IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA (GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA) PRETORIA THIS 8TH DAY OF AUGUST 2017 TUESDAY CRIMINAL TRIALS IN COURT GA AT 10:00(07-11/08/17) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN PELOELE CC 109/16 IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN VISSER CC 29/16
IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI Page 2 of 19 URGENT COURT IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MATOJANE CRIMINAL APPEALS IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWANEPOEL Name of Advocate for the state: Jacobs No. Case no. Name of appellant 1. A333/16 P S Makgolo 2. A270/16 L Mandi 3. A611/16 J T Lekhuleni + 1 REVIEW JUDGEMENT IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWANEPOEL 1. The State vs Daniel Khoetha+1 A365/17
Page 3 of 19 CIVIL APPEALS IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELE AJ MEC FOR HEALTH VS SAINAH VIRGINIA KHUMALO A453/16 ROMANS PIZZA (PRETORIA) CC VS ANAK KUTMAR NEERPUTH + 2 OTHERS A257/15 IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELE AJ ADMISSIONS IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELE 1. K. H MPSHE ATT 42277/17 2. N. M SELOKO ATT 42211/17 3. K.TSHIVHASE ATT 42766/17 4. M. SNYMAN ATT 43083/17 5. B. MUKWEHWA ATT 42837/17 6. M. M MATSIE ATT 422774/17 IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWANEPOEL 7. R. M MAKHAMBENI ATT 33223/17 8. P.S BOTES ATT 40331/17
Page 4 of 19 9. P. M GRIMBEEK ATT 42778/17 10. M. M L MALAPILE ATT 42324/17 11. T. B MONGWE ATT 42768/17 12. K. N NGCOBO ATT 42767/17 UNOPPOSED MOTIONS IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRETORUIS IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOKOSE AJ OPPOSED MOTIONS IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN OOSTEN IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FISHER IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MADIMA AJ IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SARWILLA AJ
Page 5 of 19 IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TSATSIWANE AJ UDGMENTS Please enrol the following Judgments for 8 August 2017 and allocate the same Court we will be utilizing for Civil Appeals. JUDGMENTS IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE Parties: FC Hamisi v State Case no.: A33/17 Parties: R Mkhwanazi v State Case no.: A863/2016 Parties: Law Society v MCE Bopape Case no.: 12484/16 and 66185/2016 IN COURT 8D AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SARDIWALA AJ CASE NO.: 54655/15 LEDIRANG LOGISTICS (PTY) LTD VS MAKGOTLOE TRADING ENTERPRISES CC +2 APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL 1. CASE NO.: 54790/2014 J D W TRUTER VS RAF 2. 71053/2016 UMMI PROPERTIES (PTY) LTD VS ABSA BANK LTD
Page 6 of 19 IN COURT 8F AT 10H00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA PIETER SCHALK VAN DER VYVER & ANOTHER v MINISTER OF WATER AFFAIRS CASE NO: A231/2017 IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEAVE TO APPEALS IN COURT 4 AT 09:30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW Saaknommer: 65685/13 Partye: Sifiso Ndwandwe And Mohammed Tawfit Mohamed Mehrez and Another IN COURT 4C AT 9:30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA CASE NO.: 36706/2014 VOSLOORUS SQUARE CC APPLICANT V
