Evaluating the impact of feedstock quality on delivered cost: Two case studies from the US Southeast region Laurence Eaton*, Matthew Langholtz, Craig Brandt, Erin Webb, Mark Downing Oak Ridge National Laboratory November 5, 2012
Motivation Forest resources represent significant quantity of projected biomass for new uses (between 178-367 MMDT/yr, 23-33% of primary resources in 2030) but vary in Quality, price availability, yield assumptions What is the delivered cost of woody feedstocks that incorporate feedstock quality and yield growth? What is impact of feedstock supply mix when the cost to clean up lower quality feedstocks is incorporated into delivered cost. Fits within a multi-lab study of optimal facility size for woodusing thermochemical conversion facility in US Southeast, though applicable to biopower 2 Managed by UT-Battelle
Initial Results from Two Sites Delivered price ($/dt) $70 $60 $50 $40 $30 $20 $10 $0 Rankin, 5MM base Aiken, 5MM, Base Aiken, 5MM, high-yield - 1 2 3 4 5 Million Dry Tons/year Three curves shown, no difference between Base and HY implies no SRWC supplying feedstock demand 1.9 Million DT/year = ~164 Mil gal/yr 3 Managed by UT-Battelle
Methodology: Resource Potential Estimates Utilized Billion Ton Projections Nutshell: BT2 provides gross potential of dedicated energy crops (from cropland and pasture) and primary forest and agricultural residues Supply curves of resources potentially available at farmgate/forest landing prices of $40-80/dry ton Assume all forecasted demands (food, feed, fiber, exports) are met before energy crops are grown Relative prices and returns are explicitly accounted for, used a profit maximizing model that chooses highest profiting crop for landowner subject to existing market and environmental sustainability constraints Energy crops compete for land with traditional crops and pasture systems as well as other energy crops Residues are available in all years; however, woody crops (noncoppice) begin to mature by 2021 4 Managed by UT-Battelle
Methodology: Resource Potential Estimates (continued) The BT2 included some instances of competition among dedicated energy feedstocks Avoided these irregularities by removing projected prices for herbaceous feedstocks altogether Areas where woody-using facilities would be cited would be unlikely to provide landowners with long-term contracts for grasses Resources considered for facilities: Primary Forest Resources include: Logging Residues, Forestland thinnings, Non-coppice Woody Crops, Pulpwood for Bioenergy Smoothed SRWC production to account for flexibility in harvest length Averaged projected harvests in 2022 across stands maturing in 2021-2023 5 Managed by UT-Battelle
Methodology: Throat Supply Curves BT2 Supplies are estimated at the farmgate/forest landing Do NOT include transportation, logistics, storage, and pre-processing needed to get supplies to biomass using facilities Supply Characterization Model (formerly ORIBAS) estimates the delivered cost of feedstocks Dumps all feedstocks at county centroids, solves location for facility at optimal road network intersections and feedstock supply Executed model to solve locations to supply 5 million dry tons/year, chose two potential sites #1 Rank: Rankin, Mississippi (High Density) #5 Rank: Aiken, South Carolina (Low Density) 6 Managed by UT-Battelle
