Why Conventional Hi-Speed Rail Can t Solve Nation s Traffic Problems

Similar documents
MicroRail Alternate to Light Rail

MEGARAIL TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS, Inc.

Transportation 2040: Plan Performance. Transportation Policy Board September 14, 2017

Kenosha-Racine-Milwaukee (KRM)

Funding Scenario Descriptions & Performance

Urban Transportation in the United States: A Time for Leadership

PEACHTREE CORRIDOR PARTNERSHIP. Current Status & Next Steps

Three ULTra Case Studies examples of the performance of the system in three different environments

Factors affecting the development of electric vehiclebased car-sharing schemes

DAVID DAVID BURNS BURNS RAILROAD RAILROAD INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING ENGINEERING CONSULTANT CONSULTAN CHICAGO CHICAGO, USA, USA

ConnectGreaterWashington: Can the Region Grow Differently?

A PARADIGM FOR TRANSPORT REFORM JOHN GARDINER

Comprehensive Regional Goods Movement Plan and Implementation Strategy Goods Movement in the 2012 RTP/SCS

TXDOT PLANNING CONFERENCE. Quincy D. Allen, P.E. Houston District Engineer June 16, 2016

Ohio Passenger Rail Development. Northwest Ohio Passenger Rail Association

RUF capacity. RUF International, May 2010, A RUF DualMode system can obtain very high capacity by organizing the vehicles in small trains.

Automated Vehicles, the Hype, the Reality, and Possible Futures

An Overview of High Speed Rail. David Randall Peterman Congressional Research Service

Vanpooling and Transit Agencies. Module 3: Benefits to Incorporating Vanpools. into a Transit Agency s Services

5. OPPORTUNITIES AND NEXT STEPS

The USDOT Congestion Pricing Program: A New Era for Congestion Management

Disruptive Technology and Mobility Change

Proposal for September 2006 Start of Commuter Rail from Lovejoy on the Macon Line to Atlanta

Diverging Diamond & Roundabouts: How to Keep on Trucking Along. Meredith K Cebelak, PhD, PE & Michael A Flatt, PE

Contents. Executive Summary...1 Introduction...2 Operating Plan...4 System Connectivity...5

Rocky Mountain. Corridor Input Team. Alternatives Overview. TEMS, Inc. / Quandel Consultants, LLC TEMS, Inc. / Quandel Consultants, LLC

Public Transportation. Economics 312 Martin Farnham

Help shape your community investment in Wake Transit. Fiscal Year 2019 Draft Work Plan Summary

Introducing the Solution to LA s Airport Congestion Problem

Planning of the HSR Network

Stakeholders Advisory Working Groups (SAWGs) Traffic and Transit SAWG Meeting #7

DAILY TRAVEL AND CO 2 EMISSIONS FROM PASSENGER TRANSPORT: A COMPARISON OF GERMANY AND THE UNITED STATES

BIRMINGHAM CONNECTED Anne Shaw Tuesday 20 January 2015

Metropolitan Council Budget Overview SFY

Service Quality: Higher Ridership: Very Affordable: Image:

SERVICE DESIGN GUIDELINES

PROPOSAL OF HIGH CAPACITY URBANAUT PUGET SOUND REGIONAL MONORAIL MASTERPLAN WASHINGTON STATE, USA

Click to edit Master title style

Georgia Department of Transportation 2006 Fact Sheet Lovejoy to Atlanta Rail Line visit the website at

Development of the Preferred Option and Implementation Plan

Overview of Regional Commuter Rail Webinar: Phoenix, Arizona December 18, 2013

Independence Institute Denver West Parkway, Suite 185 Golden, Colorado i2i.org/cad.aspx BRT = BTR

Roundtable New Delhi, India

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION

What is the Connector?

REPORT CARD FOR CALIFORNIA S INFRASTRUCTURE WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT CALIFORNIA S TRANSIT FACILITIES

The Future of Transportation on the Caltrain Corridor

TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ABOUT SWEEP ECONOMIC BENEFITS OF TRANSIT SYSTEMS: COLORADO CASE STUDIES

Leadership NC. November 8, 2018

6/6/2018. June 7, Item #1 CITIZENS PARTICIPATION

Brainstormed Solutions - Passenger

EXCEPTION TO STANDARDS REPORT

Breakout Session. The Mobility Challenges of Our Growing & Sprawling Upstate

NEW YORK SUBURBAN RAIL SUMMARY (COMMUTER RAIL, REGIONAL RAIL)

THE WILSHIRE CORRIDOR: RAIL AND ITS ALTERNATIVES. Prepared By: Jacki Murdock Transportation and Environmental Planner

Integrating HSR Into Existing Regional Transportation Systems

Executive Summary. Draft Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report ES-1

HOT Lanes: Congestion Relief and Better Transit

Travel Demand Modeling at NCTCOG

Proposed Downtown Miami Link

BRT: A solution to an urban transport crisis or a financial burden?

The project faces a number of challenges:

Southern California - CHSRA

New York, We ve Got a Problem!

