~~ l; j ames D. Beasley

Similar documents
Re: Demand Side Management Plan, 2016 FEECA Annual Report

AUSLEY MCMULLEN ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW 123 SOUTH CALHOUN STREET. P.O. BOX 391 (ztp 32302) TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32301

BEFORE THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION. The following Commissioners participated in the disposition of this matter:

Docket No EI Date: May 22, 2014

April 20, Docket No EI Environmental Cost Recovery Clause

AUSLEY MCMULLEN. December 14, 2017 VIA: ELECTRONIC FILING

BEFORE THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

c~~h FLORIDfl.. PUBLIC~ UTILITIES FILED 7/11/2018 DOCUMENT NO FPSC - COMMISSION CLERK

NHPUC No. 3 - Electricity Delivery Thirtieth Revised Page 4 Unitil Energy Systems, Inc. Superseding Twenty-Ninth Revised Page 4

~M3t~v L-- AUSLEY MCMULLEN. July 20, VlA: ELECTRONIC TRANSMISSION

~/}~ FLORIDfl PUBLIC~ UTILITIES. Re: Docket No EI CONTINUING SURVEILLANCE AND REVIEW OF FUEL COST RECOVERY CLAUSES OF ELECTRIC UTILITIES

First Revision of Sheet No P.S.C.U. No. 50 Canceling Original Sheet No ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER ELECTRIC SERVICE SCHEDULE NO.

