Rousseau et les physiocrates : la justice entre produit net et pitié

Transcription

1 Rousseau et les physiocrates : la justice entre produit net et pitié Yves Citton To cite this version: Yves Citton. Rousseau et les physiocrates : la justice entre produit net et pitié. Études Jean-Jacques Rousseau, 1999, Rousseau: économie politique, pp <hal > HAL Id: hal Submitted on 25 Jul 2013 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.

2 «Rousseau et les physiocrates : la justice entre produit net et pitié», In Etudes Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Numéro spécial Rousseau: économie politique, édité par Reinhard Bach, 1999, pp A BCDCEFD EDCACA ABCDDDABEFEDAAE ADD FAEE CE AE FD DE A BD ABDFDDEEEDADBAEDBFAE DDDECCDEEAFBDEBFEEED BADEEEEAEFEECCDDBDAE ADEAEDEDEDDDEEEDDEEFCD AEEEDEAFBDDBEEDEE ADEFEDEEFEADEAEDEBEDE FCAEDEAEBDDDBEDEEFBDCDDBAEE BFEDDE EBDEDFBADEAFFD EEBEEFBEAEEFADDBEE FBDDABEEEEEEBDEAE DBEEEEEEFDFEEEDE FEAEDEEEEFADA B DE E E ABCEAE E ADDFE A E DFDEEEDEEDEEAEEBEDE EBDEEDEDDEECDEEEFBEE E AEFD EF E FD AE BDE E EDBADEABDEAEEBDE EDEEAEABFDDEEFD EADEEEEEEEEAEEEAEDB EDABCDEDDADDAEDD FF

3 2 Yves Citton ADEEBDEEBFEEDEABEFFEE FDDEAEEFDDEAEDEBEFEE DBEEEEDEDDFEDEAE EEDEEEDEAEBDDDBBBEDECDAE EDEFDEEEAEEEAEADDDE FADE AEAEFFDDBEDFDECDEAE EDDEFEEEEDEAEABDAE DDDBAEEEFEEEAEDDDCEED ABDEBDEEABDEEDEAEDE CDDEEDADEAEEABDE EEECAECDAEBDEFDDEEE AE DE DE FDDE AE FAD E ED DEEEEEFEEEAEFFEEEADD EFEDEAEEEEEEFAEEE FEDEDBEAEEEEDEAEDDEAEEDEDD DBBDDDBBBADBEEBEBBEEDDE FFEECBAEEEEDAEDE EAEEEEBDBDECDAEFFDDAE FDDFEAEEAEAADEAEA E AE FD FE F ED E AE FBFFBEEFEDAEDEEAEDAE DEEFDAEEABDBDEEAE BBDEAEAAEEDDEEADEABCDDEE AEAEDAEDEEDCCDEAE EBDDE DE CE ABEDD DBDE AFEBCFFEFEAEDEEF CEE AAEAEEDEEBDEDDEAE EDEDEFDEABAEDEAEED BDECEDDBCEDBDBDCDBDCEDB ABADEBDDBDDDEBCBEDEFCD DEBAEAEDDFDBDEAAEDDFDDBCEDBDED EEAEDEDBABE DAEDEDDAEBADEEDFCDED DADDEEDEDEEDCCDDBABDBDCEDB BBEDAEBAEDBDCAEDBEABDFEDDEDE EF

