OPTIMAL LOCATION OF THYRISTOR CONTROLLED SERIES COMPENSATOR USING SENSITIVITY APPROACH NEW HUANG CHIN UNIVERSITI TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA

Transcription

1 OPTIMAL LOCATION OF THYRISTOR CONTROLLED SERIES COMPENSATOR USING SENSITIVITY APPROACH NEW HUANG CHIN UNIVERSITI TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA

2 OPTIMAL LOCATION OF THYRISTOR CONTROLLED SERIES COMPENSATOR USING SENSITIVITY APPROACH NEW HUANG CHIN A project report submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Master of Engineering (Electrical-Power) Faculty of Electrical Engineering Universiti Teknologi Malaysia JUNE 2014 i

3 To my wonderful family, I love you with all my heart. iii

4 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT First of all, I would like to express my gratitude to my project supervisor, Prof Ir. Dr. Mohd Wazir Mustafa, for his admirable support and guidance throughout the research. I would also like to extend my appreciation to my wife, Ooi Hsiao Ping for her love, patience, and encouragement. And most importantly her understanding of allowing me to spend most of time on this project report. Last but not least, I must acknowledge my parents whom without their support, I could never been capable of accomplishing my studies and academic work.

5 v ABSTRACT The vast development and world globalization had caused the existing power system in most country to hit its bottleneck. In order to sustain the demand, the current power supply will need to be expanded. Due to cost saving from expansion the power system network, the system operator has to allow the system to operate nearer to the system thermal limit and subsequently increase the transmit capacity. The Availability Transfer Capability (ATC) can be increased using Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS). However, FACTS devices are very expensive and high generation scheduling cost. This project is to focus on how to determine the optimal location to install this expensive FACTS devices. Optimal location of the installation of FACTS devices can be determined using the sensitivity analysis. There are several types of FACTS devices, and Thyristor Controlled Series Capacitors (TCSC) has been selected to use in the project report on account of its overall performance and cost effectiveness to relieve congestion. The scope of this project report will using sensitivity based approach to determine the optimal location of TCSC. MATLAB is used to perform the power flow of the power system and the result is adopted into sensitivity index model. Then the location of the TCSC is determined using the most positive sensitivity index. The simulation is tested using POWERWORLD on chosen 5-bus system, IEEE 14-bus system and also 30-bus system. As a result, the optimal location of TCSC is determined and verified.

6 vi ABSTRAK Pembangunan and globalisasi telah menyebabkan system kuasa yang sedia ada dalam kebanyakan negara mencecah kesesakan. Dalam usaha mengekalkan permintaan, bekalan kuasa perlu dipertingkatkan. Pengendali sistem kuasa perlu membenarkan sistem untuk beroperasi hamper kepada had sistem haba supaya boleh jimat daripada pengembangan rangkaian sistem kuasa, dengan ini keupayaan menghantar kuasa dapat dipertingkatkan. Keupayaan keterdapatan perpindahan boleh ditingkatkan menggunakan Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS). Walau bagaimanapun, peranti FACTS sangat mahal dan kos generasi tinggi. Projek ini adalah untuk memberi tumpuan kepada bagaimana untuk menentukan lokasi yang optimum untuk memasang peranti FACTS. Lokasi optimum pemasangan alat-alat FACTS boleh ditentukan dengan menggunakan analisis sensitivity. Thyristor Controlled Series Capacitors (TCSC) telah dipilih daripada beberapa jenis peranti FACTS untuk digunakan dalam laporan projek disebabkan oleh prestasi keseluruhan dan keberkesanan kos untuk memberikan kestabilan sementara. Skop laporan projek ini akan menggunakan pendekatan berasaskan sensitivity untuk menentukan lokasi optimum TCSC. MATLAB digunakan untuk melaksanakan aliran kuasa sistem kuasa dan hasilnya dipindahkan ke dalam model indeks sensitivity. Kemudian lokasi TCSC ditentukan menggunakan indeks sensitivity yang paling postitif. Simulasi ini dilaksanakan dengan menggunakan POWERWORLD pada sistem 5-bas, IEEE sistem 14-bas dan juga sistem 30-bas. Kesimpulannya, lokasi optimum TCSC ditentukan dan disahkan.