UNITIL ENERGY SYSTEMS. INC. CALCULATION OF THE EXTERNAL DELIVERY CHARGE

Re: Docket No EI CONTINUING SURVEILLANCE AND REVIEW OF FUEL COST RECOVERY CLAUSES OF ELECTRIC UTILITIES

FLORIDfl.. PUBLIC~ UTILITIES

BEFORE THE NEW MEXICO PUBLIC REGULATION

2016 ANNUAL CONSERVATION REPORT

~ Gulf Power. August 29, 2018

~~~o: n. FLORIDfl PUBLIC~ UTILITIES. Re: Docket No EI CONTINUING SURVEILLANCE AND REVIEW OF FUEL COST RECOVERY CLAUSES OF ELECTRIC UTILITIES

OUTDOOR LIGHTING ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE SCHEDULE "OL-26''

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION OF OREGON PACIFICORP. Exhibit Accompanying Direct Testimony of Judith M. Ridenour

THE CONNECTICUT LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY, DBA EVERSOURCE ENERGY. STREET AND SECURITY LIGHTING RATE 116 Page 1 of 9

Vermont Public Power Supply Authority 2018 Tier 3 Annual Plan

STREET LIGHTING ELECTRIC SERVICE (Governmental Authority) RATE SCHEDULE "SL-30''

Proposal Concerning Modifications to LIPA s Tariff for Electric Service

Panola-Harrison Electric Cooperative, Inc. Louisiana Tariff Effective: March 3, 2004

OUTDOOR LIGHTING ELECTRIC SERVICE RATE SCHEDULE "OL-25''

ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER A DIVISION OF PACIFICORP

KANSAS CITY POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY P.S.C. MO. No. 7 Fourth Revised Sheet No. 39 Canceling P.S.C. MO. No. 7 Third Revised Sheet No.

Town of Skaneateles ADDENDUM TO RFP DOCUMENTS

RATE FPL UNMETERED PROTECTIVE LIGHTING

RE: Advice Schedule 45 Public DC Fast Charger Delivery Service Optional Transitional Rate REPLACEMENT PAGES

FISCHER, FRANKLIN & FORD Attorneys and Counsellors GUARDIAN BUILDING, SUITE GRISWOLD STREET DETROIT, MICHIGAN

Metropolitan Edison Company Rate RS - Residential Service Revenue Effects of Settlement Rates - FTY 12/31/17

STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA UTILITIES COMMISSION RALEIGH NOTICE TO CUSTOMERS DOCKET NO. E-34, SUB 46 BEFORE THE NORTH CAROLINA UTILITIES COMMISSION

Large General Service Time-of-Use Storage Program

Florida Public Service Commission Rule Development Workshop

Thank you for your time and attention to this matter. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions regarding the filing.

UNION POWER COOPERATIVE

FITCHBURG GAS AND ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY NET METERING SCHEDULE NM

STREET LIGHTING ELECTRIC SERVICE (Governmental Authority) RATE SCHEDULE "SL-29"

Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.

Topic Small Projects (< 100 kw) Large Projects (>100 kw)

2017 Colorado Phase 2 Regulatory Rate Review Frequently asked questions

JEA Distributed Generation Policy Effective April 1, 2018

Rl~~ ~~ A. Gulf Power. February 24, 2018

FITCHBURG GAS AND ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY NET METERING SCHEDULE NM

October 4, Schedule A4: revised Net Output Factor (%) for Fort Myers 3C and 3D.

Docket 50-ER-108 Algoma Utilities. Final Form Rate and Rule Tariff Sheets Amendment 78. Filed By: Public Service Commission of Wisconsin

Florida Department of Revenue

VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY

d/b/a EVERSOURCE ENERGY Cancels M.D.P.U. No. 44 STREET AND SECURITY LIGHTING RATE S-1

Indianapolis Power & Light Company I.U.R.C. No. E-18 Original No. 90 One Monument Circle Indianapolis, Indiana

Indianapolis Power & Light Company I.U.R.C. No. E-17 Original No. 90 One Monument Circle Indianapolis, Indiana

THE CONNECTICUT LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY dba EVERSOURCE ENERGY AND THE UNITED ILLUMINATING COMPANY

TELL CITY ELECTRIC DEPARTMENT RATES AND CHARGES

Unitil Energy Demand Response Demonstration Project Proposal October 12, 2016

STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION DE LIBERTY UTILITIES (GRANITE STATE ELECTRIC) CORP. d/b/a LIBERTY UTILITIES

Attention: Mr. Patrick Wruck, Commission Secretary and Manager, Regulatory Support

FUEL ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE

August 18, 2016 NWN OPUC Advice No A / UG 309 SUPPLEMENT A (UM 1766)

RATE SLM PUBLIC STREET AND HIGHWAY LIGHTING

Pennsylvania Power Company. Rate RS - Residential Service Revenue Effects of Settlement Rates - FTY 12/31/17

ATLANTA CLEVELAND DAYTON WASHINGTON, D.C. CINCINNATI