4 Justice entre pitié et produit net 3 EEEEFDAEEE ED ADEBFBEFDDEEEEEAD DEEAEAE EDEEEEEEAEDBDADDAE EEAEADBADEEEEEEDE DEAEFDDFEEEDADDADEDABF DDDAEEDBEEEDDDDEDEEE EFEAEEEFDEDCDEEEDEEDE AEDDEDEEAEEFDEECD FCEDAEEFEAEFDDADEEEEE EADBFEEEEFDEDADDA DFEDBEECDEFDEAEDBB FEEFECDEDAEECCEDEDC AADEEEEDECDFBDEDE DCDDEAEEEDEEFFDEEEEDA DDFDEEFEEEEBEEEDE EAEEEEDB DEEE DBEBAEEFDEFDECDEE EDEDECDFFBEDBEEFECDEDC FEAEDEDDECEEAEED EEEFEDF EEEEAEDFADAEEDEEED AEFDDEEDAEEEEEE DEEEFDEEEEDEE B EFEBEEEFECCDEEFDFE DDAEEEDDDEFEEDADCCBEEEE DE AE E AEDE E EDEAE BEEDCDBFEBDEAEAEEFD FDEEBFEFDEDDDBBDAEEEEE BFEDE AEEFEEDEFEEBDEAD ADEEEDFDBEAEEEEAABCDEEDDEEE DEBFAADEEEDEEEAECEEAEE DEEDDEDEEDEDD DBBDDDBBBADBDEEF EE FCD D D DE DF DAEDEDDAEDDDBEBDDBDEBD CCDEBDFEDDEDEFF FCDFDF EEEDDBAEEBDDE CDADDDEDF

5 4 Yves Citton ABADADEEFEAEEEDF EDFBDCBDEADADBBD BEDEEABFEAEEDEADEDEFDAE EEDE E E EEFD DE E A AED DADFEEEDDEFEFDCDE DEDDCECDF EADAEDEEDDEEDB FAEEAEDAEDE FDEEDDEAEFEDECCEABDE FDFEEAEDAEEAECEEDAE EAEDEEDEEFDEDEAE EDDAEEEAEDEFEEAEAEAE ABEEABAEFDDEAEDBBEFDEED E DE E FE EE DE A FEE DDEFBADEDDEECAEEE B B CDB AE DEABFEAE D CD AE DEEAEAEEECECD ABFE AE EE BE F FEAE E D E AE EFDAEBDEDFFEEEBEAE FDEEDECAEEEFFBE D CBD BE ADEEE AE ABCDDDEE DEAEAEEDEEEEEEEEE EDEEAEDFDEAEFECEDEEFAD EEFEFEEFFDFAE AE AE DE F AE E AE DE BEDEEBE EEFBDEEADE FCDFDF DEEEEDBAEADBDCD ADDEBABEDBDDDF FACEDBDEFEFBEDDEAE BDEFDDECDDFFEEDEDDDDDCDAD DAEEDEEFEFEDEAEEBDEA BDAEFEBEAEECDCDBDBDD ABBDCDDDCDDDAEDB BBBDDBEBBBADBABCDBADD EDEDDCDDBDEED ABEDDEDEAEDDDDEEE DEBDDBEDDDDDDFCDADDDBDD

6 Justice entre pitié et produit net 5 CAEEDEDEECDEADEE DFBDC AE FEE E E FDDFE AE DDD FADDEEEADDFDEEDDDCD DEEDCEECDEEDABDDCCDDABD DEDC E E FFBEDE E DE A E AE DEDECCDEDEEEAEDDDE E AE E F E EE D AD FE DEFFADAEDEAEDE EEEAABCDDDABEDAEEBDAAE DEADEAEFEAEEFADEDFFEB EDDDEEEFAEDEEEEDDEFEDE AEEEAEEEEDEADEEBE FBDEEEADDEEDFEEEEEE AECEAEDEDBEAEBBDBAEEEEE EEADDEFFFDEAEAD FFDBDECDEEDEDEDEABEBAE CDAEEECCEDEAEDEDDBBEB FE D E FE BD AE DEE E EE EFEDE AE DE DE E F DEEE EAABEFFEEEAEFFBDBBDE EDEEEEEDEFD EAFADEEEEEBDEEADAF EAEDFEEFAEEFADDFA EEFDEADEFADEEEBAD EFBEDDFEEE E FDEEAEDBBEBEAEEEFD EBBDCDAEDEEDBBEABEDEF ECDCAEDEEAEFAEEEE ADDAEEDEAEEAEEDEEDEFF DEEDEBCDCDBEDDDDCEDED FFEEFBDCDEAEBDEFDDECE BDEAEDAEEDDBEDDDEDCABEA EADEEEDEDDBCEDBF DFF DEADEBEDDDE DF BADEEDFDEFEF

