Use of Microgrids and DERs for black start and islanding operation João A. Peças Lopes, FIEEE May 14 17, 17 Wiesloch
The MicroGrid Concept A Low Voltage distribution system with small modular generation units providing power and heat to local loads A local communication infrastructure A hierarchical management and control system: MicroGrid Central Controller (MGCC) Local Load Controller (LC) Local Microsource Controller (MC) Operation Modes: 1. Normal Interconnected Mode 2. Emergency Mode: Autonomous Operation Intentional Islanding Forced Islanding
MV networks of the future Muti-Microgrids with DER Concept of Multi Microgrid An evolution from the MG concept; MV network; Larger geographic dimension; Topological diversity; Very large number of active players; Developed over a large communication infrastructure. 3
Control Structure of the Distribution Grid Hierarchy of Control Imposed by the large number of elements to control; Distribution Management System Central Autonomous Management Controller Requires a communication infrastructure Smart meters can be used as nodes for communication Last mile communication protocols (PLC, RF wireless Mesh networks) 4
An Overview on MG Operation and Control Issues - 1 MicroGrids are inverter dominated Grids: New issues are introduced in terms of operation and control in comparison with conventional power systems comprising synchronous generators MG are systems with very low global inertia and comprise MS with slow response: During MG islanding operation, load tracking problems arise since microturbines and fuel cells have slow response to control signals and are inertia less A system with clusters of MS designed to operate in islanded mode requires some form of energy buffering to ensure initial energy balance The active power shortage caused in the MG when moving to islanding operation or due to load or power variation during islanding operation mode must be compensated by energy storage devices
An Overview on MG Operation and Control Issues - 2 Moving to islanding operation (forced islanding): When the MG transfers to island operation, an immediate change in the output power control of the MS is required: MS operation mode change from a dispatched power mode to one controlling frequency of the islanded section of the network The control strategy to be adopted has to combine the frequency control strategy with the storage devices response and load shedding possibilities, in a cooperative way to ensure successful overall operation, although acting independently at the MC and LC level MicroGrid Black Start: If a system disturbance causes a general black out such that the MG is not able to separate and continue in islanding mode, and if the MV system is unable to restore operation in a predefined time, a first step in system recovery will be a local BS The strategy to be followed will involve the MGCC and the local controllers Use of predefined rules to be embedded in the MGCC software
MG Modeling 1 MS Modeling A library of MS dynamic models was developed and implemented in MatLab Simulink MicroSources: Fuel Cells Microturbines Wind Generators Photovoltaic Generators Storage Devices: Flywheels Batteries Network Control and Management Systems
MG Modeling 2 Inverter Modeling Main approaches for controlling power electronic interfaces : PQ inverter control: Designed for grid connected operation The inverter is controlled to meet an active and reactive power set point (the set points are determined through specific algorithms or control functionalities) In addition to active and reactive power flow control, this inverter is also responsible for the control of the DC link voltage Voltage Source Inverter (VSI) control: Designed for standalone operation (parallel operation with other VSI or with a stiff AC system is also possible) The inverter feeds the load with pre defined values for voltage and frequency TheVSIisusedinordertointerfaceastoragedevice(suchaflywheelorabattery) with the AC grid. By making use of the energy stored in such devices, the VSI is able to emulate the behaviour of a synchronous machine, thus controlling voltage and frequency on the AC system
MG Modeling 3 Inverter Modeling Voltage Source Inverter Control: Frequency/active power and voltage/reactive power droop control concepts Q k V V P k w w Q P 0 0 1 01 1 01 Q k V V P k w w Q grid P grid
MS Classification Regarding Control Grid forming units: storage devices (coupled to VSI) Definition of voltage and frequency in islanded systems Power balance in islanded systems Grid supporting units: SSMT and SOFC MS with capability of producing controllable active power on demand can be used for MG active power secondary frequency control in islanded systems through the use of some form of dispatch Grid parallel units: PV and micro wind generator Uncontrolled MS, injecting the maximum power extracted from the primary energy resource into the grid
MG Control for Islanding Operation Single Master Control Strategy P, Q & V measurements from MC and LC Frequency measurement from VSI Droop Settings MGCC P&Q Settings VSI Control V, I V, I PQ Control Q Set Point Controller V DC P V DC DC AC VSI Electrical Network AC DC Primer Mover Loads
MG Control for Islanding Operation Multi Master Control Strategy