EXHIBIT A-2 Amending Chapter TMC (all additions and amendments effective April 1, 2018) Chapter ELECTRIC ENERGY REGULATIONS AND RATES 1

RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the City Council, following a public hearing, adopt the attached resolution which:

Guideline on Energy Storage

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

N.H.P.U.C. No ELECTRICITY GRANITE STATE ELECTRIC COMPANY DBA LIBERTY UTILITIES. SUPERSEDING N.H.P.U.C. No. 17 TEMPORARY RATES

Filed with the Iowa Utilities Board on July 27, 2018, TF STATE OF IOWA DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE IOWA UTILITIES BOARD

July 24, Docket No EI FPL s Petition for Approval of a New Depreciation Class and Rate for Energy Storage Equipment

STATE CORPORATION COMMISSION DIVISION OF PUBLIC UTILITY REGULATION. May 22, 2018

STATE OF MINNESOTA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION. Beverly Jones Heydinger

Superseding Revised Sheet No. 63 REVISED SHEET NO. 63 Effective March 1, 2011 Effective September 1, 2012 ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE

RIPUC No Cancelling RIPUC No Sheet 1 THE NARRAGANSETT ELECTRIC COMPANY NET METERING PROVISION

KAUAI ISLAND UTILITY COOPERATIVE KIUC Tariff No. 1 Lihue, Kauai, Hawaii First Revised Sheet 80 Cancels Original Sheet 80

THE CONNECTICUT LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY, DBA EVERSOURCE ENERGY. PARTIAL STREET LIGHTING SERVICE RATE 117 Page 1 of 5

Information Packet Kissimmee Utility Authority Customer-Owned Renewable Generation Interconnection And Net Metering Program

-and- Peter W. Gurnham, Q.C., Chair. ("Utility"), made application on January 14, 2015, to the Nova Scotia Utility and Review

s m BC hydro REGENERATION December 22, 2011

STATE OF ILLINOIS ILLINOIS COMMERCE COMMISSION

RESOLUTION NO

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND AND PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

September 21, Advice No , NEW Schedule 50 Retail Electric Vehicle Charging Rates

RAPPAHANNOCK ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE SCHEDULE NEM-8 NET ENERGY METERING RIDER

Reforming the TAC and Retail Transmission Rates. Robert Levin California Public Utilities Commission Energy Division August 29, 2017

National Grid. Narragansett Electric Company INVESTIGATION AS TO THE PROPRIETY OF COMPLIANCE TARIFF CHANGES. 2 nd Amended Compliance Filing

Household Renewable Energy

H 7366 S T A T E O F R H O D E I S L A N D

CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NOVATO ORDINANCE NO. 1620

September 2, Ms. Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 888 First Street, N.E. Washington, D.C.

STATE OF INDIANA INDIANA UTILITY REGULATORY COMMISSION

Methodology of Cost Allocation

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) APPLICATION

Beyond Net Metering Issues for Washington State

: : : : : : : Commonwealth Edison Company ( ComEd ), pursuant to Section of the Public

Southern California Edison Revised Cal. PUC Sheet No E Rosemead, California (U 338-E) Cancelling Revised Cal. PUC Sheet No.

Peace River Electric Cooperative, Inc.

SDG&E Customer Distributed Generation Programs. Steve Jaffe Senior Market Advisor Customer Innovations Group September 14, 2009


Transcription:

AUSLEY MCMULLEN ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW 123 SOUTH CALHOUN STREET P.O. BOX 391 (ZIP 3232) TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 3231 185) 224 9 115 FAX (85) 222 756 September 5, 217 VIA: ELECTRONIC FILING Ms. Carlotta S. Stauffer Commission Clerk Florida Public Service Commission 254 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee, FL 32399-85 Re: Petition of Tampa Electric Company for Approval of Conservation Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program Dear Ms. Stauffer: Attached for filing in the above-styled matter is the Petition of Tampa Electric for Approval of Conservation Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program. JDB/pp Attachment Thank you for your assistance in connection with this matter. Sincerely, ~~ l; j ames D. Beasley

