Challenges in grid planning and market integration moving towards the digital energy shift Trondheim, 28 April 2017 Information Technology and Electrical Engineering the digital energy shift
Click to edit Master title style Page 2
About ENTSO-E 43 TSOs from 36 countries 532 million citizens served 828 GW generation 305 Thousand Km of transmission lines Ten-Year Network Development Plans Adequacy forecasts Market Integration Network Codes RDI
TSO challenges in high RES Page 4
RES does not follow Demand Page 5
A new paradigm for the power system Sept 2016 in Denmark, one week (source Energinet.dk) 6
SO&AF 2015 DK NO 2020 Page 7
Page 8
Page 9
Risks of missing capacity... Risk of missing capacities Source: IHS CERA 2nd Public Stakeholder Consultation Workshop TF ADAM 17 June 2014
Challenges towards a high RES future Page 11
Interconnectors are enablers Page 12
Net-Load ramps to increase significantly - partially balanced by transmission Page 13
RES production is not 100% predictable - forecast errors could be smoothed with more interconnections Page 14
TYNDP 2016 putting the right infrastructure in place to integrate renewables 2x more interconnection capacities by 2030 Integrating up to 60% renewable energy sources Up to 5 /Megawatt hour reduction on bulk power prices 1% increase in the total consumer bill 150 billion investment 50 80% emissions down 30 90 TWh reduced RES spillage
Market Design needs revision Page 16
The current market design needs adjustment Missing market design Enable scarcity pricing Integrate RES and Demand into the market EU Framework" for CRM Adequacy-based Cross border participation Signals to Customer Dynamic pricing Easy to switch Data management, smart meters and hubs New Governance DSO-TSO cooperation Regional TSO cooperation Stronger NRAs and MS cooperation 17
PRICE SIGNALS REFLECTING THE REAL COST OF ELECTRICITY Prices should drive power usage, dispatch and investments Prices should thus reflect the actual situation of the system Enable scarcity prices in all market timeframes (DA, ID, Balancing) Imbalance prices to be more costreflective (up to VOLL in times of scarcity) Introduce dynamic pricing at retail level Markets should value flexibility and all system services Allow development of risk-hedging products to protect oneself against price volatility 18
ENCOURAGE DEMAND RESPONSE by: Allowing customers to play their part in supporting the system and therefore reducing the need for additional thermal generation capacities Moving from flat rates to dynamic pricing Avoiding the price-blunting effect of some taxes and levies put on electricity HOW? Offering customers different types of power contracts/options to make profit of their flexibility potential Allowing customers to value this flexibility in all markets and regardless of which grid they are connected to or which supplier they have a contract with 19
Click What to steps edit forward Master to title improve style RES integration into the market? 1 Phase out of the priority dispatch for RES 2 Expose mature renewable energy sources to the market 3 Renewable energy sources need to have balancing responsibilities 4 RES support needs to be market-based 5 Create a regional and European framework for RES support
The (digital) Energy Shift Page 21
DELIVERING THE ENERGY TRANSITION 27% renewables by 2030 = +/- 45% for the power system NEW CHALLENGES Wind System stability Resource variability New connections Changed power flows Integrating demand-side resources Empowering consumers & managing data Unlocking flexibility Hydro Solar Flow North-East South-West Flow North-south
Click EMPOWERING to edit Master THE CONSUMER title style Some countries are using dynamic pricing Dynamic retail pricing registered in EU legislation Implementation of: Europe wide market coupling (CACM) Balancing network code as facilitator of demand response Data privacy and security Demand response for balancing and other markets Smart apps, data hubs, non-discriminatory access well integrated with DSOs/TSOs software Compliance with data protection regulation 2020 INNOVATION 2025 23
Different risks should be addressed in different time horizons Short term Mid term 6 months 1 year 5 years 10 years Operational decisions UNCERTAINTIES Investment decisions Policy/political decisions Page 24
Page 25
Page 26
TYNDP 2016 Viability of the energy mix insight report Challenges Issues Mitigating actions Reduction of system inertia Voltage System strength Need for flexibility Total system inertia ROCOF Frequency containment Voltage control means Voltage dips Fault level for converter stable operation Fault current for protections Balancing Synthetic inertia and frequency containment provision Securing large imbalances Implementation of NCs Synchronous compensators Unit commitment constraints Investments on the network side: synchronous condensers, SVCs Implementation of NCs Implementation of NCs - fault current contribution of converterbased sources Expectable evolution of transmission system protection schemes towards more differential protections System interconnections New flexibility sources at relevant timescales Page 27
TYNDP 2016 Scenarios = Mid-term common scenario (EP2020 = Sc.B 2020) Page 28
TYNDP 2016 Scenarios Bottom-up: collection from national correspondents Top-down: constructed by a team of experts Page 29
TYNDP 2016 Insight on Reduction of system inertia Synchronous area equivalent inertia H[s] for Continental Europe (CE) Synchronous area equivalent inertia H[s] for Great Britain (GB) 2020 2030 2030 2030 2030 2020 2030 2030 2030 2030 Page 30
[TAKE AWAYs] FOCUS TECHNICAL AREAS FOR THE DIGITAL SHIFT Generation and Transmission Technology Development / Availability / Flexibility Lack of inertia /Synthetic inertia / Adequacy risks therein Less Synchronous Generation /Reactive System Strength/Voltage collapse Network survival from system split in New Energy World Network operation in New Energy World Rise of Simultaneous New Technologies / Need for interoperability DSO TSO / Prosumers / Smart Grids Page 31
Thank you for your attention Daniel Huertas Hernando Scenarios, Market Analysis, Adequacy Daniel.HuertasHernando@elia.be