California Harbors & Navigation Code Boating Under the Influence

Transcription

1 1 California Harbors & Navigation Code Boating Under the Influence A boat is a motor vehicle and is subject to many of the same laws and penalties as those regulating cars, trucks, buses or even bicycles when it comes to drinking and operating a boat. Tragic accidents happen every year throughout the country that are attributable to drinking while boating or engaging in water activities. Under California Harbors & Navigation Code 655, it is unlawful to operate a recreational boat while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or to have a blood alcohol concentration level (BAC) of 0.08% or higher. Similar to CVC 23152, you can be charged with two criminal counts being under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs and having a BAC of 0.08%. If you are under the age of 18, you may not have a BAC of 0.02%. Under this section, you are prohibited from operating any of the following vessels or engaging in using certain water equipment while under the influence or being over the legal limit: Motor boats Jet skis Water skis Inner tubes pulled by a motor boat Aquaplane Sailboats with a motor This prohibition does not apply to rowing a boat, kayaking or canoeing. One notable difference between operating a car and a boat is that you may drink and have open containers in your boat. The law just prohibits you from being under the influence or having a BAC of 0.08% while boating. Commercial Boat Operators The limit for operators of commercial boats is 0.04%. Commercial boats include: Fishing boats Tour boats Ferries Sport fishing boats Boating While Causing Injury This code section includes a provision for an aggravated offense found under California Harbors & Navigation Code 655(f). Its provisions state that you can be found guilty of aggravated BUI if you: 1. Operate a vessel or manipulate water skis, jet skis or an aquaplane or similar device 2. While under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs 3. While violating any law or engaging in negligent conduct in operating the vessel or manipulating water skis, jet skis, an aquaplane or similar device 4. And your conduct proximately causes bodily injury to another person

2 Any kind of injury suffices under this section. You must, though, have engaged in speeding or reckless operation or engaged in some other illegal or negligent act that led to the injury. Presumptions of Being under the Influence Anyone who operates a motor vehicle, including a boat, impliedly consents under law to give a sample of their breath or blood for testing of their BAC if a peace officer has probable cause to request it. Refusing to submit can lead to automatic suspension of your driver s license for at least one year depending on whether you have multiple convictions. If your BAC is under 0.05%, you are presumed to not be under the influence (though commercial operators will be charged) but you are presumed that this was your BAC within 3 hours of your operating the vessel. If it is more than 0.05% but under 0.08%, there is no presumption either way but in any case, the DA can still charge you with being under the influence if there are other facts at hand. You are presumed to be under the influence if your BAC is 0.08%. It is also legally presumed that this was your BAC within 3 hours of your operating your vessel or being on water skis and other included devices, though you can challenge the test results as well as show evidence that you were not under the influence to rebut the presumption. It is still possible, though, that you could be found not guilty of being under the influence but guilty of having a BAC of 0.08%. If you refused chemical testing, your refusal can be used against you at trial as proof of your intoxication. Your driver s license will be suspended for a minimum of one year and you likely face jail time. Demeanor or Other Indicia of Intoxication or Under the Influence Harbor patrols and other law enforcement officers are on the lookout for boat operators and water recreational users who exhibit reckless behavior, speeding, equipment violations or other waterway violations. Water skiers generally may not exhibit reckless conduct but the boat operator may. In any case, the officer who observes the conduct or is alerted to it will question the operator and skier and look for signs of drinking and intoxication. While not illegal to drink on a boat, it can certainly cause an officer to inquire further. Signs of possible intoxication or being under the influence include: Watery, bloodshot eyes Slurred speech Confusion over questions asked Irrational or inappropriate responses Stumbling on the vessel Admission to drinking Because it is difficult to administer standard field sobriety tests on a vessel or other craft, an officer can still have you perform certain tests that the officer can use as evidence that you were under the

3 3 influence. The following tests were designed to be used by officers looking for intoxicated boat or motor craft operators: Horizontal gaze nystagmus moving a pen from side to side and seeing how the person tracks it. If there is jerking of the eyes, the officer will consider it an indicia of intoxication Finger- to- nose defendant closes his eyes, tilts his head back 45 degrees and touches his nose. The officer will look to see if the person hesitated or was looking for his nose or not understanding the instructions. Palm pat place hands palm to palm, bottom hand stationary while top hand flips above the bottom hand, touches the palm and returns to palm to palm. Fingers are kept parallel and not off to the side. You count each time the hands make contact. Following directions is a key. Fistful of field both hands are in fist with left fist at center of their chest and right fist against the left. The person counts out loud while moving the fists straight away from the chest in a step by step fashion. After number 4, the person opens their fists and claps 3 times, remembering where their fists just were, before moving their closed fists back to the position it was just in before clapping. The person then does the step by step in reverse order back to their chest, counting from 5 to 8. Finally, the person opens their fists and lays their hands in lap palms down. About 50% of sober individuals get this one right the first time. If the officer feels you performed poorly, then you can be asked to take a breath or blood test. Administrative Per Se Hearing Like the driver of a car who is charged with a DUI, you have a right to an administrative or Per Se hearing before the DMV where the issues are whether there was probable cause to stop and detain you and if your BAC was 0.08%. This hearing does concern your driver s license and not your boating license. If you refused testing, then the issue is whether it was reasonable under the circumstances. Once you are arrested for a BUI, you only have 10 days to file a request for an administrative Per Se hearing pertaining to the revocation or suspension of your driver s and boating license. You can challenge your BAC results or their validity by offering evidence or testimony that the machine was not properly calibrated, was improperly serviced or maintained, that the technician was not certified or that a blood test was tainted. There are numerous challenges that an experienced DUI or BUI defense attorney can raise. Sentencing and Penalties for a BUI A BUI, like a DUI, is a misdemeanor offense. For a first offense, you face up to a year in county jail and/or a fine up to $1,000. More significantly, you can lose your driver s license for 6 months to up to 5 years depending on the circumstances, nature of the boating violations and conduct. Other possible sentences depend on whether you caused injury to someone and if you have a prior offense: If you cause injury to someone, the matter becomes a wobbler, meaning if you are charged with a felony, you face 16 months, 2 or 3 years in county jail. If a misdemeanor for causing injury, you face a mandatory minimum jail sentence of 90 days and a fine up to $5000.