BEFORE THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION In re: Petition oftampa Electric Company ) for approval of Conservation Street and ) DOCKET NO. Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program. ) ) FILED: September 5, 217 PETITION OF TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY FOR APPROVAL OF CONSERVATION STREET AND OUTDOOR LIGHTING CONVERSION PROGRAM Tampa Electric Company (''Tampa Electric or "the company"), pursuant to Sections 366.82, 366.5 and 366.6, Florida Statutes, petitions the Florida Public Service Commission ("Commission") for approval of the company's proposed Conservation Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program ("the Program") as a Demand Side Management (" DSM") program, approval of the company's program description attached hereto as Exhibit "A'' and programs standards attached hereto as Exhibit "B", and to allow Tampa Electric to recover the remaining unamortized costs in rate base of its Metal Halide ("MH") and High-Pressure Sodium ("HPS") street and outdoor luminaires and associated communication expenditures of its Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program through the company's Energy Conservation Cost Recovery ("ECCR") Clause. As grounds therefor, the company says: I. Tampa Electric is an investor-owned public utility regulated by the Commission pursuant to Chapter 366, Florida Statutes. Tampa Electric is subject to the Florida Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act ("FEECA"), Sections 366.8-85, 43.519, Florida Statutes. Pursuant to FEECA, the Commission has approved DSM goals for Tampa Electric and Tampa Electric has a DSM plan approved by the Commission designed to achieve its DSM goals. 2. Tampa Electric's address is 72 North Franklin Street. Tampa, Florida 336 I. Correspondence, notices, orders and other documents concerning this petition should be sent to:

James D. Beasley j beasley@ausley.com J. Jeffry Wahlen jwahlen@ausley.com Ausley McMullen Post Office Box 39 1 Tallahassee, FL 3232 (85) 224-91 15 (85) 222-756 (fax) Paula K. Brown regdept@tecoenergy.com Manager, Regulatory Coordination Tampa Electric Company Post Office Box I I I Tampa, FL 336 I (813) 228-1444 (8 13) 228-177 (fax) 3. The objective of the proposed program is to convert the current standard MH and HPS street and outdoor luminaires to energy efficient Light Emitting Diode ("LED") luminaires, in order to significantly reduce the quantity of electricity consumed within the company's service area for street and outdoor lighting. All new installations under the program will be energy efficient LED luminaires. 4. Tampa Electric will seek recovery of the costs of providing the LED luminaires in a separate petition requesting approval of tariff provision for addressing that service. 5. Tampa Electric is seeking approval to recover the remaining unamortized costs in rate base for these MH and HPS luminaires that will be converted in this program within the ECCR clause. The unamortized amount for the eligible luminaires is $37,78,595 as of August 3 I. 217. and if approved, will be recovered through the ECCR at a rate to coincide with conversion of the luminaires. Tampa Electric projects this conversion will add approximately 44.4 cents to the ECCR clause in each of the five years the project is active. If the Program is approved, the company would begin recovering these unamortized costs and associated communication expenditures effective with the new ECCR factors in 219. 6. Tampa Electric has conducted cost-effectiveness tests showing that the Program is cost-effective as a DSM program with the following scores: 2

Rate Impact Measure Test: 1.5 Total Resource Cost Test: 2.17 Participant Cost Test: 61,884 7. Tampa Electric has approximately 242, street and outdoor lighting luminaires in operation at this time. Of these luminaires, 29,821 are non-led and are eligible to be convetted under the proposed conservation program. 8. Tampa Electric expects that if the Program is approved, the company will commence with the conversion project in the last quarter of2 17. The program should produce a total winter peak demand savings of 29.7 MW and an annual energy savings of approximately 127.9 GWh by the completion ofthis conversion project. 