AGENDA REPORT. Martha Eros, Transportation Planner MODIFYING PREFERENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE D ON THE

Transcription

1 Page 1 of2 2. Categorical Exemption 6. Correspondence No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt 3. City Council Notice of Public Meeting 5. February 4, 2016 Traffic & Parking Commission Staff Report 4. February 4, 2016 Traffic & Parking Commission Minutes (Excerpt) AGENDA REPORT support of staff s recommendation. 200 block of El Camino Drive to add a Sunday regulation. The Commission voted 5-0 in On February 4, 2016, the Traffic & Parking Commission reviewed a City-initiated request to modify the No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday permit regulation on the INTRODUCTION The Traffic & Parking Commission recommends that the City Council approve a resolution of the Council of the City of Beverly Hills modifying Preferential Parking Permit Zone D on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way as follows: RECOMMENDATION Attachments: 1. Resolution 200 BLOCK OF EL CAMINO DRIVE BETWEEN CHARLEVILLE MODIFYING PREFERENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE D ON THE BOULEVARD AND GREGORY WAY Subject: RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS Martha Eros, Transportation Planner From: Aaron Kunz, AICP, Deputy Director of Transportation To: Honorable Mayor & City Council Item Number: E 7 Meeting Date: February 16, 2016

2 Meeting Date: February 16, El Camino Drive DISCUSSION Background information is provided in the February 4, 2016 Traffic & Parking Commission staff report. Four residents from the 200 block of El Camino Drive spoke in support of a Sunday parking regulation at the February Traffic & Parking Commission meeting. Five letters in support of the permit modification were also received. The Traffic & Parking Commission noted their concern that no feedback was received from the businesses on South Beverly Drive. Public Notices advising of City Council review at the February 16, 2016 formal meeting were mailed February 5, 2016 to the same mailing list used for the Traffic & Parking Commission. Notices were mailed to residents on the 100, 200 and 300 blocks of El Camino Drive; the 200 blocks of South Rodeo Drive and South Beverly Drive; and residences and businesses of the 100 and 300 blocks of South Rodeo Drive and South Beverly Drive within a 500 radius of the project area. City-Initiated Review Per Beverly Hills Municipal Code Chapter 7, Article 2, Section Modification of an Existing Zone, modifying an existing permit zone may be initiated (A) at the request of the Traffic & Parking Commission or City Council, or (B) a resident-initiated petition signed by a minimum of 60% of the residents on the affected street block(s). In February 2015, the single-family residents from the 200 block of El Camino Drive initiated a petition letter to add a Sunday permit parking restriction on the street block to address displaced resident parking generated by South Beverly Drive employee and commuter intrusion. The petition letter was signed by 21 of the 28 single-family homes and submitted to the City in March The petitioners were challenged with accessing apartment/condominium security buildings, but were able to obtain 10 of 54 signatures from the multiple-family dwelling units. The request for a City-initiated permit modification in lieu of a qualifying petition was reviewed by the City Council/Traffic & Parking Commission Liaison Committee on September 2, 2015 and referred to the Traffic & Parking Commission for consideration. On December 3, 2015, the Traffic & Parking Commission reviewed and supported a City-initiated process in lieu of a qualifying resident petition requiring a minimum of 60% (49/82) signatures. The Traffic & Parking Commission acknowledged the petition letter and attempts to secure signatures from the multiple-family buildings. FISCAL IMPACT The cost of modifying parking signs would be nominal and installed by City staff. Susan Healy Keene, AICP b- VCommunity Development Director Approved By Page 2 of 2

