Regional Workshop on Transport Sector Inspection and Maintenance Policy in Asia Bangkok, 1-12 December 21 Kiyoyuki Minato Japan Automobile Research Institute 1
Air pollution and Traffic congestion Every day, We are facing these problems No Rule Mixed Traffic, Persons and Motor vehicles High Sulphur fuels Poor maintenance 2
Analysis of Motorcycle and Passenger Car Dissemination (1986 vs 1996 ) Number of motorcycles per 1 persons 1 1 1 1 Motorcycle dissemination range 1 Under $1, India Under $1, Thailand Taiwan Malaysia Japan Italy South Korea France Germany Australia South Africa United Kingdom Passenger car dissemination range 1 1 1 1 Number of cars per 1 persons $1, und up 3
Fighting Urban Air Pollution From Plan to Action For Clean Air in Asia, Technical Approach Vehicle Inspection & Maintenance System Improved Fuel Quality 3. Develop Vehicle Emission Standards 4. Use of Alternative Fuels CNG,LPG etc. 5. Better Traffic Management (Traffic Congestion) 4
Air Pollution in Big Cities TSP SO2 CO NO2 Japan(Tokyo) B A A B B A China(Beijing) E D D D C B Korea(Seoul) B B A C B A Taiwan ( Taipei ) D B B B B B Thailand(Bangkok) E B B B B C MalaysiaiKLj B B C C C C Indonesia(Jakarta) D C C B C C The Philippines(Manila) D B D D D C An atmospheric inside density of each material : com pared with the WHO standard. A :Very low pollution,who guidelines exceeded by less than a factor of half. B :Low pollution, WHO guideline are normally met. C :Moderate to heavy pollution, WHO guidelines exceed by up to a factor of two. D :Moderate to heavy pollution, WHO guidelines exceed by up to a factor of three. E :Serious problem, WHO guidelines exceeded by more than a factor of three. O3 Pb 5 Source: WHO
For Clean Air in Asia Viewpoint of Technical Approach Clean Vehicle Technology Appropriate Maintenance Vehicle Emission Control Clean Fuels 6
IInspection & Maintenance (1)I & M programs are key feature of pollution reduction strategies (2)Simple routine maintenance can reduce emissions dramatically (3)Older diesels are a major source of SPM 7
Purpose for Inspection & Maintenance in Japan Prevent Air pollution Reduce fuel consumption Secure Safety 8
1 before192 Market Share in Used-Vehicles 1 before191 market sharei%j 8 6 4 2 193 194 195 196 197 198 market sharei%j 8 6 4 2 192 193 194 195 196 197 1 Car MC Bus Truck Malaysia(1999) 19 before191 1 Car MC Bus Truck Indonesia(1998) 198 before191 8 6 4 2 Car MC Bus Truck Thailand(1998) 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 market sharei%j 8 6 4 2 Car MC Bus Truck Taiwan(1998) 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 9
INPUT Energy consumption Gasoline, Diesel, CNG Automobile regulations Fuel economy Emissions Flowchart of Asia JARI model Car stock estimation by 23 International trade scheme Automobile market Ownership and income Sales Car stock Average car price Diffusion rate of vehicles Socio-economic factor Population GDP growth Living expenditure Emission gases from vehicles estimation by scenario OUTPUT Proposition for Energy policy Environmental policy and sustainable development Living expenditure fn. 1
Passenger Cars and Emission gas Trend 6. Thailand 5. Indonesia Passenger Cars 4. 3. 2. 1. 16 14 12 1 8 6 4 BAU EURO2 EURO2+I/M. 21 26 211 216 221 226 Year Emission gas from Passenger cars 8 Thailand Indonesia 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 BAU EURO2 EURO2+I/M 2 21 26 211 216 221 226 Year 21 26 211 216 221 226 Year 11
Basic Legal system for Vehicle Environmental Pollution Control Setting of Environmental quality standards for air pollution Environmental Pollution Control Air Pollution Standard Setting of permissible limits for vehicle emissions Road Vehicle Act ( I & M ) Consideration for assurance of permissible limits 12
Effects of Vehicle Inspections For Prevention of Environmental Pollution 1. Reduction of Exhaust Emissions 2. Reduction of Noise Emission 3. Saving of Fuel 4. Enhancement of User s Consciousness for Vehicle Safety and Pollution Control 13
For International Hamonization of Vehicle Standards Past Own Vehicle safety standards and Environmental Pollution Standards Future International Harmonization of Vehicle Standards (1)Merits on Administration Streamlined International distribution (2)Merits on Manufacturers Standardization of Auto Parts (3)Merits on Users Expanded Choice of Imported Vehicles Reduction in Prices of Vehicles 14
Improved Fuel Quality Phase out Leaded Gasoline Reduction of Sulfur Content (1)Around 85% of gasoline sold worldwide is unleaded. (2)Quick phase out is possible : Thailand 5 years (3)Average phase out cost is US$ 1-2 cents/liter (refinery modification etc.) 15