9. This proposal is consistent with prior Commission decisions for this type of conservation conversion of street and outdoor lighting to more energy efficient luminaires. See, e.g., Tampa Electric' s Docket No. 19871- EG. I. Tampa Electric believes this Program satisfies a strong desire by many cities and communities within the company's service area that have requested to have LED street and outdoor installed in place of MH and HPS luminaires. Cities and communities served by Tampa Electric, like other cities and communities across the United States, view LED street and outdoor lighting as a "win-win" proposition because of the energy savings associated with LED technology, coupled with the improved physical lighting characteristics that offer the prospect of increasing roadway safety and personal security in outdoor areas after dark. I I. LED street and outdoor lights offer additional benefits to cities and communities served by Tampa Electric. LED luminaires do not contain toxic chemicals, such as mercury, thus the risks associated with the ultimate disposal is not as great. Also, with LED lighting there is no waiting period for the lights to come on as compared to older street and outdoor luminaires. 3

Perhaps one of the most important features of LED luminaires is the directional nature of the light source. LED luminaires minimize light pollution because the distribution of the light is focused in one direction versus a more diffusion of light in many directions. Finally, LED luminaires provide for future opportunities to decrease the potential use of energy even further through dimming controls and can be leveraged to support smart cities functionality such as automatic notifications if the light is out or blinking in an area to show emergency responders where they are needed. 12. If this program is approved, the company plans to initiate separate communications and notifications regarding the project to the communities and customers the company serves. The cost of this advertising will be approximately $5, per year during the 5-year period of the program. 13. The approval of the company's proposed Conservation Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program will help Tampa Electric achieve the goals of FEECA and Commission Rule 25-17. I, Florida Administrative Code, is directly monitorable and will yield measurable results. 14. Attached hereto as Exhibit A" is Tampa Electric's proposed program description for its proposed Program. 15. Attached hereto as Exhibit B" are Tampa Electric's proposed program standards for its proposed Program. 16. Attached hereto as Exhibit "C'' is Tampa Electric's project summary for the luminaires and associated wattage changes eligible for its proposed Program. 17. Tampa Electric is not aware of any disputed issues of material fact regarding the matters asserted herein. There has not been any prior agency action in this proceeding; therefore, Tampa Electric cannot allege "when and how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision." Since there is no agency action for which Tampa Electric is seeking reversal or 4

modification, there are no statutes or rules Tampa Electric contends require reversal or modification of Commission action. WHEREFORE, Tampa Electric respectfully petitions the Commission to approve the company's proposed Conservation Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program, approve the program description contained in Exhibit "A" and program description and standards contained in Exhibit "B" and allow Tampa Electric to recover the remaining unamortized costs in rate base of its MH and HPS lumina ires and associated communication expenditures through Tampa Electric's ECCR clause. DATED this 5'h day of September 217. Respectfully submitted, n~~lz ~~.BEASLEY J. JEFFRY WAHLEN Ausley McMullen Post Office Box 391 Tallahassee, FL 3232 (85) 224-9115 ATTORNEYS FOR TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY 5

EXHIBIT A 6

TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY EXHIBIT A PAGE 1 OF 8 Program: Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program Start Date: TBD Program Description The Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program is designed to encourage the conversion from Non-Light Emitting Diode (LED) street and outdoor lighting luminaires to eligible LED luminaires in a five-year program. The goal of this program is to install energy efficient LED street and outdoor lighting technology to reduce the energy consumption and demand and reducing Tampa Electric's peak demand. Tampa Electric will recover the remaining unamortized costs in rate base with the eligible Non-LED luminaires. Program Participation Standards Program Standards are submitted concurrently with this program