3 m 2

4 RESOLUTION NO.1 6-R- RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS MODIFYING PREFERENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE D ON THE 200 BLOCK OF EL CAMINO DRIVE BETWEEN CHARLEVILLE BOULEVARD AND GREGORY WAY WHEREAS, pursuant to Beverly Hills Municipal Code Section (a), modifying an existing permit zone may be initiated at the request of the Traffic & Parking Commission or City Council; WHEREAS, there is an existing permit parking regulation of No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way; WHEREAS, on September 2, 2015, the City Council and Traffic & Parking Commission Liaison Committee concurred that the Traffic & Parking Commission review a resident request for a City-initiated review process to modify the existing permit regulation on the 200 block of El Camino Drive in lieu of a qualify resident-initiated petition signed by 60% of the residents on the affected street block(s); WHEREAS, on December 3, 2015, the Traffic & Parking Commission reviewed and supported a request for a City-initiated review process for the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way; WHEREAS, the City-initiated permit modification requested adding a Sunday parking permit regulation to address commuter parking; WHEREAS, on February 4, 2016, the Traffic & Parking Commission investigated the need to modify the Preferential Parking Permit Zone on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way; B \ v1.doc -1-

5 WHEREAS, on February 4, 2016, the Traffic & Parking Commission recommended modifying the regulation to No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way to add a Sunday regulation; and WHEREAS, following parking occupancy studies and field checks, Transportation Planning staff supported a No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt to address commuter parking on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way; WHEREAS, Transportation Planning has reviewed the proposed project and has determined that the project is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act and has issued a Categorical Exemption; follows: NOW AND THEREFORE, the Council of the City of Beverly Hills does hereby resolve as Section 1. Based upon the evidence and testimony presented to the City Council, including the information set forth in the Agenda Report, the findings required by BHMC Section (d) to justify modifying Preferential Parking Permit Zone D on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way can be made. Section 2. The Council finds that the following designated preferential permit zone is required due to commuter vehicles regularly interfering with available public parking adjacent to residential property zone; or that such vehicles are the cause of unreasonable noise and pollution in the residential environment; or that there is no reasonable alternative which is feasible or practical to reduce the identified street parking problem to acceptable levels. Section 3. The City Council hereby approves modifying Preferential Parking Permit Zone D on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way B \ v1.doc -2-

6 subject to the provisions of the Beverly HillsMunicipal Code Section (d), with a regulation of: No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt Section 4. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this resolution and shall cause this resolution and this certification to be entered in the Book of Resolutions of the Council of the City. Adopted: ATTEST: JULIAN A. GOLD, M.D. Mayor of the City of Beverly Hills, California BYRON POPE City Clerk (SEAL) APPROVED AS TO FORM: APPROVED AS TO CONTENT: DAVID M. SNOW Interim City Attorney SUSAN HEALY KEENAI Director of Community Development -3- B \ v1.doc

7 ATTACHMENT 2

8 BevcrlyHffls.org CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT- PLANNING DIVISION 455 North Rexford Drive Beverly Hills, CA (310) FAX: (310) Categorical Exemption Name of Project: 200 block of El Cam mo Drive Location: Both sides of the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way. Type of Business (if commercial): N/A; residential Project Description: Modify the existing Zone D permit parking regulation on the 200 block of El Camino Drive from No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday to No Parking Anytime, except by permit. Applicant s Name: City of Beverly Hills Phone: Applicant s Address: 455 North Rexford Drive City: Beverly Hills, CA Zip: If different, provide: Agent s Name: Community Development Department Phone: Agent s Address: 455 North Rexford Drive City: Beverly Hills, CA Zip: The undersigned, having received this project for processing, has reviewed it for environmental impact and concluded that the project qualifies for a categorical exemption under the procedures adopted by the City of Beverly Hills and no further environmental assessment is necessary. Comments: Applicable Exemption Class: 1(c) Operation of existing public right-of-way; no expansion of use. Proposed changes not antiçpated to result in significant displaced parking. Reviewed by Date O13o1 I. I

