ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTION TABULATION OF BIDS CONTRACT # 2017021 TRACS No. Project No. County District Gross Length Net Length Prepared By: 999 UN 999 H873601C 999-A-(436)T 16961 UNKNOWN CENTRAL 0 Rik Richter Highway Termini Location Work Description STATEWIDE VARIOUS LOCATIONS WEIGH-IN-MOTION INSTALLATIONS
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 1 of 8 BID RESULTS FOR 2017021 Bid Opening Date : 7/28/2017, Prequalification Required, Engineer Specialist : Rik Richter Completion Date: 200 Working Days The proposed Weigh-In-Motion Installations project is located at 16 locations statewide. The proposed work consists of installing Weigh-in-Motion (WIM) systems that includes installation of loop detectors, quartz piezoelectric sensors, poles, cabinets, foundations, equipment and solar panels. The work also includes horizontal directional drilling of conduit, loop lead in cable, pull boxes, activation of the WIM systems,.and other related items. Bid Rank Department Estimate Bid Amount Contractor Extended Sum of s +% $2,060,000.00 DEPARTMENT ESTIMATE $2,060,000.00 1 +12.5% $2,318,270.00 2 +20.7% $2,486,942.00 3 +25.4% $2,584,246.80 4 +46.4% $3,015,838.94 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC 2035 W. MOUNTAIN VIEW ROAD PHOENIX, AZ 85021 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. 22023 N 20TH AVE SUITE A PHOENIX, AZ 85027 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. 11056 AIR PARK ROAD ASHLAND, VA 25005 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. 3820 W. Happy Valley Road, Ste. 141 #496 Glendale, AZ 85310 Winning Bidder is 12.5% Over Department Estimate (Difference = $258,270.00) $2,318,270.00 $2,486,942.00 $2,584,246.80 $3,015,838.94
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 2 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 7016030 EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE II, VERT.PANEL, TUBULAR MARKER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 10,000.000 $0.300 $3,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.150 $1,500.00-50.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $1,500.00-50.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1.190 $11,900.00 +296.7% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.250 $2,500.00-16.7% 7016031 EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE III, HIGH LEVEL FLAG TREES) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,020.000 $0.750 $765.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.350 $357.00-53.3% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.450 $459.00-40.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $3.570 $3,641.40 +376.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.590 $601.80-21.3% 7016032 EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (RIGID) Bid Rank Department Estimate 172.000 $0.600 $103.20 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.650 $111.80 +8.3% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.000 $172.00 +66.7% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $4.760 $818.72 +693.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.590 $101.48-1.7% 7016033 EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (SPRING TYPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,310.000 $0.800 $1,048.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.550 $720.50-31.2% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.700 $917.00-12.5% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $4.760 $6,235.60 +495.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.590 $772.90-26.3% 7016035 EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE A) Bid Rank Department Estimate 3,522.000 $0.200 $704.40 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.200 $704.40 +0.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $704.40 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $0.600 $2,113.20 +200.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.170 $598.74-15.0% 7016037 EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE C) Bid Rank Department Estimate 10,000.000 $0.300 $3,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.200 $2,000.00-33.3% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $2,000.00-33.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $0.600 $6,000.00 +100.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.170 $1,700.00-43.3%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 3 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 7016050 EACH-DAY TRUCK MOUNTED ATTENUATOR Bid Rank Department Estimate 102.000 $600.000 $61,200.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $90.000 $9,180.00-85.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $600.000 $61,200.00 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $416.750 $42,508.50-30.5% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $760.020 $77,522.04 +26.7% 7016051 EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (LESS THAN 10 S.F.) Bid Rank Department Estimate 172.000 $0.550 $94.60 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.400 $68.80-27.3% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.500 $86.00-9.1% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $5.950 $1,023.40 +981.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.540 $92.88-1.8% 7016052 EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (10 S.F. OR MORE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,310.000 $0.650 $851.50 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.400 $524.00-38.5% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.500 $655.00-23.1% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $5.950 $7,794.50 +815.4% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.650 $851.50 +0.0% 7016061 EACH-DAY FLASHING ARROW PANEL Bid Rank Department Estimate 28.000 $20.000 $560.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $21.000 $588.00 +5.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $50.000 $1,400.00 +150.