4 If you receive probation on a BUI causing injury with a prior BUI or DUI, you must serve a minimum 90 days in jail. For receiving felony or misdemeanor probation for a non- injury BUI but with a prior non- aggravated BUI within 7 years, you still have to spend a minimum of 5 days in jail. For causing death while operating a boat under the influence, you face up to 10 years in prison. Defenses to a BUI Defenses to a BUI include: Lack of Proof of Intoxication Harbor patrol and other officers can stop your vessel for boating infractions, speeding or reckless conduct. Any of these violations is not necessarily proof that you were under the influence since many people operate their boats irresponsibly or do not obey all boating laws while perfectly sober. Once an officer boards your boat, you may be suspected of being under the influence, especially if you have alcohol onboard or the officer sees passengers drinking. Your demeanor is observed closely but fatigue, dehydration, sun burn and nervousness can mimic signs of intoxication. Your performance on the field sobriety tests that were designed for boat operators can also be affected by these factors that have nothing to do with drinking or taking drugs. Unlawful Stop and Detention Although difficult in many cases to prove, an officer may have stopped your boat and detained you without probable cause. For instance, if the officer had been stopping all boats in the area where the operators were seen to be relatively young or of a particular race, then this is an unlawful justification and lacks probable cause. Invalidity of the Breath or Blood Test No chemical test is fool- proof and results are not uncommonly ruled inadmissible into evidence. There are dozens of ways to challenge a breath and blood test, including: Breathalyzer was not properly calibrated Device was not serviced or maintained according to manual or protocol Testing technician was not certified You regurgitated into the machine You were not observed properly before taking the breath test The blood test results were not properly preserved Chain of evidence not established These are just a sampling of the defects that can occur that can result in a false high reading. Expungement of a BUI Conviction

5 5 Expungement of your criminal conviction pursuant to California Harbors & Navigation Code 655 is possible since sentencing for a misdemeanor or felony under this section does not include serving time in state prison, a factor that will not offer you expungement relief. Under PC , you may petition the court to expunge your BUI conviction. An expungement seals or keeps your record of conviction from appearing on a public database should anyone conduct a criminal background check, including landlords or private employers or any other member of the general public. An expungement does not result in the complete eradication of your conviction record. It remains accessible to public employers, state and federal, including law enforcement and court personnel. And, if you commit another offense, your expunged conviction can be used for sentence enhancement. This is also true for civil purposes such as the Department of Motor Vehicles that will increase your license suspension period. A major benefit of obtaining an expungement is that it enables you to state on any employment application or rental application, even under oath, that you were never convicted of a crime. You do have to disclose your conviction, along with the fact that it was expunged, when doing the following: Applying for a professional license or for public sector employment Applying for elected office Applying for a license or contract with the State Lottery Commission Applying for the military or a law enforcement position a felony expungement will render you ineligible unless you have it reduced to a misdemeanor, if a wobbler, before the expungement Eligibility for Expungement A conviction, misdemeanor or felony, qualifies you for an expungement since no state prison time is imposed for that offense. You may petition the court once you satisfy these other conditions: You completed all conditions of your sentence and probation You have not committed a subsequent offense You have no criminal charges pending You did not violate your violation Minor probation violations do not necessarily render your conviction ineligible so long as you did not commit a serious misdemeanor or a felony offense. A court will review your overall criminal record and your need for the expungement order such as your When applying, you will use Form CR Petition for Dismissal. You can also ask the court to do the following before you file: 1. File a motion to grant early termination of your probation 2. If your conviction was a felony under California Harbors & Navigation Code 655 and a wobbler, petition the court to reduce it to a misdemeanor under PC 17(b)(3) before expunging it. This will allow your Second Amendment right to own or possess a firearm to be reinstated. Further, you will not have to disclose that you were originally convicted of a felony and it will make you at least eligible for military service and for employment by law enforcement.

6 All documents regarding the expungement must be timely served on the DA and probation department to give them an opportunity to contest it. Few expungements are contested by the DA unless there is an obvious disqualifying fact. If granted, you will receive an Order of Dismissal- - Form CR Your record should be removed from public databases within a few months at most.