Page 7 of 19 TRAMORE PROPERTY GROUP (PTY) LTD & 3 OTHERS RESPONDENTS IN COURT 4C AT 9:30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA CASE NO.: 29212/2012 C M MONKWE APPLICANT V BODIBA E & 4 OTHERS RESPONDENT IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE INQUEST IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 INQUEST UNTILL 11 AUGUST BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE f Mr Ahmed Timol will resume in the Pretoria High Court on Monday 24 July 2013 and will continue until Friday 11 August 2017. PART HEARD MATTERS IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE Page 8 of 19 SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE IN COURT 6E AT 10:00(FROM 31/07/17 TO 25/08/17) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 4E AT 10:00(31/07/17 TO 11/08/17) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI IN COURT 8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA IN COURT B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE 3 RD COURT MOTIONS IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW
Page 9 of 19 CIVIL NOTE 1 PLEASE TAKE NOTE OF THE FOLLOWING 2 MAKE SURE IF A MATTER IS REMOVED THAT COURT RULE 41 APPLIES AND NEEDS TO BE SERVED AND FILLED AT ROOM 7.40 3 IF A MATTER STANDS DOWN TO A DATE TO BE ALLOCATED/ OR POSTPONED PLEASE UPLIFT THE FILE IN COURT AND BRING IT TO ROOM 7.40 THE TRAIL ROLLS CLOSE EVERY DAY AT 12 NOON 2 WORKING DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING DATE NO LATE FILLING THE PRACTICE NOTE NEEDS TO BE STAPLED INTO THE LEFT SIDE OF THE FILE CIVIL TRIALS ALLOCATIONS ONLY IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P AA M F HANYANE VS RAF 63829/13 BB P BRETT VS RAF PP 7/8/17 3739/16 CC J VERSTER VS RAF 21624/15 DD M KUTUMELA VS RAF 77610/14 EE R S ERASMUS VS RAF 68760/13 CIVIL TRIALS DRAFT ORDERS ONLY IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P A M S DIBETSO VS RAF 13870/16 B MD MPANE VS RAF 34859/16 C MK HLUNGWANE VS RAF 57092/15 D M D SELEPE VS RAF 88513/15 E K MAHLANGU VS RAF 61879/14 F NM MDANA VS RAF 45282/14
Page 10 of 19 G SEABELA M J VS RAF 48260/16 H S E MNCUBE VS RAF 16215/13 I Z L KHANYE VS RAF 19171/16 J V G KHOZA VS RAF 80641/16 K R BEAUKES VS RAF 51663/16 L H W MAKONDO VS RAF 29775/14 M T K NUKERI VS RAF 16025/16 N LETSOALO MF VS RAF 73610/16 O FM MTSHWENI VS RAF 8951/16 P M A MATLA VS RAF 23514/16 Q MAKWENA P MOJELA VS RAF 30421/16 R L Z SATHEKGE VS RAF 12662/17 S MABUELAM C VS RAF 18000/17 T ADV T E HLOKWE VS RAF 37770/13 U MH REDELINGHUYS VS RAF 350/14 V TJ MEYER VS RAF 10126/11 W ADV M MPHAGA VS RAF 50071/10 X PHETLA LJ VS RAF 89187/15 Y LM MAHASHA VS RAF 5357/17 Z D HADEBE VS RAF 59670/15 Z1 P MASANGO VS RAF 58096/15 Z2 J PRETORIUS VS RAF 66080/12 Z3 MOSEKALEME M S VS RAF 5545/16 Z4 JH GOUWS VS RAF 22731/16 Z5 P MARUMO VS RAF 39547/13
Page 11 of 19 PRETORIA THIS 08 DAY OF AUGUST 2017 CIVIL TRIALS IN COURT 6E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AP LEDWABA DJ P 1A H C PRETORIUS VS RAF PREFDATE 67209/14 1B M BOTHA VS RAF PREFDATE 39944/15 1C M J MAPHALLE VS RAF PREFDATE 83072/14 1D L E MATLOU VS RAF PREFDATE 32367/14 1.CJ NIEWSTAD VS RAF MERITS 72655/14 2.DO MOKGELE VS RAF MERITS 14496/16 3.E KESHEBANG VS RAF MERITS 6961/16 4. C EZE obo MINORS VS RAF REMOVED 94042/15 5. OD MOLEMA VS RAF MERITS 14495/16 6. AC WILLEMANS VS RAF MERITS 18549/16 7. EC KING VS RAF MERITS 84143/15 8. S HAVINGA VS RAF MERITS 81975/15