description. Program Savings Demand and energy savings were obtained using wattage data from each existing elig ible Non-LED lamps and the proposed LED lamps that will be installed in its place. Operating hours were estimated using the United States Naval ObseNatory tables for Tampa, Florida. The analysis yielded the following expected savings per lamp conversion performed: Summer Demand: Winter Demand: Annual Energy:. kw.133 kw 576 kwh Program Costs Unamortized depreciation capture: $18.6 per fixture. The estimated administrative cost per participant is $. Program Monitoring and Evaluation Tampa Electric will monitor and evaluate this program through cost-effectiveness techniques approved in the company's previously filed Demand Side Management Monitoring and Evaluation Plan, Docket No. 941173-EG. 7

PROGRAM NAME: STREET AND OUTDOOR LIGHTING CONVERSION (a) (b) (c} (d) (e) Total Annual Cumulative Cumulative Total Number of Number of Penetration Number of Number of Eligible Program Level Program Year Luminaires Luminaires Luminaires % Luminaires 217 29,821 29,821 3,51 1.7% 3,51 218 29,821 26,311 42,115 21.7% 45,625 219 29,821 164,196 42,115 41.8% 87,74 22 29,821 122,81 42,115 61.9% 129,855 221 29,821 79,966 42,115 82.% 171,97 222 29,821 37,851 37,851 1.% 29,821 223 29,821 1.% 29,821 224 29,821 1.% 29,821

PROGRAM NAME: STREET AND OUTDOOR LIGHTING CONVERSION \l}itiit:[~:'trrt~rn:mf:~1it?itii{~: ~utift1\tlj({~rn:m:~:r~ff:ml4<1tm8!k ~~tsa~:jff??\tn~~:::un:tti:~r:h:;:::mm:nr:mn?:~:ti{fjrf:m.m:~~:ttt~:~g Per Per Per Total Total Total Lumina ire Luminaire Luminaire Annual Annual Annual kwh Winter kw Summer kw GWh Winter MW Summer MW Year Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction 217 576.133. 2.22.467. 218 576.133. 26.28 6.68. 219 576.133. 5.538 11.669. 22 576.133. 74.796 17.271. 221 576.133. 99.55 22.872. 222 576.133. 12.857 27.96. 223 576.133. 12.857 27.96. 224 576.133. 12.857 27.96.

PROGRAM NAME: STREET AND OUTDOOR LIGHTING CONVERSION m:r:rimt::~:tm::rtt:::rmttj{:lu:::m:::::::rnn:::::rm%:{ttm~::tm:m:::m::m:r~mmtt:ae:::g.:e f9.s.rf\lto:8jit:jt:ttjtt::tm:::::mt~:::m::::u::(::::h:@i:::mtmtiuwtjtl: Per Per Per Total Total Total Lumina ire Lumina ire Lumina ire Annual Annual Annual kwh Winter kw Summer kw GWh Winter MW Summer MW Year Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction Reduction 217 69.142. 2.139.497. 218 69.142. 27.84 6.463. 219 69.142. 53.469 12.428. 22 69.142. 79.135 18.393. 221 69.142. 14.8 24.359. t-oo' 222 69.142. 127.867 29.72. 223 69.142. 127.867 29.72. 224 69.142. 127.867 29.72.

INPUT DATA PART 1 PROGRAM TITLE: Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion PROGRAM DEMAND SAVINGS & LINE LOSSES (1) CUSTOMER KW REDUCTION AT THE METER (2) GENERATOR KW REDUCTION PER CUSTOMER (3) KW LINE LOSS PERCENTAGE I. (4) GENERATION KWH REDUCTION PER CUSTOMER I. (5) KWH LINE LOSS PERCENTAGE I. (6) GROUP LINE LOSS MULTIPLIER I. (7) CUSTOMER KWH PROGRAM INCREASE AT METER I. (8)" CUSTOMER KWH REDUCTION AT METER II. II. II. II. ECONOMIC LIFE & K FACTORS (1) STUDY PERIOD FOR CONSERVATION PROGRAM (2) GENERATOR ECONOMIC LIFE (3) T & D ECONOMIC LIFE (4) K FACTOR FOR GENERATION ~ II. (5) K FACTOR FORT & D t-' (6Y SWITCH REV REQ(O) OR VAL-OF-DEF (1) UTILITY & CUSTOMER COSTS Ill. (1) UTILITY NONRECURRING COST PER CUSTOMER Ill. (2) UTILITY RECURRING COST PER CUSTOMER Ill. (3) UTILITY COST ESCALATION RATE Ill. (4) CUSTOMER EQUIPMENT COST Ill. (5) CUSTOMER EQUIPMENT ESCALATION RATE Ill. (6) CUSTOMER & M COST Ill. (7) CUSTOMER & M ESCALATION RATE Ill. (8)" CUSTOMER TAX CREDIT PER INSTALLATION Ill. (9)" CUSTOMER TAX CREDIT ESCALATION RATE Ill. (1 )' INCREASED SUPPLY COSTS Ill. (1 1)' SUPPLY COSTS ESCALATION RATE Ill. (12)' UTILITY DISCOUNT RATE Ill. (13)' UTILITY AFUDC RATE Ill. (14)' UTILITY NON RECURRING REBATE/INCENTIVE Ill. (1 5)' UTILITY RECURRING REBATE/INCENTIVE Ill. (16)" UTILITY REBATE/INCENTIVE ESCAL RATE.133 KW /CUST.21 KW GEN/CUST 7.% 68 KWH/CUSTIYR 5.2 % 1 KWH/CUSTIYR 576 KWH/CUST/YR 25 YEARS 25 YEARS 25 YEARS 1.4181 1.4181 18. $/CUST. $/CUSTIYR 2.4%. $/CUST 2.3%. $/CUSTIYR 2.3%. $/CUST.%. $/CUSTIYR.%.6976.646. S/CUST. SICUSTIYR.