9 ATTACHMENT 3

10 Community Transportation 455 Beverly Request to BEVERLY HILLS CITY COUNCIL NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING 200 Block of El Camino Drive Modify a Preferential Parking Permit Zone The City of Beverly Hills invites your participation in a City-initiated review to modify the Preferential Parking Permit Zone on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way. MEETING: DATE: TIME: LOCATION: PETITION: ACTION: Beverly Hills City Council Tuesday, February 16, :00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard. City Hall, Council Chambers, 455 N. Rexford Drive, Beverly Hills, CA, Modify the existing No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt regulation to include a Sunday regulation. Consideration of a Traffic & Parking Commission recommendation to modify the permit regulation on the 200 block of El Camino Drive as follows: No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt. As the Traffic & Parking Commission unanimously recommended approval to modify the existing regulation, the item will be placed on the City Council Consent Calendar. The City Council will only discuss the item if a Councilmember pulls the item for discussion or a speaker card is submitted for the item. coj1j 0 ci >. o 0:: w w o 0 -J w 0:: w I GREGORY WAY lcrnc[fl I The Traffic & Parking Commission is an advisory board to the City Council. The City Council may approve, deny, or modify the petition request. Please note that a preferential parking permit does not exempt vehicles from the City s no overnight parking ordinance between 2:30-5:00 a.m. PUBLIC COMMENT: Persons wishing to comment on this proposal are invited to attend the February 16, 2016 City Council meeting and/or submit written comments. Any communication received by the City becomes part of the public record. By By Mail: transportation beverlyhills.orcj City of Beverly Hills Community Development - Transportation Planning 455 North Rexford Drive, Beverly Hills, CA If you would like additional information regarding this proposal, please contact Community Development - Transportation Planning at (310) City of Beverly Hills - Development Department - - N. Rexford Drive - transportation@beverlvhills.org Kills, CA Date Mailed: February 5, 2016

11 ATTACHMENT 4

12 Phase Traffic and Parking Commission Regular Meeting Minutes February 4, 2016 CARRI ED REPORTS FROM PRIORITY AGENCIES 2. Police Department Report Sargent Dowling provided an update on the Police Department report. CONTINUED BUSINESS No items NEW BUSINESS Block of El Camino Drive Consideration of a City-initiated modification to the existing permit parking regulation on the 200 block of El Cam mo Drive to add a Sunday regulation Speakers: Sharon Ignarro, Julie Trantham, Bruce Horowitz, Arnon Gurman Motion: MOVED by Commissioner Meshkaty, SECONDED by Commissioner Friedman to adopt the resolution as presented (5-0). AYES: Commissioner Meshkaty, Commissioner Friedman, Commissioner Licht, Vice Chair Seidel, Chair Manaster NOES: None ABSTAIN: None CARRIED PROJECT UPDATES 4. Bikeshare 1 Review of proposed bike share Commission public outreach. Martha Eros provided details of comment in March. station locations and scheduling of Traffic and Parking proposed bikeshare locations for review prior to public QUARTERLY UPDATES 5. Parking Quarterly Report Russell Platamone, Parking Services Manager, provided an update to the Parking quarterly report. Page 2 of 3

13 ATTACHMENT 5

14 LLS (9 CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS TRAFFIC & PARKING COMMISSION TO: FROM: Traffic & Parking Commission Martha Eros, Transportation Planner February 4, 2016 SUBJECT: 200 Block of El Camino Drive City-Initiated Parking Permit Zone Request to Modify Preferential ATTACHMENTS: A. Area Map B. Parking Occupancy Counts C. February 4, 2016 Public Notice D. December 3, 2015 Traffic & Parking Commission E. Correspondence Minutes (Excerpt) This report outlines a City-initiated review to modify of the existing preferential parking permit regulation on the 200 block of El Camino Drive. Staff recommends modifying the existing No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday parking regulation to add a Sunday restriction as follows: Background No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt The 200 block of El Camino Drive is composed of 28 single-family homes and six multiplefamily buildings with 54 dwelling units. There is no intersecting alleyway between the single and multiple-family buildings. The existing permit regulation of No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt was established in February 1979 ( ) to address resident parking displacement generated by employees and patrons visiting the adjacent Wilshire Boulevard and Beverly Drive commercial corridors. Archive records include a petition signed by 79% (22 of 28) of the single family homes on the 200 block of El Camino Drive. In February 2015, the single-family residents from the 200 block of El Camino Drive submitted a letter to add a Sunday permit parking restriction on the street block to address South Beverly Drive employee and commuter intrusion. The petition letter was signed by 21 of the 28 singlefamily homes and submitted to the City in March The petitioners were challenged with accessing apartment/condominium security buildings, but were able to obtain 10/54 signatures from the multiple-family dwelling units. On December 3, 2015, the Traffic & Parking Commission accepted the City-initiated process in lieu of a resident petition to review a modification to the existing permit parking regulation on the 200 block of El Cam inc Drive. Discussion Staff conducted a parking occupancy survey on Sunday, January 10, 2016 from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. In addition to the parking occupancy survey data collected by the Traffic Engineering