Page 12 of 19 9. N TSHABALALA VS RAF MERITS 62037/15 10. TJ SEBOKA VS RAF MERITS 26289/16 11. NM KULA VS RAF NO FILE 17036/16NP 12. MAHLATSE J SELOWA VS RAF 90048/16 13. MJ TODI VS RAF MERITS 10269/16 14. S MASONDO VS RAF MERITS 2727/16 15. PP MAHLANGU obo MGC VS RAF MERITS 17735/16 16. L MAKHAFOLA VS RAF MERITS 40942/16 17. CL MOLEKWA VS RAF MERITS 54601/16 18. NE DUMA VS RAF MERITS 5091/16 19.LK NOGWANE VS RAF MERITS 97846/15 20. A COETZEE VS RAF MERITS 1009/16 21. FS COETZEE VS RAF MERITS 1007/16 22. FS COETZEE VS RAF MERITS 1008/16 N NAIDOO VS RAF MERITS 1284/16 24. J L HOLL VS RAF 56068/12 25. TE MTHETHWA VS RAF MERITS 13183/14 26. R SKHOSANA VS RAF MERITS 81612/15 27. SSS MKUTHA VS RAF MERITS 15838/15 28. DL MKASE VS RAF MERITS 46651/15 29. TJ SEPENG VS RAF MERITS 16384/16
Page 13 of 19 30.NJ MIJILIBE VS RAF MERITS 3334/16 31. NJ NDLOVU VS RAF MERITS 193871/15 32. S GOVENDER VS RAF MERITS 99923/15 33. LM MNYAKENI VS RAF NO FILE 99769/15NP 34. NC MATAI VS RAF MERITS 83872/15 35. TJ MOFOKENG VS RAF MERITS 57493/14 36. TA SIHLALE VS RAF MERITS 17012/16 37. HA SANDENBERG VS RAF MERITS 88743/15 38. GB JORDAN VS RAF MERITS 15544/13 39. M CLARKE VS RAF MERITS 32368/14 40. GP XULU VS RAF MERITS NO FILE 75421/15NP 41. J MORERO VS RAF CERTIFICATE 73177/13 42. AB ZITHA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 38419/12 43. T MODZIYA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 21852/14 44. PR DU TOIT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 21296/13 45. ERASMUS AJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 26958/13 46. O BRANDOW VS RAF CERTIFICATE 30422/15 47. NKOSI VT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 88930/14 48 NDABA CS VS RAF CERTIFICATE 73551/10 49. PIETERSE JL VS RAF CERTIFICATE 68892/12 50. BANDA F VS RAF 45835/12
Page 14 of 19 51. MOFOKENG DR VS RAF CERTIFICATE 14047/10 52. RUWENDE B obo MINOR VS RAF NO FILE 70339/14NP 53. O PIENAAR VS RAF 74728/15 54. MAJAKE MR obo T VS RAF CERTIFICATE 48981/14 55. CJ BUZUIDENHOUT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 39486/13 56. EILAAR AM VS RAF CERTIFICATE 52391/15 57. JIKA C VS RAF NO FILE 18500/15NP 58.MASOPA KC VS RAF CERTIFICATE 18500/15 59. ROSSOUW VL VS RAF CERTIFICATE 62725/14 60. DT CHAUKE obo LJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 15060/15 61SEFARA DM VS RAF CERTIFICATE 88907/14 62. PELZER NE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 12201/14 63. LESEILANA MP VS RAF 23729/15 64. ADV VENTER VS RAF CERTIFICATE 57437/15 65. REKGOTSO WB VS RAF CERTIFICATE 32253/14 66. FOURIE JJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 57851/14 67. NTULI MP VS RAF CERTIFICATE 36727/14 68. MASIMULA BH VS RAF CERTIFICATE 98474/15 69. PILLAY GA VS RAF NO FILE 5945/13NP 70.MAHLANGU G VS RAF CERTIFICATE 60411/15NP 71.TBT QWABE VS RAF 75730/15