% AVOIDED GENERATOR, TRANS. & DIST COSTS IV. (1) BASE YEAR IV. (2) IN-SERVICE YEAR FOR AVOIDED GENERATING UNIT IV. (3) IN-SERVICE YEAR FOR AVOIDED T & D IV. (4) BASE YEAR AVOIDED GENERATING UNIT COST IV. (5) BASE YEAR AVOIDED TRANSMISSION COST IV. (6) BASE YEAR DISTRIBUTION COST IV. (7) GEN. TRAN. & DIST COST ESCALATION RATE IV. (8) GENERATOR FIXED & M COST IV. (9) GENERATOR FIXED O&M ESCALATION RATE IV. (1) TRANSMISSION FIXED & M COST IV. (11) DISTRIBUTION FIXED & M COST IV. (12) T&D FIXED O&M ESCALATI ON RATE IV. (13) AVOIDED GEN UNIT VARIABLE & M COSTS IV. (14) GENERATOR VARIABLE O&M COST ESCALATION RATE IV. (15) GENERATOR CAPACITY FACTOR IV. (16) AVOIDED GENERATING UNIT FUEL COST IV. (17) AVOIDED GEN UNIT FUEL ESCALATION RATE IV. (18)' AVOIDED PURCHASE CAPACITY COST PER KW IV. (19)' CAPACITY COST ESCALATION RATE NON-FUEL ENERGY AND DEMAND CHARGES V. (1) NON-FUEL COST IN CUSTOMER BILL V. (2) NON-FUEL ESCALATION RATE V. (3) CUSTOMER DEMAND CHARGE PER KW V. (4) DEMAND CHARGE ESCALATION RATE V. (5)" DIVERSITY and ANNUAL DEMAND ADJUSTMENT FACTOR FOR CUSTOMER BILL CALCULATED BENEFITS AND COSTS 1(1) ' TRC TEST- BENEFIT/COST RATIO 1(2)' PARTICIPANT NET BENEFITS (NPV) 1(3)' RIM TEST BENEFIT/COST RATIO I I I 217 221 218 682.22 $/ KW 37.16 $/KW 69.64 $/KW 2.4% 12.27 $/KWIYR 2.4% 2.24 $/KWIYR 8.54 $/KWIYR 2.4%.198 CENTS/KWH 2.4% 13.2% 3.95 CENTS/KWH 3.69%. $/KWIYR.% 2.727 CENTS/KWH 1.%. $/ KW/MO 1. % 1. 2.17 61 884 1.5 "'tl m -I )> X )> G') :I: :!1:: m td "'tl )> <11 ~ )> m r.., m (') -I :: (') :!1:: "'tl )> z -<

TOTAL RESOURCE COST TESTS PROGRAM: Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (1) (11) (12) (13) CUMULATIVE INCREASED UTILITY PARTICIPAN T PROGRAM DISCOUNTED SUPPLY PROGRAM PROGRAM OTHER TOTAL AVOIDED AVOIDED FUEL OTHER TOTAL NET NET COSTS COSTS COSTS COSTS COSTS GEN UNIT T&D SAVINGS BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS BENEFITS YEAR S(OOO) $() $() $() $() $() $() $() S(OOO) $() $() $() 217 632 632 27 27 (65) (65) 218 7,763 7,763 157 4 1 567 (7,196) (7,331) 219 7,949 7,949 161 1,312 1,473 (6,476) (12,99) 22 8,14 8,14 165 2,143 2,38 (5,832) (17,754) 221 396 371 3,25 3,972 3,972 (14,721) 222 387 368 3,4 3,795 3.795 (1 2,13) 223 373 364 3,689 4,426 4,426 (9,59)... 224 361 361 2,468 3,189 3,189 (7,7) 1') 225 a 352 358 2,577 3,287 3,287 (5,153) 226 344 356 4,113 4,813 4,813 (2,53) 227 334 354 3.921 4,69 4,69 ( 181) 228 328 353 4,389 5,69 5, 69 2,233 229 316 351 3,477 4,144 4,144 4,78 23 39 35 4,185 4,844 4,844 6,93 231 3 349 4.588 5,236 5.236 8,131 232 295 348 4,613 5,255 5,255 1,42 233 285 347 5,719 6,351 6,351 12.21 234 278 346 6,238 6,862 6,862 14,381 235 275 345 5,653 6,273 6,273 16,245 236 277 345 5,119 5,742 5,742 17,839 237 28 347 5,548 6,175 6,175 19,442 238 281 35 5,319 5,95 5,95 2,886 239 282 353 4,839 5,475 5,475 22,128 24 287 357 5,958 6,62 6,62 23,527 -om... >>< 241 )> 287 36 7,323 7,97 7,97 25,17 (i):!:!!: mro "' )> NOMINAL 24,483 24,483 6,625 7,915 99,874 114,414 89,931 a>:::::j > m r- NPV: 21,483 21,483 2,93 3,579 4, 81 46,59 25,17 -n m ()... Discount Rate.6976 BenefiVCost Ratio - [col ( 11 )/col (6)). 2.17 :;tj!!: "' )> z -<

PARTICIPANT COSTS AND BENEFITS PROGRAM: Street and Outdoor Lighting Converston (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (1) (11) (12) SAVINGS IN PARTICIPANTS TAX UTILITY BILL CREDITS REBATES YEAR $,) $,) $!) 217 63 218 854 219 2,487 22 4,186 221 5,78 222 5,192 223 5,377 224 5,566 225 5,697... 226 5,815 cu 227 6,1 228 6,124 229 6,382 23 6,526 231 6,719 232 6,841 233 7,62 234 7.242 235 7,331 236 7,342 237 7,418 238 7,562 239 7.717 24 7,778 241 7,998 NOMINAL 146,356 NPV 61,884 In service year of gen unit 221 CUSTOMER CUSTOMER OTHER TOTAL EQUIPMENT O&M BENEFITS BENEFITS COSTS COSTS S!OOO) S! OOO) $() S! OOO) 63 854 2,487 4,186 Q 5,78 5,192 5,377 5,566 5.697 5,815 6,1 6,124 6,382 6,526 6,719 d 6,841 7.62 7.242 7,331 7,342 () 7,418 7,562 7,717 7,778 7,998 146,356 61,884 #DIV/1 CUMULATIVE OTHER TOTAL NET DISCOUNTED COSTS COSTS BENEFITS NET BENEFITS S!OOO) S! OOO) S!OOO) S!OOO) 63 63 854 861 2,487 3,34 4,186 6,453 5.78 1,331 5,192 14.37 5,377 17,624 5,566 21,96 5,697 24,418 5,815 27,587 6,1 3,644 6,124 33,561 6,382 36,42 6,526 39,118 6,719 41,732 6,841 44,22 7 62 46,62 7,242 48,922 7,331 51,1 7,342 53,138 7,418 55,64 7.562. 56,899 7,717 58,649 7,778 6,2.99 7.998 61,884.,m -4 146,356 )>>< )> G) ::I: s: m 61,884 ID.,... :::::j )> )> m r "T1 m () -4 AI () s:., )> z -<