7 6 Yves Citton EFEEDEFEEEDEEEEEDEE EE EDEAEEEDEAFADEDC FEAEBDEBDEEEEDEEAEAE E D E E EE E EDE EE F E DEAEDDABEDEBDAEEEDFFDED EE EAEAEFEBEBDEED FFDEAEADEEABEDBBDAEEFE DEAEDDEEEAEDDEEFADE BBDEDEAAEEDDFEEAE DEEFECCDEEFDEDFDDAEE AFDDEEFECEAEFEFEAEEEE AEA FEDE E B D DE EFD BDEAEDEEFFADEEEADD BDEEEADEADEEDEEEE EDEEEEDEEE EEEEEEAEDEDAEFEDE AEAEDEDAAEAEEED CDDEEDDCEEEEEEEEAE FDAEEADDE DDDAFADEEDE EEBDEAEFDEEFEEE D EE E F AE AE AE DE F AE E AE DE BEDE E BEDAEDEFAEFADDB EFCDFEEEDDE DEEEDDEEDEDEFAE DEEEAEDBDADDAEEAEEADE EEDADEAEEDEE DABADBBEFEDEEEDEFDEEE EBDECEEEFDCDEFFEE EDEEEDADEEFDDFEAEDEAEE EFEABDEDB DFAE DAEDEDDAEEEADEE EEDEEDBADCADDDDBBBDBAEDCA EDEADEF DEFDF ABCDEDFDF BADEEDFDEF DAEDEDDAECDBCCDBED AADDDF

8 Justice entre pitié et produit net 7 EEBFBEFEEEBDEDBEDBFEAE DEEEEDEDFAEDEDADEE EEAEAEDBAEDBDEAECDBEED AEDEEFDDFEAEFAECBADBDABDAE EEEDABDEFDDEDADDFEEFBBD ECCEDEEFDDADCDDDFBEEADDE FDCDEEDDEEEDEDEDFDAAEDD AEEEDEFFEEEAEEBD B E ABD AE DE ED DDE ADDDEFBAEDEEFDE BDEDEDDDEEFEEEAEBD AAFECDEEEAEDEEDE FEAFAEBDEFDDEEDDE EEEFEBADEFEEBBDEBDE EAAEFDEEDDEEECAA EEFEAEDCDEEEADEEDE DCDEEDABDCDDEDFDEDE EEDDEAEAEEAE FDEEEDEDF DEAEE CEDDFBEAEBEBEAEDBFEEE AEBBDEAEEDAEFFABD EEDCAEEEDBBEDFEAB FEEFFDEDDFBEDEE EEEAEDBDB EDCFFEECDA EBDEEDDEEEEEEED EEFDDDBADCDEAEDAADAED DDEDBBADEEEDBBDEBEBAEE DEEEEEEEAEDEFEAEDEE CDEEEDDEEECD DEABEDEAEEDD DEDEFCDFAEFEFEDEA EEDEEABDBEBFEADAEEDE DDEDBDCDEDEADFEAE DEDDEBDDEBEDB FDFF EEDFCDDBDBBCDDBABADB CBDBEEAEFF EEEEADDDEDEEED DEDBDEBADEDDDEF BADEEDFDEF

9 8 Yves Citton FEEEAEEDEEDDFEADFD ECEDDFBADEFEEEDBFDE AEEEDEFCDEEDEAEEEEE DBAECDE EBCDEAEEFAEAAED DEE EEEEADAED FDFDEDEDEEEBE EEDD EFDEEFDAEEEEFCAEBCDE EFDEEDEBAAEEEEEEAE EBDEEEEEEEAEDBD AEEEDDDEEEFEDEAEFDADB E FEEDEAEEFEEFAE ADEAEADEAEEADABBFBDE FDDEEEDABDEFDDEEADEABDABEF DBDBEBDEDFDEEFED EE D D D FE D DE D EEE AE ADDEAEFDAEEAEDEAE DDEAEFDAEFD DEDBEABEAEDEAFE EECDDCEAEDDDED EFAEDEFEEDEADB DEDDEEEFEAEEAEEFFCA EEEEDEFDBDAEEEDEE EAEEDEFDDEEEEEEEDEADE FD EDDAEDEFEFDBFE FDEEEFDDBFEEEEFDD DEADDAEDEE DAEFFFE EEAEFEAEBDBEEDEDEEEDACD ECDECDEEADE BEEEDDAEBBFEDFDDEA B E DECBEE EBDDE A E AE FB A BCEEDEDEDBEEFEFFDDE FACEDBDEF DDFDF DAEDEDDAEDBFCDBEA BDFEDDEDEEF BADEEDEF FACEDBDEF BDEBBEDCCDEDDBEBEAF BADEEDFDEF

