China (SAC) Comment 2008-03-13 08:50:28 It is intended to be adopted in the future. Comment 2008-03-11 16:54:20 NF EN ISO 10432 Use of NF EN ISO 10432 Comment 2008-02-25 16:41:01 Adopted as UNI EN ISO 10432:2004 Korea, Republic of (KATS) Comment 2008-03-17 07:13:35 This standard has not yet adopted as a Korean national standard. Publication of this standard as a national standard will be considered in the future. Comment 2008-03-17 16:23:14 NEN-EN-ISO 10432:2005 Comment 2008-03-17 11:43:26 EN ISO 10432:2004
Comment 2008-02-14 13:27:40 BS EN ISO 10432:2004 Comment 2008-03-17 17:24:25 The MMS elected not to adopt the 11 th edition of API Spec 14A in a final rule issued 3/15/2007 even though they were involved in and aware of the changes to the 11 th edition from the 10 th edition (which they have adopted). Believing that this time they will participate again and provide the taskgroup with language acceptable to them and subsequently adopt the results into legislation, the US suggests we vote to revise/amend the document. Adopted as API Spec 14A, 11th edition Products in this country are based on API Spec 14A which is an identical adoption of ISO 10432Referenced in US Code of Federal Regulations 30CFR250.806 and 30CFR250.198
ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398D Systematic Review voting result Reference ISO 13625:2002 Committee ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Edition number 1 Vienna agreement ISO lead 2008-05-15 English title French title Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Drilling and production equipment -- Marine drilling riser couplings Industries du pétrole et du gaz naturel -- Équipement de forage et de production - Connecteurs de tubes prolongateurs pour forages en mer Start date 2007-10-15 End date 2008-03-17 Opened by ISO/CS on Status 2007-10-15 01:07:43 Closed by ISO/CS on 2008-03-18 02:21:17 Closed Voting stage Systematic review Version number 1 Vote in parallel with Note Q.1 "Recommended action" Questions Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"
Votes by members Country Member Status Confirm Confirm & Correct Revise / Amend Withdraw Abstain Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5 Argentina IRAM P-Member X No Yes No Austria ON X Yes Identical Yes No Brazil ABNT P-Member X Canada SCC P-Member X China SAC P-Member X No No No France AFNOR P-Member X Yes Identical No No Germany DIN P-Member X Indonesia BSN P-Member X Italy UNI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Korea, Republic of KATS P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Netherlands NEN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Norway SN P-Member X No Yes No Poland PKN P-Member Spain AENOR O-Member X Yes Identical Yes No United Kingdom BSI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No USA ANSI Secretariat X No Yes No P-Member TOTALS Total of P-Members voting: 8 Confirm with or without correct: 7 Revise/Amend: 1 Withdraw: 0 7 0 1 0 5 5 Yes, 4 No TOTALS 7 0 2 0 6 7 Yes, 4 No P-Members having abstained are not counted in this vote 5 Identical, 0 Modified 7 Identical, 0 Modified 7 Yes, 2 No 9 Yes, 2 No 0 Yes, 9 No 0 Yes, 11 No
Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" 7 x Confirm Argentina (IRAM) China (SAC) 4 x Abstain Brazil (ABNT) Canada (SCC) Germany (DIN) Indonesia (BSN) 2 x Abstain with survey replies Austria (ON) 2 x Revise/Amend 0 x Confirm, with correction of errors 0 x Withdraw Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" 7 x Yes Austria (ON) 4 x No Argentina (IRAM) China (SAC) Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" 7 x Identical Austria (ON) 0 x Modified
Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" 9 x Yes Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) 2 x No China (SAC) Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" 11 x No Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) China (SAC) 0 x Yes Comments from Voters Member: Comment: Date: Austria (ON) Comment 2008-02-07 08:18:00 OENORM EN ISO 13625 China (SAC) Comment 2008-03-13 08:51:48 No comments. Comment 2008-03-11 16:33:37 NF EN ISO 13625 Use of NF EN ISO 13625 Comment 2008-02-25 16:42:49 Adopted as UNI EN ISO 13625:2002
