Third Cycle Validation Report

Transcription

1 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 1/8 Third Cycle Validation Report OF THE CCL 14B

2 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 2/8 Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION NORMATIVE REFERENCES STRUCTURE OF CCL PASS PASS AUTOMATIC TOOL ASSESSMENT To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences PASS To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences PASS To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences CONCLUSION... 8

3 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 3/8 1. Introduction Files for First Cycle: CCL14B CCL_15OCT14.zip complete file. Controlled Vocabulary 07JUL14.docx Controlled vocabulary file. Files for Second Cycle: CCL14B CCL_25NOV14.zip complete file. Controlled Vocabulary 25NOV14.docx Controlled vocabulary file. Files for Third Cycle: CCL14B CCL_07DEC14.zip complete file. Controlled Vocabulary 25NOV14.docx Controlled vocabulary file. This validation report only addresses this last document. No validation was performed on the Reference-BIE and Reference-qDT libraries. 2. Normative References Core Components Technical Specification (ebcc, a.k.a. CCTS) version 2.01 ISO Information Technology - Metadata registries: Naming and Identification Principles for Data Elements TBG17 CCL (Core Component Library) Submission Guidelines and Procedures UN/CEFACT/TBG17/N004 Draft Version 3.0 ICG AUDIT PROCEDURES CEFACT/ICG/2009/IC002 Version 1 Release 0

4 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 4/8 3. Structure of CCL 3.1 Pass Pass Pass 3

5 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 5/8 4. Automatic Tool Assessment 4.1 Pass To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts Rule C21 (The Dictionary Entry Name shall only contain verbs, nouns and adjectives unless a different part of speech is part of an official title, part of a term listed in the Oxford English Dictionary, or part of a Controlled Vocabulary.) Violations. UID DEN TYPE Comments UN Building Improvement. Occupied During Construction. Indicator BCC LM: Added to CV. UN Business Profile. Off Premises Activity. Percent BCC LM: Added to CV. UN Declaration Requirement. Rendered To. Code BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Insurance Object. Subject of Insurance. Code BCC LM: Added to CV. UN Insurance Policy. Insurer Duty To Defend. Code BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Insurance Policy. Other Insurance With Insurer. Indicator BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Insurance Policy. Paid In Full. Indicator BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Kitchen Protection. Automatic Gas Electric Shut Off. Indicator BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Kitchen Protection. Hood Duct Over All Equipment. Indicator BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Occupancy. Area Open To Public. Measure BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Proximity. From Subject. Code BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Proximity. To Subject. Code BCC LM: Already in CV. UN Security. Building Last Visited By. Code BCC LM: Added to CV. UN Transport Means. On Board. Gear ASCC LM: Added to CV. UN Vessel_ Transport Means. On Board. Fishing_ Gear ASBIE LM: Added to CV. Following words are not in English dictionaries of Oxford Dictionaries online at UID DEN/Definition Words Comments UN Vehicle. Auxillary Heating System. Indicator Auxillary LM: deprecated due to misspelling. UN The indication of whether or not the vehicle is equipped with an auxilliary heating system. Auxiliary LM: deprecated

6 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 6/8 due to misspelling. UN External Building Protection. Water Availablity. Code Availablity LM: Corrected. UN UN Building Insurance Factor. Content Earthquake Susceptability Grade. Code Validation Result_ Document. Validator_ Identification. Identifier Susceptability LM: Corrected. Validator LM: This spelling found in Oxford. It says a person who or thing which confirms the validity of something. UN The identifier of the validator for this validation result document. Validator LM: This spelling found in Oxford To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library Following BIEs are not based on any CC. UID DEN TYPE Comments UN Fishing_ Gear. Role. Code BBIE LM: Added BCC UN Vessel_ Identity. Vessel_ Name. Text BBIE LM: Added BCC

7 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 7/ To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences A following BIE in 14A has DEP indicator, however, that of 14B has no indicator. UID DEN TYPE Comments UN Document. Signature Location. Text BBIE LM: Corrected 4.2 Pass To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts Following Data Type has no representation term. UID DEN/Definition Type Comments UN Unit_ Measure_.Type DT LM: Fixed To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences Following DT in 14B are new Data Types, however, that have no indicator. UID DEN TYPE Comments UN Air Flow_ Unit_ Measure. Type DT LM: Removed from qdts; not used in any messages. UN Transport Service Category_ Code. Type DT LM: Removed from qdts; not used in any messages.

8 16 th Dec VALIDATION REPORT Page : 8/8 4.3 Pass To identify any inconsistencies with the unique identification of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies with the names of the artefacts To identify any inconsistencies between the ASCCs and the target ACCs To identify any inconsistencies between the UDT library and the ACC library To identify any inconsistencies between the QDT library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies between the ASBIEs and the target ABIEs To identify any inconsistencies between the ACC library and the ABIE library To identify any inconsistencies of 14A / 14B Differences 5. Conclusion We are pleased to announce that the Core Component Library for 14B have been produced in compliance with existing procedures and we consider that it is going to satisfactory for publication. END