10 Justice entre pitié et produit net 9 FDBAEEEDADEEFDDE AEADEEAEDB EEEDAEFFEEDEAEDAEDBE EEDEEAEBDEFDDEBDEEEEEE DEEEBEEDFDECADEE ECDEDFBEFEDEEDEAEDBDD AEEAEBFEFEDEEEE A FEFE CCDE E E FDDE AE CD E ADDEEBDDEAEEADEEABDE DEEDEEBFDEAEEEEEDA EEAEDEEDDEABDEFEE EAEDEEDEEDEDBD CCEAEEDEECCD DEFDEEBDEEADFEEEE ADEFDFEDEEDDED DBEADFABBBEECDEEEDFDEDAECDE BAEEDDDBD EAEAEADEEEFEFECCEAEEFD EEECCDEEFDAEFDEBFE DEAEAEBDEFDDBEEBDE CDEEAEDBEDDCDDEEEEFDEDEDEAD AEEFDFDDEAEDEDCDDD DFBDCAEDDDAEFADCDCDECDE AEDBDEDBDDCCEFFDEE FDEBEEEADBAEFDEDEE EEEFAEAEAEDEF AEEAEDEBEDEEBE EDAFDEEEDDE AE FD EE E AE DE FF AE DE E ABEEDEEFEAEEEFEDE EFEDDDAEEEEDDAEFEAEE EEAEEABDDABEEECDAEDE DAEEEEBDEAEBBDD EEAAEBDEEAEDEADEE AEFDECEDFBDBEDEEEAEBDE DEFDDEEFECEAE DEAE DEADBBEDECCDEDDBEBEA DFF DEAEEDEDEABEDCDABBDD BBDBAEABEDCABBDDADBDBDBADEDDD

11 10 Yves Citton BDEEEDEEADDAEEEDE FBEADDFEEEEFFE AEEDEEDBEFEEDECBEEE EEEDEEAEAEDDEEDCDDAE DCDEDBDEDEBEFEEEE EEDEEAECDEEDEEEDDDEED EDEEDEDEEEEEFDDDAE FECEAEEDEEDEAFDE ABDDFBDCAEBDE EDEEEDEEEBEEAEDCDE EFDDEEDEAEBDEDBADEEADEAEE DEADABFEAEAEDDED EFEDBFDEAEEEF CDEEDEAEEDEFABCDDDBDAEDEAEEDD ADFEAFECAEDCDEEFDEFEDDEA BEDEDDBAEEDEEAECDEDE DEEEEAEEEDADEDEDEEDE AEDEFFAEEFEAEEFEA ABEEFDDFEADBDBEEBDDAE DEAEADDDFDDEEDEDEAEDEADDEE FBEFEAEEAEDAEFDDEEBDE D BD E CD DCDE E DD A ADAE FFDBB EEECDEEFDEADEEEDBEDDFBAEE EFDEEADDDABBBEEEDEAEF EEDBAEEEDAEEEF DBCCDEEEDEEADE DBEFEDFEEEAEFEDBEEAEAE FEEAEAEDECDDAEDFBDEDECDE AEEFBEFEAEDBFBEFEAEDEDEEEE BEE D E E E A EE AE DE CE EEEDEFFAEDEBDEE E FBFFDE D ED AE EFDDE A E CDDEAEDDDDEFD F EDBEDBBDBAEEEFE F EEEBDEEFAED FEBCDBDBFDAEECD DBADEDB