Page 15 of 19 72. C B SMITH VS ARAF SERT 42054/12 73 P T MPANGANE VS RAF SER T 39860/14 74 P MAKHUBELA VS RAF 70818/12 75 H S KHUMALO VS RAF SERT 67455/14 76 LS MKGHONTO VS RAF SERT 25753/10 77 G K SWAARTBOOI VS RAF 79732/15 78. L KGASI VS RAF SERT 4582/16 79. P MOYO VS RFA CERT 99009/15 80. MALAPE S D VS RAF PREDATE REMOVED 24827/16 81.PT KHASEBE VS RAF MERITS 39504/15 A STRYDOM VS RAF MERITS 1888/15 83. SM BUTHELEZI VS RAF MERITS 24520/15 84. J PIENAAR VS RAF 74727/15 85. MAHLO M MOYAHABO VS RAF 66814/16 86. I SIBAYA VS THE MIN OF POLICE CIVIL 42833/10 87. ABSA BANK VS JP TEREBLANCHE CIVIL 947/13 88. EQSTRA VS SHAUN BOWLEY +1 OTHER NO FILE 6228/16NP 89. M DLAMINI obo VS PRASA CIVIL 53270/16 90. N PELZER VS THE MEC FOR DEPT WORKS CIVIL 71082/14 91. M MPOFU VS MIN OF SA DEFENCE CIVIL 9805/13 92. PJ MCKECHNIE VS MF SOLOMON + 2 OTHERS CIVIL 98199/15 93. S MMUS VS MIN OF POLICE CIVIL 43936/13NP
Page 16 of 19 94. MPHEKWANA D A VS RAF 23758/16 95. T V MATHONSI VS RAF 12971/16 96. JP MASEKO +1 OTHER MEC FOR WORKS CIVIL 23789/11NP 97. JT SEOKA VS SC SIBIYA CIVIL 25598/15 98. JN RAMAISA VS MIN OF SAFETY AND SEC CIVIL 28760/09 99. ECOLIGHTS DIS VS MAYAN SUNLIGHT NO FILE 50300/14NP 100. J PIENAAR VS RAF NO FILE 74277/15 NP 101 P MAKOU VS RAF NO FILE 52738/14NP 102 E JAMBAYA VS RAF READY NO FILE 12093/12 NP 103 MAAKE L O VS RAF 6575/14 104 H B KLOPPERS VS RAF SERT 2142/14 105 M S MALAHLELA VS RAF 39176/16 106 TK MATHABATHE VS RAF 22382/15 107 L K MASHABELA VS RAF 22344/15 108 R MOLOPI VS SERT 4679/16 109 SIMON J MASINA VS RAF NO FILE 2470/14NP 110 H A ESTELLE VS RAF 25795/16 111 T F BASHEE VS RAF 66073/16 112 V MULEYA VS RAF NO FILE 62717/16NP 113 J SEKHOHOLA VSRAF 37303/16 114 KK EXUPERE VS RAF 76209/14 115 T K MASHABA VS RAF CERT 58073/09
Page 17 of 19 116 T MAGUBANE VS RAF 90639/15 117 N NQALATHI CS RAF CERT 24742/16 118 A MODISE VS RFA 45993/12 119 MDAYALA PN VS RAF CERT 29631/14 120 M W MNGOMEZULU V RAF NO FILE REMOVED 25151/11NP 121 M J NKABINI VS RAF 69034/13 122 BK MASILELA VS RAF NO FILE 59989/09NP 123 ADV BG MOGASWA VS RAF NO FILE REMOVED 83017/14NP 124 T D SENYANE VS RFA NO FILE 8304/14NP 125 V B JAKO VS RAF NO FILE CERT 93763/15NP 126 E MATHONSI VS RAF 84688/14 127 S MDLADLA ` VS MIN OF POLICE NO FILE 72836/16NP 128 T C MOETSI VS RAF 14821/16 129 H R JOUBERT VS RAF NO FILE 34211/16NP 130 G S MITHILENI VS RAF 18672/16 131 CHAUKE F VS RAF NO FILE 31992/13NP 132 LP TSHETLHANA VS RAF NO FILE 65170/16NP 133 D PHILISWA VS RAF 33946/15 134 M C MOKONYANE VS RAF CERT 81453/15 135 C KATSE VS RAF 16391/15 136 M N MASHIYANE VS RAF 19987/15 137 E WILLIAMS VS RFA CERT 73390/13 138 G SHONGWE VSraf 99039/15 139 MENOE LM VS RAF CERT 22168/15 140 M G MAKHAMPONYE VS RAF CERT 75946/15
Page 18 of 19 141 J LEDWABA VS RAF NO FILE 37021/13NP 142 T L MAHADIME VSQ RAF CERT 25206/14 143 BANDA F J VS RAF NO FILE ` 45835/12NP 144 K MALOSE VS RAF MERITS 63851/15 145 SEKGOBELA G VS RAF 7676/15 146 M MADZUNYA VS RAF 4683/16 147 M J BOTHMA VS RAF 86879/14 148L DUMA VS RAF 47060/15 149 S B MAKAMO VS RAF 29065/16 150 MVELASE SS VS RAF 36897/14 CIVIL COURT JUDGES IN COURT C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA
Page 19 of 19 IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BASSON IN COURT2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE COLLIS AJ IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTEPE AJ COURTS AVAILABLE