An overview of national, international and state low carbon fuel policies

Transcription

1 An overview of national, international and state low carbon fuel policies Dr. Chris Malins Packard grantees meeting, June 2015

2 Context: The market for liquid fuels World Energy Council, symphony energy scenario 120 EJ of total transport energy demand 105 EJ of liquid fuel demand 95 EJ of fossil fuel demand Exajoules of transport fossil fuel demand, 2050: 2

3 The potential market for unconventional oil Up to 44 EJ of liquid fuels could come from unconventional oil by 2050 Exajoules of transport fuel demand (fossil + alt.), 2050: ~ 700 MtCO2e/yr (at a carbon differential of 15 gco2e/mj) 3

4 The potential market for biofuels IEA estimates that up to 33 EJ of liquid fuels could be supplied by biofuels Exajoules of transport fuel demand (fossil + alt.), 2050: ~ 500 MtCO2e/yr (increase in worst case) ~ 1,500 MtCO2e/yr 4 (saving in best case)

5 Key policies Biofuel mandates 5

6 EU status The Renewable Energy Directive as primary policy Still target 10% renewable energy in transport (2020) The ILUC Directive : Cap the contribution of food-based fuels at 7 of the 10 percent A 0.5% target for fuels from a defined list of second gen feedstocks 2030: An overall 27% renewable energy target Unclear whether [alt/bio] fuels will have an EU level target 6

7 EU observations The commitment to delivering cellulosic fuels must be demonstrated at MS level (e.g. Italy) There is considerable difference of opinion over the future of food-based biofuels Shut down Phase out Freeze Ramp up Enhanced focus on waste and residual feedstocks, ILUC avoidance Post 2020 is highly unclear 7

8 US federal policy The Renewable Fuel Standard remains effective at dictating supply of renewable and advanced fuel Lack of clarity over likely evolution of volumes to 2022 Standard blend levels a barrier to increased fuel deployment The cellulosic mandate remains challenging, but cellulosic RINs are now being generated Biogas from landfill Cellulosic ethanol How to set the cellulosic mandate? Companies have missed targets in past Excessively low targets could however suppress growth 8

9 Other major markets Brazil Sugarcane ethanol blend levels remain high, relatively stable around 25% Favorable tax treatment for ethanol is being used to offset falling gasoline price Biodiesel at 7% Modest ethanol exports in 2015 (1.3 billion litres) Indonesia Introduction of a new palm export levy to fund biodiesel subsidy Fund may also support land rehabilitation, smallholder replanting By 2025: 25% biodiesel for road transport 5% biofuel for aviation 20% ethanol for road (5% by 2020) 9

10 Key policies Low carbon fuel standards 10

11 California Successful LCFS re-adoption Revised pathway values and process Increased certainty: re-adoption + introduction of credit clearance mechanism LCFS credit values increased to over $80 per tonne Potentially more important now as an investment driver for new technologies 11

12 Germany LCFS-like implementation of the Fuel Quality Directive (FQD) since start of 2015 Replaces biofuel volume mandates No indirect land use change accounting under FQD Unclear whether and which other EU Member States might follow suit 12

13 Pacific region Oregon Clean Fuels Program moving forward British Columbia RLCFRR continues Washington Clean Fuels Standard stopped by political action Limited prospect for additional LCFSs in the near term 13

14 Key policies Aviation 14

15 Market based measure for global aviation Being developed by International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) to help aviation meet target for carbon neutral growth from 2020 Offset program, with credits for biofuel use as one emissions reduction option Unlikely on its own to offer enough value to bring new fuels to market (will require complementary incentives) 15

16 Key policies Oil 16

17 Carbon intensity reporting for oil California MCON reporting continues Carbon intensities set on each oil stream coming to California Credits for innovative emissions reduction projects Europe Modifications to the fuel quality directive introduce oil origin reporting Upstream emissions reductions to be eligible towards FQD compliance 17

18 Closing thoughts 18

19 Closing thoughts Cellulosic fuel production incentives may be firming up again Adoption of biofuel policies in developing world has slowed but not stopped New fuel technologies will raise new sustainability questions 19

20 Look, progress! 20

21 Thanks for listening! 21