12 Justice entre pitié et produit net 11 E EFE BB F E AED A DDDE DBFFDEDEEAEFFEDFDDBEAE DEFEEBDEECDEDBEEFD DEEABCCBEFDAEDFBDCF CDFEEEDEEEDEEEE BCBEEEEADBEDD EEEFDEAEFBEBDEBDE DFEFAEADDEEEEEBDEAE ADDBDEEEEAEBDAEBDEDE EEE AE BD E BE E DDE ABE FFEEDEEDCEDE ABADCDAEADDEDAEBABDE AEEEAEEDDDDAE EFADEEAEDEEADFBEEBDD CABDEDEEDEEFEDC EAEEEEEBEEADEEACDED ECDBEADFEDFEFCEF CAEECDADADDEEAEEAE DEEEDEDFBEEDEDE EDEEFEAEEFEEDEE DDEDEADADEEEEDEEEE CDDFADDEDEFDEAECDEDA FADEDEEEADEAAEEDDEEED EDFDEEEEEFADEEDE DDEB BEDEBADDEEEBDDDEBDE FDAEBBEEDEAEDED DEEDDDEEFEFE EAFDAEEAEEEDEEEDEEE EAEEFEBEDEEDEBADEEDDDAE DBEDDEAECBEEABBBE ADDDFEEEE EAEBEEEEEFDDAEFAEEED BDE E E DB AE DE DBD D EEEBBEAEDEEEAEDE FEEFEAEBDEBEBDEEFFB FDAEDEDECDEFECDEEAED EEFDEEEFFDEEDEEEED

13 12 Yves Citton EEAEDEDEBEDCEDEEE FEFBDBAEEEFE BBBEEDEEEEABCDDDBDEEF DDDEADEEAEFDAEBEE EDEEFEECDAEDEAEDE ABCDDEBDAEDEEFFDBBEDEAEDED EBEEFDDEEDECDEEEFDDED EDCAEDEEAEFFDBDECDEEFEE EEEEFADEFAEDEDEDE EEDDFADDBAEEEEEBBE AEDEEDEFADEFDEDECDEE ADEEEFFDEEEDEEEFFDBDE BAEEFEEFFEFEFDEE EFAEDEFABCDEEEEFEEEEE EEAEEAEDEEADBFCDEABD EBE BE D AE EE ABCDDD E DEE FFEEEEEEDECDEEEEE EDBAEADDBDEEDFBDEDFEAE DECDEBBEEADFEEFEDE EDEEDECDEFDDEEFEDDFEAE FDAEBBDBEEDADDAAECD ADDEEBEECBDBFEEDBAEBDE EEEDECDEBBEDFDEAEDCDEAED E E BDEE E E D EE AEFCDADEEEEDAEFEEEEE BDEEEFDEEEFEEFEEAE ECDEEADEDDDDAEDEE DDEDAECDEEAEDECDEBADEBBEAE DE FDD ABE E FD AE DEE AE DD EFADEDEEFFDEEDDAEEE EEADEDBDEDEDFFADEE DEABEEFEFEEEAD DEDCEDEABADCDBD DBBABDDEBEDFDFF

14 Justice entre pitié et produit net 13 E E ADDE E EEFE AE DB E E DE F ABE BDE EDE AE EE AE DE ECEEFEAEDDBDDEDCDE FDEAEEEEEECCEAEDBEBCEAEE EAEDEDEEEFAEDCDE EEEEBDFEEEDEEBFEFEEEA FDDDDEDFEDEEEDDDFDE EEEEADEFDEEEBDEEEEA EDBBFDEEEADDFDECDE DEEDEDDEDEAEFDE AAEFDDEDECEAEBAEDE EDCDDAEDEDFADEEADE AEEEFDDBEEDEADAEECEE CDEEEAEAECEBCCEF EEFDDBCEAEDEEBDEEEDE ACDAEDAEAEFCEDDDEAFDEE EEFEEEEEEEADCCEAE DDEEEDEADBEADBDAEDE DEEDCDDAECDEEE DAEEDAEFDDDEEE DEEADEEFEDEAEDEEE DEDAEEECDEFEEAE EADEEEAE BEFFEEFFDDEEEAEDAEE DCEDEFEEEEEDEFEEDAE ADDEDBFDEDAEAEDBFDBE EEDEEFEBBEEFAEDEEFDDEDE EDEDFFDEEDAECDEDD FDAEEADEECCDEFDEFFEE AEEDEDEFDDFEEFEAFDCEADEE EEDDEADDEBEDFBDEE BDE EDE E E E ADE E BAE BBE DE AE D E EDA D ADA ED DEEDDCDABEEDEAADEE ADDDBBDFCDDBAEDBE FFDEEEBDEAEEEBDE AEEDDEEEDDDFFAD BDDEDDDEBBBDDBDDEDAE DEDE EEDDDBDDDE DFF