7 vii TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER TITLE PAGE DECLARATION DEDICATION ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ABSTRACT ABSTRAK LIST OF TABLES LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF APPENDICES iii iv v vi vii xi xii xiii 1 INTRODUCTION Introduction Problem Statement Objectives Scope of Work Report Organization 3 2 LITERATURE REVIEW Introduction FACTS technology Brief Modeling of FACTS Controllers The Thyristor-controlled Reactor The Static Var Compensator The Thyristor-controlled Series Compensator 7

8 viii The Static Compensator The Solid State Series Compensator The Unified Power Flow Controller Advantages of TCSC Sensitivity Approach on TCSC Other Researchers Works Sensitivity Based Analysis For UPFC Real Power Flow Performance Index Sensitivity Approach For TCSC Loss Sensitivity Indices for SSSC Summary 16 3 METHODOLOGY 3.1 Introduction MATLAB MATPOWER POWERWORLD SIMULATOR 20 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 4.1 Introduction Bus Test System Solution Using Sensitiviy Analysis Manual Installation To Other Lines Bus System Discussion IEEE 14-Bus Test System Solution Using Sensitivity Analysis Discussion IEEE 30-Bus Test System Solution Using Sensitivity Analysis Discussion Summary 34

9 ix 5 CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORKS Conclusion Future Works 35 REFERENCES Appendix (A-C) 39-78

10 x LIST OF TABLES TABLE NO. TITLE PAGE 4.1 Sensitivity Coefficient Simulation Summary Summary of Result From Installing TCSC at Different Branch Sensitivity Index For IEEE 14-Bus System Sensitivity Index Comparing Zone A and Zone B Sumamry of TCSC Installation in Different Line Sensitivity Index For IEEE 30-Bus System Most Sensitive Line In IEEE 30-Bus System Summary of TCSC Installation in Different Line In IEEE 30-Bus System 34

11 xi LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE NO. TITLE PAGE 2.1 Family Tree of FACTS Devices Model of TCR Model of the SVC Model of TCSC Model of STATCOM Model of SSSC Model of UPFC Model of transmission line with TCSC Injection Model of TCSC Flow Chart for Proposed Method in Effective Location of TCSC Operating Range of a TCSC (Solid Lines) and allowed regions for the reactance (bold lines) Bus Test System IEEE 14-Bus Test System Power Flow Concentrated in Zone A of IEEE 14-Bus System IEEE 30-Bus System 30

12 xii LIST OF APPENDICES APPENDIX TITLE PAGE A.1 MATLAB M-file For 5-Bus System 40 A.2 MATPOWER RESULT OF POWERFLOW 41 A.3 POWERWORLD With 5-Bus System 42 A.4 20% of TCSC in 5-Bus System 42 A.5 65% of TCSC in 5-Bus System 43 A.6 20% TCSC at line 1-2 in 5-Bus System 43 A.7 20% TCSC at line 2-3 in 5-Bus system 44 A.8 20% TCSC at line 1-4 in 5-Bus system 44 A.9 20% TCSC at line 2-5 in 5-Bus system 45 A.10 20% TCSC at line 3-5 in 5-Bus system 45 B.1 IEEE 30-BUS Common Data Format 46 B.2 MATLAB M-file of 14-Bus IEEE System 48 B.3 MATPOWER Power Flow Output of 14-Bus IEEE System Page 1 50 B.4 MATPOWER Power Flow Output of 14-Bus IEEE System Page 2 51 B.5 IEEE 14-Bus System in POWERWORLD 52 B.6 IEEE 14-Bus System in POWERWORLD With 70MVA Line Limit 53 B.7 20% of TCSC Installed in Bus 12 to Bus B.8 20% TCSC Installed in Bus 3 to Bus 4 55

13 xiii B.9 IEEE 14-Bus With 20% TCSC On Line 1 (Bus 1 to Bus 2) 56 B.10 IEEE 14-Bus With 20% TCSC On Line 2 (Bus 1 to Bus 5) 57 B.11 IEEE 14-Bus With 20% TCSC On Line 5 (Bus 2 to Bus 5) 58 B.12 IEEE 14-Bus With 20% TCSC On Line 4 (Bus 2 to Bus 4) 59 B.13 IEEE 14-Bus With 20% TCSC On Line 7 (Bus 5 to Bus 4) 60 C.1 IEEE 30-BUS Common Data Format 61 C.2 MATLAB M-file of IEEE 30-Bus System 64 C.3 MATPOWER Power Flow Output of IEEE 30-Bus System 67 C.4 IEEE 30-Bus System in Power World Simulator 70 C.5 IEEE 30-Bus System With 80MVA Line Limit in Bus 3 to Bus 4 71 C.6 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 3 to Bus 4 72 C.7 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 1 to Bus 3 73 C.8 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 2 to Bus 4 74 C.9 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 3 to Bus 4 75 C.10 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 2 to Bus 5 76 C.11 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 2 to Bus 6 77 C.12 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 4 to Bus 6 78 C.13 IEEE 30-Bus With 20% TCSC On Bus 5 to Bus 7 79