15 TPC: 200 El Camino Drive Modify Zone D Page 2 team, Parking Enforcement collected additional windshield vehicle counts with consistent results. On average, 91% (51 of 56 spaces) of the residential parking spaces were occupied during the 6-hour survey period, with peak-hour occupancy of 96% recorded at the 2 p.m. hour. On average, 76% (39/51) of the spaces were occupied by commuter vehicles. Occupancy Period Average Occupied I Total Spaces Average Commuter Study: 10 a.m /56 (91%) 39/51 (76%) Peak Hour: 2 p.m. 54 /56 (96%) + 42/54(78%) Vehicles Total Vehicles Commuter Commuter 6+Hr Duration / 90 (79%) 22 / 71 (31%) A total of 90 vehicles were recorded during the survey period. Fourteen of the 19 (74%) resident vehicles were parked at the north end of the block adjacent to the multiple-family buildings and displayed current permit placards. There were 12 vehicles with disabled placards parked randomly throughout the street for 1-hour intervals each. The adjacent sections of Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way have four parking spaces east of El Camino Drive; all eight spaces were occupied throughout the survey period. Based on high commuter occupancy and long-term parking, and the lack of an enforcement tool to regulate vehicle turn-over on Sunday, staff recommends modifying the existing permit regulation to add a Sunday restriction, except by resident permit. Noticing Notices advising of the February 4, 2016 Traffic & Parking Commission meeting were mailed on January 25, 2016 to residents on the 100, 200 and 300 blocks of El Camino Drive; the 200 blocks of South Rodeo Drive and South Beverly Drive; and residences and businesses of the 100 and 300 blocks of South Rodeo Drive and South Beverly Drive within a 500 radius of the project area. Recommendation Pending public comment and Traffic & Parking Commission discussion, staff recommends modifying the existing permit zone on the 200 block of El Camino Drive with a regulation of: No Parking Anytime, Permit 0 Exempt

16 ATTACHMENT - A

17 200 EL CAMINO DRIVE PREFERENTIAL PARKING PERMIT ZONE D. I II I I I I I II I 100 El Camino and Charleville: j jj c C Me ers. - ( I II I I c 0 ) IL] i:1j I I 200 El Camino Drive: Zone D ci I I No Parking Anytime, Mon - Sat Street sweeping: Wedrrhurs AM L...J U 28 Single Family 54 Multiple Family 60%49/82 Letter: 31/82 signatures (38%). AddSunday Q) 0 ) I I 2 Charleville Boulevard: (no change) 9 metered spaces (north side); Zi N Mixed parking regulations (south side) 110 E Z > r 100 El Camino Drive (commercial): U 0 I I 1-HR, 8am-6pm, Except Sunday E ) UJ meere spaces o < L 0 O I jjj I - 0 I D 300 El Camino Drive: Zone C 0 -j No Parking Anytime (north); Z z CO No Parking, 8am-6pm, Mon-Sat (south) I I1 200 South Rodeo Drive: Zone C C C_GREGORY WAYQ No Parking Anytime I I I d I f 300 South Rodeo Drive: Zone C NoParking,8am-6pm,Mon-Sat II hi i I