15 14 Yves Citton E EDAEEECDDEEAEFE ADDADEEECAEEEEEAEFEBEE FBEEEEEEABBBAEEBE ECEEEFFEEDEE EFABCDAAEEFDDBEAE EEEBDEAEAEAEBDAE FDEEDEABDEEFBEEDE ABDEFDDEDDEAEDEDE FEEAEBBEEEFCDEEDEE ABDDEEDFFEEBDCDDBADAEBFE DBEDCCDEE DEEDEEE DDABDEEFEAEEAEEFFCAE EEEDEFADDEAEBDEBBEDCCDED DBEBEECEDEAEEECE EFEAEDDEDEEEEBE ECDAEDEEEADEEFDDEED FFEBDEEBEFDDBEEDFBEACAE DEDEAEDEDBEEE DFDEDEEEDCDEADEFBEEFE EAEEFEAEFAAEFDAEE EEEDBDEEEDEEEDDEE AEEEEDBEBEDDDFDE FDDEAEDE EAEBE AEDDBDDDEEAEDEADCCBBEEADAE BDEFDDEAEDEAEBECD FEDEEDEEEEEEEDEEE EEEDACCDEFDBAEDEDBDEDDE EEEDEEEEEDBAEEEDE EFDDEAEEAEEEEEDFDBF FDDBDEEEBDEFEFEEFFEEA DEBDEAEDEEAEFDEEEE EEEEECEABEFDEEAFDEEAD AEAEDDEDEADBDE DDCDDFDEEEDAEEDCDFDDD DFDFFCDFDF EEBEBBEEDDDBDCDBDB AECDBCCDBDDADF EEBBDDDDDBDDEDB CADBDDABDAEEF AEF

16 Justice entre pitié et produit net 15 EEEEDEEEEAE DEFEDEBADEEDEBDEE FBDEEEDEAEFDEAE AEDEADEEECAEEDBFEEAE DEEAAEADEEDEAFEE FDAEEAEFFDBDECDEAEEAEDBB EEECCBEEEEEAECDEEEAE D AEDCB BEABEA ADEFEEDBDBEEEEFBAAEEEE AEFDEABFBABBADEAEEDAEEAE EEEDEEABDBDEDEEEADDDADEAE ADDDEEAEDADDAEDBDEDFBE FEDEDBEFAEFEED AEDEDDDEEEEFDDEAEFD FDDFFBEFADEFAEBDEAEDEADEEE ADDEABEEEEEFFBE FBAEEDEFFDBDECDEEFDDAEE DECDEFEEEEAEEDEDEAE EEDEDEEFEDEEDEDCEE DDBEEBDAEDEBDEEDEEEE DEEAEDBCCEDADDEEEE FEDEBDAEFDDBDEDDE FDBDEEDEFCCEDDE EABCDDEDDEADEFEDAEDCDDDDEEEE DFEEDEAEDED EDEDBAEDADEDEDE EEE DAEDCDDDEDEFDDEEEDABDAEDEE EADDCFFEFEEDFEFEDEAEDE FDEFDEAEEEEFEEE BADE EDDEEDBFEBCEDAEEAEEEAE DEEAAEEADEDAEFEAECD EDAEEFCAEEFDAEDBB EEFFDDAEDEDADEDEDFE EEEEBDEEDEEAEFEBEEE DEEDBDADDAEAEEDE DBBEEEEEDEEEEEEE FCDFDF FCDFDFF DDDBDFDF

