Underpinning Readiness at the Right Cost and Effective Life Cycle Maintenance Distribution Statement A "Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited" Presented to: DoD Maintenance Symposium Presented by: 14 November 2011 RDML(select) CJ Jaynes, USN Assistant Commander for Logistics & Industrial Operations, Naval Air Systems Command
Condition Based Maintenance (CBM) Objectives Reduce Total Ownership Costs Increase Operational Availability Improve Flight Safety Improve Maintenance Efficiency 2
CBM Definition Condition Based Maintenance System of on-board sensors, self-monitoring systems, and off-board diagnostics that enable problem detection and maintenance only when needed CBM Elements On-Board Sensors/Self-monitoring Systems Ground Stations Data Management & Engineering Analysis Outcomes Mechanical Diagnostics Component condition / health Structural Appraisal of Fatigue Effects (SAFE) accurate usage data / component life Fatigue Life Expended Tired Unexpected failures Assumed Life Light Use Early Removals Flight Hours 3
CBM Working Group & Demo Project NAVAIR CBM Working Group formed to provide Enterprise-wide CBM solutions and policy Focused on Demo Project with an H-53E squadron to set up an end-to-end CBM construct Identify gaps Evaluate CBM tools Develop data architecture and warehousing requirements Develop gov t owned data analysis tools and processes Establish CBM Enterprise policy Track 7 life limited and 5 health monitored components 4
CBM Working Group & Demo Project (cont d) Demo Schedule FY12-FY13 Finalize Tasking & Schedule: Now Dec. 2011 Data Collection/ Transmission/ Storage/Analysis: Jan. 2012 Jan. 2013 Follow on Analysis & Evaluation: Jan. 2013 Sept. 2013 Follow on tasks CBM Policy Implementation FY14 CBM Data Analysis Tool Kit FY14 CBM ALE Implementation FY14/15 Funding FY11/12/13: OCO Funding FY14: FR CFT Affordability Initiatives & POM 14 process 5
CBM WG Demo Project Overview (Component Candidates) Preventative Diagnostic Predictive Prognostic OBJECTIVES Increase Operational Availability Improve Flight Safety Improve Maintenance Efficiency Reduce Total Ownership Costs CBM Enablers On-Board Systems (Sensors) Ground Based Systems (Flight Line Diagnostics) Data Management and Analysis System Life Management Main rotor sleeve Spindle assembly Main rotor lower hub plate Main rotor upper hub plate Main rotor shaft extender Main gearbox housing Main rotor shaft Health Monitoring Tail Rotor Drive Shaft Hangar Bearing Assembly Main Rotor Head Pitch Control Rod and Damper Bearing Main Gearbox Oil Cooler Blower Bearing Assembly Intermediate Gearbox Nose Gearboxes Maximize Combat Power 6
NAVAIR CBM+ WG Vision Facilitator of CBM Collaboration CBM Baselining and Common Requirements Capture CBM Process Validation and Demonstration CBM Common Solution Evaluation CBM Enterprise Policy CBM Common Enterprise Tool ( App Store ) THE UNDERLYING PMA QUESTION When does the CBM WG help my CBM approach? 7
MH-60S Aircraft & Systems Cockpit Chart 8
MH-60S 12 Month Aircraft RFT Gap Analysis 12 Month Cumulative RFT Gap = 27.6 TOP 20 RFT GAP REASONS 12 Month Contribution Value 12 Month Contribution Percent Number of Occurrences 9
H-60 CILR Top 10 Main Rotor Elastomeric Bearing Assy AF AP 2$ NS 3.78% NM 1R 1$ 011589606 Tail Dr Shft Viscous Mtd Sprt Bearing NS 1$ 1R AP 1.85% NM 013298573 Main Rotor Blade 1.69% 011589679 015779486 012481978 010965592 013470735 013454835 015199017 AV NM NS CN 1$ Sensor-Sight Turret AV PS CN 1$ 1.55% 1.50% T1308/APS124 Transmitter Mod AF PM PS 2$ AV 1.36% Push Rod Attachment Bolts NM 1R 1.33% Main Rotor Damper Assy 2$ AP 1R AV 1$ NM NS 1.23% Main Module Gearbox Assy AV 1$ NS NM 015523522 1.10% 1.00% EAK13/A37J10 Eng Tor Rtr Sp Ind AF 799 CN 2$ 1R AP Main Rast Probe Assy PS AF AP 2$ Removed/Replaced at Phase D during Spindle inspection/repair Vendor issue resolved; DLA Consumable Item. DCB lowered life limits. Supply Availability impact due to high demand from DCB145 Repair Cost $156K Quarterly Demand 21.94 (26) Units RFI Repair Cost $82K Qtrly Demand 6.25 (77) Units RFI; Supply status HEALTHY SAC Flt Control subcontractor self retaining issue bolts R & R for multiple insps/repairs. Supply good. High Maintenance Manhours. 1,000 BCMs a Year Corrosion #1 Driver Rpr $7K;Qtr Dmd 11;Sply Good;20 RFI; I Lvl Rpbl;AFM$ High-repl fcplate $1.5K Damage to Teflon guide strips during extension and retract Continue to Monitor Continue to Monitor Capability being stood up at NADEP CP. Gradually healthier as CTI gets on-line Depot and I-Level Capability IN WORK Continue to Monitor Bulletin Proposed in redesign work held at FST pending approval to allow for bolts to be reused. ECP4603 improves reliability. DDTS installed at 3 sites. AFC356,ZEE retainer released, reduced corr. IRAC issued H60SA-140-300 Continue to Monitor Added Requirement to 112 Day; 56 to day 56 inspection Day; insp, at treat, sea and paint 10
NIRVANA The art of the possible Change maintenance intervals Intercept catastrophic failures (safety) Lengthen real part life (TOC) Reduce unnecessary maintenance actions (increase A) All platforms possible 11
QUESTIONS 12