RATE IMPACT TEST PROGRAM: Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (1) (11) (12) (13) (14) AVOIDED NET CUMULATIVE INCREASED UTILI TY GEN UNIT AVOIDED BENEFITS DISCOUNTED SUPPLY PROGRAM REVENUE OTHER TOTAL UNIT & FUEL T&D REVENUE OTHER TOTAL TO ALL NET COSTS COSTS INCENnVES LOSSES COSTS COSTS BENEFITS BENEFITS GAINS BENEFITS BENEFITS CUSTOMERS BENEFIT YEAR $() $() $() S(OOO) S(OOO) S(OOO) S(OOO) S(OOO) $() S(OOO) S(OOO) $() S(OOO) 217 632 28 659 27 27 (632) (632) 218 7.763 39 8,152 41 157 567 (7,585) (7723) 219 7,949 1,68 9,17 1,312 161 1,473 (7,544) (14316) 22 8,14 1,761 9,9 2,143 165 2,38 (7,592) (2517) 221 2,123 2,123 3,61 371 3,972 1,849 (1916) 222 2,144 2,144 3,427 368 3,795 1.651 (17927) 223 2,165 2,165 4,63 364 4,426 2,261 (16418)..- 224 2,187 2,187 2,829 361 Q 3,189 1,3 (15793) 225 2,29 2,29 2.929 358 3,287 1,78 (15164) 226 2,231 2,231 4,457 356 4,813 2,582 (13757) ~ 227 2,253 2,253 4,255 354 4,69 2,356 (12556) 228 2,276 2,276 4,716 353 5,69 2,793 (11226) 229 2,298 2,298 3,793 351 4,144 1,845 (144) 23 2,321 2,321 4,494 35 4,844 2,522 (9355) 231 2 345 2,345 4,888 349 5,236 2,892 (823) 232 2,368 2,368 4,98 348 5.255 2,887 (718) 233 2.392 2.392 6,4 347 a 6,351 3,959 (5834) 234 2,416 2.416 6,516 346 6,862 4,446 (4421) 235 2,44 2,44 5,928 345 6,273 3,833 (3282) 236 2,464 2,464 5,396 345 5,742 3,277 (2372) 237 2.489 2,489 5,828 347 6,175 3,686 (1415) 238 2,514 2,51 4 5.6 35 5,95 3,436 (581) 239 2,539 2,539 5,121 353 5,475 2.936 85 24 2.564 2,564 6.245 357 Q 6,62 4,38 941 241 2,59 2,59 7,61 36 (j 7,97 5,38 27 -om... NOMINAL 24,483 52,572 77,55 16,499 7,915 114,414 37,358 )>X )> G>:l.: s: NPV 21,483 23,1 44,583 43,11 3,579 46,59 2,7 mm " c»::::j )> m Discount rate:.6976 BeneftVCost Rallo- [col (12)/col (7)]: 1.5 )> 'T1 r m..., ) () () s: " )> z -<

EXHIBlTB 15

TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 1 OF 1 Program: Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program Participation Standards 1. Only active Non-Light Emitting Diode ("LED") luminaires, as identified in Tampa Electric's Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program, to be converted to LED luminaires are eligible for this program. 2. The unamortized collection amount is $18.6 per eligible converted luminaire. 3. Upon completion of the five-year Street and Outdoor Lighting Conversion Program, the company shall notify the Florida Public Service Commission within 3 days. 4. Tampa Electric will randomly perform field verifications on a minimum of 1 percent of the converted LED luminaires. All luminaires not selected for field review will have an office verification to validate installation information. 5. The reporting requirements for this program will follow Rule 25-17.21 (5), F.A.C. Additionally, program expenses will be identified in the ECCR True-Up and Projection Filings. 16

EXHIBIT C 17

TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY EXHIBITC PAGE 1 OF 1 Proposed Street and Outdoor Liqhtinq Conversion Proqram Luminaire Replacement Watt/fixture Count Luminaire Type Wattage LED Wattage saved 6,332 Cobra (closed) 62.5 27. 35.5 2 Post Top (closed) 62.5 26. 36.5 11,755 Cobra/Nema (closed) 87.5 27. 6.5 4,88 Coach Post Top (closed) 87.5 26. 61.5 82,91 Cobra 125. 47. 78. 5,6 Nema 125. 27. 98. 8,93 Classic Post Top 125. 39. 86. 3,387 Colonial PT 125. 7. 55. 18,62 Salem PT 125. 55. 7. 2,211 Shoebox 125. 88. 37. 14 3 Cobra 187.5 15. 82.5 12 General PT 187.5 39. 148.5 283 Salem PT 187.5 76. 111.5 13 Shoebox 187.5 15. 82.5 81 General PT 218.75 39. 179.75 946 Salem PT 218.75 76. 142.75 13 Shoebox (closed) 218.75 15. 113.75 18,24 Cobra 312.5 145. 167.5 886 Flood{_ closed} 312.5 199. 113.5 1,646 Shoebox 312.5 133. 179.5 131 Cobra 437.5 133. 34.5 51 Flood 437.5 199. 238.5 323 Shoebox 437.5 182. 255.5 13 355 Cobra 5. 182. 318. 2,43 Flood 5. 199. 31. 375 Monqoose 5. 225. 275. 1 38 Shoebox (closed) 5. 182. 318. 534 Cobra 5. 133. 367. 1,31 Flood 5. 199. 31. 4,57 Shoebox 5. 247. 253. 2,165 Flood 125. 255. 995. 3,365 Shoebox 125. 33. 92. 29,821 Total Avg. Per Luminaire Total kw Annual kwh saved saved 224.79 973,76.73 3 16 711.18 3,78,616 251.41 1,88,337 6,466.98 27,994,91 495.88 2,146,615 765.66 3,314 457 186.29 86,49 1,32.1 4 5,636,834 81.81 354,134 1,179.75 5,17,2 15.15 65,57 31.55 136,596 1.7 4,643 143.98 623,274 135.4 584 581 1.48 6,41 3.55.2 13,225,655 1.56 435,319 295.46 1,279,4 39.89 172,678 12.16 52,655 82.53 357,249 4,246.89 18,384,362 614.94 2,662.27 13.13 446,418 438.84 1,899,694 195.98 848,369 31.33 1.343,392 1,156.21 5,5,117 2,154.18 9,325,28 3 95.8 13,41,49 27,896.97 12,763,189.133 576 18