17 16 Yves Citton ECDEEEDDDFDDEDADEAEADD DCDDEEAAEEDABDD FBEEDEEAEDEADAEDEDEEA E E D E CE E AE E EDC ABEDB BDEEE EABDD DE DEEFE DEDDE EEEDBDEEFEEFEAE EDFDEAEBDEECEDEEEF AEDEDEFFECEAEEEBDEADE DEEFEAEEDFDFDEBD FADAEDEEFAFEEDDDECD E DAE AE DFDE AE FECEDE E FADEEFEFEEFFD F AE AE AE DE F AE E AE DE BEDE E BE AE EE E FDEDEEDEBDEDAD DEEFEEEDBDADDAE BBAEEFCDEDEABFEAEDEEDBE EEEABEFFEEAEDBBEEEEEAFFEDCE CD ADB D BDE DDEEE BEE AB E DED FBE E DADDA EEEFBEAEFFAEABFEAEDBEDE EDEEFEEEEEEEE AD EE DD E ADDE DCDDEEE E CE ADDFDDEDEDEEECCEFFEDCAEEFF AEABFEAEDEEAAEDDDE AEFFEDEADDEFEDEDDEE FEDBEFEDEAEEEDDFDDE D E D BDB AE AD DDEE FAD AE DEBDFBAEDAEFFEDEBEAEDBB DBDDEEBEFDDDAEDADDA EFDE AE EE E BDE AE EE DD E AE EEFEAEBDDFCDEAEFEFE FDEEDEDEDEAEEEAEDE EEAEEDECCD EAEEDAEBEBDEAE DEDCDD E D EB DE FDE EDE FEEAEFBEDEDDEFEDEEEEAE DEEEEFACEDBD DEDDEDBCBEDBDBCCDED DBEBDDDEDBAEBEADF

18 Justice entre pitié et produit net 17 EDBFDEAEEEDEFCDEEDEAE EDEEADDCDEDEEE DEEEFFEEDAEDEDAEDECDEDAE EAFABFBEEEECAEEEEAE DEECDFDEADEAFDEEEEDA DEDEDEEADDEFEAEDE DEFEEEBEEEDAEEEDE E E EE DCDE EE DE DE D FADEDADEDDEDEEFDDEEEE EDAAEDAEFEDEDEAE DEEDEFDAEDEDDEAED DEDFEDEDFEDEEDEADED FEFEDEADDDEBEFFDBB EDEEEDAEDEDEEAEEADDEE AEAEEFAEFECEDDEABEDE DEDBEEDEAEEEFFDDBBEEEE AEEEEEADEFDECDAEAEE FADEABCDDDEAEBDEEB DEEEEADDDBDEEEEEDE AEAEEDEEEDBDAEDEEAE EABDFAEE DDEEAEFEEE BDEEFEABEEEABCDDDAE FDAEDEEAEDECDEFFBEFAE FBFFEAEAEAEFDDBEAEDEFEE BABDEEFDDEEFEAEEAE DEEEDEACDAEDAEAEFCEDDDE AFDEEEEFEEEEEEA DDFFFAEAEFCDEAE ABEDEEEBDEFEDECCDBAEEBBE AEDEEAEBCACDE FEFECDEEDEAEBDEEADE A E DBB ABCDD E BBD AE E CE AE FADEBDAEDEEDCDEEDED FCDFDF