Green Line Long-Term Investments

The Century of Cities

on the Real Estate Industry Rutt Bridges

Aren t You Really a Mobility Agency? Why The Vanpool Works for Transit

6 Things to Consider when Selecting a Weigh Station Bypass System

1.3 OVERVIEW OF THE CORRIDOR

Conventional Approach

Kendall Drive Premium Transit PD&E Study

HIGH-SPEED RAIL THE LONE STAR WAY CONNECTING DALLAS & HOUSTON

Transit Fares for Multi-modal Transportation Systems

Factsheet to the. SwissRapide Express. Project. Tomorrow s. Transport. Today

Chapter 4 : THEME 2. Transportation

Equitable transit-oriented development: Tools + Tactics

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION

Opportunities to Leverage Advances in Driverless Car Technology to Evolve Conventional Bus Transit Systems

PHILADELPHIA SUBURBAN RAIL SUMMARY (COMMUTER RAIL, REGIONAL RAIL)

BCA Benefits and Assumptions Summary

Transportation Demand Management Element

Submission to Greater Cambridge City Deal

IC Chapter 5. Speed Limits

Transportation Infrastructure Development in Thailand: Go Green or Go Grey?

A Better Transit Plan

Crenshaw-Prairie Transit Corridor Study Public Meetings

National and Regional Electronic Toll Interoperability

VEHICLE TOLLING & MANAGEMENT. By: Julian Holtzman, Dan Moser, and Whitney Schroeder

Broward County Intermodal Center And People Mover. AASHTO Value Engineering Conference Presentation. September 1, 2009 San Diego, CA

CITY OF ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN 301 E. Huron St., P.O. Box 8647 Ann Arbor, Michigan

2016 Congestion Report

Seoul. (Area=605, 10mill. 23.5%) Capital Region (Area=11,730, 25mill. 49.4%)

NEW MOBILITIES EMERGING IN PARIS

Status of Plans March Presented by CAPITOL REGION COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS

Dixie Transportation Planning Office

Successful Passenger Rail in the State of California

Transportation: On the Road to Cleaner Air Did you know?

Theme of the Workshop. How the Railways contribute to improving quality of life?

Pass Your Driving Test - Mistakes to Avoid

Transcription:

18 Part one of a two part presentation Why Conventional Hi-Speed Rail Can t Solve Nation s Traffic Problems 18th Century Technology Poor Fit to Current Problem ROAM graphics & photos Analysis by ROAM Transport Systems, Fort Worth, Texas SuperWay, MegaWay, CargoWay, MicroWay, CarLiner, CarFerry, SkyCoach, CargoLiner, WhisperLiner, MegaLiner, & PersonLiner are trademarks of ROAM Transport Systems U.S. PATS. 6,039,135, 6,401.625, 6,435,100. 6,615,740, 6,742,458, 6,834,595, 6,837,167,& 7,926,425 B2 OTHER U.S. & INTERNATIONAL PATENTS PENDING ROAM is a registered trademark of XIP,LLC licensed to ROAM Transport Systems Reg. U.S. Pat. & Tm. Off. 1 5-28-15

Past Rail Studies Hi-speed passenger rail Very small part of problem Federal / corridor identification studies Various state & regional studies Emphasis on commuter & airport passengers These groups are low percentage of inter-city traffic Major traffic & road impacts of heavy trucks ignored Links to airports Major H-S rail emphasis Emphasis on very small part of real problem! 2

The Impossible Hi-speed Rail Dream European high-speed train influence Americans see (and ride) high-speed trains ( Most of the expensive right-of-ways acquired in WWII era ) Many dream that U.S. could & should have such systems The practical high-speed rail dream busters Dual, high-quality, wide-guage railways ROW very costly! ( U.S. railroads do not meet these standards ) Fares can t even cover O&M costs! High subsidies! Exclusive, grade-separated track and very wide curves Lack of transport at each end deters users! 3

Some Rail Hard Truths! Current railways can not accept hi-speed trains Need costly upgrades even for Accela-type trains Rails now near capacity with freight train service Dual or tripple-tracking & grade separation essential railroads indemnification required! Many curves too sharp for even 150-mph trains Politics will limit effective travel speeds Local pressures tend to force many local town stops Local, en-route stops take time and reduce overall speed Simple economics make local-stop trains impractical Current railways and high speed are incompatible 4

Other Major Rail Problems! Hi-speed passenger trains don t solve truck problem Trains not designed for truck-type cargo handling Cargo handing or special trains would impede schedules Truck traffic impacts, noise levels and pollution not solved Most users need cars at both ends of trip Won t park at station & then rent car at destination Effective public transit in most areas Woefully lacking! Commuter traffic is short-range, low-speed traffic Public transit home work train stations usually poor! Not worth two or more mode changes & lost time! Rail Studies not working on total problems 5

Almost Inescapable Conclusions! Trains unlikely to serve many destinations Unable to serve many points Can t provide enough lines Ridership requires many stops Effective speed reduced Trains unlikely to attract large number of users Few commuters find them attractive Schedule problems People starting by car Likely to continue by car Very high cost with only minor traffic impacts Probably not a viable and affordable approach! 6