18 Zone C I Preferential Parking Permit Zone 200 El Camino Drive D 1 Commcial (pink) ille flt:i Multip U] Family (orange) 54 - Zone 200 El Camino Drive: ZONE D No Parking Anytime, Monday - Saturday Street sweeping, Wednesday/Thursday AM 2sSingle Family 54 Multiple Family 60% = 49/82 Petition Letter: 31/82 signatures (38%) Add Sunday Single 28 amily (yellow) > >- -J LJ > U] o LI, Charleville Boulevard: (NO CHANGE) Mixed parking regulations on north and south sides 100 El Camino Drive: 1-HR, 8am-6pm, Except Sunday > C cii -o C 300 El Camino Drive: ZONE C No Parking Anytime (North End); and No Parking, 8am-6pm, Monday - Saturday (South End)

19 m z I w

20 200 El Camino Parking Occupancy Survey Date: Sunday, January 70, 2016 TOTAL PARKING OCCUPANCY 200 EL CAMINO Time of Day 1 OAM 11 AM NOON 1 PM 2PM 3PM 4PM AVG Occupied Capacity* % Occupied 82% 91% 91% 95% 96% 89% 91% 91% NON-RESIDENT PARKING OCCUPANCY Time of Day 1 OAM 11 AM NOON 1 PM 2PM 3PM 4PM AVG Non-Residents (NR) Residents(R) Capacity* NR Occupancy 65% 76% 76% 79% 78% 78% 80% 76% R Occupancy 35% 24% 24% 21% 22% 22% 20% 24% 200 El Camino Occupancy I $4I 60 82% 91% 91% 95% 96%. % Occupied Time Occupied PARKING DURATION # Hours Parked TOTAL # Vehicles % Veh. Parked 26% 12% 13% 10% 4% 6% 29% 100% *Capacity is calculated mathematically using standard design lengths, and can be increased by reducing the distanc between vehicles and using smaller vehicles. Averages and percentages are rounded to the nearest whole number. 200 El Camino parking occupancy summary

21 ATTACHMENT - C

22 NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING 200 Block of El Camino Drive Request to Modify a Preferential Parking Permit Zone The Community Development Department invites your participation in a City-initiated review to modify the Preferential Parking Permit Zone on the 200 block of El Camino Drive to include a Sunday restriction on the 200 block of El Camino Drive between Charleville Boulevard and Gregory Way. MEETING: Traffic & Parking Commission DATE: Thursday, February 4, 2016 TIME: LOCATION: PETITION: 9:00 a.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard City Hall, Room 280-A, 455 N. Rexiord Drive, Beverly Hills, CA Modify the existing No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt parking regulation to include a Sunday restriction. D o >- -J o LU LU o 0 > 0 -J LU LU I GREGORY WAY fcflc[fl STAFF RECOMMENDATION: PUBLIC COMMENT: Pending public comment, staff recommends modifying the permit regulation as follows: No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt Persons wishing to comment on this item are invited to attend the February 4, 2016 Traffic & Parking Commission meeting and/or submit written comments. Any communication received by the City becomes part of the public record. Please submit correspondence a minimum of 24-hours in advance of the meeting date to allow for routing. By By Mail: transportation(beverlyhiils.orq City of Beverly Hills Community Development - Transportation Planning 455 North Rexiord Drive, Beverly Hills, CA The Traffic & Parking Commission is an advisory board to the City Council. The Commission s recommendation will be forwarded to the City Council for consideration at a future date. The City Council may approve, deny, or modify the Commission s recommendation. If you would like additional information regarding this proposal, please contact the Transportation Planning Division at (310) City of Beverly Hills Community Development - Transportation 455 N. Rexford Drive Beverly Hills, CA transportation@beverlyhills.org Date Mailed: 1/25/2016