19 18 Yves Citton DBEDDFCEDDBEEAEEEE DEFADEEDEAEECDEEFDEFEE EEBEEFDDEEEDFDE EADECDDDDDEEFEE ADCDEFEDEEAEEEEFBDEE ADEEEADFDE EEEDEE AEFFDAEFBCBEEEADEBDBE FDAECDADDEEADDCFFE FE ABBEED EE EE A D DDEEADFFDFEEEEFDAEBEED AECAAEDEEFEFEADCCD EEEFDAEEEEEDEAEEDAEE FAD EEDDAEEEEEECDEF EEEADEADEADDEAD AEDEDEABDEBEE AE AEEE DD ED FDDFE E AE E DEEAEEDBBAEDEDE CDAEEEBDEEEBEAEEDABE ADEFEEFADDEBDEEAEEBB FAEEACCEEDAEDEEEEDC DDEFDEAEDEEDABEDDCD AECEEAEEDEEEEBAFDDE DBEEDEAEEDEAEBDDDDEE BFEFAEEBEEEAEEFFDD FDEEEEFEDEDAEDEEA ECEDEADAEEEEEEDAECD AEDE BDE EDBE F E ECEE EEDAE DFEAEBFEFAEFEFDFDEE ABEEDAEDBAEFEBEEDEEFCD FE DE AE CE EE E ADDFECDDEEEEEBEBBEEDDE DEDEFDDEFFEEDBEEEEDE ABCDEDFDF DEEDDEDEED FDECCDEDDBBDEAFF DFEEFEDEADDBDEAE EAEAEEDEEDDBD DEBDCDDEEEEEEEE AEEEFDDDEDEEEBCDDBDBDDBEDD DDDEEDE

20 Justice entre pitié et produit net 19 AEBDDDEABFEDEAEEAADEFEFEDE FDEEEFEEBEFFABDE EEAEFEEADCCBEDDBEDEEEE AEEEFEBEFDDEBEEEECDEEEE EEBDEFDBEEEEDBFEEE FFEEDDEEBDDDDBDAEBDDD DDEFEDEEAEADEEBE FCDBDEEEFDEBEAFDDEEE FDDAEDEBDDEEEEBDEFE EEAEEBEEAEDBFDDEAEDE FADEAEDEDADDAEEEE ADDAEFDDDBAEDEEECDEFEE EABDEEEDFDEBDEEFBEE DEEDEEDBADEEFEEDDAE FDDEEFDEEDBDEAEEBDEE DDAAFEEFDDAEEDEADDDDDDE DFBCEEFEEADEE ABDDCAEDEAEFDAEDEEDED ADEEADECDCDBFEBADCDAEDDE EDEEDBDEAEDBBDBCDAEE EBDEEFEEEDDFEACEAE ABDECDDABDEEEEBFDAEAEE DDEE EEEDAEDEEAEEEFDEE AEDEBDEEEEEEEEEDFEE AEEAADEFDDBDEDEDEAE DEDBEBECCDDDBBDFEF AEEDFDEDEAEBEEBDDD CEDCEDBABBDEEAFCDF DFEEAEEEEEAEEDCDEAEFEE ADEEDBBFEEEEDCDEAEF EEEDEFDEFDEEEFF ADCCDDEEEEEAECDEADE EDAEEA FDDEABDEEAEDEEEDFDEE EEABDEBAEABEEEADDFDEEE EFDDDEDEAEFDDECDEAEADDAEE AEFEEDDDFEEBAABABBDDD DDBFDBBEDBDBEBEDEFF BEBBEEDDFDFFCDFDF BBDDDDDBFDF

21 20 Yves Citton FDAEDEEEDDEDEEED EDEEEEDDFDEEAE ADFDAEEFEEAEEEDE CDAEDBBEAEEDCDAD EE F EDE E EE DDE EE DE E DEEEEDEBEEEAEEDED AEEDEEDEEEEBDEAEDEDD EFDDEEDEEEFEFDDBAEABBBEE CDEEDCABBDEEBEAEEEED EDEEEEEAEDE E EDEEEFDDEEAEAEDEBDEABE BCDE EE DEE A E BFE D AD FEDEEECCEFEEEAEDBE E DEEE FAEE ABD F A ECCAEE AE DEEEFEEFEDDEDADEFEFEAE ABCDBEAEDEEDABCEDEEE EDEADFDDCDCAEDBEFDEF AEEEDEAEDEEAEBDBDAEEEECD AEEBADEFDDAEDBBDDBBDEEE BDEAEDEEAEFEFEDEDEBDEDEEDDE ADEEAEAEDEBDDEE E DDE AE E E A EE AE DE BDEEABCEDEEEEEEEDF AEDEEEEAEDDEDCEEEE BBDDDDDBFDF FCDFDF EDCDDDDDDEDBAADEBD DBEFEADDEAEDEFECCAEE AEDEEDDAEEBDDDDD BBDDDDDBFDF