MG Emergency Control Strategies - 1 Primary frequency control VSI control principle makes it possible to react to system disturbances based only on information available at its terminals MG operation does not rely on fast communications among MS controllers and the MGCC Running in a larger time frame, a secondary control approach can be used to improve system performance VSI active power output is proportional to the MG frequency deviation max grid 1 min VSI frequency decrease due to active power increase P P1 P0 Pmin P 0 P 1 Pmax P
MG Emergency Control Strategies - 2 Load shedding: Uses controllable/interruptible loads concept To allow a fast response to the imbalance between load and generation Emergency functionality to aid frequency restoration to its nominal value after MG islanding Frequency Deviation Load Shedding (%) 0.25 30 0.50 30 0.75 1.00
MG Emergency Control Strategies - 3 Secondary frequency control: During MG islanding operation, the frequency drifts from the nominal value following power or load variations Power balance is assured by energy storage devices If MG frequency stabilizes in a value different from the nominal one storage devices would keep on injecting or absorbing active power whenever the frequency deviation differs from zero. P P max Correct permanent frequency deviations during islanding operation f min f f f f max 0 P min
Voltage control: MG Emergency Control Strategies - 4 In LV distribution grids, the resistive part is predominant over the inductive part Active power flow is linked to voltage magnitude; reactive power flow is linked to the phase difference between bus voltages R C L coupl 2 V V inv invvgrid Pinv cos( ) R R C C V grid V inv V DC VinvVgrid Qinv sin( ) R C Reactive power injection cannot be used for voltage control purposes VSI are used to control voltage in its connection point PQ controlled inverters can be used for reactive power support Power factor correction of the loads near the MS Minimization of MG total losses
Dynamic Simulation of MicroGrids Test System M
Dynamic Simulation of MicroGrids Simulation Platform
25 Results from Simulations MG Intentional Islanding 25 P - SSMT1 (kw) 15 P - SSMT2 (kw) 15 10 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 10 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 25 25 P - SSMT3 (kw) 15 P - SOFC (kw) 15 10 10 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 5 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 P - VSI (kw) 1 0.5 0-0.5 MG islanding P - MV (kw) 50 40 30 10 0-1 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 Time (s) -10 0 30 60 90 1 150 180 Time (s)
Results from Simulations MG Forced Islanding droop control 50.5 30 Frequency (Hz) 50 49.5 49 P - SSMT1 (kw) 10 0 48.5 0 5 10 15 25 30-10 0 5 10 15 25 30 80 30 P - VSI (kw) 60 40 0 P - SSMT2 (kw) 10 0-0 5 10 15 25 30-10 0 5 10 15 25 30 25 40 P - SOFC (kw) 15 10 5 0 0 5 10 15 25 30 Time (s) P - SSMT3 (kw) 30 10 0 0 5 10 15 25 30 Time (s)
Results from Simulations MG Forced Islanding Secondary Frequency control 50.5 30 Frequency (Hz) 50 49.5 49 P - SSMT1 (kw) 10 48.5 0 30 60 90 1 150 0 0 30 60 90 1 150 60 30 P - VSI (kw) 40 P - SSMT2 (kw) 10 0 0 30 60 90 1 150 0 0 30 60 90 1 150 P - SOFC (kw) 35 30 25 15 10 5 0 0 30 60 90 1 150 Time (s) P - SSMT3 (kw) 35 30 25 15 10 5 0 0 30 60 90 1 150 Time (s)
Results from Simulations MG Forced Islanding Secondary Frequency Control + Load Shedding 50.2 Frequency (Hz) 50 49.8 49.6 P - SSMT1(kW) 15 10 49.4 0 50 100 150 5 0 50 100 150 P - VSI (kw) 25 15 10 5 0-5 0 50 100 150 P - SSMT2 (kw) 15 10 5 0 50 100 150 25 30 P - SOFC (kw) 15 10 P - SSMT3 (kw) 25 15 5 0 50 100 150 Time (s) 10 0 50 100 150 Time (s)
Results from Simulations Load following during islanding operation 50.5 30 Frequency (Hz) 50 P - SSMT1 (kw) 25 49.5 0 300 400 500 600 15 0 300 400 500 600 40 30 P - VSI (kw) 0 - P - SSMT2 (kw) 25-40 0 300 400 500 600 15 0 300 400 500 600 30 30 P - SOFC (kw) 25 15 P - SSMT3 (kw) 25 10 0 300 400 500 600 Time (s) 15 0 300 400 500 600 Time (s)
MG Operation Issues Moving to islanding operation: How to achieve a seamless transition and ensure MG survival? Key Issues: Is the energy available in storage devices enough for a seamless transition to islanded operation? How much load must be shed? These questions are related to MG frequency stability: MG ability to restore the balance between local load and generation in the moments subsequent to system islanding
Service Restauration Main Steps I Using the MV Network The MMG Energization of the MV Network and Synchronization of Islands: 1. Switch off loads, separate transformers from the grid and disconnect reactive power sources. 2. Create islands inside the MMG, around each micro grid and around each generator with black start capability. 3. Build the structure of the MV grid. 4. Synchronization the several islands. 5. Connection of priority loads. 6. Energization by steps of the MV/LV transformers connecting micro grids to MV network as well as with the remaining branches. 7. Synchronization of the micro grids with the MV network. 8. Energization of the remaining MV/LV transformers. Restauration of Load and Reconnection of Generation: 9. Restauration of load simultaneously with an increase of generation from controllable power sources, or alternatively by connecting noncontrollable DG. 10. Connection of non controllable DG to the MV grid. 11. Increase load taking into account the available generation capability. 12. Activation of the AGC in the MMG. ( This allows to assure the operation of the grid near the nominal frequency when in islanding conditions). 13. Connection of the MMG to the NH grid upstream when this network becomes available. 25 Porto, 1 Jun 10