23 a - IN3LAJHDVIIV

24 Traffic & Parking Commission Regular Meeting Minutes December 3, 2015 Motion: Action: Motion by Commissioner Seidel, Second by Commissioner Levine to approve the minutes as presented. ( , Licht abstain, Manaster absent). Approved as presented. Consideration of the November 16, 2015 Traffic & Parking Commission Special meeting minutes. Motion: Action: Motion by Commissioner Seidel, Second by Commissioner Licht to approve the minutes as presented. ( , Levine abstain, Manaster absent). Approved as presented BLOCK OF EL CAMINO DRIVE Consideration of a City-initiated modification to the existing permit parking regulation on the 200 block of El Camino Drive to add a Sunday regulation. (Vice Chair Manaster arrived 9:37 AM) Planner: Public Input: Motion: Action: Martha Eros, Transportation Planner Karen Horowitz (petition submitter), Bruce Horowitz, Dr. Lou Ignarro, Dr. Sharon Ignarro, Arnon Gurman, Nancy Heim, Nancy Markoff on behalf of John Markoff, Julie Trantham Motion by Commissioner Levine, Second by Commissioner Seidel (5-0) The Commission accepts the city initiated process in lieu of a resident issued petition for the modification to existing permit parking regulation on 200 block of El Camino Drive. 4. ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATION FEES AND ENFORCEMENT Overview of the Electric Vehicle Charging Station policies, enforcement and proposed fees for use. Mario Inga and Russell Platamone, Parking Services Managers, provided a presentation updating the Commission on electric vehicle charging stations in the City. Page 2 of 3

25 ATTACHMENT - E Correspondence included in February 16, 2016 City Council Agenda Report Attachment 6 -

26 9 IN3IAJHJVIIV

27 200 El Camino Drive Modify Preferential Parking Permit Zone D City-Initiated Existing Regulation: Modification: No Parking, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt No Parking Anytime, Permit D Exempt As of Wednesday, February 10, 2016 DATE ADDRESS SUPPORT OPPOSE 02/09/ El Camino Dr X Traffic & Parking Commission 02/04/ El Camino Dr XX 02/01/ El Camino Dr, #204 X 01/31/16 252ElCaminoDr XX 01/28/ El Camino Dr, #202 X 01/27/ block of El Camino Dr X 12/02/ El Camino Dr X 12/01/ El Camino Dr X 02/01/15 Resident Letter X

28 SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Tuesday, February 09, :10 PM Martha Eros; Christian Vasquez FW: Petition: Modify the existing No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt Regulation to include Sunday Regulation From: Oliver Josephson [mailto Sent: Tuesday, February 09, :04 PM To: WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Subject: Petition: Modify the existing No Parking Anytime, Monday through Saturday, Permit D Exempt Regulation to include Sunday Regulation To Whom it May Concern, I am a resident at 201 El Camino Drive who has parking Permit D and heavily relies on the Permit D parking available. During the week, it is often impossible to find a space, in overnight and daytime zones, and when anyone parks in our zone on Sunday I never get a parking space. Therefore I approve of the no parking regulation except for Permit D to include Sunday as well. Permit D users have so little space in comparison to people like Permit C holders therefore, it is unfair that on days like Sunday our little bit of space can be used by people who do not even reside in our area. We pay high rent and taxes to live here therefore the least you could do is make sure we can park on our street no matter what day it is. And there are still plenty of 2 hour parking except Sunday zones near the heart of Beverly Hills for people to park freely on Sundays. Also do not allow livery and limo and car service drivers to take up our parking spaces while they wait for their passengers. It is noisy when I am trying to sleep with their engines running and they unfairly hog our spaces and make it hard to park during the day when I come home. On a whole OTHER IS SUE, the majority of people in our parking zone have terrible parking etiquette in terms of taking up empty space from doing sioppy parking jobs. There should be a pasted set of rules for proper parking etiquette so spaces are not wasted and there should some penalties like tickets or being towed if people do not follow the proper parking rules. There are often limited spaces available because of sloppy parking jobs. Also more importantly, if you could fix it, Permit D users need MORE overnight parking space and should able to park ANYWHERE overnight in the Permit D zone with the overnight permit rather than the small fraction of the block you let Permit D users park overnight in. In all, your parking situation is flawed and nonsensical, and it needs to be fixed. It makes my life so stressful and miserable living here at times because I often have to stress over not getting a parking space to leave my car during the day or at night when I come home. Thank you for your consideration, Oliver Josephson 1