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $178.610 $5,001.08 +793.1% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $12.290 $344.12-38.6% 7016067 EACH-DAY CHANGEABLE MESSAGE BOARD (CONTRACTOR FURNISHED) Bid Rank Department Estimate 102.000 $35.000 $3,570.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $37.000 $3,774.00 +5.7% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $50.000 $5,100.00 +42.9% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $238.140 $24,290.28 +580.4% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $38.410 $3,917.82 +9.7% 7016075 HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (CIVILIAN) Bid Rank Department Estimate 256.000 $50.000 $12,800.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $52.000 $13,312.00 +4.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $49.000 $12,544.00-2.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $67.360 $17,244.16 +34.7% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $41.280 $10,567.68-17.4%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 4 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 7016080 HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (DPS) Bid Rank Department Estimate 816.000 $65.260 $53,252.16 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $65.260 $53,252.16 +0.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $65.260 $53,252.16 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $65.260 $53,252.16 +0.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $65.260 $53,252.16 +0.0% 7310010 EACH POLE (TYPE A) Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $850.000 $12,750.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $455.000 $6,825.00-46.5% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $575.000 $8,625.00-32.4% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1,382.420 $20,736.30 +62.6% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $983.270 $14,749.05 +15.7% 7310197 EACH BREAKAWAY BASE FOR LIGHTING POLE OR SIGNAL FLASHER Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $400.000 $6,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $460.000 $6,900.00 +15.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $540.000 $8,100.00 +35.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $244.700 $3,670.50-38.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $558.830 $8,382.45 +39.7% 7310200 EACH POLE FOUNDATION (TYPE A) Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $750.000 $11,250.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $835.000 $12,525.00 +11.3% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $800.000 $12,000.00 +6.7% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1,572.000 $23,580.00 +109.6% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1,386.480 $20,797.20 +84.9% 7320070 L.FT. ELECTRICAL CONDUIT (3") (PVC) Bid Rank Department Estimate 740.000 $15.000 $11,100.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $21.000 $15,540.00 +40.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $10.000 $7,400.00-33.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $10.990 $8,132.60-26.7% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $18.390 $13,608.60 +22.6% 7320294 L.FT. ELECTRICAL CONDUIT (3") (HDPE) (DIRECTIONAL DRILL) Bid Rank Department Estimate 900.000 $37.000 $33,300.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $50.000 $45,000.00 +35.1% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $27.500 $24,750.00-25.7% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $78.930 $71,037.00 +113.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $56.590 $50,931.00 +52.9%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 5 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 7320420 EACH PULL BOX (NO. 7) Bid Rank Department Estimate 36.000 $800.000 $28,800.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $575.000 $20,700.00-28.1% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1,050.000 $37,800.00 +31.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $846.100 $30,459.60 +5.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $693.240 $24,956.64-13.3% 7340030 EACH CONTROL CABINET (TYPE III) Bid Rank Department Estimate 15.000 $2,900.000 $43,500.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $1,130.000 $16,950.00-61.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1,050.000 $15,750.00-63.8% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1,963.820 $29,457.30-32.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3,077.130 $46,156.95 +6.1% 7350040 EACH LOOP DETECTOR (WIM) (6' X 9') Bid Rank Department Estimate 36.000 $1,000.000 $36,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $980.000 $35,280.00-2.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $650.000 $23,400.00-35.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1,320.530 $47,539.08 +32.1% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1,237.930 $44,565.48 +23.8% 7350165 L.FT. LOOP DETECTOR LEAD-IN CABLE Bid Rank Department Estimate 1,440.000 $1.500 $2,160.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $0.750 $1,080.00-50.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.000 $1,440.00-33.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1.640 $2,361.60 +9.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2.120 $3,052.80 +41.3% 9010001 L.SUM MOBILIZATION Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $205,091.140 $205,091.14 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $264,817.340 $264,817.34 +29.1% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $249,967.440 $249,967.44 +21.9% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $306,879.180 $306,879.18 +49.6% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $273,886.000 $273,886.00 +33.5% 9240011 L.SUM FORCE ACCOUNT WORK (PULLBOX AND CONDUIT RECONDITITIONING) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,500.000 $3,500.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 6 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 9240014 L.SUM FORCE ACCOUNT WORK (LANDSCAPE REPAIRS) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,500.000 $3,500.