ONE PERSON TRAIN OPERATION Mike Palmer Deputy Chief Operating Officer
OPTO: STATUS UPDATE Definitin f ne persn train peratin Best practice wrld wide Benefits Cncept f peratins Impact n peple and assets Timelines and milestnes Current status Safety cncerns Next steps Pst intrductin f OPTO 2
DEFINITION One Persn Train Operatin (OPTO) is a technlgical change and mdernizing step that remves the need fr a guard n the train and permits the driver f the train t becme a Train Operatr - respnsible fr the safe driving f the train, peratinal incidents, peratin f the train drs and train dr mnitring n departure 3
JUSTFICATION FOR CHANGE Technlgy has develped s that ne crew member can safely drive the train AND perate dr cntrls; The vast majrity f subway authrities perate trains with a single crew member including Paris, Lndn Undergrund, Chicag, LA, Mntreal, Hng Kng, Berlin, Lisbn, Madrid, Glasgw, Stckhlm, Bangkk Recent cnversins t OPTO include Philadelphia and Lndn Overgrund Ntable exceptins include New Yrk and Trnt NO subway has reverted back t tw persn peratin n the grunds f safety 4
SOME METRO / SUBWAY EXAMPLES Lndn First ATC/ OPTO Victria line 1968 First manual train/opto - Piccadilly Line 1987 Last OPTO line Nrthern line cmpleted 2000 Chicag Yellw line - OPTO since pening in 1964 Full cnversin t OPTO f full system in 1998 Bstn Started in 1996 (Blue line) and finished in 2012 with the Red line 5
SUBURBAN RAIL TOO A CASE STUDY Lndn Overgrund 60% f the netwrk was already OPTO Cnversin f an additinal line t OPTO in 2013 prmpted a strike by the RMT unin claiming custmer safety wuld be cmprmised Verified statistics frm Transprt fr Lndn OPTO lines had ne dr related incident fr every 7m passengers Cnventinal lines had ne dr related incident fr every 4m passengers OPTO intrduced after strike 6
AND CLOSER TO HOME The SRT (line 3) has perated safely with One Persn Train Operatin since its pening in March 1985. 7
BENEFITS Huge ptential fr lng term savings Line 4 pilt facilitates rllut t lines 1 & 2 at a later date Safer Guarding Clearer and mre cmprehensive view f platfrm (3 views) Full benefits realized at ATC intrductin when driving wrklad further decreases Reinvestment int imprved efficiency TTC increasing statin staff presence Incidents managed as efficiently with statin based supprt Safety f emplyees and public nt sacrificed Future service imprvements require n new hires Crewing f each train is simplified ie nly ne persn needs t be allcated r fund in advance r n the day 8
WE HAVE A CLEAR POLICY Train crew reductins frm 2 t 1 persn peratin will be accmmdated thrugh Attritin retirements and resignatins Transfers and prmtins within the TTC Future service imprvements Increasing statin staff presence 9
CONCEPT OF OPERATION Radmap f OPTO Identify nrmal, degraded and emergency issues Tabletp simulatin f OPTO cncepts Issues and interdependencies identified Stakehlder invlvement Driven ut technical requirements Fundatin f rule bk changes 10
CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS - OPTO Safety/Emergencies Train/platfrm safety interface Train evacuatin Operatr rescue Fire and smke expsure Defective train Cmmunicatin Custmers Transit cntrl Rules & Prcedures Subway rule bk Statin Incidents Statins supprt Emergency alarm/dr issues Delay management Crewing Turnarund time End f line/turnbacks Training 11
IMPACT ON PEOPLE AND ASSETS Statin Staff Increase in deplyment f statin staff Training Delay minimizatin Wayside Equipment CCTV n platfrm Wireless cnnectin t train Tunnel Ventilatin Upgrade Repair Track Level Safety Statin departure zne Track wrkers present 12
4 CAR TR SETS FOR OPTO THE CASE Cnverting an lder T1 train which has a smaller cab and is mre basic in technlgy is cmplex, mre expensive and takes lnger 4 Car TR Trainsets n Line 4 - Shepherd Fastest way t intrduce OPTO Increases capacity by 5% n the line with n extra trains Cst savings in crew and maintenance training n lines 1 and 4 (1 train type) ATC in 2019 means access t Line 4 frm Line 1 will be via ATC signalling. Better t address the issue nw and nce nly Trainbrne Upgrades Operatr desk dr cntrls Platfrm t train CCTV Crrect side dr enable (prevents wrng side dr pening) 13
TRACK TO TRAIN INTERFACE - CHOICES USE OF MIRRORS One view Train alignment needed Early technlgy Nt TTC ptin 14
CONVERSION OF AN OLDER TRAIN Less space N space in cab fr CCTV mnitrs 15
TRACK TO TRAIN MONITORING 96TS Jubilee line Purpse built fr OPO Multiple CCTV views Departure mnitring Preferred TTC ptin 16
BOMBARDIER LU OPTO TRAIN 17
TIMELINES AND MILESTONES Line 4 Rllut 12/31/15 CCTV Develpment Wireless Develpment 6 t 4 Car TR Train mds Prcedures and Rules Safety certificatin Safety assurance Line 1 Rllut Lessns learnt n Line 4 CCTV/Wireless Install 6 Car TR Cab Mdificatins Prgramme t be develped Live Exercises 2015 Evacuatin frm train Driver Cllapse / Rescue Disabled Train Recvery 8 car push ut Rear Cab peratin Smke Resilience Line 2 Rllut T sn t determine staging/explring synergies ATC vs. OPTO vs new rlling stck One jined up slutin 18
CURRENT STATUS CCTV Wireless design cmplete - platfrm t train CCTV camera installatin n Line 4 is cmplete TR trainset #61 was delivered as a 6 car train and will be cnverted t a 4 car train Subject f future bard paper Cnsultatin with unin Lcal 113 19
SAFETY CONCERNS N evidence wrld wide where OPTO is in peratin f an increased safety risk We are wrking with CMet fr histrical and current OPTO safety statistics and perfrmance We already have OPTO here at the TTC Training, Peple r Equipment t mitigate Custmer incidents with the train / platfrm interface Driver illness / rescue Fire and smke expsure Detrainment / tunnel evacuatin Train recvery due t defect 20
NEXT STEPS Engineering design t mdify TR cabs (this reprt) Mdify 6 x 4 car TR trains Install Train Dr Mnitring (TDM) equipment Develp rule bk changes and training OPTO Trial Operatins Nrmal/Abnrmal/Emergencies/Failure Mdes Develpment f SOP s; Cntingency Plans Prvides validatin f SRB and emplyee training Include live exercises ie evacuatin, smke incident 21
POST INTRODUCTION OF OPTO Pst Intrductin Review f Line 4 pilt Lessns learnt, SRB validatin, technlgy suitability Develpment f business plan fr Line 1 Line 1 implementatin mdified as required as the result f the Line 4 pilt Line 1 technical preparatin and emplyee training Line 2 Wrk thrugh the issues f ATC and T1 replacement alngside OPTO t determine the mst cst and time effective means f migratin 22