Methodology: Feedstock Quality Disaggregated the primary forest feedstock base into two feedstock categories Low Quality: Thinnings, Residues High Quality: Pulpwood for bioenergy, SRWC (predominantly pine in this region) Forced cleaning of Low Quality Resources at +10/dt cost increments to identify when High Quality Resources gain a competitive advantage over Low Quality Resources (effectively tax low quality) Used Baseline Scenario and High Yield (3%) Scenario 7 Managed by UT-Battelle
Low Density, Aiken, SC $100 $90 $80 $70 $60 $50 $40 $30 $20 $10 $0 0 1 2 3 4 Million dry tons per year BL HY +$10 BL +$10 HY +$20 BL +$20 HY +$30 BL +$30 HY 8 Managed by UT-Battelle
High Density, Rankin, MS $100 $90 $80 $70 $60 $50 $40 BL HY $30 $20 $10 $0 +$10 BL +$10 HY +$20 BL +$20 HY +$30 BL +$30 HY 0 1 2 3 4 Million dry tons 9 Managed by UT-Battelle
Results Low Q and High Q Feedstocks at $0/dt preprocessing costs Aiken, SC Facility Size (dry tons/day) 551 1102 2205 5512 Marginal Delivery Price ($/dt) Baseline $ 37.60 $ 40.96 $ 44.76 $ 54.57 +10 $ 47.60 $ 50.96 $ 54.76 $ 64.30 +20 $ 56.84 $ 60.69 $ 64.39 $ 72.22 +30 $ 65.62 $ 68.71 $ 71.84 $ 78.13 High Yield $ 37.60 $ 40.96 $ 44.76 $ 54.57 +10 $ 47.60 $ 50.96 $ 54.76 $ 63.09 +20 $ 55.62 $ 58.87 $ 62.77 $ 69.05 +30 $ 61.46 $ 63.65 $ 68.71 $ 73.65 Percentage of Supply as SRWC Baseline 0% 0% 0% 0% +10 0% 0% 0% 1% +20 14% 7% 3% 17% +30 3% 37% 38% 48% 10 Managed by UT-Battelle High Yield 0% 0% 0% 0% +10 0% 0% 0% 12% +20 28% 36% 30% 40% +30 81% 83% 70% 68%
Results Rankin, MS Low Q and High Q Feedstocks at $0/dt preprocessing costs Facility Size (dt/day) 551 1102 2205 5512 Marginal Delivery Price ($/dt) Baseline $ 30.75 $ 34.21 $ 40.33 $ 49.85 +10 $ 40.75 $ 44.21 $ 50.33 $ 58.56 +20 $ 50.75 $ 54.20 $ 58.35 $ 66.52 +30 $ 57.31 $ 58.35 $ 61.74 $ 66.52 High Yield $ 30.75 $ 34.21 $ 40.33 $ 49.85 +10 $ 40.75 $ 44.21 $ 50.33 $ 58.07 +20 $ 50.75 $ 53.81 $ 57.31 $ 62.98 +30 $ 57.31 $ 58.35 $ 61.74 $ 66.52 Percentage as SRWC Baseline 0% 0% 0% 0% +10 0% 0% 0% 3% +20 0% 13% 9% 40% +30 66% 67% 95% 85% 11 Managed by UT-Battelle High Yield 0% 0% 0% 0% +10 0% 0% 0% 12% +20 0% 33% 28% 44% +30 66% 67% 95% 85%
Results, continued Aiken, SC Facility Size (dt/day) 551 1102 2205 5512 Delivery Price Delta (increasing tax) Baseline +10 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 9.73 +20 $ 19.24 $ 19.73 $ 19.63 $ 17.65 +30 $ 28.02 $ 27.75 $ 27.08 $ 23.56 Rankin, MS Facility Size (dt/day) 551 1102 2205 5512 Delivery Price Delta (increasing tax) Baseline +10 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 8.71 +20 $ 20.00 $ 19.99 $ 18.02 $ 16.67 +30 $ 26.56 $ 24.14 $ 21.41 $ 16.67 High Yield +10 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 8.52 +20 $ 18.02 $ 17.91 $ 18.01 $ 14.48 +30 $ 23.86 $ 22.69 $ 23.95 $ 19.08 High Yield +10 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 10.00 $ 8.22 +20 $ 20.00 $ 19.60 $ 16.98 $ 13.13 +30 $ 26.56 $ 24.14 $ 21.41 $ 16.67 12 Managed by UT-Battelle
Discussion Throat supply curves for these two regions are very elastic (high responsiveness of quantity to price) Divergence of Baseline and High Yield occurs at larger facilities sizes and higher low quality feedstock taxes SRWC begin to feed facility demand at pre-processing costs of $10/dt for the Aiken, SC site, and $20/dt for the Rankin, MS site The difference between the Baseline and High Yield throat curves and those with pre-processing costs decrease with facility size and level of pre-processing tax 13 Managed by UT-Battelle
Conclusions and Final Thoughts The price premium for delivered SRWC is $10-20/dt in the representative low density region; $20-30/dt for high density area Region supply inventories is next step, residues are only available when logging is present The price of delivered feedstock is reduced for facility when it can receive many feedstock types, increased when feedstock quality is critical technical constraint Results only suggest feedstock mix from First of a Kind Facility, More facilities=higher prices 14 Managed by UT-Battelle