14 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction Despite the rapid and extreme pace of world development in recent year, the rate of growth for transmission facilities construction speed is still much slower compared to load demand growth. Amongst the reason is because the power utility operator is still using the existing infrastructure with minimum investment to meet this load demand growth. In addition, environmental factor, economic reasons and other factors also contribute to this dilemma. After years of research and observation, Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS) is introduced to solve this problem. 1.2 Problem Statement From the introduction, there is a lot of FACTS technology that can be used to enhance system performance by controlling the power flows in the network. Each FACTs devices is suitable in different application such as load flow control, voltage control. Hence the optimal location of FACTS devices should be determined. 1

15 2 1.3 Objectives The main objectives of this project is to determine the optimal location of TCSC devices in order to relieve the system congestion. The methodology will be carried out in a 5-bus system, IEEE 14-bus system and finally IEEE 30-bus system. Other sub-objective is to master the application to perform power flow and to simulate power flow analysis using software such as MATLAB and POWERWORLD. 1.4 Scope of Work In order to achieve the research objective several works need to be done. First to perform literature review on previous researchers works, to study FACTS devices and explore which is suitable for steady state condition. Besides, the method to solve power flow in power system need to be explore and master in order to determine which is the most suitable method to carry out power flow calculation. Follow by deciding the method for determining the optimal location for TCSC. Lastly, the results of optimal location is verified by using software simulation.

16 3 1.5 Project Organization This project is represented by five chapters as below: Chapter 1: Introduction to this project is being discussed. The problem statement, objectives, scope of works and project outlines is elaborated. Chapter 2: Discussion about the FACTS technology in power system, the types of the FACTS devices and how they are being installed and performed in power system. This chapter is to have a review on other researchers works on deciding the optimal location of FACTS devices mainly on the sensitivity analysis approach. Chapter 3:The methodology and software being used in this project is eloborated. Two main software to be used in this project is MATLAB and POWERWORLD. Chapter 4: This chapter is the results and discussion obtained in this project which is tested differently on 5-bus test system, IEEE 14-Bus test system and IEEE 30-Bus test system. Chapter 5: The last chapter is about the conclusion of this project and the future possible works which can be done to fine tune the optimal location of TCSC in power system.

17 37 REFERENCES [1] Miller, T.J.E., 1982, Reactive Power Control in Electric Systems, John Wiley Interscience, Chichester. [2]Kinney, S.J., Mittelstadt, W.A. Suhrbier, R.W., 1995, Test Results and Initial Operating Experience for the BPA 500KV Thyristor Controlled series Capacitor:Design, Operation, and Fault Test Results, Northcon 95, in IEEE Technical Conference and Workshops Northcon 95, Portland, Oregon, USA, Oct. 1995, New York, pp [3] Nabavi-Niaki, A., Iravani, M.R., 1996, Steady-state and Dynamic Models of Unified Power Flow Controller (UPFC) for Power System Studies,IEEE Trans. Power Systems 11(4) [4] Venu Yarlagadda, Dr.B.V.Sankar Ram, Dr.K.R.M.Rao, 2012, Automatic Control of Thyristor Controlled Series Capacitor (TCSC)(IJERA) Vol.2, Issue 3, May-Jun 2012, pp [5] Tlijani Kamel, Guesmi Tawfik, Hadj Abdullah Hsan and Ouali Abderrazak, 2012, Optimal location and parameter setting of TCSC based on sensitivity analysis, First International Conference on Renewable Energies and Vehicular Technology. [6] B.Likhitha, J.Srinivasa Rao, J.Amarnath, Sensitivity Approach For The Effective Location of TCSC in a Deregulated Electricity Market, 2012, IOSR Journal Of Engineering ISSN: Volume 2, Issue 6 (June 2012), PP [7] G.Vinod Kumar, J.Srinivasa Rao, J.Amarnarh, 2013 Transmission Congestion Management by Using Series Facts Devices and Changing Participation Factors of Generators, International Journal of Modern Engineering Research (IJMER), ISSN: [8] Bongkoj Sookananta, 2009 The Sensitivity Index and The Differential Evolution Technique Applications on The Determination of FACTS Placement [9] Swapnil Sute & V.P. Rajderkar, 2012, Sensitivity Based Analysis For the Optimal Placement of UPFC for Congestion Management [10] P.S. Vaidya and V.P. Rajderkar, 2012, Enhancing Power System Security By Proper Placement of Thyristor Controlled Series Compensator (TCSC), LACSIT International Journal Of Engineering and Technology, Vol.4, No.5

18 38 [11] Navid Eghtedarpour& Ali Reza Seifi, 2011 Sensitivity-Based Method For The Effective Location of SSSC, Journal of Power Electronics, Vol.11 No.1,January [12] [13] [14] [15] Xunchi Wu, 2010, Reactive Power Compensation Based on FACTS Devices, Columbia University, USA.