Leaded to Unleaded Gasoline in Asia Japan United States Thailand 1996 1996 1997 1998 1999 2 198 1996 Korea 1998 Taiwan 2 Singapore 2 Malaysia 2 Philippines China Indonesia India Vietnam leaded gasoline leaded gasoline unleaded gasoline 45% unleaded gasoline 45-5% unleaded gasoline 5% 16
Sulfur Reduction Program for Diesel Fuel in Asia 1996 1997 1998 1999 2 Japan United States Korea Taiwan.5%.5%.5%.5% Singapore.5%.5% Thailand.25%.5% Malaysia.5%.5% Philippines.5%.3-.5% China.5%.2% Indonesia India.5%.5% Vietnam 1.% 17
Sulphur Free Fuels for Diesel Fuel Maximum sulphur content limits (ppm) 5 4 3 2 1 Japan EU USA Final target : sulphur free Year 18
Trends in SO 2 CO NMHC Concentration in Japan Annual Average SO2 Conc. ppm.3.25.2.15.1.5 SO2 CO Sulfur in Diesel Fuel.5% -->.2% NMHC *1 Sulfur in Diesel Fuel.2% -->.5% 197 1975 198 1985 199 1995 2 12 1 8 6 4 2 Annual Average CO, NMHC Conc. ppm, ppmc F.Y. Average at Roadside Air Pollution Monitoring Stations Government data 19
Emission Standards (1)Improved Fuel Quality (2)Reduce Local/Global Air Pollution (3)Influence Urban Form (4)Energy-Saving Measures for Motor Vehicles CO2 emission reduction Improvements of Motor Vehicle Fuel Consumption 2
Emission Standards in APEC Emission Standards in Asia Bangladesh 95 96 97 98 99 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 Cambodia Euro1 propsed Hong Kong Euro1 Euro2 Euro3 Step1 Step2 Step3 India Euro1 Euro2 Euro3 Indonesia Euro1 propsed Euro2 propsed Malaysia Euro1 Step1 Step2 Philippines Euro1 Step1 Step1 Step2 PRC Euro1 Euro2 Step1 Step2 Thailand Euro1 Euro2 Euro3 propsed Step1 Step2 Step3 Step4 Vietnam Euro1 Step1 Emission Standards in Europe Car STEP 2 STEP 3 LDV HDV STEP 4 STEP 2 STEP 3 STEP 4 EURO 2 EURO 3 EURO 4 EURO 1@introduction 1992 STEP 1 introduction 1992 21
Comparison of Passenger car Emissions Standards Useful Life (km) ( Nitrogen Oxide (NOx) limits ) Tier 2 : 193,8km Euro4 : 1,km New-Long : 8,km.4.3 Japan EU US Gasoline Tier 1.8.6 Tier 1 Euro 3 Diesel fuel NOx g/km.2.1 NLEV Euro 3 New- short Euro 4 Tier 2 New-long NOx g/km.4.2 New- short NLEV Euro 4 New-long Tier 2 Year Year 22
Comparison of Heavy-Duty Diesel NOx & PM Standards ( NOx, PM limits g/k-wh) 6 Japan EU US NOx.3 PM 4 g/kw-hr 2 New-Short Euro 3 Euro 4 g/kw-hr.2.1 Euro 3 New-Short New-Long New-Long Euro 4 Year Year 23
Use of Alternative fuels (1)Advanced biomass to liquid fuel conversion. (2)Argentina, Egypt and India have major CNG initiative (3)Economic for vehicles with high annual usagebuses, trucks (4)Tax incentives for clean vehicles (5)Initial additional capital cost offset by lower fuel. 24
Use of Clean-Energy Vehicles Short Cruising distance Long Subcompacts and small cars Electric vehicles Hybrid cars Passenger cars Trucks and buses CNG vehicles (in areas offering CNG supply) Methanol cars Diesel-replacement LPG cars 25
Traffic Congestion (1)Economic loss (2)The main factor of air pollution (3)Deterioration of public transport service and increase of private car use 26
Effects of Vehicle Inspections For Safety of in-use Vehicles 1. Reduction of Road Traffic Accidents due to Poor Maintenance 2. Improvement of Road Traffic Congestion due to Mechanical Trouble 3. Control of Illegally Modified Vehicles 4. Thoroughness of Recall Campaign 27
Average Speeds of Travel by Regions 25 Asian cities delay of road construction rapid increase of vehicles poor traffic light system Mixed Traffic, Persons and Motor vehicles 3 6 2 25 5 15 1 2 15 1 4 3 2 5 5 1 Average speed (km/h) Average speed (km/h) Average speed (km/h) EU 3-4km USA: 5-6km Asia: 1-2km 28
Vehicle speed / Fuel economy & Emission Vehicle speed : 6-8km/h is best for good fuel economy & low exhaust emission Fuel economy index 12 1 8 R 6 w 4 2 4km/h=1 Asia cities zone Economy zone NOxrow NOx emission 5 4 3 2 1 4km/h=1 Asia cities zone Economy zone 11 22 33 44 55 66 77 88 99 11 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ˇ km/h 4km/h1 Rw otfijœ{'fi Ł Vehicle speed (km/h) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ˇ km/h Vehicle speed (km/h) 4km/h1 Rw otfijœ{'fi Ł 29
LRT in Asia Reduction of Traffic Congestion Reduce air pollution Bangkok, Thailand 3 Kuala Lumpur Malaysia
ITS/EV City Car System Demonstration Project in Yokohama Control center Information service Navigation data Battery power warning Call button Reservation and billing service Telephone and Internet Fee payment Remote management Data entry Vehicle monitoring;emergency message Audio service Customers and business partners Round trip One-way trip Member/user Vehicle station Unmanned rental service ID authentication/rental/ return Door locking/unlocking Fee confirmation Other vehicle stations 31
Proposition in Asia Countries Improved Vehicle Inspection Improved Cleaner Fuels phase out leaded gasoline reduction of sulfur contents 3. Improved Vehicle Emissions Standards 4. Promotion for Clean Fuel Vehicles CNG,EV, etc 32