Thank you for your time! Laurence Eaton Eatonlm@ornl.gov 15 Managed by UT-Battelle
TX ND WI KS LA MN PA MI MS TN AL MO AR FL GA NY KY NC OK VA OH SC WV SD NE IL DE MD NJ VT IN IA ME OR MA NH WA CT RI AZ CA CO ID MT NM NV UT WY Millions dry tons TX LA KS MS WI FL MN AL PA AR TN GA NY KY MI SC NC OK WV OH VA MO ND MD VT IN ME NJ SD MA NH WA IL CT OR DE RI AZ CA CO IA ID MT NE NM NV UT WY Millions dry tons 25 2022 Projected Woody Crops Production, Baseline, $60/dt 20 15 10 5 0 30 2022 Projected Woody Crops Production, High Yield (3%), $60/dt 25 20 15 10 5 0 16 Managed by UT-Battelle
Initial Findings Total available supply/total acreage of state Ballpark estimates for 50 mile radius around facility (operating 365 d/yr, 20% field to throat loss) 500 DT/d=29 dt/mi^2 1000 DT/d=58 dt/mi^2 2000 DT/d=116 dt/mi^2 5000 DT/d=290 dt/mi^2 7500 DT/d=436 dt/mi^2 10000 DT/d=581 dt/mi^2 17 Managed by UT-Battelle
Feedstock Density (dt/sq. mile per year) 300 250 200 150 100 50 $20/dt $30/dt $40/dt $50/dt $60/dt $70/dt $80/dt 0 2000 DMT/d Baseline Feedstock Density Woody Crops and Pulpwood for Bioenergy 1000 DMT/d 500 DMT/d 18 Managed by UT-Battelle
Feedstock Density (dt/sq. mile per year) 300 250 200 150 100 50 $20/dt $30/dt $40/dt $50/dt $60/dt $70/dt $80/dt 0 2000 DMT/d High-Yield ( 3%) Feedstock Density Woody Crops and Pulpwood for Bioenergy 1000 DMT/d 500 DMT/d 19 Managed by UT-Battelle
$40/dt Baseline vs. High Yield 2022 Million Dry Tons Million Dry Tons GA NC MS LA AL VA AR SC WI WA OR KY ME FL TX TN MO PA MN MI CA WV NY IN IL OK OH ID MT NH MD VT IA KS MA NE DE SD CO WY NM AZ ND CT NJ UT RI NV GA NC M LA AL VA AR WI SC W OR KY M FL NY TX TN PA M W M MI CA IN IL OK O ID M VT N M IA KS M NE DE SD CO W N AZ N CT NJ UT RI NV 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 0 4 3.5 3 2.5 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 20 Managed by UT-Battelle 20
TX WI KS PA LA MN MI MS NY GA OH FL AR NC AL SC VA ND MO TN CA KY WV WA IL MD SD ME VT OK NJ CT MA CO IN NH NE OR NV DE MT UT IA ID NM RI WY AZ Million Dry Tons TX AR LA GA MS AL WI NC FL TN MN VA SC NY PA WA OR KY ME MI WV MO CA OH IN IL OK VT NH ID MT MD IA NJ MA KS DE NE CT CO NM SD AZ WY ND UT RI NV Million Dry Tons $50/dt Baseline vs. High Yield 2022 20 15 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 10 5 0 25 20 15 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 10 5 0 21 Managed by UT-Battelle 21
TX WI ND LA PA MS MN KS GA FL MI AL TN NC CA NY MO AR VA KY SC OH OK WA IL WV OR AZ ME IN MD NJ CO MA NV NE SD NM IA UT VT ID NH DE CT MT WY RI Million Dry Tons TX LA MS KS AL GA WI AR FL MN TN PA NC KY SC VA NY MI MO WV WA OR OK ME OH CA IN ND IL MD VT NH AZ ID MT NM CO UT IA NJ MA SD CT DE WY NE NV RI Million Dry Tons $60/dt Baseline vs. High Yield 2022 25 20 15 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 10 5 0 35 30 25 High Quality Primary Forest Resources Low Quality Primary Forest Resources 20 15 10 5 0 22 Managed by UT-Battelle 22
Initial Screening Total available supply/total acreage of county Ballpark estimates for 50 mile radius around facility (operating 365 d/yr, 20% field to throat loss) 500 DT/d=29 dt/mi^2 1000 DT/d=58 dt/mi^2 2000 DT/d=116 dt/mi^2 5000 DT/d=290 dt/mi^2 7500 DT/d=436 dt/mi^2 10000 DT/d=581 dt/mi^2 23 Managed by UT-Battelle
24 Managed by UT-Battelle
25 Managed by UT-Battelle
26 Managed by UT-Battelle