Korea, Republic of (KATS) Comment 2008-03-17 07:15:18 This standard has not yet adopted as a Korean national standard. Publication of this standard as a national standard will be considered in the future. Comment 2008-03-17 11:24:02 NEN-EN 13625:2002 Comment 2008-03-17 11:45:09 EN ISO 13625:2002 Comment 2008-02-14 13:28:04 BS EN ISO 13625:2002
ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Materials, equipment and offshore structures for petroleum, petrochemical and natural gas industries Drilling and production equipment Secretary: American Petroleum Institute, 1220 L Street NW, Washington, DC 20005, USA Tel: +1 202 682 8000 Fax: +1 202 962 4714 ISO/TC 67/SC 4 N 398E Systematic Review voting result Reference ISO 17078-1:2004 Committee ISO/TC 67/SC 4 Edition number 1 Vienna agreement ISO lead 2008-05-15 English title Petroleum and natural gas industries -- Drilling and production equipment -- Part 1: Side-pocket mandrels French title Industries du pétrole et du gaz naturel -- Équipement de forage et de production -- Partie 1: Raccords à poche latérale Start date 2007-10-15 End date 2008-03-17 Opened by ISO/CS on Status 2007-10-15 00:00:57 Closed by ISO/CS on 2008-03-18 00:10:37 Closed Voting stage Systematic review Version number 1 Vote in parallel with Note Q.1 "Recommended action" Questions Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"
Votes by members Country Member Status Confirm Confirm & Correct Revise / Amend Withdraw Abstain Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5 Argentina IRAM P-Member X No Yes No Austria ON X Yes Identical Yes No Brazil ABNT P-Member X Canada SCC P-Member X China SAC P-Member X No No No France AFNOR P-Member X Yes Identical No No Germany DIN P-Member X Indonesia BSN P-Member X Italy UNI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Korea, Republic of KATS P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Netherlands NEN P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No Norway SN P-Member X No Yes No Poland PKN P-Member Spain AENOR O-Member X Yes Identical Yes No United Kingdom BSI P-Member X Yes Identical Yes No USA ANSI Secretariat X Yes Modified No No P-Member TOTALS Total of P-Members voting: 8 Confirm with or without correct: 8 Revise/Amend: 0 Withdraw: 0 8 0 0 0 5 6 Yes, 3 No TOTALS 8 0 1 0 6 8 Yes, 3 No P-Members having abstained are not counted in this vote 5 Identical, 1 Modified 7 Identical, 1 Modified 6 Yes, 3 No 8 Yes, 3 No 0 Yes, 9 No 0 Yes, 11 No
Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" 8 x Confirm Argentina (IRAM) China (SAC) 4 x Abstain Brazil (ABNT) Canada (SCC) Germany (DIN) Indonesia (BSN) 2 x Abstain with survey replies Austria (ON) 1 x Revise/Amend 0 x Confirm, with correction of errors 0 x Withdraw Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" 8 x Yes Austria (ON) 3 x No Argentina (IRAM) China (SAC) Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" 7 x Identical Austria (ON) 1 x Modified
Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" 8 x Yes Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) 3 x No China (SAC) Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" 11 x No Argentina (IRAM) Austria (ON) China (SAC) 0 x Yes Comments from Voters Member: Comment: Date: Austria (ON) Comment 2008-02-07 08:18:54 OENORM EN ISO 17078-1 Brazil (ABNT) Comment 2008-03-04 13:37:33 We have been suggestd to standartize the distance between the mandrel neck and the valve seat in order to reduce wire line tools. This has been done through CD, DIS and FDIS. No acceptance resulted to this claim. At the moment, we have no additional comments regarding the rest of the ISO 17078-1. China (SAC) Comment 2008-03-13 08:28:15 No comments.
Comment 2008-03-12 11:14:43 NF EN ISO 17078-1 Use of NF EN ISO 17078-1 Comment 2008-02-25 16:48:07 Adopted as UNI EN ISO 17078-1:2004 Korea, Republic of (KATS) Comment 2008-03-12 07:14:29 KSBISO17078-1:2007 Comment 2008-03-17 16:21:29 NEN-EN-ISO 17078-1:2004 Comment 2008-03-17 11:46:31 EN ISO 17078-1:2004 Comment 2008-02-14 13:28:27 BS EN ISO 17078-1:2004 Comment 2008-03-17 21:03:09 Once all parts of 17078 are complete, they will likely be adopted back as API 11V documents replacing existing ones. Not adopted at present.content largely present in API 11V1 and similar documents. API currently waiting on ISO taskgroups to complete their work before back-adoption begins.