29 WebCBH TRANSPORTATION SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Nancy Heirr Thursday, February 04, :47 AM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Julie & Dennis Trantham 200 Block of El Camino Drive Hello, I live at 216 El Camino Drive and am in favor of the modification of the Preferential Parking Permit Zone for the 200 block of El Cam mo. Requiring permits on Sunday would greatly alleviate the lack of parking places for residents and guests of residents on Sundays. it is almost impossible to have family or friends over on Sundays. I hope you will consider our request as well as those of our neighbors. Best, Nancy Heim & Victor Reskin 216 El Camino Drive 1

30 WebCBH TRANSPORTATION SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Nancy Helm Sunday, November 29, :17 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION 200 Block of El Camino Drive To the Traffic & Parking Commission, We support extending the existing parking restrictions on Zone D to include Sundays. It is often very hard to find a parking space on our own Street, especially when we have guests visit. Please let me know if you should have any questions. Best, Nancy Heim & Victor Reskin 216 El Camino Drive Beverly Hills 1

31 Transportation Viken Bedrossian 209 El Camino Dr Apt 204 Beverly Hills CA SUPPORT 1/28/2016 FEB 0 tig Lv;y City of Beverly Hills Community Development N Rexford Dr Beverly Hills CA Dear Sir or Madam, Planning This is in response to your letter regarding the petition to modify the parking D requirement to include Sundays. Currently, there is no permit requirement for Sundays and that makes it very difficult for us residents to find street parking on El Camino. Therefore, I encourage you to include Sundays and disallow parking for people without permit D. Furthermore, on weekdays there are a number of people who borrow permit tags from residents and park their cars on El Camino all day while they go to work on adjacent streets. I have observed a black Chevrolet arriving daily at 5:00 am and not leaving until hours later. While I am not certain, it appears that this person is coming from another community and using up our parking privileges. This type of behavior makes the parking availability increasingly difficult on street sweeping days. Finally, there are those who use handicap tags unlawfully to park in our valuable spaces. This is especially difficult for us when they take up our spaces overnight. However, in this case, I do understand that there may be little or nothing that can be done. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to voice our concerns and comments. Sin rely, Viken B drossian

32 or SUPPORT Subject: FW: Permit D Exemption From: smmcbenn@aol.com [mailto. Sent: Sunday, January 31, :28 AM To: WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Subject: Permit D Exemption I am a homeowner on El Camino Dr. since 1964 and strongly urge that the Permit D Exemption parking regulation include Sundays. It is hazardous for me to exit my driveway and impossible for me or my family to park in front of my house -- Please act now! Sarane Bennett 252 El Camino Dr. nearby! 1

33 WebCBH TRANSPORTATION SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: Monday, November 30, :16 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Sunday Parking on El Camino Dear Traffic and Parking Commissioners, I have been a property owner at this address since I 964. I appreciate the current parking restrictions, but I would like it extended to Sundays. I am unable to attend the Dec. 3 meeting but would like my voice heard: Limit Sunday Parking! Sarane Bennett 252 El Camino Dr 1

34 SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: ILENE WOOLF Thursday, January 28, :40 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Meeting Feb 4, 2016 traffic and Parking commission please read To whom it may concern, I am writing this in regards to the Feb. 4, 2016 meetin9 at City Hall in room 280-A 9:00am. For the petition to modify the existing no parking anytime Monday thru saturday to include sunday. I having been living at 209 El Camino Dr. #202 for aprox 17 years, the parking on this street 200 Block of EL Camino Drive is getting so hard to park your car, just simple things like if you want to go to the market and bring your groceries upstairs is almost impossible especially on sunday. So I am in favor of changin the existing no parking and please do include Sunday s. In addition, please keep in mind that everyday of the week, there are so many people that park with handicap stickers and they are not deserving of that. They leave no spaces for the people that actually need it. This may be another issue. Thank you Ilene Woolf 209 El Camino Drive #202 Beverly Hills, CA 90212

35 SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: sohsie Wednesday, January 27, :37 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Comment on modification of permit parking 200 block el camino To whom it may concern, I am 100% in support of modifying the parking zone on 200 el camino to no parking anytime, permit D Exempt. Currently it impossible for me to park anywhere on el camino on a sunday and I end up parking blocks away just to go to my own apartment on El camino. There is a 2 hour free parking garage on beverly drive so there is no reason for people to park on the 200 block of el camino. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Steven 1