II - Using Low Voltage MicroGrids for Service Restoration DG maturation can offer ancillary services, such as the provision of Black Start in Low Voltage grids Black Start is a sequence of events controlled by a set of rules A set of rules and conditions are identified in advance and embedded in MGCC software These rules and conditions define a sequence of control actions to be carried out during the restoration stages The electrical problems to be dealt with include: Building LV network Connecting MS Connecting controllable loads Controlling voltage and frequency Synchronization with the MV network (when available)
MG Black Start General Assumptions MS with Black Start capability: Launch local generation autonomously Hierarchical control of the MicroGrid is used: Load Controller (LC) Microsource Controller (MC) MG Central Controller (MGCC) MicroGrid has ability for: Load and microsources disconnection after system collapse Disconnection of the distribution transformer Periodical records about MicroGrid status
MG Black Start Sequence of Actions Multi Master Operation in the initial stages of the procedure Disconnect all loads and sectionalize the MG so that some microsources may feed its own loads Creation of small islands inside of the MG Start energizing the LV cables and the distribution transformer (using the storage device) Synchronize the other microsources with the LV network Connect controllable loads taking into account the available storage capability (including motor load start up) Connect non controllable microsources or those without black start capability to get crank power from the energized MicroGrid
MG Black Start Sequence of Actions Change the MG control scheme to Single Master Operation Batteries assumed to be installed in microsource s DC link are not suitable to respond to frequent load variations charge/discharge cycles reduce significantly the life cycle. Flywheel storage systems can operate equally well on frequent shallow discharges and on very deep discharges. Reconnect to the main grid
MicroGrid Black Start Fault in the upstream MV network followed by unsuccessful MG islanding PV Microturbine MV LV Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 30 30
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 31 31
PV Microturbine MV LV Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 32 32
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 33 33
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 34 34
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 35 35
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 36 36
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 37 37
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 38 38
PV Microturbine Wind Gen Storage Device Fuel Cell 39 39
MG Black Start Test System The fast transients associated with the initial stages of the MG restoration process were analysed using an EMTP RV tool, being the long term dynamics evaluated using the MatLab Simulink simulation platform
MG Black Start Results Small Islands Synchronization 50 Frequency (Hz) 49.5 49 SSMT 1 SSMT 2 SSMT 3 48.5 0 10 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 40 Active Power (kw) 30 10 0 SSMT 1 SSMT 2 SSMT 3-10 0 10 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Time (s)
MG Black Start Results Development of the Service Restoration Procedure Frequency (Hz) Active Power (kw) Active Power (kw) 50.4 50.2 50 49.8 49.6 90 100 110 1 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 0 210 2 40 0 MG main storage - 90 100 110 1 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 0 210 2 SSMT 1 60 SSMT 2 SSMT 3 40 0 load connection WG connection PVs connection Motor load start up 90 100 110 1 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 0 210 2 Time (s)
MV Restauration from the MV side Impact in frequency from a sequence of restauration actions 50.4 Frequência (Hz) 50.2 50 49.8 0 100 0 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Tempo (s) Impact in the voltage from a sequence of restauration actions Tensão (p.u.) 1.06 1.04 1.02 1 0.98 0.96 Subestação AT-MT (NMV) Pior Caso (NMVR13A) 0 100 0 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Tempo (s) Evento Data Local 43
Summary and Main Conclusions Key issues for a successful MG islanded operation: An adequate sizing of storage devices coupled with static converters in order to provide efficient frequency and voltage control in the islanded MG The implementation of efficient load shedding mechanisms Secondary load frequency control Rules and conditions to be checked during the restoration stage by the MG components can be derived and evaluated via simulation to identify feasible procedures Hybrid bottom up / top down approaches can be adopted to reduce the total restauration time following a black, which will increase resilience of distribution grids and of the power system as whole.