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3,500.000 $3,500.00 +0.0% 9240015 L.SUM FORCE ACCOUNT WORK (QUARTZ SENSOR INSTALLATION AND TRAINING) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $25,000.000 $25,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $25,000.000 $25,000.00 +0.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $25,000.000 $25,000.00 +0.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $25,000.000 $25,000.00 +0.0% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $25,000.000 $25,000.00 +0.0% 9240100 L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS WORK (RECORD DRAWING DOCUMENTATION) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1.000 $3,500.000 $3,500.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $14,560.000 $14,560.00 +316.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2,000.000 $2,000.00-42.9% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $28,134.540 $28,134.54 +703.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $52,898.430 $52,898.43 +1411.4% 9240121 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (QUARTZ SENSOR, 1.75M 40M CABLE AND GROUT) Bid Rank Department Estimate 120.000 $8,000.000 $960,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $7,440.000 $892,800.00-7.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $8,950.000 $1,074,000.00 +11.9% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $7,732.710 $927,925.20-3.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $9,903.430 $1,188,411.60 +23.8% 9240122 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (QUARTZ SENSOR, 1.75M 100M CABLE AND GROUT) Bid Rank Department Estimate 24.000 $8,500.000 $204,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $8,400.000 $201,600.00-1.2% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $9,000.000 $216,000.00 +5.9% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $8,430.590 $202,334.16-0.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $11,035.240 $264,845.76 +29.8% 9240133 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (INSTALL CABINET EQUIPMENT, TEST AND CALIBRATE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $6,000.000 $96,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $855.000 $13,680.00-85.8% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2,100.000 $33,600.00-65.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $654.980 $10,479.68-89.1% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2,436.870 $38,989.92-59.4%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 7 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 9240134 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (DATA RECORDER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $13,000.000 $208,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $38,100.000 $609,600.00 +193.1% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $35,175.000 $562,800.00 +170.6% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $38,069.670 $609,114.72 +192.8% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $44,000.000 $704,000.00 +238.5% 9240135 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (COMMUNICATION EQUIPMENT) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $1,000.000 $16,000.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $1,080.000 $17,280.00 +8.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1,050.000 $16,800.00 +5.0% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $1,338.730 $21,419.68 +33.9% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1,506.740 $24,107.84 +50.7% 9240136 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (40 WATT - 12 VOLT SOLAR PANEL MODULE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 14.000 $220.000 $3,080.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $240.000 $3,360.00 +9.1% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $225.000 $3,150.00 +2.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $319.900 $4,478.60 +45.4% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $389.070 $5,446.98 +76.8% 9240171 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (90 WATT - 12 VOLT SOLAR PANEL MODULE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 2.000 $300.000 $600.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $360.000 $720.00 +20.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $325.000 $650.00 +8.3% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $435.390 $870.78 +45.1% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $601.280 $1,202.56 +100.4% 9240172 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (TOP OF POLE MOUNT WITH 4" WELDED GIMBAL) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $110.000 $1,760.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $665.000 $10,640.00 +504.5% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $45.000 $720.00-59.1% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $141.290 $2,260.64 +28.4% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2,122.160 $33,954.56 +1829.2% 9240173 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (12 VOLT 6 AMP CHARGE CONTROLLER WITH LVD) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $60.000 $960.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $345.000 $5,520.00 +475.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $625.000 $10,000.00 +941.7% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $741.400 $11,862.40 +1135.7% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $502.250 $8,036.00 +737.1%
Printed: 8/23/2017 Page 8 of 8 Measure Description Quantity Unit Price Extended Amount 9240175 EACH MISCELLANEOUS WORK (100 AMP HOUR 12 VOLT SEALED LEAD ACID BATTERIES) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16.000 $200.000 $3,200.00 1 ROADWAY ELECTRIC, LLC $300.000 $4,800.00 +50.0% 2 C S CONSTRUCTION, INC. $375.000 $6,000.00 +87.5% 3 DIGITAL TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC. $480.640 $7,690.24 +140.3% 4 N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $502.250 $8,036.00 +151.1%