36 WebCBH TRANSPORTATION SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: anthony clifford Wednesday, December 02, :24 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION Limited Sunday on El Camino I reside on 240 s el Camino drive and the parking situation on Sunday amounts to a dangerous situation by where anyone from outside our area can park on out Street leaving no room for our selves famil y or guests. Please extend the existing Zone D parking restrictions to Sunday. Thank you. Anthony Clifford. Sent from my iphone 1

37 WebCBH TRANSPORTATION SUPPORT From: Sent: To: Subject: Karen Watson Tuesday, December 01, :13 PM WebCBH TRANSPORTATION 200 Block of El Camino Drive Thank you for your consideration of our request to modify parking restrictions on the 200 block of El Camino Drive to include Sundays. As residents, we support this modification request, as it would enhance residents ability to utilize street parking for theft own needs, and for visiting family and friends. Due to our proximity to the businesses of S. Beverly Drive, parking on our street is challenging most days (We have never seen so many able-bodied drivers with handicap permits!). But parking is particularly difficult on Sundays. Currently, street parking is filled up very early every Sunday morning. Furthermore, unlike the turnover in street parking that occurs Monday-Saturday, Sunday parkers, for the most part, are in place for the majority of the day, leaving residents little or no street parking access. The long hours suggest these cars are not being parked to access Beverly Drive, so a change should not present a negative impact to businesses there. The residents of El Camino are not opposed to sharing our street for short-term parking needs of other area residents and visitors. However, we are not really sharing on Sundays, as our street s parking is taken first thing, and by all-day parkers. We respectfully ask that you align restrictions for all seven days of the week, so we have some opportunity to utilize our street on Sundays. Thanks again for your review of this issue. Karen Watson and Rich Gershen 253 El Camino Drive Karen Watson 1

38 From: Residents (From 212 to 265) of El Camino Drive Re; Changing Sunday Parking Code Date: February 1, ElCamino To: Department of Public Works, City of Beverly Hills Houses: Resi e 212 El Camino 216 El Camino \j) -4C1-- tl-%fttt,j 217 El Caminr 220 El Camino 221 ElCamino 7W ] 224 El Camino 225 El Camino 228 El Camino 229 ElCamino I 232 ElCamino 233 El Camino 3ii9-236 El Camino fy1 t P- IAi &i fz.r jr / 241 El Camino l?7lc tjbo 244 ElCamino 24OElCamino 237ElCamino 5 - S RLJ49 I ri0 ix, -t o tf1/tr Signature Date The residents of 212 through 265 El Camino Drive request that the parking rules on our Street change to No Parking Any Time Except by Permit Monday through Sunday. Currently, Sunday is excluded.

39 245 El Camh 24$ El 265ElCamino El Camino Ski j2yj 2h/,s 252E1 253 El 256 El 257 El Camino 260 El Camino 261 El Camino 249 El Resident Signature Date

40 To: Department of Public Works, City of Beverly Hills From: Residents (From 212 to 265) of El Camino Drive Re: Changing Sunday Parking Code Date: March 6, 2015 ( The residents of El Camino Drive request that the parking rules on our Street change to No Parking Any Time Except by Permit Monday through Sunday. Currently, Sunday is excluded. Apt: Resident Signature Date CD ç/71m> L c3e;;115?i

41 From: Residents (From 212 to 265) of El Camino Drive Re: Changing Sunday Parking Code 0 c\ 5 _- Date: March 6, 2015 ftk pc Y I V - t L,-s j,i-< S \p(q \\hoi Q- 9&1 ( /%Ø) 2o (Qi A] ILe- 3f1Z1(% j03 :LIwi&i -ft To: Department of Public Works, City of Beverly Hills The residents of El Camino Drive request that the parking rules on our Street change to No Parking Any Time Except by Permit Monday through Sunday. Currently, Sunday is excluded. Apt: Resident ignature Date t K5 H t