The High-speed Rail Cost Problem! Typical system cost $70 to $125M per mile! Cost in urban areas Far more! Added ROW & construction costs in urban areas Costs for railway, upgrades and maintenance Very high Revenue almost never covers O&M costs Current U.S. H-S rail plans Can never fund it! Any conventional high-speed rail project likely DOA 7

Worse traffic Likely Results with H-S Rail! Even more cars More trucks Problems still exist More new studies More promises Higher tax burden Paying for H-S rail Even higher highway maintenance costs 8

Please continue to part two 9

Part two of a two part presentation How Hi-Speed MegaWay Solves Nation s Traffic Problems 21st Century Technology Solution to Traffic Problem ROAM graphics & photos Analysis by ROAM Transport Systems, Fort Worth, Texas SuperWay, MegaWay, CargoWay, MicroWay, CarLiner, CarFerry, SkyCoach, CargoLiner, WhisperLiner, MegaLiner, & PersonLiner are trademarks of ROAM Transport Systems U.S. PATS. 6,039,135, 6,401.625, 6,435,100. 6,615,740, 6,742,458, 6,834,595, 6,837,167,& 7,926,425 B2 OTHER U.S. & INTERNATIONAL PATENTS PENDING ROAM is a registered trademark of XIP,LLC licensed to ROAM Transport Systems Reg. U.S. Pat. & Tm. Off. 10

MegaWay Attacks Full Problem Low-cost hi-speed inter-city passenger service In non-stop SuperWay trains No railroads involved Most passengers in their own automobiles Commuter & local passenger service In trains and in users own automobiles Ends freeway and road traffic congestion High-speed cross-country and local cargo Solves the total transport & traffic problem 11

Hi-speed Dream Realized without Rail U.S. H-S (110-125-mph) beat by non-stop 120-mph No rails! Rubber tires run on narrow, steel road surfaces Non-stop, point to point without usual railroad stop delays Elevated SuperWays with enclosed WheelWays 120-mph over current freeway ROWs No costly new ROW! Fares can cover both initial and O&M costs! No subsidies! Electric power and steering from inside wheelways bars Weather-proof wheelways allow all-weather operation Personal car transport at each end attracts users! 12

Some Really Good News! Current freeway ROWs accept elevated SuperWays Need costly railroad upgrades Not used for SuperWays No impact on freight train service capacity Grade separation easy with ultra-light SuperWays over freeways No railroad interfaces! Freeway curves no problem for 120-mph SuperWays Politics do not impact non-stop travel speeds Local towns easily served by short, non-stop trains or cars Off-line station stops never delay through traffic Local, non-stop trains are economically practical Current freeways and high speed SuperWays are compatible 13

Some Real MegaWay Results! MegaWay solves most heavy truck problems MegaWay cargo carriers move most box truck cargo MegaWay cargo carriers intermix with passenger vehicles Much of truck traffic impacts, noise levels and pollution ends Most passengers have their cars at both ends of trip No parking at station & then renting car at destination No need to depend upon public transit at any point Lower speed MegaWays provide commuter service Most people start and end their commutes in their own cars! No lost time typical of other commuting systems! Results of working on the total problem set 14

The Inescapable Conclusions! MegaWay can do what high-speed rail can t Able to serve many points Lines along any freeway High total speed without time-killing stops MegaWay will attract large number of users Most commuters find them attractive Shortest time People start and end trip by car No mode changes! Very low cost with major traffic reductions MegaWay is a viable and affordable approach! 15

MegaWay vs High-speed Rail Costs! Typical rail system $70 to $100M per mile! Typical MegaWay system $16M per mile! No major SuperWay urban area construction costs SuperWay needs no railway upgrades and maintenance MegaWay revenue covers O&M & initial costs MegaWay Cost like adding a freeway lane! MegaWay cost easily affordable in most cases! 16

MegaWay Results Cut big trucks Cut traffic & road damage End freeway traffic jams 120-mph, non-stop travel in our own cars 120-mph, non-stop public train service Electric power for low air pollution All-weather travel No snow & ice impacts Avoid hundreds of billions for high-speed rail Nothing else offers anything close! 17

401 West Jim Wright Freeway, Suite113 Mail Address P. O. Box 121728 Fort Worth, Texas 76121 (817) 738-9507 FAX (817) 367-2373 contact@roamtrans.com www.roamtrans.com Revolutionary, High-speed, Multi-user 21st Century Transport! Unprecedented level of service Low transportation user costs Near-term & affordable solution to traffic & air pollution problems 18 ROAM Transport Systems, Fort Worth, Texas SuperWay, MegaWay, CargoWay, MicroWay, CarLiner, CarFerry, SkyCoach, CargoLiner, WhisperLiner, MegaLiner, & PersonLiner are trademarks of ROAM Transport Systems U.S. PATS. 6,039,135, 6,401.625, 6,435,100. 6,615,740, 6,742,458, 6,834,595, 6,837,167,& 7,926,425 B2 OTHER U.S. & INTERNATIONAL PATENTS PENDING ROAM graphics & photos Reg. U.S. Pat. & Tm. Off.